Let and identify the real weight and Cartan spaces using a Weyl group-invariant positive inner product. For a regular , meaning for every root, specialize to . Then the value of the formal character at is , but both Weyl alternants in the Weyl character formula vanish there. We compute their leading terms instead of substituting into that zero-over-zero expression.
Expand
For every root reflection , replacing by changes the sign of , by replacing with in the sum. Replacing by also changes its sign, by replacing with . Thus the polynomial vanishes whenever or lies on any reflecting hyperplane. It is divisible by in its first variables and by in its second variables. Distinct positive roots give distinct linear factors; each product has degree .
The polynomial has degree in each group of variables. Therefore for , and for it has the form
with a constant independent of both variables. At , the Weyl denominator formula gives
Consequently . For strictly dominant , its leading coefficient is nonzero, and the ratio of the two Weyl alternants tends to
The coroot is , so the root-length factors cancel in each ratio. This proves the Weyl dimension formula by the lowest-degree alternant proof of the Weyl dimension formula, including the limiting step.
Give the real root span an inner product with orthonormal. The B2 root system consists of four short roots on the coordinate axes and four long roots on the diagonals. Choose the long-first simple roots
The positive roots are , and . The corresponding simple reflections are
They generate every signed permutation of the two coordinates. Thus the Weyl group has order eight and is the symmetry group of a square; every element sends to or , with independent signs.
Since form an integral basis of , the root lattice is . The simple coroots are and . Therefore the weight lattice is
Solving gives the fundamental weights
The cone of dominant weights is
Indeed and are exactly the two simple-coroot pairings. This describes representations of the Lie algebra, or of its simply connected Spin group; half-integral weights are allowed. For representations descending to itself, the weight must lie in , equivalently must be even.
The displayed torus-only Weyl integration formula needs to be a class function, meaning . This hypothesis is implicit in the usual formula but is not printed here. We prove the general version for a continuous function, then specialize:
Here and are probability Haar measures; is the invariant probability measure on the homogeneous space ; and is the finite Weyl group.
We use the following standard maximal-torus facts, as permitted: every element of a connected compact Lie group lies in some maximal torus; all maximal tori are conjugate; two elements of a fixed are conjugate in exactly when they are in the same -orbit; and the complexified Lie algebra decomposes into and one-dimensional root spaces. Opposite roots of a root system give real two-dimensional planes in . At an element for which no root character has value one, the identity component of its centralizer is .
Choose a positive root system . Regard each root as a character through the Adjoint representation. A convenient globally defined denominator is
The usual Weyl denominator additionally has a unit-modulus factor , with half the sum of positive roots. Where that half-weight is not a global torus character, it may be interpreted on a covering torus; the squared modulus is nevertheless unambiguous. In either convention,
Average an inner product on over the Adjoint representation to make it invariant. It defines a bi-invariant Riemannian metric on and the quotient metric on . Consider the conjugation map
At , identify the source tangent directions with and , and translate the target tangent vector to the identity by . Differentiating gives
The two summands are orthogonal. On a real root plane, is a rotation with complex eigenvalues . Thus the absolute real Jacobian determinant on this plane is . The torus direction contributes one. Therefore the conjugation Jacobian for a compact Lie group is
This is also the Jacobian for the normalized measures: the Riemannian submersion has fibers isometric to , so ; the probability-volume normalization factors cancel.
Let be the elements for which . The restriction of is a local diffeomorphism onto the regular elements of . It is -to-one. Indeed, fixing , any pair with has , because conjugation identifies the identity components of the two centralizers. Thus , and there is exactly one pair for each coset in . This argument does not require the full centralizer of to be connected.
The nonregular locus has measure zero. In it is a finite union of sets of smaller dimension; their conjugation images are images of smaller-dimensional manifolds under , and hence have zero volume in . The change-of-variables formula for the regular covering therefore gives
For a class function, the inner integral is , proving the required formula with its correct hypothesis.
Without conjugation invariance, the torus-only expression can be false. For with diagonal , take . It vanishes on , whereas its group integral is : the two squared coordinates of a Haar-distributed unit column have equal means and sum to one. Thus the conjugacy average cannot simply be dropped.
For a Cartan-Weyl basis, the Jacobi identity gives
Thus the bracket has joint Cartan weight . If , it belongs to the zero-weight space, which is the Cartan subalgebra, and so is a linear combination . If is a nonzero root, its root space is one-dimensional and the bracket is proportional to . If that nonzero sum is not a root, the bracket vanishes. This proves the asserted forms without assuming every pair of roots has a root sum.
