Original questions are transcribed from the public-domain edition. Credit: Wellcome Collection; original supplied by Royal College of Physicians, London. Source and public-domain rights statement.
The explanations distinguish the descriptive categories used in 1865 from present pathology. They are educational accounts of disease mechanisms and examination findings.
Original question.
Describe the general appearance and the microscopical structure of a lung affected by pneumonia, discriminating between the several stages of the disease.
The classical sequence in lobar pneumonia is congestion, red hepatization, grey hepatization, and resolution. These are overlapping morphological phases, not a clock that every pneumonia follows. An affected lung may contain adjacent areas in different phases; bronchopneumonia has scattered airway-centred foci rather than uniform involvement of a whole lobe. Modern antibiotic treatment often interrupts the textbook sequence.[ref]
During congestion, the lung is heavy, dark red and boggy but still contains some air. Its cut surface gives a blood-stained watery fluid. Microscopy shows distended alveolar capillaries, oedema within alveoli, and an early cellular exudate, before dense pulmonary consolidation has developed. Reduced alveolar ventilation begins as fluid replaces the normal air space.
In red hepatization, the affected lobe is enlarged, firm, red and substantially airless. Its granular cut surface resembles liver, which explains the name; it is not a transformation into liver tissue. The alveoli are occupied by a mesh of fibrin containing abundant red blood cells and neutrophils, while the alveolar capillaries remain congested. Filling of neighbouring air spaces produces continuous pulmonary consolidation. Associated pleurisy may put a fibrinous exudate on the overlying pleura.
In grey hepatization, pulmonary consolidation remains, but the colour becomes grey, grey-brown or yellowish as intact red blood cells disappear and the fibrin and inflammatory leukocytes dominate. Microscopy shows degenerating neutrophils, debris and persistent intra-alveolar fibrin; the conspicuous vascular engorgement of the preceding phase diminishes. Grey colour by itself does not establish a separate pathogen or mean that an abscess has formed.[ref]
In resolution, the intra-alveolar exudate is broken down, ingested by macrophages, removed through airways and cleared by absorption. The lobe softens and becomes aerated again. Where the alveolar septa have survived, the architecture can return nearly to normal; an air-space exudate need not become a permanent scar. Failure of clearance may instead lead to organisation and fibrosis; destructive infection can produce abscess or empyema. These are possible outcomes, not obligatory further stages.
A useful examination compares a cut section and a thin histological section from each region, following the alveolar septa to distinguish filling of existing air spaces from destruction of the framework. A dense airless piece may sink in water, but this physical test only shows reduced air content: atelectasis can also sink. The distribution and the microscopy establish why the tissue is airless.
Original question.
State the pathology of Diabetes mellitus, and mention other forms of disease with which it is apt to be associated.
Diabetes is a disorder of glucose regulation with persistent hyperglycaemia; the glycosuria is a consequence, not a sufficient explanation of its cause. In 1865 the relation between hepatic glycogen, circulating glucose and urinary sugar was actively disputed. A contemporary account could reasonably discuss failure to assimilate food and excessive delivery of sugar from the liver; it could not possess the later demonstration of insulin deficiency. An 1863 discussion of diabetes documents competing interpretations of the hepatic experiments, rather than an agreed single lesion.[ref]
In the modern account, type 1 diabetes results from destruction of pancreatic beta cells and severe deficiency of insulin. Type 2 diabetes combines insulin resistance with inadequate compensatory insulin secretion. Disease of the pancreas can also cause diabetes. Reduced restraint of hepatic glucose production and impaired peripheral disposal of glucose contribute to hyperglycaemia. These mechanisms distinguish types that were not separated in the question's terminology.[ref]
When the filtered glucose load exceeds renal reabsorptive capacity, glycosuria causes an osmotic diuresis: loss of water and electrolytes produces polyuria, dehydration and polydipsia. Inadequate use of fuels and increased breakdown of stored fat and protein explain wasting despite appetite. Severe insulin deficiency promotes ketogenesis and can cause diabetic ketoacidosis; it is not correct to make this the inevitable state of everyone with diabetes. Conversely, renal glycosuria can occur without the systemic metabolic disorder, so a urinary sugar test alone does not settle the diagnosis.Symptoms and signs; complications: glycosuria and osmotic diuresis[ref]
The associated diseases should be separated into predispositions, complications and coincident illnesses. Pulmonary wasting called “phthisis” was prominent in period accounts, but the historical label does not establish that every reported lung cavity was tuberculous.[ref] Modern diabetes increases susceptibility to active tuberculosis; it does not convert sugar into tubercle. Diabetes also increases susceptibility to some other infections and can accompany recurrent skin infection, poor wound healing and gangrene.[ref] Long-standing hyperglycaemia is associated with retinopathy, nephropathy and peripheral neuropathy; accelerated atherosclerosis contributes to coronary artery disease, stroke and limb ischemia. Obesity is commonly associated with type 2 diabetes, although severe untreated disease may cause loss of body mass. None of these associations licenses a claim that every diabetic patient has the same anatomical lesions.[ref]
For an 1865 investigation, repeated urine testing could demonstrate reducing sugar and its variation with diet; simultaneous study of the blood and liver was needed to investigate the source. The distinction between glucose already present during life and glucose formed in an unfixed liver after death is crucial experimental design: post-mortem chemical change must not be mistaken for the living organ's output. Modern diagnosis measures blood glucose and longer-term glycaemic exposure rather than inferring the entire disorder from the taste or appearance of urine.[ref]
Original question.
