Assume and zero initial cavity amplitude. Taking Laplace transforms gives
Eliminating the mode yields the passive cavity input-output transfer function
Its unique pole is , so the cavity's internal mode decays and its causal input-output response is stable. A nonzero initial amplitude would add to the output, a decaying transient.
For a precise Nyquist stability criterion interpretation of this open cavity, rewrite the mode equation as an integrator with negative state feedback. Its return ratio is , and its characteristic equation is . The frequency locus lies on the imaginary axis. The Nyquist indentation excluding the pole at the origin maps to a large semicircle in the right half-plane; the whole contour has no winding around . There are no right-half-plane open-loop poles within that indented contour, so there are no unstable characteristic zeros. There is also no zero-frequency characteristic root, since the physical characteristic polynomial is . This recovers asymptotic stability.
Do not use the plant as a return ratio without specifying an additional feedback connection. Indeed
and its locus passes through at . That would indicate a marginal mode for a new unity-negative-feedback loop with characteristic factor , but not instability of the original cavity. Part (e) supplies the actual return ratio for the beam-splitter network.
The deterministic law cannot be transplanted unchanged into measurement-based quantum feedback. Evaluating its state-dependent scalar requires knowledge of the current quantum state. In fact is the expectation value of a Hermitian observable, but that expectation cannot be obtained exactly from a single system without measurement backaction. Tomography uses many independently prepared copies, not a nondisturbing readout of one evolving state.
Continuous weak measurements can supply a noisy record and a conditional state estimate, but then the state follows stochastic measurement dynamics with additional disturbance and decoherence, rather than the closed unitary equation used in part (a). A new stochastic stability analysis is required. One may instead simulate the corrected Lyapunov quantum control from known initial data and apply its waveform as open-loop control, or learn a pulse across repeated experiments as in Question 3. Those procedures do not constitute real-time state feedback on a single quantum trajectory. The separate source error in part (a) remains: even ideal knowledge of the state would not make its printed overlap law monotone.
The feedback law printed in the PDF is not sufficient for the asserted monotonicity. We first derive the exact identity, then give a counterexample and the corrected law. Both density operators evolve unitarily, so and are constant. Thus
Cyclicity of the trace gives . These drift terms cancel in the derivative of the overlap, leaving
Here is real: is Hermitian, and the trace of the product of two Hermitian matrices is real. This is the Hilbert-Schmidt Lyapunov feedback identity.
For a direct counterexample to the source's overlap law, take , , and . All are admissible qubit operators and states. The printed overlap is , but gives . Hence : the distance initially increases. This proves that feedback based on state overlap need not be stabilizing.
The intended Lyapunov quantum control replaces the overlap by its control-direction derivative:
The conclusion is nonincrease, not strict decrease or automatic convergence. For example, opposite computational-basis pure states, diagonal , and give and zero control even though . Target convergence requires further invariant-set and reachability conditions. A target with a different spectrum is also inaccessible under Quantum Hamiltonian evolution. The density-operator derivatives in the governing equations use the dots visible in the PDF, which the TeX loses.
A 4f pulse shaper supplies an experimental realization of spectral pulse shaping. A first diffraction grating separates the frequencies of a broadband coherent pulse; a lens maps them to distinct transverse positions in its back focal plane. Place an amplitude-and-phase mask, or calibrated spatial light modulator with appropriate polarization optics, in that Fourier plane. A second lens and grating recombine the shaped spectrum into one output beam. The original schematic below shows the frequency channels and the four focal-length separations.
Figure 1.
Original 4f spectral pulse-shaping schematic showing dispersing and recombining gratings, two lenses, and a frequency-resolved complex mask
. Details.
If the mask is , then . In principle choose wherever the input spectrum is nonzero and recover the temporal waveform by inverse Fourier transform. Set the desired real physical field by conjugate symmetry of its positive and negative frequency components; its envelope and carrier phase implement the optimized control in the appropriate interaction frame.
A passive mask cannot amplify spectral components or create frequencies absent from the input, so the desired waveform must respect available bandwidth and may need overall rescaling or amplification elsewhere. Finite spectral resolution limits the useful temporal window, while total bandwidth limits the shortest temporal features. A phase-only modulator cannot in general implement independent amplitude and phase shaping without extra optics. These are hardware admissibility constraints, not corrections supplied by the variational calculation after the fact.
For a concrete variational method, maximize the terminal-observable objective with a fluence penalty,
where weights the control cost. Enforce the dynamics with a complex costate and the real augmented functional
Variation of restores the state equation. Integrate the variation by parts; because , the terminal coefficient gives , and the interior coefficient gives
This equation has final data, so it is integrated backward. Variation of the real control gives the variational costate gradient for Hamiltonian quantum control
In particular an unconstrained stationary pulse satisfies . The state, adjoint and control equations form a coupled two-boundary-value problem, so the stationarity formula is not an independent explicit solution for .
Use direct-adjoint looping: start from an admissible pulse, propagate the state forward, set the terminal costate, propagate it backward, compute the gradient on the time grid, and update the pulse with an ascent step and line search. Project amplitude bounds and impose bandwidth constraints within the parametrization or update. Repeat until the projected gradient is small. For gate objectives the forward variable is the propagator and the costate is matrix-valued; for mixed-state objectives it is the density operator. Gradient ascent pulse engineering applies the same efficient forward/backward differentiation to time-slice amplitudes. The variational conditions identify local stationary controls and require numerical convergence checks; they do not prove global optimality of a nonconvex control landscape.
In adaptive experimental quantum control, parametrize a reproducible pulse by a finite real vector , for example in a calibrated waveform basis. Prepare the same initial state for each trial, apply that pulse without feedback during the run, and estimate the objective from repeated measurements. No accurate dynamical model is required if the laboratory can evaluate the objective.