With the stated normalization, put . The commutators become
The adjoint relations make , , the usual SU(2) Lie algebra generators. Hence every finite-dimensional SU(2) irreducible component has eigenvalues , with an integer. Therefore has integer eigenvalues , including in the finite-dimensional Adjoint representation. Algebraically this is the sl2 subalgebra associated with a root.
If , another use of the Jacobi identity gives
The bracket is therefore zero or lies in the eigenvalue- space. Within one irreducible SU(2) ladder it is proportional to the next chosen vector . If the full eigenspace has multiplicity, the weight statement is the general one; proportionality to one named vector presupposes the ladder choice. Similarly lowers this eigenvalue by two, and the ladder weights run from to in steps of two.
For a root vector , its weight is
The adjoint SU(2) ladder therefore proves
For nonparallel , raising and lowering move its joint Cartan weight through the root string . The finite irreducible ladder has weights symmetric about zero. Starting at , reaching its partner requires . The corresponding nonzero vector lies in the root space of , proving the Weyl reflection property:
There is no zero joint root in this string when are nonparallel. Its one-dimensional root spaces prevent two irreducible ladders with the same weight parity from overlapping, so the ladder argument applies to the entire string. For , reflection simply interchanges the two opposite roots, which already exist by the adjoint relation.
For angle and length restrictions, set and . These Cartan integers have the same sign when nonzero and obey
For nonparallel, nonorthogonal roots, is an integer strictly between zero and four. The possibilities are consequently:
  • : , equal lengths, and or .
  • : , squared-length ratio or , and or .
  • : , squared-length ratio or , and or .
Orthogonal roots have and . Parallel roots have ; the integer pairs would allow only length multiples . The stated reducedness condition excludes the latter two, so parallel roots are equal or opposite, with angles zero or and equal lengths. Thus
Not every root system realizes every listed angle.
The orthogonal pair alone gives no ratio through . To finish the length restriction for a simple Lie algebra, use irreducibility of its root system. Let span the Weyl group orbit of . Both and are invariant under the orthogonal root reflections. If a root had nonzero projections in both, reflection of its projection in would have a nonzero component, violating invariance. Hence every root is entirely in one of these subspaces. A proper nonzero would split the root system into two orthogonal parts, contradicting irreducibility. This proves that the Weyl orbit spans an irreducible root space.
In particular, some orbit root is nonorthogonal to any chosen , and . Applying the previous integer-pair restriction to therefore also handles orthogonal :
There can be at most two different root lengths: three lengths would have ratios two and three relative to the shortest, but then the longest-to-middle squared-length ratio would be , which is forbidden. A reducible collection of orthogonal rank-one factors could have independently chosen scales; the simple-algebra assumption excludes that exception.
Choose a generic linear functional to define positive roots. The simple roots are those positive roots which cannot be written as sums of two positive roots; they form a basis in which all root coefficients are integers of one sign. Distinct simple roots have nonpositive inner product: if their inner product were positive, their root string would contain their difference, and whichever difference is positive would decompose one of them. In rank two, irreducibility excludes the orthogonal case. The allowed simple-root angles are therefore , giving the three irreducible diagrams in the classification of rank-two root systems: A2 root system, B2 root system and G2 root system. Reflections in the two simple roots generate their respective six, eight and twelve roots.
Here are explicit simple-root choices and positive roots; adding their negatives gives each complete diagram.
  • For A2 root system, take and . The positive roots are ; all have squared length one.
  • For B2 root system, take the long and short . The positive roots are . These give the four axis roots and four diagonal roots, with squared lengths one and two. The rank-two Lie algebra is isomorphic to this one; changing the long/short ordering changes its Cartan presentation.
  • For G2 root system, take short and long . The positive roots are . They give two hexagons rotated by , with squared lengths one and three.
The nonnegative coefficients in each positive-root list verify the chosen simple roots explicitly. The orthogonal four-root system is rank two but reducible, so it is not a diagram for the simple algebra assumed here.
Define the Cartan matrix in the column-coroot convention:
Using the ordered roots above gives
The alternative row-coroot convention transposes these matrices. Stating the convention and root ordering avoids a spurious disagreement in the unequal-length cases.
Figure 1.