What are the varieties of softening which are found in the cerebro-spinal axis, and what are the most usual causes of the disease in the several parts of that structure ?
“Softening” describes disintegration of nervous tissue; it does not identify one cause. The 1865 colour categories were chiefly red, yellow and white softening. They must be distinguished from the causal classification into vascular injury, inflammation, pressure-related injury, trauma and post-mortem change. Historical observers sometimes interpreted pale ventricular softening as a consequence of oedema; modern pathology requires evidence of tissue death before calling such a region encephalomalacia.[ref]
Red softening contains conspicuous extravasated blood, sometimes with vascular engorgement. It may occur in a haemorrhagic cerebral infarction, a contusion or destructive inflammation. Yellow softening is a later discoloured, friable focus containing products of tissue and blood breakdown, often with lipid-laden macrophages. White or pale softening has little visible haemorrhage; an ischaemic focus in the white matter can be pale, as can waterlogged tissue around a cerebral ventricle. These appearances overlap through time. Neither red colour proves primary encephalitis nor white colour proves absence of vascular disease.
In the cerebral hemispheres, a major cause of genuine destructive softening is interruption of arterial blood flow: thrombosis on diseased arteries, an embolus from the heart or another artery, or inadequate perfusion during severe systemic circulatory failure. The territory supplied by the obstructed vessel helps explain a focal lesion; prolonged global failure particularly injures vulnerable neurons and boundary zones between arterial territories. Cortical lesions and deep lesions involving the basal ganglia or internal pathways can therefore have different distributions. Cerebral infarction evolves through neuronal injury, removal of dead tissue by microglia and macrophages, and liquefactive necrosis; a chronic lesion may leave a fluid-filled cavity with surrounding gliosis.[ref]
In the cerebellum and brainstem, interruption of the vertebrobasilar circulation is likewise an important vascular cause; local haemorrhage, trauma and infection are alternatives. Suppuration can cause destructive softening in any region, and a nearby tumour can injure tissue by compression, interference with its blood supply or associated oedema. These mechanisms must be investigated rather than inferred from consistency alone.
In the spinal cord, destructive myelomalacia can follow vascular interruption, severe compression, direct trauma or inflammatory myelitis. Vertebral disease or an epidural mass may compress both the spinal cord and its vessels. Infarction often involves the territory of the anterior spinal artery; reduced perfusion can preferentially damage the vulnerable central gray matter. Myelitis can also disrupt tissue without a primary arterial obstruction. It would be misleading to transfer the relative frequency of cerebral embolism unchanged to every spinal lesion.[ref]
At examination, record the location, vascular territory, firmness, colour and adjacent membranes; inspect the arteries and search for an embolic source or compression. Microscopy asks whether there is necrosis, inflammatory exudation, haemorrhage, myelin debris, cellular clearance or repair. Finally exclude simple post-mortem autolysis.
Original question.
Mention the best known varieties of Pityriasis, and describe their microscopical characters.
The historical name pityriasis grouped finely scaling eruptions; its varieties were not all one fungal infection. A useful period list is simple or scalp pityriasis, pityriasis rubra, pityriasis versicolor and pityriasis nigra. The names describe distribution or colour, and classifications differed. In particular, “nigra” was sometimes a very dark form of “versicolor,” sometimes a pigmentation disorder with little true scaling. It cannot safely be translated into one present species of fungus.[ref]
Simple pityriasis, often called pityriasis capitis on the scalp, gives loose, whitish, bran-like scales with little or variable redness. Microscopy of a scale principally shows flattened keratinised epithelial cells and debris. An oily or inflamed scalp can also contain organisms normally living there; this does not make every case identical to pityriasis versicolor. Present descriptions of dandruff and seborrhoeic dermatitis explain many such appearances, but the historical label cannot retrospectively specify the cause of each case.[ref]
Pityriasis rubra denoted a conspicuously red, scaling eruption, sometimes extensive. Detached scales are again principally epidermal material. A modern skin biopsy may show an inflammatory pattern, but there is no single microscopical organism that defines the historical category. It must not automatically be renamed pityriasis rubra pilaris, a distinct follicular disorder. An extensive red and peeling skin is a pattern requiring causal diagnosis, rather than proof of one infection.[ref]
Pityriasis versicolor produces irregular pale, yellowish-brown or brown patches, commonly on the upper anatomical trunk, with a fine surface scale. Here the microscopy is especially discriminating: a superficial scraping, cleared with potassium hydroxide, shows clusters of round yeast forms and short curved hyphae within the stratum corneum. Modern classification places the organisms in Malassezia. The older “Microsporon furfur” terminology should not be read as identification of a modern Microsporum dermatophyte. On a histological section the organisms occupy the horny surface layer and are made conspicuous by suitable fungal stains.[ref]
Pityriasis nigra calls first for verification of what is actually being described. If it is dark pityriasis versicolor, the same superficial yeast and hyphae may be found; if the lesion is pigmentation without a fungal eruption, this finding cannot be assumed. A contemporary discussion explicitly recorded the overlap of nigra and versicolor and disputes over the significance of the supposed parasite.[ref] Thus epidermal scales are common to the description, but demonstrable fungal structures particularly distinguish pityriasis versicolor. Examine actual scrapings with a optical microscope, compare several fields and use appropriate controls before attributing a different scaling disorder to a fungus.
Original question.
Give a sketch of the natural history, and shortly describe the external appearance, of the entozoa found in the human abdominal viscera in this country.
The principal intestinal Entozoa to describe are roundworms, threadworms, whipworms and tapeworms; the chief visceral larval form is the hydatid. “In this country” refers to the British setting of the paper. It is not a claim that all human helminths were common or acquired locally. A contemporary account already distinguished Nematoda, Cestoda and Trematoda, and recognised that an adult worm and a larval cyst could be different phases of one life cycle.[ref] The life cycles below use present knowledge to explain transmission; their inclusion does not imply that every migratory stage or intermediate host was established in 1865.
Ascaris lumbricoides lives as a large, cylindrical, unsegmented, tapering roundworm in the small intestine; adults are cream-coloured or pinkish and roughly 15–35 cm long, with the male generally smaller and its tail curved. Eggs leave in faeces and become infective after development in the environment. After ingestion, larvae cross the intestinal wall, pass through the liver and lungs, ascend the airway, are swallowed and mature in the small intestine. Adults can wander into the bile ducts. The pulmonary migration belongs to the larval history, not to the usual location of the adult.[ref]
Enterobius vermicularis, the threadworm, is a small white nematode of the caecal and adjacent colonic region. The female is about 8–13 mm long and has a conspicuous pointed tail; the male is shorter. The gravid female migrates to the perianal skin and deposits eggs, often at night, so itching and transfer by contaminated fingers favour renewed infection. Eggs become infective rapidly; a pulmonary migration is not part of its usual life cycle. This explains why a perianal adhesive sample can be more useful than an ordinary stool examination.[ref]
Trichuris trichiura, historically Trichocephalus dispar, inhabits the caecum and colon. The adult is about 3–5 cm long, with a very slender anterior portion embedded in the mucous membrane and a thicker posterior portion projecting into the lumen: the outline resembles a whip. Eggs pass in faeces, mature in soil and infect after ingestion. The adult shape and the characteristic eggs with polar plugs distinguish it from the preceding worms.[ref]
Adult Taenia are flat, ribbon-like tapeworms, several metres long, with a small attachment head or scolex, a narrow neck and a chain of proglottids. Taenia solium has four suckers and a hooked rostellum; Taenia saginata, also called Taenia mediocanellata in period literature, has four suckers but lacks that crown of hooks. Their larval cysticerci occur in pig and cattle tissues respectively; ingestion of inadequately cooked infected meat permits an adult to develop in the human small intestine. Eggs and segments pass in faeces. Egg appearance alone does not reliably distinguish these two species.[ref]
For Taenia solium, swallowing eggs is a different event from swallowing pork cysticerci: eggs can establish tissue cysticercosis in humans, including abdominal tissues, whereas pork larvae cause intestinal taeniasis. A cysticercus is a small fluid-filled bladder with an invaginated scolex, not a miniature chain of segments.[ref]
The hydatid of Echinococcus granulosus is particularly important in the liver. Humans acquire eggs from contamination associated with infected dogs and act as intermediate hosts. Larvae reach viscera and form a fluid-filled cyst with a laminated wall and an inner germinal layer; brood capsules, protoscolices and sometimes daughter cysts develop inside. The tiny adult tapeworm belongs in the dog's intestine, not as the normal human liver worm. Dogs complete the cycle by eating infected viscera from an intermediate host.[ref]
Less usual examples deserve proportionate mention. Diphyllobothrium latum is a broad, segmented fish tapeworm with two longitudinal attachment grooves rather than four suckers; aquatic intermediate hosts and infected fish link it to humans. It should not be presented as a uniformly common British infection.[ref] Fasciola hepatica, a leaf-shaped fluke roughly 2–3 cm long with oral and ventral suckers, can inhabit the bile ducts; its cycle requires a freshwater snail and infective stages on aquatic vegetation. Human disease was an unusual counterpart of an important infection of grazing animals.[ref] Trichinella spiralis has minute intestinal adults after ingestion of infected meat, but its enduring encysted larvae occupy skeletal muscle; those muscle cysts should not be misdescribed as the typical abdominal hydatid.[ref]
Gross form and location guide identification, but microscopy of eggs, larvae or segments and knowledge of the life cycle supply the confirmation.
Original question.
State the chemical composition of biliary calculi.
Gallstones contain chiefly cholesterol and/or bile pigment, with variable calcium salts and an organic matrix. They are mixtures with different predominant components, not one compound with a universal formula. The period word cholesterin denotes cholesterol.
Cholesterol-rich stones contain crystalline cholesterol, often with a smaller pigmented nucleus and layers of other material. Mixed stones combine cholesterol, pigment, calcium salts and an organic matrix including mucin. Pigment stones contain much less cholesterol; a major constituent is calcium bilirubinate, related to the bile pigment bilirubin. Minor inorganic constituents can include calcium carbonate and calcium phosphate. Not every visibly dark stone has the same composition, and no fixed percentage follows from the question.[ref]
The useful modern subdivision of pigment stones is into black and brown types. Black stones commonly contain polymerised pigment with calcium salts; brown stones include calcium bilirubinate and calcium salts of fatty acids, particularly in infected stagnant duct bile. These refinements explain why neither “all stones are cholesterol” nor “all stones are lime salts” is adequate.[ref]
Chemical examination should distinguish the fractions rather than infer them merely from the external colour. Cholesterol can be extracted with a suitable organic solvent and recognised in recrystallised material; microscopy can show characteristic plate-like crystals. A mineral residue after removal or destruction of organic matter indicates an inorganic fraction, but residue alone cannot identify a particular salt. Layering, facets and colour describe growth and packing and are not chemical analyses. In particular, calcium bilirubinate is not interchangeable with calcium carbonate, and cholesterol is not a bile salt.
Original question.
What are the causes of the condition described as Angina Pectoris ?
Angina pectoris is most usefully explained by transient inadequacy of the myocardial oxygen supply relative to demand. It is a clinical syndrome, rather than the name of one visible anatomical lesion. The characteristic constricting chest discomfort may radiate to the arm, neck or jaw and be provoked by effort; the question concerns its causes, not a claim that every chest pain is angina pectoris.[ref]
The common structural basis is coronary atherosclerosis. Narrowing limits the increase of coronary blood flow that should accompany exercise. An affected heart may receive sufficient oxygen at rest and insufficient oxygen when its rate, force of contraction and wall stress rise. Plaque disruption with thrombosis can abruptly worsen supply; persistent severe ischemia can then cause myocardial infarction. Pain from transient ischemia does not by itself prove myocardial necrosis.
Other mechanisms include coronary artery spasm, impaired regulation of small coronary vessels, or increased demand in left ventricular hypertrophy, severe aortic stenosis, or tachycardia. Reduced delivery through severe anaemia, low arterial oxygen or low perfusion pressure may provoke symptoms even without a new obstructing plaque. Structural narrowing, vasomotor change, blood oxygen-carrying capacity and cardiac work therefore have to be considered together.[ref]
For an 1865 interpretation, coronary “ossification” or degeneration, diseased cardiac or aortic structures and neural or spasmodic explanations belonged to the historical discussion. These did not establish a single universal cause. A report published in January 1865 described a pathological case associated angina pectoris with diseased coronary arteries, but isolated cases cannot demonstrate that a particular valve or vessel lesion is necessary in every patient.[ref] The modern supply-and-demand account explains why severe symptoms can coexist with relatively inconspicuous large coronary arteries, and why substantial coronary disease need not cause pain at every moment.
A pathological investigation inspects the coronary origins and course, their lumen and wall, the myocardium, the aortic valve and ventricular thickness. Clinical investigation adds evidence of reversible myocardial ischaemia and distinguishes it from infarction or non-cardiac pain. Modern electrocardiography and appropriate imaging address functions that a nineteenth-century post-mortem inspection alone could not measure. A normal-looking vessel on gross inspection cannot exclude coronary microvascular disease or a transient coronary artery spasm.
Original question.
Give the differential diagnosis between Syphilis in the infant, Varicella, Varioloid, and Variola, as usually described.
Infantile syphilis, varicella, modified smallpox and ordinary smallpox are distinguished by the whole illness: age and history, prodrome, distribution, lesion depth, successive crops and the speed of evolution. No isolated “spot” supplies an infallible diagnosis. Varioloid is the historical name for modified smallpox, particularly after vaccination; it is not a synonym for varicella.
In an infant, the relevant syphilis is chiefly congenital syphilis, transmitted during pregnancy. It can be unapparent at birth and declare itself later with persistent nasal discharge or “snuffles,” poor growth, fissuring near the mouth, a copper-coloured maculopapular or peeling eruption, and lesions on palms and soles. Bullae or pustular appearances can occur. Associated hepatosplenomegaly, jaundice and painful bone disease support a systemic process rather than a simple crop of transient vesicles. The eruption is not required to pass synchronously through the stereotyped smallpox sequence. Maternal infection and appropriate serology matter; absence of a rash at birth does not exclude infection.[ref][ref]
Varicella, or chickenpox, typically produces delicate superficial itchy vesicles on a red base, especially on the anatomical trunk, with successive crops. Consequently fresh papules, vesicles and crusts coexist in one area. In children the preceding illness is often mild or absent. Individual lesions evolve quickly, and ordinary superficial lesions usually heal without the deep pitting associated with destructive smallpox lesions, although secondary infection can scar. The distribution is generally centripetal rather than most dense on the distal limbs; palms and soles are much less commonly affected.[ref]
Ordinary variola, or smallpox, classically begins with a marked febrile prodrome, often including headache, backache and prostration, before the rash. Lesions favour the face and extremities, can affect palms and soles, and proceed through firm papules to deep-seated vesicles and pustules, often with central depression. Within a given region they are relatively alike in developmental stage. The lesions evolve over days rather than the rapid successive crops of varicella; crusting and separation may leave depressed scars. Severe confluent, flat or haemorrhagic forms depart from the uncomplicated textbook pattern, so the absence of perfect pustules is not a universal exclusion.[ref][ref]
Varioloid retains the cause of smallpox but has a modified course. Prior vaccination can yield fewer and more superficial lesions, faster evolution and less secondary fever. The prodrome can still be substantial. Sparse lesions and shortened evolution can resemble chickenpox, so vaccination history and the entire time course help, but neither a vaccination scar nor mild disease proves the diagnosis. Varioloid and variola belong on a spectrum of the same infection, whereas varicella is caused by a different virus.[ref]
Thus the characteristic contrast is persistent multisystem infantile infection for congenital syphilis, superficial lesions in mixed-stage crops for varicella, deeper regionally synchronous lesions with a severe preceding fever for ordinary smallpox, and attenuation of the latter pattern for varioloid. Current confirmation uses tests appropriate to the suspected organism; the historical clinical distinctions remain valuable descriptions, but they do not replace modern laboratory confirmation.

Ancestors (9)

  1. Second examination
  2. 1865
  3. Past exam of the medicine course of the University of Oxford
  4. Medicine course of the University of Oxford
  5. Undergraduate course of the University of Oxford
  6. Course of the University of Oxford
  7. University of Oxford
  8. List of universities
  9. Home

Incoming links (3)

View article source

Discussion (0) New discussion

There are no discussions about this article yet.

Articles by others on the same topic (0)

There are currently no matching articles.
See all articles in the same topic Create my own version