One concrete algorithm is experimental finite-difference gradient ascent. For every parameter, run trials at and estimate
Update to an admissible projection of , test the new pulse, and reduce the step size if performance deteriorates. Averaging many shots controls statistical noise; choose large enough for the difference to exceed the measurement uncertainty but small enough to approximate a derivative. Repeat until no statistically significant improvement remains. Multiple starting pulses help explore distinct basins, but this does not guarantee a global optimum. Resource penalties and hardware restrictions belong in the objective or the admissible parameter set.
The feedback is across experimental runs: a measured objective chooses the next pulse. Each individual trial is open-loop control. This distinction matters because the algorithm does not require an instantaneous nondestructive state measurement on the system being controlled.
Use pulse areas in the convention , with the other channel switched off for a single-channel pulse. Substituting into part (c) shows
Here the arguments denote area and phase. For , the off-diagonal factors are and . For , the phase reverses those two signs. Thus these choices implement the gates exactly on all basis states, not only on one population.
To implement , let and and apply channel 1, channel 2, then channel 1 again. Each active swap contributes , so direct tracking gives
Hence , including the overall minus sign and middle-state phase actually printed in the PDF. Alternatively equal zero-phase envelopes give , where . Since , its exponential is . One simultaneous pulse with gives .
For population transfer alone, the two zero-phase pulses followed by take , so the target population is exactly one. If a positive final amplitude is desired, phases give . Both choices require area on each channel.
For each fixed phase , the single-transition Quantum Hamiltonian is , so its generators at different times commute. Its exact propagator depends only on . On the active two-level subspace, ; on the spectator state, . Thus it is an embedded two-level quantum rotation, not an involution on the whole three-dimensional space. Explicitly,
The spectator entries in both matrices are exactly one; the converted TeX damages the second matrix, so these entries use the PDF.
The proposed combined exponential is false in general for two independent envelopes. Direct multiplication gives
so
The constant pulse-axis condition for removing time ordering holds if both envelopes are proportional to the same function, but not for generic independent controls. For example, turn on only the first transition, then only the second. The result is , whose Baker--Campbell--Hausdorff formula includes a nonzero commutator correction, rather than simply .
There is also a literal source defect: the PDF's right-hand exponent omits the factor on its second term. With it would give , which has eigenvalues and is not unitary for real nonzero , whereas the true propagator is unitary. Even after repairing that missing factor, time ordering is still necessary unless the commutators vanish.
The Pauli matrices obey and , so has . Its entries are and , with zero diagonal. Substitute this matrix into the involution exponential formula:
The drive phase selects the transverse rotation axis, while the quantum pulse area selects its rotation angle.
From , induction gives and . The matrix exponential converges absolutely in finite dimension, so its even and odd terms may be separated:
This involution exponential formula requires no Hermiticity assumption on . Hermiticity is needed if the exponential is additionally asserted to be unitary.
With , the free propagator is . If are its Quantum Hamiltonian eigenvalues, conjugation multiplies the matrix element of by . Therefore the interaction picture Quantum Hamiltonian is
Opposite off-diagonal phases are complex conjugates, as required by Hermiticity. The upper – element has the opposite phase sign to the upper – element because the middle level lies above both outer levels.
Differentiate . The free propagator satisfies , so the Schrödinger equation gives
Thus the interaction picture removes the drift and gives , with . The transformed control Quantum Hamiltonian is time-dependent even though the original control matrix is constant.
For , direct multiplication gives and . It is therefore a dark state of a driven Hamiltonian for every real control, and
Starting from this state, the reachable physical ray is a singleton, so it cannot be transferred to or any distinct ray. More generally commutes with both generators; hence is conserved. The system thus fails full-qutrit pure-state controllability, density operator controllability, and unitary operator controllability.
This is the appropriate full-space meaning of the PDF's phrase about all senses of controllability. It does not preclude control within a restricted invariant subspace: the bright state couples to with strength , while the dark line is isolated. The bright and dark state reduction of a star-coupled Hamiltonian makes that invariant decomposition explicit.
Assume piecewise-constant real controls with freely chosen duration, as in the usual finite-dimensional quantum controllability theorem. We can establish the strongest notion here: the Dynamical Lie algebra is , so the system has unitary operator controllability, and consequently both pure-state and fixed-spectrum density operator controllability.
To verify the hypotheses explicitly, use matrix units and put , , . Then and
Since and , linear combinations of these two elements isolate and . Their commutators with give and , respectively. Further commutators give two independent traceless diagonal generators, since , as well as the two – generators. These eight generators span the special unitary Lie algebra .
Finally . Subtract its traceless component, already in the generated algebra, to obtain a nonzero multiple of . This proves the Lie algebra of the unitary group is all of , not merely . The compact-group controllability theorem then gives access to every unitary with a suitable control and some duration. This does not assert controllability at every predetermined short time or under additional bandwidth constraints. This proves that two adjacent transitions generate the qutrit unitary Lie algebra.
A reachable set contains all states attainable from a specified initial state by admissible control inputs in the allowed times, and controllability means that every target in the declared state space is reachable from every initial state. For a closed quantum control system, distinguish pure-state controllability on state rays, density operator controllability on fixed-spectrum unitary orbits, and unitary operator controllability for entire propagators. State engineering asks for a particular state transfer; process engineering asks for an entire quantum gate, which must act correctly on every input. A closed Hamiltonian evolution preserves density-operator eigenvalues, so arbitrary mixed states of different spectra cannot be connected even by a fully operator-controllable system.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact