Arbitrage Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
An arbitrage is an allowed self-financing portfolio with zero initial wealth, nonnegative terminal portfolio wealth almost surely under the physical probability measure , and strictly positive terminal wealth with positive probability. In a finite model where every state has positive probability, nonnegativity means no loss in any state. Positive expected return alone does not establish arbitrage: losses may still occur.
For the binomial market example, suppose the European call option sells for 13 while its replicating portfolio costs . Sell the call, buy its replicating portfolio, and lend the surplus in the bank account. The initial net cost is zero. At maturity the call obligation and portfolio cancel in either state, leaving . A price below permits the reversed construction, using short selling and borrowing. This is the law of one price made operational; the assumed trading permissions are essential.
In a Brownian complete market with constant coefficients and nonsingular , maximize expected CRRA utility of terminal portfolio wealth divided by a geometric stock index. Writing and , the pointwise marginal condition gives . Its state-price budget constraint determines . Conditional lognormal moments and replication then give the displayed constant dollar fractions. The first term is ordinary optimal risk exposure; the second hedges the random benchmark. The bank holds the remaining fraction, which can be negative when borrowing is allowed.
For unrestricted final portfolio wealth in an -period binomial market, write for the bank growth factor, for absolute risk aversion, and for the binomial-market probability density. The displayed optimizer has the state-price budget constraint . Its exponential utility derivative satisfies for a constant . The concave supporting-tangent inequality bounds any competing expected utility by this value, because the expected linear error is . Strict concavity proves uniqueness, and market completeness supplies replication. The formula is altered by a constraint requiring nonnegative final wealth. With physical up probability and risk-neutral probability , .
A constant-proportion portfolio holds a fixed fraction of its portfolio wealth in the stock. In the Black-Scholes model with bank rate , initial wealth , and no consumption, its value is
The stock holding is and the remaining value is invested in the bank account. The Itô formula verifies when the physical stock drift is .
A consumption satisfaction stock smooths past consumption by . Unlike multiplicative habit utility, the running utility function may depend on this stock alone. A unit of present consumption raises future consumption satisfaction while costing one unit of financial portfolio wealth.
For exponential utility on unrestricted terminal portfolio wealth in the Black-Scholes model, the optimal dollar holding in the stock is the displayed deterministic amount. Set and let be the Brownian motion under the risk-neutral measure. The terminal optimizer is . Its marginal utility is proportional to the state-price density, and the concave supporting-tangent inequality proves global optimality under the state-price budget constraint. The expected utility at the optimum is . A nonnegative-wealth constraint changes this optimizer.
Investment with fixed debt service Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-14
A fixed loan principal contributes a constant interest outflow . If the objective stops when available portfolio wealth reaches zero, the value function has an absorbing boundary . This differs from requiring the portfolio to finance the debt service forever.
With the binary Brownian drift filter, a stock of observed excess drift is driven by the same Brownian motion as its information state . The Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation for portfolio wealth , dollar stock holding and value includes . Consequently . For CRRA utility, homogeneity gives and hence the displayed stock fraction. The second term is intertemporal hedging demand; replacing the unknown drift by its posterior mean while omitting this term does not generally give the optimal policy.
In a complete market with a unit cash asset and normalized strictly positive state-price density , the optimal positive terminal portfolio wealth is whenever it is replicable in the admissible class. The state-price budget constraint is an equality: . The utility conjugate inequality gives for every affordable positive claim. This value can be infinite, because while need not be finite. Even completeness for bounded claims suffices to approximate the value: set and . Each claim is bounded and costs , while its expected logarithmic utility tends to the displayed value by monotone convergence after an integrable lower bound is subtracted.
Logarithmic utility 2026-10-14
Logarithmic utility on positive portfolio wealth has derivative and relative risk aversion one. Its utility conjugate is , since the maximizing wealth is . It satisfies the Inada conditions.
Marginal utility 2026-10-14
The additional utility function obtained per additional unit of consumption or portfolio wealth. For a differentiable utility function it is its derivative; for a concave utility function it is nonincreasing. In a complete-market allocation, equating marginal utility to a multiplier times the state-price density compares the utility benefit of a payoff with its financing cost. The concave supporting-tangent inequality makes this comparison a global optimality certificate rather than only a local first-order condition.
For an integrable discrete trading strategy under an equivalent martingale measure, discounted portfolio wealth plus accumulated discounted strategy payments is a martingale. Conditioning its terminal value gives the displayed identity. A formula involving future payments alone requires terminal liquidation, , or inclusion of that terminal value in the final payment. For an attainable claim paid only at maturity, liquidation yields its usual conditional discounted expected value.
The no-borrowing portfolio constraint is . Net asset returns must be added to the original principal. Thus the two final portfolio wealths are
The expected utility is
The probabilities are those of the investor's beliefs; no risk-neutral measure is being used in this preference calculation.
