Work in the frame in which the distant fluid is stationary, and take the pressure at infinity as zero. In the Unscaled Papkovich–Neuber representation, choose the harmonic potentials
Both are harmonic away from the sphere's centre: is harmonic there and . Substitution into , , gives the translating sphere in Stokes flow:
Here . At the coefficients of sum to one and those of sum to zero, so the no-slip boundary condition is satisfied. The field decays at infinity. The Papkovich–Neuber representation enforces the Stokes equation and incompressibility, and Uniqueness of Stokes flow identifies the physical solution.
Differentiate radially at fixed direction :
On the surface, multiplying the specified Newtonian fluid stress tensor by the outward normal from the solid gives
Thus the surface traction in translating-sphere Stokes flow is uniform and the fluid's force on the sphere is
This is the Stokes drag law; an external force of the opposite sign maintains the motion.
For stable shear-driven turbulence, let be the rate of production of turbulent kinetic energy by mean shear and the rate consumed by buoyancy work. The Flux Richardson number is
With an upward coordinate and vertical turbulent buoyancy flux , , while shear production is . In a locally steady balance without net turbulent-energy transport or storage, , so and the dissipation-normalized mixing coefficient is . A global ratio need not equal this local production-normalized Flux Richardson number when energy transport, storage, or bulk acceleration is important.
The interfacial Richardson number in this tank is
In model S,
Thus the relative importance of interface stratification changes continually. If mixing efficiency depends on interfacial Richardson number, constant is not generally self-consistent over substantial deepening; it can at best describe a regime where that dependence is weak. In model K,
A local efficiency depending only on this ratio can therefore remain constant, provided the fixed interface thickness and the other empirical coefficients remain appropriate.
The energetic reason to expect intermediate behavior is that entrainment must both lift and homogenize dense fluid and mobilize it. The whole upper-layer kinetic energy budget has the form , apart from additional boundary losses. Keeping the characteristic speed constant makes and requires a continuing power supply to accelerate new fluid, together with dissipation in an ever larger layer. Keeping constant instead forces the speed to decline as . A finite lid forcing plausibly produces an initial regime near the former and a deeper regime near the latter, rather than indefinite constant-speed entrainment.
One can make this expected bracket quantitative after matching the models' initial interface speed . Suppose the actual speed lies between and , and the same local coefficients are used. Set . Then
Integrating these inequalities gives
Equivalently, if with , the local power closure yields a late-time depth exponent between and . This is the intended energetic interpolation between K and S, not a universal bound following from the printed assumptions alone. Different efficiencies or unmatched initial coefficients can invalidate pointwise ordering; quantitative prediction requires the lid-to-interface power transfer and the actual energy budget.
Under the Boussinesq approximation, total upper-layer kinetic energy is , where is its volume root-mean-square speed. For solid-body rotation of angular speed , direct radial averaging gives , consistent with that energy expression. A constant implies . Define to obtain the fixed-energy turbulent mixed layer relation
With , the interfacial power model for entrainment used in (b) gives
Multiply by and integrate from . This yields
The fixed-energy two-layer entrainment law is therefore
Here uses the same lid-speed normalization as part (b). All numerical geometry factors depend on the chosen characteristic stress/speed convention. The formula ceases to apply once .
The exponent requires the local power to decrease as . It does not follow from constant upper-layer kinetic energy and a fixed fraction of unspecified lid power alone. For example, an imposed constant shaft power together with a constant fraction going to potential energy would give constant , not this exponent. The appropriate distinction between local interface power and global forcing appears explicitly in the primary study Entrainment and mixed layer dynamics of a surface-stress-driven stratified fluid, equations (3.6)–(3.7); the calculations above use that local interpretation.
