If generate the module , define the R-module homomorphism
This is a surjection by the definition of generation. Conversely, an R-module homomorphism that is a surjection sends the standard basis vectors of the free module to a generating family, since every vector in is their linear combination. Thus
This is the finite generation as a quotient of a finite free module criterion. The zero module causes no exception: it is generated by the empty family, or by one zero element.
For the requested example, take , with the usual integer scalar action. Reducing both coordinates modulo two gives an R-module homomorphism that is a surjection with nonzero kernel , so it is not an isomorphism. Every image of is a cyclic module, whereas every element of has additive order at most two and has four elements. Hence admits no such surjection from .
Choose a finite-dimensional generating vector subspace containing , and write for the linear span of products of elements of . The Gelfand–Kirillov dimension is
For a nonzero finitely generated module considered as a right module, choose a finite-dimensional generating vector subspace and define the Gelfand–Kirillov dimension of a module by
For left modules, replace by . These values are independent of the choices: two algebra-generating vector subspaces satisfy and for some positive integers , and two module-generating vector subspaces are contained in bounded-degree translates of one another. The corresponding growth bounds differ only by a constant rescaling and shift of , which do not change the limit superior.
Let be a nonzero standard graded algebra, generated by elements of degree one. It is a homogeneous quotient ring of the polynomial ring . By the Hilbert-Serre theorem, its Hilbert series is a rational function whose only possible pole is at . After canceling, write it as with , where . The cumulative dimensions are the coefficients of and are eventually a polynomial in of degree , with positive leading coefficient. With , these cumulative dimensions equal . Consequently
For the algebra is finite-dimensional and nonzero, so the cumulative dimension is eventually a positive constant. If the zero algebra is allowed, the common convention is an exception to the printed assertion; the integer conclusion concerns nonzero unital algebras.
For the Weyl algebra , the total-degree filtered algebra structure has associated graded ring . Its ordered monomials form a basis. Every finitely generated module has a good filtration of a module, and its associated graded module is finitely generated over . The Hilbert-Serre theorem therefore shows that its Gelfand–Kirillov dimension is an integer in .
A nonzero module of Gelfand–Kirillov dimension zero here would have eventually constant cumulative dimension, hence be finite-dimensional. This is impossible in characteristic zero: taking the trace of the endomorphisms representing gives . For right modules the right-action operators reverse composition and give the negative identity instead, with the same contradiction. Thus
Both occur. The regular module has , hence Gelfand–Kirillov dimension two. For a right module of Gelfand–Kirillov dimension one, take with and . These actions satisfy the defining relation because . The module is a cyclic module generated by , and . This also gives the lower bound for this particular Weyl algebra without invoking a general inequality for higher Weyl algebras.
Fix a Young tableau of shape , let be its column stabilizer, and put
These are the Column antisymmetrizer of a Young tableau and its polytabloid. The Specht module is generated by as a cyclic module, so the nonzero R-module homomorphism has . Because its extension commutes with the group algebra action,
Expand in the tabloid basis of the Young permutation module . At least one tabloid therefore satisfies .
If a row of contains two entries from the same column of , their transposition fixes . Pairing the terms indexed by and in makes them cancel. This remains valid in characteristic two, since the paired coefficients sum to zero there as well. Thus each row of meets each column of in at most one entry.
The first rows of consequently contain at most entries from column of , where is the conjugate partition. Hence
By the dominance order on partitions, this proves
This is dominance from a nonzero column antisymmetrizer. The extension is what allows us to apply to an element of without dividing by the column stabilizer's order, which might vanish in the given field.
Put . A finitely generated module over is finite-dimensional over , and multiplication by is a nilpotent linear map with . Its Jordan normal form exists over because its minimal polynomial is a power of . Each Jordan block has size and is the cyclic module . Hence
A submodule of is an ideal of , and its inverse image is an ideal of the principal ideal domain containing . The only possibilities are with . Thus all submodules form the chain
Every successive quotient is the one-dimensional simple module on which acts as zero. This is its unique composition series, so is a uniserial module and is an indecomposable representation: two nonzero direct summands would be incomparable submodules. Only is simple.
For of order , the group algebra satisfies
since in characteristic . Consequently, up to isomorphism, are precisely the finite-dimensional indecomposable modules, and . The finite-dimensional convention follows from the finite-generation hypothesis; “exactly” counts isomorphism classes.
The symmetric group acts transitively on the Young tableaux of a fixed shape. Moreover, for every permutation , so every polytabloid is a translate of any fixed one. Hence the Specht module is a cyclic module generated by .
It remains to see that . In its expansion, the coefficient of the tabloid is one: if and , then . Thus the generator, and therefore the module, is nonzero.