Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2004 / iii / Paper 2 / 4

The orbits of a normal subgroup $N$ are blocks for the primitive group action. If every orbit is a singleton then $N\le G_{[\Omega ]}$, giving the second alternative. Otherwise $N$ is transitive, and $G=N{G}_{\alpha }$.

Work in $G/N$. Every $g\in G$ can be written $nh$ with $n\in N$, $h\in G_{\alpha }$. Conjugation by $n$ has no effect on the image of a subgroup in this quotient, while $h$ normalizes $A$. Thus every conjugate of $A$ has the same image $AN/N$. The generation hypothesis says this image generates all of $G/N$. But it is already an abelian subgroup, so $G/N$ is abelian and $G^{\prime }\le N$. This proves the Iwasawa simplicity lemma in its possibly nonfaithful form:

For $i\ne j$, put $x_{ij}(a)=I+a{E}_{ij}$. When $a\ne 0$ this is a transvection: it fixes the hyperplane $v_j=0$ pointwise and has rank-one difference from the identity. Its inverse is $x_{ij}(-a)$ and its determinant is one.

Left multiplication performs a row addition. For an invertible matrix, bring a nonzero entry into a pivot position by a signed interchange, then clear its column by row additions. A signed interchange on two coordinates is itself a product of row additions, becauseRepeating the pivot construction and then clearing above the pivots reduces any determinant-one matrix to a diagonal matrix of determinant one. FinallyA determinant-one diagonal matrix is a product of such two-coordinate matrices, using the last coordinate to compensate each of the first $n-1$ diagonal entries. Each displayed matrix is a product of elementary transvection matrices. Hence reversing the elimination provesThis argument works over every field, including characteristic two.

Let $S=S{L}_n(F)$ and let $Z$ be its scalar center. Its action on the lines of $F^n$ has kernel exactly $Z$: a linear map fixing every line is diagonal in a basis, and fixing the lines spanned by $e_i+e_j$ makes all its diagonal entries equal. The action is two-transitive. Indeed an ordered pair of distinct lines can be represented by two independent vectors and extended to a basis. A linear map between two such bases can be adjusted to determinant one by scaling one target basis vector; this preserves both target lines. Therefore $S/Z$ has a faithful primitive group action.

Fix $L=Fv$. The mapsform an abelian subgroup: all products of the rank-one terms vanish. It is normal in the line stabilizer, since conjugation replaces $v$ by a scalar multiple and transports $f$. Its conjugates contain every transvection, and hence generate $S$ by 4(b). The same statements hold for its image in $S/Z$.

It remains to prove perfectness rather than assume it. Use the group commutator convention $[x,y]=xy{x}^{-1}{y}^{-1}$. If $n\ge 3$, distinct $i,j,k$ giveEvery elementary generator is consequently in $S^{\prime }$. If $n=2$ and $|F|>3$, choose $a\in F^{\ast }$ with $a^2\ne 1$. There are at most two roots of $a^2=1$, so such a choice exists. For $h=\mathrm{diag}(a,a^{-1})$,Varying $b$ gives every upper transvection; conjugating by $w(1)$ gives every lower one. Again $S^{\prime }=S$, and its projective quotient is a perfect group.

Apply 4(a) to this faithful primitive projective action. Every nontrivial normal subgroup contains the commutator subgroup, which is the whole quotient. ThusThe restriction is real: $PS{L}_2(2)\cong S_3$ and $PS{L}_2(3)\cong A_4$ are not simple.

Replace $F^n$ by a symplectic vector space $(V,B)$ of dimension $2m$, and elementary row operations by symplectic transvectionsThe cross terms in $B(Tx,Ty)$ cancel, and $B(v,v)=0$, so these maps preserve $B$. Their inverses are $T_{v,-c}$.

They generate $Sp(V)$ by the following symplectic basis elimination. If $B(u,v)\ne 0$, a single transvection with direction $v-u$ and parameter $1/B(u,v)$ sends $u$ to $v$. If $B(u,v)=0$ and $u\ne v$, choose $w$ with both $B(u,w)$ and $B(w,v)$ nonzero: the union of two proper hyperplanes does not exhaust a vector space, even over ${\mathbb{F}}_2$. Two transvections then suffice. Thus one can make a form-preserving linear map fix the first basis vector $e$. Next align its partner $f$, while keeping $e$ fixed. Two partners have difference in $e^{\perp }$, so the preceding single-transvection construction uses a direction in $e^{\perp }$ whenever their mutual pairing is nonzero. If it is zero, the intermediate partner $f+ae$, $a\ne 0$, has nonzero pairing with both. All these transvections fix $e$. Once both $e,f$ are fixed, recurse on their nondegenerate symplectic orthogonal complement. This proves generation over every field.

Use the action on the points of projective space, whose kernel is the scalar center $Z=\{\lambda I:{\lambda }^2=1\}$. For $m=1$ this is the $S{L}_2$ case. For $m\ge 2$ the action is primitive, although it is generally not two-transitive. The stabilizer of a line $L$ has two orbits on other lines: those orthogonal to $L$ and those not orthogonal to $L$. This follows by extending a hyperbolic pair, or an independent isotropic pair, to a symplectic basis. A block containing $L$ and a second line $M$ contains the entire corresponding orbit of the stabilizer of $L$. The stabilizer of $M$ then supplies a line of the other type: choose a vector orthogonal to one of $L,M$ and not to the other. Nondegeneracy and independence guarantee such a vector, also in dimension four. Hence the block contains both orbits and is the whole set.

The transvections along $L$ form an abelian normal subgroup of its stabilizer; their conjugates generate the group. Thus the Iwasawa simplicity lemma applies as soon as perfectness is established. For $|F|>3$, every transvection lies in an embedded $S{L}_2(F)$ acting on a hyperbolic plane, and 4(c) proves that embedded group perfect.

For the remaining fields, the perfectness of finite symplectic groups has a short direct proof. Over ${\mathbb{F}}_3$ with $m\ge 2$, all parameter-one transvections have the same class $t$ in the abelianization, and $3t=0$. In an isotropic plane with basis $u,v$, the four directions $u,v,u+v,u-v$ give commuting transvections whose product is $1$: their rank-one terms add to zero, sinceover ${\mathbb{F}}_3$. Thus $4t=0$, giving $t=0$. Parameter-two transvections are inverses, so all generators vanish in the abelianization. Over ${\mathbb{F}}_2$ with $m\ge 3$, use the seven nonzero vectors of an isotropic three-space. Their commuting transvections multiply to $1$, since each diagonal coordinate of ${\sum }_{0\ne v}v{v}^{\mathsf{T}}$ occurs four times and each off-diagonal coordinate twice. Their common abelianized class satisfies $2t=7t=0$, and again the group is perfect.

Consequently the projective symplectic group is simple, with the necessary exceptionsThe first two are the linear exceptions; the last is $S{p}_4(2)\cong S_6$, proved in 6(c). The word “projective” matters: the unquotiented symplectic group may have the nontrivial scalar center $\{I,-I\}$.