Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge / 2016 / Paper 1 / Section C

identical particles have the same intrinsic properties, including mass, charge and spin. Their labels are bookkeeping devices rather than measurable identities. When wave functions overlap, quantum mechanics supplies no observable trajectory that permanently identifies “particle 1” independently of “particle 2”. A many-particle description must therefore treat exchange consistently. The Hamiltonian and physical observables are invariant under relabelling identical particles.

For two particles, the exchange operator obeys ${\hat{P}}_{12}^2=\hat{I}$. The usual three-dimensional symmetrization postulate selects states symmetric under exchange for bosons and antisymmetric for fermions. In relativistic quantum theory, the Spin-statistics theorem associates integer spin with bosons and half-integer spin with fermions under its locality and positivity assumptions; the connection is not derived merely from ${\hat{P}}_{12}^2=\hat{I}$ in elementary nonrelativistic mechanics. For orthonormal one-particle states $u$ and $v$, the two-particle spatial combinations areThe sign concerns the complete state, including spin and other internal variables, not necessarily the spatial factor alone.

The antisymmetric state vanishes if both fermions occupy the same one-particle state: this is the Pauli exclusion principle. For $N$ fermions in orthonormal spin orbitals ${\chi }_j$, the normalized Slater determinant $\Psi =(N!{)}^{-1/2}\det [{\chi }_j(i)]$ supplies the required exchange sign. Bosonic occupation has no corresponding upper limit, and symmetrized products describe many bosons. Fermionic occupation is zero or one per complete one-particle state; two electrons can still occupy the same spatial atomic orbital with opposite spin.

Spin and spatial symmetry are linked. A two-electron spin singlet state is antisymmetric, so its spatial factor must be symmetric. A symmetric triplet state instead requires an antisymmetric spatial factor. Exchange then changes pair correlations and the energies available when interactions depend on particle separation, even without introducing a new classical “exchange force”. It contributes to atomic shell structure, bonding and magnetic behaviour.

In an occupation-number description, bosonic creation and annihilation operators satisfy $[{\hat{a}}_i,{\hat{a}}_j^{†}]={\delta }_{ij}$, whereas fermionic operators satisfy $\{{\hat{c}}_i,{\hat{c}}_j^{†}\}={\delta }_{ij}$ and anticommute among themselves. The latter imply $({\hat{c}}_i^{†}{)}^2=0$. This formalism implements the same exchange constraints without assigning permanent particle labels.

For noninteracting particles in thermal equilibrium, the mean occupation of a state of energy $ϵ$ isFermi-Dirac statistics produces a filled Fermi sea at zero temperature and degeneracy pressure; Bose-Einstein statistics permits macroscopic Ground state occupation when the density of available states and thermodynamic conditions allow condensation. The different statistics therefore have measurable collective consequences, not just different notation.^[ref]

When phase-space occupation is dilute, both distributions reduce to the Maxwell–Boltzmann statistics limit. Likewise, well-separated localized wave packets have negligible overlap and small exchange corrections, so effectively labelled classical trajectories can become a useful approximation. In two spatial dimensions more general exchange statistics are possible; the standard boson/fermion account here concerns ordinary three-dimensional particles and their total states.

For the nonrelativistic Coulomb Hamiltonian with reduced electron-proton mass $\mu$, separation in Spherical coordinate system gives ${\psi }_{n\ell m}(r,\theta ,\varphi )=R_{n\ell }(r)Y_{\ell m}(\theta ,\varphi )$. The quantum numbers obey $n\ge 1$, $0\le \ell \le n-1$ and $-\ell \le m\le \ell$. These are joint eigenstates of energy, $L^2$ and $L_z$, with the latter two eigenvalues $\ell (\ell +1){\hslash }^2$ and $m\hslash$.

The Coulomb bound-state energies and characteristic length areFor example, ${\psi }_{100}=(\pi a_{\mu }^3{)}^{-1/2}{e}^{-r/a_{\mu }}$ is spherically symmetric and has no radial node. In general the radial part contains an exponential times a Generalized Laguerre polynomial, with $n-\ell -1$ radial nodes. The spherical harmonic specifies angular structure and azimuthal phase; real linear combinations of degenerate $m$ states give familiar directional orbitals.

The leading Coulomb energy depends on $n$ alone, giving $n^2$ spatial states for each principal shell, or $2n^2$ including electron spin. Fine structure, Lamb shift and Hyperfine structure lift parts of this ideal degeneracy. An atomic orbital is a probability amplitude, not a classical planetary path.^[ref]

Quantum tunnelling is supported by transport and decay through barriers that classical particles of the same energy cannot traverse. Three complementary examples are:

Together these test barrier penetration in nuclear decay, vacuum-gap transport and semiconductor transport. Their detailed currents depend on state supply and matching as well as the barrier transmission probability.

For the Quantum harmonic oscillator defineThe Canonical commutation relation gives $[\hat{a},{\hat{a}}^{†}]=1$, andThus the creation operator and annihilation operator raise or lower the energy by one quantum. Positivity of ${\hat{a}}^{†}\hat{a}$ and termination of downward stepping give $E_n=\hslash \omega (n+1/2)$, $n=0,1,\dots$. Normalized actions are $\hat{a}|n⟩=\sqrt{n}|n-1⟩$ and ${\hat{a}}^{†}|n⟩=\sqrt{n+1}|n+1⟩$. The annihilated ground state obeysThe nonzero Ground state energy is the zero-point energy, consistent with position-momentum quantum uncertainty. Since $\hat{x}=\sqrt{\hslash /(2m\omega )}(\hat{a}+{\hat{a}}^{†})$, a perturbation linear in position connects only neighbouring number states. The algebra is especially useful for matrix elements and selection rules.^[ref]