To connect the prescribed interfacial drag coefficient to the energy supply, state the lumped interfacial power model for entrainment explicitly:
It estimates the power transmitted by lid-driven flow to the mixing interface. Constant geometric and transfer factors are included in or . It is the local stress-power interpretation required for the depth laws in this question, not an identity equating arbitrary lid shaft power to interfacial power. With the potential energy of two-layer entrainment from (a),
In model S, and are constant, so
Thus the depth increases at a constant rate proportional to the inverse bulk Richardson number, with , until the layer reaches . Here the prescribed must be read as a characteristic speed. Literal pure solid-body rotation has zero radial velocity, so the PDF's parenthetical description of as radial cannot simultaneously be a strict component statement and the assumption .
If the phrase about lid work is taken literally as shaft power , the interfacial stress alone does not specify the lid torque or its energy transfer to the interface. The preceding closure is therefore a visible model assumption, not a hidden consequence of solid-body rotation.
Let and . The closed tank has constant mass, so
Therefore . Under the Boussinesq approximation, define and obtain
The gravitational potential energy is especially easy to evaluate with the stipulated downward depth coordinate: the gravitational potential per unit mass is . Hence
This proves the potential energy of two-layer entrainment relation
The positive sign expresses the lifting and homogenization of dense entrained fluid within the upper layer. The fixed thin interface is neglected in this leading two-layer energy integral.
The eddy viscosity in the prescribed mixing length model is
Thus at a fixed similarity coordinate , every nonzero value grows as . Its maximum occurs at a fixed coordinate maximizing , so the maximum itself has the same downstream scaling.
The formal argument intended by the edge assumption is also clear. If one independently stipulates for , then . This would put the maximum eddy viscosity at the edge and give
independent of , provided . That is a conditional scaling calculation, not an admissible solution of the full momentum problem.
The printed edge claim fails for the reason established in part (e): forces , and therefore
A nontrivial profile has positive eddy viscosity in the interior; hence its maximum cannot occur at that finite free edge. Moreover has a zero denominator, so it is not a finite effective Reynolds number under the literal assumptions.
The intended downstream cancellation is valid if one uses a consistent interior reference point with , for example the maximum of . Since and ,
which is independent of . This is a qualified correction of the reference point, not a proof of the false edge maximum.
First derive the formal turbulent plane jet similarity equations, then check the printed edge conditions. Define a streamfunction by , , so mean incompressibility is automatic. Momentum conservation gives . With , the closure balance gives . Hence and the consistent self-similar ansatz is
An odd gives symmetric and antisymmetric . Direct differentiation gives
The advection and Reynolds stress terms become
Thus the two required consistency equations, the first for and the second for a symmetric finite-width profile, are
The second is momentum normalization; it is the equation referenced as (2) in the PDF, although its display in part (d) has no printed number. Use an infinite upper limit for a decaying profile of infinite support. Symmetry sets . A finite centreline velocity and continuous zero centreline stress give the integrated first equation
These equations establish the similarity reduction. They also give a direct finite-edge stress condition for a mixing-length jet. At a finite edge , requires . For finite , the integrated equation forces . A nontrivial decreasing velocity profile has nonzero shear somewhere inside, so zero edge shear cannot be its maximum. Allowing a one-sided nonzero edge shear instead produces nonzero edge stress and an unbalanced jump in the conservative momentum equation.
For a concrete diagnostic, take on , so . It has zero edge velocity and its largest one-sided shear magnitude at the edge, matching that descriptive condition. Yet at the integrated equation has left-hand side zero and right-hand side : such a profile is not a solution of the stated momentum closure.
The centreline is also problematic for a smooth interpretation. If , then , and the decreasing branch of the integrated equation gives
A continuous formal profile can have this cusp, but it is not a differentiable symmetric velocity field, and molecular diffusion cannot be neglected uniformly in that core. Therefore there is no nontrivial regular similarity solution satisfying all the printed edge requirements. The boxed consistency equations are valid; the additional coincidence of a zero-velocity edge with maximum shear is not. A consistent jet model must relax that edge definition and regularize the core or use a different mixing length.
Use mean incompressibility to convert advection into momentum-flux divergence:
Therefore the reduced Reynolds-averaged momentum equation gives
For a localized free jet, and the Reynolds stress tend to zero in the quiescent ambient as . Assume sufficient decay to differentiate its momentum integral. Integrating across the jet gives
Thus is constant. It is a specific momentum flux per unit span: multiplication by density gives the momentum flux. A clipped profile with nonzero stress just inside its artificial edge would fail this boundary-flux assumption unless an additional external momentum source were supplied.
The proposed mixing length can be motivated as a local phenomenological estimate: on either half of a self-similar jet, the centreline supplies a distinguished reference plane, and an eddy at distance might retain momentum over a fixed fraction of that transverse distance. This gives
It is compatible with the dilation , and introduces no independent outer length. In the turbulent plane jet similarity regime its typical value at is , so the scaling from part (b) has .
This argument is a modeling assumption, not a physical necessity: a jet centreline is not a wall that prevents turbulent eddies from crossing it. Thus a mixing length vanishing there cannot automatically be justified throughout the core. Parts (e) and (f) exhibit the precise difficulty: the resulting finite-velocity similarity profile has singular centreline shear and zero shear at a finite free edge, contradicting the printed edge definition. The local dimensional motivation does not make all the stipulated global jet properties consistent.
Let be the streamwise evolution scale, the jet width, and its velocity scale. A slender jet has ; mean incompressibility gives . Both mean advection terms are then . For turbulent parcels crossing a transverse distance , retention of their original streamwise momentum gives a fluctuation ; a comparable transverse fluctuating speed gives the down-gradient mixing length closure
The mixing length is an effective distance of momentum retention, with statistical coefficients absorbed into ; it is not the net transverse displacement of a mean streamline. This closure models the Reynolds stress rather than deriving it exactly.
In a slender equilibrium jet, the fluctuation magnitude inferred from momentum balance is . The transverse Reynolds stress gradient then has size , whereas the streamwise normal-stress gradient is . At sufficiently high Reynolds number, molecular transverse diffusion is smaller provided
Streamwise molecular diffusion is smaller still by . A free jet has ambient mean pressure constant to leading order; transverse momentum corrections imply only a higher-order mean streamwise pressure force. Thus high speed must be accompanied by the slender-jet ordering, not used alone to discard every other term.
For a symmetric jet decreasing away from the centre, on and on . Accordingly off the centreline, and the leading equation is
At the centreline the signed form requires the stress to tend continuously to zero; otherwise differentiation would add a distributional term. The undifferentiated Reynolds stress form is the appropriate global equation.
Let the Eulerian time average commute with space and time derivatives and let the statistically steady mean have no time derivative. Define , , and , so . Averaging instantaneous incompressibility gives
and subtracting gives for the fluctuations. Start from the instantaneous streamwise Navier-Stokes equation
Use incompressibility to write . The averaged products are and . The mean conservative terms reduce back to because . The Reynolds-averaged momentum equation is consequently
The signs use the positive covariance convention for the Reynolds stress. In particular, both quadratic averages involve the fluctuations, not products of the mean with a fluctuation; the converted TeX loses the overbar/hat structure here.
The Padé approximant of the exponential is . Replacing each exponential in its original order gives the split Crank-Nicolson method
with the analogous definition for . Operationally, first solve the substep and then the substep. The matrices , are invertible for every , since are symmetric negative definite.
An orthonormal eigenbasis of diagonalizes . Its eigenvalue for is
Therefore , and similarly . Submultiplicativity gives the contractivity of split Crank-Nicolson diffusion:
No commutativity or simultaneous diagonalization is needed for this product bound. This proves unconditional discrete stability, not positivity of every stencil weight or unconditional maximum-norm monotonicity. Nor do the individually second-order rational substeps make the ordered splitting second order: when , its leading splitting defect remains .
Put and , keeping the spatial grid fixed for the temporal error assertion. The matrix exponential expansions give
Hence the Lie-Trotter splitting commutator error is
The energy estimate from part 1 makes , and contractions, so both and have norm at most one. Telescope their th powers:
For , this gives
Thus the Lie-Trotter splitting has global temporal error . The constant here may depend on the fixed spatial operators; a mesh-uniform joint-limit error estimate needs additional regularity and commutator bounds. If and commute, this particular exponential splitting is exact, but variable diffusion coefficients generally remove that commutativity.
Write and collect only the interior values, so the actual vector dimension is . The PDF's matrix size and its indices are inconsistent with the declared interior grid ; neither affects the following stability argument when the interior indexing is used consistently.
Use the discrete L2 norm , extending by zero to the boundary. Let be the horizontal flux operator and the vertical one. Each face coefficient is shared by its two adjacent grid values, so summation by parts gives
All boundary-face terms are included. Positivity of makes symmetric negative definite on the interior grid: zero in either energy sum forces each corresponding grid line to be constant, and its zero boundary endpoint forces that constant to vanish. Consequently
This bound is independent of the spatial mesh, proving semidiscrete stability. No time integrator or time-step restriction has yet been introduced.
The tableau as printed is not a collocation tableau. Its second stage row is , whose sum is , while the corresponding printed node is . This violates the collocation tableau row-sum identity. The original PDF confirms this coefficient; it is not only a TeX transcription defect.
The required integrated basis at nodes is
so direct integration gives
Thus replacing the last stage coefficient by gives the intended two-stage Radau IIA collocation method. Its quadrature moments are
It integrates quadratics exactly but not cubics, so the collocation order theorem gives order three. Independently, , confirming the remaining third-order Butcher order condition.
For completeness the literal printed Runge-Kutta method has only order one. For the autonomous equation , the Taylor expansion of its stability function begins
whereas . Since , it is consistent, but this discrepancy already rules out order two. Therefore neither the requested equivalence nor the third-order conclusion is true without the stated coefficient repair.
The collocation order theorem identifies the classical order with the order of its interpolatory quadrature. If integrates every polynomial of degree at most exactly, but fails for some polynomial of degree , then the collocation method has order for sufficiently smooth differential equations and the local implicit stage branch. With nodes, .
Equivalently, put . If its first moments vanish,
and the next does not, then . Polynomial division explains the quadrature part: any polynomial through degree is a remainder of degree below plus times a polynomial of degree below . The remainder is integrated exactly by interpolation, and the remaining integral vanishes. Conversely a nonzero next moment is an explicit failed quadrature test. The differential-equation order assertion is the collocation theorem being stated here. In particular Gauss collocation methods achieve , Radau IIA methods achieve , and endpoint-including Lobatto IIIA methods achieve for .
Let be the Lagrange interpolation basis. Set and . Since is a polynomial of degree at most , the collocation conditions give
Integrate from zero to and to one to obtain
These are the stage and update equations of a Runge-Kutta method with nodes . Conversely, stages satisfying these equations reconstruct by integrating the displayed interpolation polynomial, so the equivalence works in both directions. Because , they also satisfy the collocation tableau row-sum identity .
For and step , a collocation Runge-Kutta method constructs a polynomial of degree at most on satisfying
The step value is . Thus the differential equation holds exactly at the prescribed collocation nodes, while the initial value fixes the integration constant. For a smooth vector field and small enough , the implicit stage equations have the local solution branch continuing the zero-step initial state; arbitrary large steps need not have a unique nonlinear solution.
Use von Neumann stability analysis on the infinite grid. For the Fourier mode , the semidiscrete eigenvalue is
Its real part is nonpositive for every frequency. The mode evolves by , whose modulus does not grow. The discrete Fourier transform and Parseval identity therefore yield
with a bound independent of , where . Hence the semidiscrete method is stable. Frequencies with are nondissipative rather than unstable.
The same sign can be seen directly by summation by parts: the centred operator is skew-adjoint, and for the unitary shift ,
This is an energy version of the dissipative second-order forward advection stencil. A subsequent time integrator would need its own stability condition; semidiscrete stability does not assert that every fully discrete method is stable.
Put . The spatial operator is the sum of a centred difference and a dissipative second-order forward advection stencil in . For a smooth function, their Taylor expansions give
Thus the leading spatial local truncation error is , generally nonzero. The semidiscretization is second order in space. Time has not yet been discretized, so there is no separate time order or time-step condition at this stage.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact