Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2010 iii Paper 51 2 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Introduce the orthonormal local vectors and . Reexpressing the second state's factors in this basis gives its Schmidt decompositionThe squared Schmidt coefficients are therefore , whereas those of the first state are .
To see directly why these distinguish the states, a local unitary operation changes the reduced density matrix toThis is local-unitary invariance of reduced-state spectra: the unitary on the traced subsystem cancels, and conjugation on leaves its eigenvalues unchanged. Here the reductions areTheir spectra differ. Hence no pair of local unitary operations carries the first state to the second. More generally, normalized bipartite pure states are locally unitarily equivalent exactly when their squared Schmidt coefficients agree, including multiplicities; sufficiency follows by mapping one pair of Schmidt bases to the other.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2010 iii Paper 51 3 b Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
An upper bound follows directly from the Schmidt-tail entanglement monotonewhere is the reduced density matrix of a bipartite pure state. On these two-qubit states, this is the smaller squared Schmidt coefficient, so and .
Here is the average-monotonicity argument needed for all LOCC strategies. The largest eigenvalue is convex: for any unit vector , , and maximizing the left side gives the claim. Hence is concave. If Alice makes a local measurement, Bob's conditional reductions average to his original reduction. Concavity therefore gives . If Bob measures, use Alice's reductions instead. The two reductions of a pure state have the same nonzero eigenvalues by the Schmidt decomposition. Refining all measurement outcomes into individual Kraus operators keeps conditional states pure; iterating the inequality covers adaptive rounds of classical communication. The same bound persists for limits of such protocols.
If success produces the target with probability , its contribution to the final average is . Failure branches have nonnegative . ThusThis is a bound on arbitrary local protocols, not merely on a particular filtering measurement.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 66 1 d Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Interpret the requested measurement as distinguishing all four stated orthogonal eigenstates, hence as their rank-one projective measurement. If they have indistinguishable degenerate eigenvalues, this assumption need not hold; the identity observable, for example, cannot reveal the basis and gives no contradiction.
Let Bob initially prepare . Alice encodes a bit by preparing or , without changing Bob's initial reduced density matrix. If Alice prepares zero, the global input is the first eigenstate, so nondemolition leaves Bob in with certainty. If Alice prepares one, the rank-one Lüders rule, after discarding the outcome, dephases Bob in the rotated basisHis output is . A computational-basis measurement then givesIt is positive for every . Repeating the experiment would transmit Alice's choice across a spacelike interval, violating quantum no-signalling. The controlled-basis measurement causality obstruction therefore excludes the entire nonzero interval, including .
At , the basis is the computational product basis, up to an irrelevant sign on the fourth vector. Alice and Bob each measure locally, then compare their results later. Each product eigenstate is preserved. Thus being a product basis is insufficient for an instantaneous quantum nondemolition measurement: a remote party's choice of which local basis is measured can still cause signalling.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 57 3 c i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Assume the proposed device distinguishes the four displayed eigenstates, as an ideal rank-one projective measurement. This assumption matters: if all four had the same eigenvalue, the identity observable would admit that eigenbasis but its Lüders rule measurement would do nothing and could not signal. The printed eigenvectors alone do not exclude this degeneracy.
For the complete resolving measurement, let , , and be the four rank-one projectors. If the nonlocal outcome is ignored, the nonselective projective measurement channel is . Each listed state's local reduced density matrix is diagonal in , with expectation for either plus state and for either minus state. ConsequentlyCompute in its even and odd two-dimensional blocks: both have diagonal entries and off-diagonal entries . ThusandTo signal, prepare Alice in and Bob initially in . Bob encodes a bit by either doing nothing or applying a local Pauli Z gate, which changes his state to . Alice's input reduced density matrix is identical in both cases, but after the hypothetical instantaneous measurement her local expectation isThe two probabilities for Alice's outcome are , so their difference is . It is strictly positive for . Repeated trials let Alice infer Bob's bit while their operations are still spacelike, violating quantum no-signalling and relativistic causality. The relativistic causality constraint on an ideal nonlocal measurement therefore permits onlywithin the specified interval. The argument requires no rapid communication of the hypothetical nonlocal outcome: Alice reads her own changed local statistics. It rules out the full ideal instrument, not merely the later classical comparison of locally obtained records.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 57 4 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Let . In the Zurek spin-bath model, , so unitary time evolution with is . The bath Hamiltonian terms commute, and device states have eigenvalues . Hencewhere the two normalized conditional bath states areTake each bath factor normalized, , and . This entails no restriction: if only the product is initially normalized, divide each nonzero factor by its norm; the product of these norms is one.