Risk neutrality means indifference between a random portfolio wealth and its certain expected value. For increasing twice differentiable expected utility preferences, this corresponds to an affine function with on the relevant wealth interval. Maximizing expected utility then amounts to maximizing expected return:
The coefficient of is strictly negative. Consequently the unique optimum is : invest all initial wealth in equity. Risk neutrality here is a preference property, distinct from the pricing use of a risk-neutral measure.
Risk aversion means that a sure mean is preferred to the corresponding risky portfolio wealth. An increasing concave utility function, with and , has this property by the Jensen inequality; strictly concave utility gives strict preference for nondegenerate risks. Differentiating the expected utility from part (a) gives
An interior optimum therefore satisfies
This balances the expected loss of marginal utility in the good state against its expected gain in the bad state. The borrowing constraint also requires checking the endpoints: if , while would require . At both state wealths equal , so
Hence an optimum never puts all wealth into deposits. If , continuity and the displayed endpoint sign give an interior root, and concavity makes every such root globally optimal. Under strict concavity it is unique.
Take bank-account values with , and let the stock multiply independently by or at each step, where . Under the physical probability measure , the up probability is ; the filtration records the successive moves. These assumptions specify the standard binomial market. If lies outside the strict interval , a long or short stock position financed through the bank account gives an arbitrage.
The risk-neutral probability in a binomial market is fixed by , giving
For successor claim values at a node with current stock price , solve the two replication equations. The current stock holding and current cash value are
The cost of this replicating portfolio in a binomial market is
Apply this backward option pricing recursion from any terminal contingent claim , including claims depending on the whole sequence of moves. It constructs a self-financing portfolio and proves market completeness by induction on the remaining number of periods. Taking successive conditional expectations under the measure with independent up probability gives the unique risk-neutral pricing value
Any other price would give an arbitrage by buying the cheaper of the claim and its replica and selling the dearer.
If is the number of up moves, a particular path has probabilities under and under . Therefore the binomial-market probability density, namely the Radon-Nikodym derivative, is
This last expression makes a function of the terminal stock price. Summing over paths gives , and strict positivity proves equivalence of the two probability measures.
For unrestricted terminal portfolio wealth , its initial replication cost is . Hence feasible wealth satisfies the state-price budget constraint . For the stated exponential utility, and . The binomial exponential-utility terminal wealth is
where
It satisfies the budget, and its marginal utility is with . The concave supporting-tangent inequality gives
Taking expectations under makes the last term zero by the budget. Strict concavity makes equality possible only when in every positive-probability state. The already constructed complete market supplies its replicating strategy, so this proves global optimality and uniqueness. The formula allows negative final wealth, as permitted by the unrestricted trading problem.
Write , , and let with . The portfolio holds shares of stock and units of the zero-coupon bond. It is self-financing when all changes of holdings are funded within it, which is the gain identity
Under the physical probability measure, write , where and . The Itô formula gives
Matching the Brownian motion coefficients forces . Since , this is precisely
Differentiating gives . Since , matching the drift coefficients now gives
These are the self-financing conditions for smooth stock and bond holdings. Conversely, substituting both identities into the Itô formula gives the gain identity, so they are sufficient as well. Smoothness and the positive lognormal distribution density of extend the identities along the price process to every , with boundary times obtained by continuity.
The portfolio with constant stock value in bond units must have , so . The first condition then gives , hence
The second condition reduces to . Initial portfolio wealth requires . Therefore the holdings are
The corresponding portfolio wealth is
Under the risk-neutral measure, , so its value in zero-coupon bond units is . This also verifies the self-financing gain equation after using the bond as numéraire.
Specify the trading conventions first. Let the bank account have value , with and its next gross return known at time . Write for the discount factor. Let be the ex-dividend asset-price vector, and the vector of cash dividends paid per unit at time ; set for non-dividend-paying assets. Under an equivalent martingale measure , each discounted cumulative asset gain
is a martingale. Equivalently, . This is the gain-process form of risk-neutral pricing, rather than a martingale assumption on raw ex-dividend prices.
Let be the -measurable holdings after trading and distributions at time . The previous holdings earn the next price change and dividends. Define the strategy's net cash payment and its residual portfolio wealth by
A negative payment is an external infusion; a self-financing portfolio with no consumption has . The discounted budget equation is
Assume these gains and payments are integrable under , for example by bounded predictable holdings and integrable discounted asset gains. Then
is a true martingale, by conditioning the displayed one-step gains. Merely assuming a local martingale without appropriate integrability would not justify the conditional equality.
Conditioning on proves the general multi-period dividend pricing identity
For a strategy liquidated at time , and all liquidation proceeds are included in . The terminal value disappears, giving exactly the requested dividend-only relation. That liquidation convention is necessary: holding one unit of the bank account with no payments would otherwise have a positive left side and zero right side.
An attainable claim paid at can be replicated by a strategy with no earlier payments and final liquidation payment . Its time- value is therefore
Two admissible replicating strategies have the same value by this identity, and the value is the same under every equivalent martingale measure for which the replication gains are true martingales. For unattainable claims this expectation is a possible model price, but the replication argument does not establish a unique price. With density process , the equivalent state-price density form is .
Use the physical dynamics of the Black-Scholes model, , with bank rate and . Write for the market price of risk. If is portfolio wealth, the dollar amount in stock, and the consumption rate, the budget dynamics are
Admissible controls are progressively measurable, locally integrable in the required drift and diffusion norms, and keep . Such a solvency restriction excludes doubling-type strategies. In a complete Brownian market, the investment-consumption problem is to maximize
where the utility functions are increasing and concave. A terminal-only problem omits the integral. Strict concavity gives uniqueness of optimal consumption and terminal wealth when an optimum exists.
The state-price density is
The Itô formula gives
Thus is a nonnegative local martingale, hence a supermartingale, yielding the state-price budget constraint
Conversely, a nonnegative consumption plan and terminal payoff satisfying budget equality and the necessary integrability can be financed in the Brownian complete market. Define
The Brownian martingale representation theorem for the total future budget supplies a stochastic-integral coefficient; comparing it with defines . This reconstructs the wealth equation with . Localization gives the representation for integrable positive budgets when an assumption is not available.
For smooth strictly concave utilities with the usual marginal-utility range, let and be the inverse marginal utility functions. The Lagrange-multiplier solution is
where makes the budget an equality. This is a global argument, not merely formal differentiation: the concave supporting-tangent inequality gives
with the analogous terminal inequality. Taking expectations, integrating, and applying the budget bound makes the difference in objectives nonpositive. Replication of the candidate budget proves attainability and optimality whenever these expectations are well-defined and finite. If the marginal-utility ranges or integrability conditions fail, existence must be established separately rather than inferred from the first-order equations.
A detailed example is constant relative risk aversion utility and , with , , , and . Put
The optimal plans from the marginal-utility equations are and . The normal distribution of gives, for ,
The budget therefore becomes , determining the multiplier explicitly. Independent Brownian increments in the conditional budget formula give . The diffusion coefficient of is , so matching the wealth diffusion determines the dollar stock holding. Consequently the finite-horizon power-utility investment and consumption optimum is
All candidate moments are finite on a finite horizon, since powers of a lognormal state-price density have finite moments. The budget and tangent argument above therefore verify optimality in this example, including admissibility and positive wealth.
For another verification of the formulas, the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation for a value function with discount measured from the current time is
Substitute . The two concave maximizations give the displayed controls, and the remaining equation is with , exactly solved by the formula above. Thus
For , interpret the integral as , so . Unlike the infinite-horizon Merton consumption-investment problem, finite horizons do not require . Consumption vanishes in the terminal-only formulation; then the integral term in is absent and the optimal stock fraction remains . Logarithmic utility is handled directly with inverse marginal utility and the same wealth-to-consumption formula at , with .
Let the bank account be , where is the one-period riskless gross return. In the binomial market, is either or , with and both successors having positive physical probability. The information at time consists of the first moves. A trading strategy chooses its holdings using only this information. A self-financing portfolio funds rebalancing from its current value; there is no external contribution.
Absence of arbitrage requires . If , borrowing to buy the stock yields a nonnegative gain, strictly positive on the up branch; if , shorting the stock and investing its price yields the reverse arbitrage. When , define the risk-neutral probability in a binomial market
Giving each successive up move conditional probability defines an equivalent martingale measure , since every finite path has positive probability and .
For a contingent claim with successor values at a node of current stock value , solve the two replication equations. The number of shares and current cash value are
Then and , so the replicating strategy costs
Hold bank-account units over that period. Starting with the terminal payoff and applying these equations backwards supplies an adapted self-financing strategy replicating every path-dependent contingent claim. This proves market completeness. A different claim price would permit an arbitrage by buying the cheaper claim or replica and selling the dearer one. Iterating the backward pricing relation gives the unique risk-neutral pricing formula
The physical up probability affects real-world frequencies but does not enter this replication price.
For a terminal payoff , write . Its current price is the restriction to the available nodes of the function
If is convex, each summand is convex in and each weight is positive; summing their defining convexity inequalities proves that is convex. This provides an explicit convex extension between the actual stock nodes, so “convex on the nodes” is unambiguous. If is strictly convex, each positive scaling preserves strict convexity, so is strictly convex as well.
For the replicating portfolio in a binomial market, the stock holding is
For , let . The next down and up holdings are the secant slopes of on the adjacent intervals with endpoints :
For any convex function and , its defining inequality at rearranges to . The inequality is strict for a strictly convex function. Applying this to the three stock values orders the two next holdings. Meanwhile the backward pricing relation gives, by subtracting its values at and ,
The coefficients are strictly positive and sum to one. Therefore the current share holding lies between the next two holdings:
Both inequalities are strict for a strictly convex payoff. For an affine payoff the share holding is constant, explaining the required weak interpretation. These are numbers of shares, not the fraction of portfolio wealth invested in the stock.