Past exam of the physics course of the year 1 of the natural sciences course of the University of Cambridge / 2022 / Section B / 7

The mass and surface area of the spherical droplet are $m=(4\pi /3)\rho r^3$ and $A=4\pi r^2$. Constant surface mass accretion rate $\beta$ meansTherefore $\dot{r}=\beta /\rho =\mu$, and the initial radius givesHere $[\beta ]=\mathrm{kg}{\mathrm{m}}^{-2}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$, $[\rho ]=\mathrm{kg}{\mathrm{m}}^{-3}$, and $[\mu ]=\mathrm{m}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$. This surface-fed growth of an accreting sphere law assumes constant droplet mass density.

Choose downward velocity $v$ positive, and assume the collected material is initially at rest in the cloud's inertial frame. This assumption is required for the equation in the question. During $dt$, momentum conservation for the droplet plus the material it collects givesup to second-order increments. Thus the variable-mass system satisfiesSince $m\propto r^3$, $\dot{m}/m=3\dot{r}/r=3\mu /(r_0+\mu t)$, givingThe notation $dv/dt$ is appropriate because $v$ here depends only on time. The extra term accounts for the momentum needed to accelerate newly collected mass; using $m\dot{v}=mg$ would omit it. For incoming material with downward velocity $u$, the more general equation is $m\dot{v}=mg+(u-v)\dot{m}$.

Set $s=r_0+\mu t$. The proposed velocity and its derivative areThe remaining term in the linear ordinary differential equation isso the sum is exactly $g$. Also $v(0)=g(r_0-r_0)/(4\mu )=0$, establishing both the equation and its initial condition:The integrating factor $(r_0+\mu t{)}^3$ explains where the expression comes from:The result has units of velocity. Its continuous $\mu \to 0$ limit is $gt$, despite the apparent $1/\mu$ in the written expression.

Introduce the dimensionless quantities $\tau =\mu t/r_0$ and $w=\mu v/(g{r}_0)$. ThenThe Taylor series at $t=0$ givesThus the initial slope is $g$, as for free fall. At late times,The oblique asymptote is $v=gt/4+g{r}_0/(4\mu )$, approached from below. Direct differentiation givesThe speed increases monotonically with decreasing slope, from $g$ towards $g/4$. It does not reach a terminal velocity in this drag-free model. Without mass accumulation, and still without drag, a drop released from rest has $v=gt$: its acceleration remains $g$, whereas the growing drop continually shares its momentum with newly acquired material.

An upward drag force $F_D\ge 0$ changes the variable-mass system equation toFor an ordinary drag force increasing with positive speed, the new curve lies below the no-drag curve. It still starts with slope $g$ if $F_D=0$ at rest. The dashed curve illustrates quadratic drag on a sphere with constant radial growth, using $F_D=\frac{1}{2}{C}_D{\rho }_{\mathrm{air}}\pi r^2{v}^2$ with constant drag coefficient $C_D$ and air mass density ${\rho }_{\mathrm{air}}$. The equation for these dimensionless quantities isThe figure uses $\eta =2$ solely to show the shape; it is not an additional datum of the paper.

There is a limitation to the usual terminal velocity sketch here. The examiner's commentary describes a curve approaching terminal velocity, but the paper maintains unbounded radius growth and specifies no drag law. A horizontal limit is justified if one additionally treats the radius as approximately fixed, or otherwise assumes a drag-to-mass ratio with a fixed limiting balance. With the growing radius and constant-$C_D$ quadratic drag just written, the late balance instead givesThis curve flattens in the sense that its slope tends to zero, but its speed remains unbounded. Thus a lower, more strongly flattening curve is warranted; a finite terminal speed requires an additional assumption. The no-growth approximation gives the familiar finite value $v_T=\sqrt{8\rho gr/(3C_D{\rho }_{\mathrm{air}})}$ for a specified fixed radius.^[ref]