Taking the partial trace over the bath gives the reduced density matrixThe orientation of this conditional environment overlap fixes the sign of the phase in the upper-right entry. Factorizing the overlap yields the decoherence factorThe populations are conserved because . Only phase coherence can be reduced. In particular,Quantum decoherence here results from distinguishable conditional bath states, although the complete system remains in a pure state under unitary time evolution.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 57 4 c i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For these three couplings, the decoherence factor becomesIt is periodic with period . To locate its extrema, put ; then . Its maximum is at , and its minimum is where , namely . The zeros on the displayed interval are . The half-integer zeros are crossings; the zeros at and are double zeros, where the curve touches zero from below.
The finite spin-bath coherence recurrence returns the device to full coherence every two time units. Negative indicates a relative phase change and is not a negative probability. When , the device reduced density matrix becomes diagonal at each zero, but quantum decoherence is not irreversible in this finite bath. The sketch explicitly displays both loss of coherence and its revival.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2014 iii Paper 62 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The Schmidt decomposition theorem states that a normalized vector in a finite-dimensional tensor product has the form , where the two families are orthonormal, , , and . Extending each family to an orthonormal basis for two qubits givesThe nonzero Schmidt coefficients can be made positive by absorbing phases into the basis vectors. Both are positive exactly when the pure state is entangled. A product state has Schmidt rank one, so one coefficient is zero; the source's assertion of two positive coefficients for every pure state needs this exception.
Choose each local orthonormal basis independently as the computational basis. In that basis . This is a local change of coordinates, implemented by separate unitary matrices, rather than a physical restriction on the original quantum state. The associated Pauli operators supply the other two local axes. Up to an irrelevant common phase, each unitary change of qubit basis corresponds to a rotation of its Bloch sphere.
Put . The Schmidt-basis Pauli correlation tensor is diagonal. The Pauli operators exchange and , while do so with minus signs, and leaves both fixed. HenceMixed components vanish: those containing one and one transverse Pauli operator map the occupied basis vectors outside their span, while the and matrix elements are purely imaginary and cancel for real Schmidt coefficients. By bilinearity, for arbitrary real vectors,For a CHSH inequality test take unit quantum measurement axesThese CHSH axes for an entangled pure two-qubit state giveThe local bound is two: for each hidden state, is when all four outcomes are , and averaging cannot increase its absolute value. Thus every entangled pure two-qubit state violates a CHSH inequality, the content of Gisin's theorem. A product state has and does not violate it, so the unqualified final claim in the question is false for that case. The maximum occurs for equal Schmidt coefficients. This excludes local hidden-variable theories satisfying measurement independence, but does not permit faster-than-light signalling: the local reduced density matrix and its quantum measurement probabilities are unchanged by the remote choice of axis.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2015 iii Paper 66 1 iv Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
Use the Schmidt decomposition of the bipartite pure state:The two reduced density matrices, obtained by partial trace, areTheir nonzero eigenvalues are identical, even if the two ambient dimensions differ. Zero eigenvalues contribute no Von Neumann entropy, soThis common Von Neumann entropy is the entanglement entropy of the bipartite pure state.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 323 4 ii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
The coefficient matrix in the computational basis isFor a bipartite pure state, the partial traces give and . Therefore the requested reduced density matrices areThe columns of are orthogonal. Their norms are and , so normalizing them gives the orthonormal setWith and , a Schmidt decomposition isExpanding this expression reproduces the minus sign in the coefficient. The two reduced density matrices both have eigenvalues and , consistent with these Schmidt coefficients.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2016 iii Paper 323 4 i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
For any normalized pure state on finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces , the Schmidt decomposition givesThe and form orthonormal sets in their respective spaces. The positive numbers are the Schmidt coefficients, and is the Schmidt rank. Taking a partial trace gives the reduced density matricesThus the nonzero eigenvalues of the two reduced density matrices agree.
One construction is a singular value decomposition of the coefficient matrix in . If , the columns of give , the complex conjugates of the columns of give , and the singular values give . This also explains why the Schmidt coefficients are real and nonnegative.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 ii Paper 2 15D b Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
Quantum no-signalling says that, without communicating a measurement outcome, any local trace-preserving operation performed on subsystem leaves all outcome probabilities for measurements on subsystem unchanged; equivalently, it leaves the reduced density matrix unchanged.
The two Bell states are orthogonal. Applying the inverse Bell-state preparation circuit, namely a Controlled-NOT gate from to followed by a Hadamard gate on , givesA computational-basis measurement therefore distinguishes them perfectly, soIf only is accessible, however,Every measurement on consequently has the same outcome distribution under both hypotheses. With equal prior probabilities no information is available, andthe error probability of a random guess.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2019 ii Paper 1 10D c Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
No. Before any operation, Bob's reduced density matrix is , independent of . Any trace-preserving operation performed only by Alice leaves Bob's reduced state unchanged when her uncommunicated outcomes are averaged. This is the no-communication theorem, or quantum no-signalling.
If Bob received the unknown state, his reduced state would instead be the pure state , which depends on Alice's input. That would let Alice signal by choosing different inputs, contradicting no-signalling. The two classical outcome bits are therefore essential.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2021 iii Paper 323 1 a i Solution 2026-09-28
The Schmidt decomposition states that every finite-dimensional bipartite pure state haswhere , , and the two displayed families are orthonormal. The integer is the Schmidt rank.
To prove it, choose product bases and writeApply the singular value decomposition . Absorbing the columns of and the complex conjugates of the columns of into new orthonormal bases gives the stated sum, with the nonzero singular values as the Schmidt coefficients. Equivalently, are the common nonzero eigenvalues of the two reduced density matrices, so .
Arrange the amplitudes of as the matrixThe second state has , where swaps the basis states. If Bob receives , his two reduced density matrices areand are identical. No measurement on contains any information about the shared state.
If Bob instead receives ,They differ because . Bob can therefore distinguish them with better-than-random success. For equal priors,so the optimal success probability is . It is generally below one, so a single copy does not permit certain identification.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2021 ii Paper 3 10D Solution Created 2026-09-23 Updated 2026-09-25
Without Alice's operation, Bob obtains outcome with probabilityIf Alice applies and then measures, but her outcome is not communicated, Bob's probability isbecause . Equivalently, a trace-preserving local operation leaves Bob's reduced density matrix unchanged. This is the no-communication theorem: local operations cannot signal without communication of their outcomes.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2022 iii Paper 325 2 Solution 2026-09-28
The pure state is entangled when it cannot be written as a product state , equivalently when its Schmidt rank exceeds one. Its subsystem states are the reduced density matriceswhere the partial trace is characterized by for every observable .
Let Bob's measurement have Kraus operators satisfying . If Alice does not learn Bob's random outcome, her state after the measurement isThis no-communication theorem means that Bob can change Alice's conditional state after she learns his outcome, but cannot change any local outcome distribution available to her alone. Standard nonrelativistic quantum mechanics is therefore operationally compatible with the prohibition of superluminal signalling in special relativity, despite its nonlocal conditional-state updates.
An exact nondisturbing state readout would destroy this protection if it reported the globally collapsed state on an absolute-time slice. For example, Alice and Bob may share Bell states. At a prearranged time Bob encodes a bit by measuring his qubit in either the computational or Hadamard basis. The usual projection postulate assigns Alice respectively one of or one of . A device returning the exact pure state lets Alice identify which basis Bob chose without waiting for his outcome, producing a superluminal signal. Equivalently, Bob may choose whether to measure, and the device distinguishes the resulting proper pure state from the original improper maximally mixed local state.
A causal alternative is a quantum state readout device located at a spacetime point that reports the local quantum state under objective collapse: take reduced states on spacelike hypersurfaces through and let those hypersurfaces approach the past light cone of . The result includes localized collapses in and excludes spacelike-separated collapses. This assumes a fixed Minkowski spacetime, localized collapse events, ordinary local unitary dynamics between them, and outputs that may control only operations in their causal future. The postulate is logically consistent because it adds a classical record of this local state without changing the state or any standard measurement probability. It also cannot support an indirect signalling algorithm. Inductively through the algorithm's events, every readout at depends only on operations, collapses, and earlier readouts in ; any operation selected from that output lies in the readout's future light cone. Composing readouts, unitary evolutions, and measurements therefore never carries a controllable dependence outside a future light cone, so relativistic causality is preserved.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2023 ii Paper 2 10D a Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
Expanding either Bell state and using removes the cross terms:Thus the two expectation values agree. Equivalently, both states have the same reduced density matrix on qubit ; the positivity of makes it a possible measurement effect but is not needed for the algebraic equality.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2023 ii Paper 4 33B b Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-25
For , tracing out subsystem 2 gives the reduced density matrixwhich is pure, so its entanglement entropy is zero.
For , the two subsystem-2 factors in part (iii) are orthogonal. The partial trace therefore removes the cross terms and givesIts nonzero eigenvalues are and , so the Von Neumann entropy isWhen , both eigenvalues are and , the maximal entropy for a rank-two reduced state.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2024 iii Paper 325 1 Solution Created 2026-09-28 Updated 2026-10-03
Let a projective measurement have mutually orthogonal projections satisfying . On a density operator , the Born rule and the Lüders rule giveconditional on outcome . On the first part of a bipartite quantum system, replace by .
The subsystems are isolated when there is no interaction term coupling them. Their Hamiltonian operator has the formso their subsequent unitary time evolution factorizes as .
The reduced density matrix of subsystem 1 iswhere the partial trace is characterized byfor every local observable . Thus contains exactly the statistics accessible by measurements on subsystem 1.
Suppose a projective measurement is performed on subsystem 2 and its outcome is not communicated. The resulting nonselective state isFor every , the cyclic property of the trace and giveHence . No local projective measurement on subsystem 1 can reveal whether the remote unreported measurement occurred. This is quantum no-signalling, which prevents a choice made at a spacelike separation from transmitting information faster than light and makes the measurement formalism compatible with relativistic causality.
The proposed nondisturbing device would violate no information without disturbance. In an ordinary quantum instrument, let be the Kraus operators associated with classical output . If every pure state remains unchanged even conditional on the displayed outcome, every nonzero must be parallel to . A linear operator for which every vector is an eigenvector is a scalar multiple of the identity, so . Its output probabilityis independent of the state. It cannot equal for arbitrary projectors. Equivalently, repeated nondisturbing samples would permit quantum state tomography of one specimen and then quantum cloning, contradicting ordinary quantum theory.
Such devices would not necessarily enable superluminal signalling. One consistent operational extension could make every sequence of outputs depend only on the local reduced density matrix and local settings. Since an unreported remote measurement leaves that matrix unchanged, all local device statistics would remain unchanged too. Other extensions could add nonlocal outcome-dependent rules and permit signalling, but that behavior is additional to the device specification rather than forced by it.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2024 iii Paper 343 2 b Solution Created 2026-09-28 Updated 2026-10-03
The Quantum de Finetti theorem says that the fixed- reduced density matrix of an exchangeable -particle state approachesas . Finite versions bound the trace norm error by a constant of order . On a bipartite lattice, the corresponding two-sublattice form is a mixtureThis is the mean-field ansatz from the quantum de Finetti theorem.
The bond energy is a linear functional of . A convex combination cannot have energy below its lowest product component, so it remains only to minimizeThe Cauchy-Schwarz inequality gives , with equality for pure antiparallel vectors. This reproduces the Néel state and per bond found in part (a).
Yes. The limiting state saturates the de Finetti mean-field lower bound: the minimizing product state belongs to the allowed de Finetti mixture, and the finite-de-Finetti error tends to zero as . At finite the theorem gives only an approximation; entanglement and correlated fluctuations can lower the energy below the product-state value by corrections that vanish in the infinite-coordination limit.