The irreducible rank-two root systems A2, B2 and G2, with long and short roots and explicit ordered simple roots highlighted
. Details.
For the chosen simple roots , the open fundamental chamber of a root system is
Equivalently for every simple coroot. Since all positive roots are nonnegative combinations of simple roots, requiring the inequality for all positive roots gives the same chamber. It is a connected component of the complement of the root reflection hyperplanes; the Weyl group permutes those chambers simply transitively.
The Closed dominant Weyl chamber is obtained by replacing the inequalities by . It is the cone generated by the fundamental weights. When the fundamental Weyl chamber is taken to include its walls, this closed convention is intended; both conventions determine the same positive system and boundary rays.
The drawn simple roots have , and . Their Cartan integers are therefore and , identifying a B2 root system. The corresponding root reflections act on coordinates by
In particular and , so both new positive roots are forced. Reflection in any root also forces its negative. Thus
These eight roots are drawn below, with the given simple pair highlighted.
Figure 1.
All roots forced by the given simple roots of the B2 root system
. Details.
For completeness, no further roots can occur. In a finite reduced root system, every root is a Weyl group translate of a simple root: reflect a nonsimple positive root in a simple root with positive inner product to decrease its height, and iterate. This standard simple-root descent may also be quoted here. The eight-vector set just listed is stable under both generating reflections, and the orbits of the two simple roots already fill it. Hence no simple-root orbit, and therefore no root, lies outside that set. This establishes both the necessity of every drawn root and exhaustion of the root system.
Let be a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra, choose a Cartan subalgebra and a set of positive roots, and write for the Weyl group. Let be a dominant integral weight and the finite-dimensional irreducible highest-weight representation with that highest weight. If denotes its weight space of weight , its formal character is . The symbols belong to the group algebra of the weight lattice and multiply by ; they are formal symbols, not matrix exponentials.
Put , the half-sum of positive roots, and let be the Coxeter length of , the least number of simple reflections expressing it. Then in the real reflection representation. The Weyl character formula states
By the Weyl denominator formula, the denominator is , giving the equivalent expression
The quotient can be interpreted in the fraction field of the formal group algebra; the theorem says it simplifies to the finite formal character above. In particular the apparent denominator does not mean that the representation has infinitely many weights.
The classification of finite-dimensional sl2 representations identifies with . In the defining two-dimensional representation,
so and
On the th tensor power, the infinitesimal operator associated with is the sum of its actions on the individual factors. These actions commute, so exponentiating their sum is the tensor product of the individual exponentials; the same holds for . Restricting to the symmetric power consequently identifies the operator on with . It follows that
Indeed contributes one minus sign from each of the tensor factors. The Weyl reflection lift in an sl2 representation can therefore square to minus the identity, even though its image in the Weyl group is an involution.
The Weyl group acts on the weight lattice by its root reflections and extends to ring automorphisms of the group ring of a weight lattice:
Weights and their multiplicities in a finite-dimensional Lie algebra representation of a semisimple Lie algebra are permuted by this action, so its formal character is Weyl-invariant.
Choose a set of positive roots and put
Here are the fundamental weights, and , where the Coxeter length counts positive roots carried to negative ones. For a dominant integral weight , let denote the finite-dimensional Irreducible Lie algebra representation of highest weight . The Weyl character formula is
The second denominator expression is the Weyl denominator formula. Both alternants change sign under each root reflection; their quotient is invariant. Although written as a fraction, the theorem asserts that it is a finite element of with the nonnegative coefficients given by weight multiplicities. The highest-weight classification specifies which label the irreducibles, while the root system and choice of positive roots determine every other term.
Work with a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra. The Dynkin diagram is obtained from its intrinsic root system, with several structure theorems entering the construction.
First choose a Cartan subalgebra . The semisimple structure theory gives the root-space decomposition
The nonzero roots span , root spaces have dimension one, and every root has its negative. The rank is .
Next use the Killing form. Its nondegeneracy on and its positive-definite restriction to the real coroot span identify the real root span with a Euclidean space. Explicitly, if , put . The sl2 subalgebra associated with a root supplies its normalized coroot and the integral pairing
The root-string theorem makes the reflection permute . Together with the absence of multiples other than , this shows that is a finite reduced root system and a crystallographic root system. These properties come from semisimple Lie algebra theory, not from the diagram's definition.
Choose a vector in that is not perpendicular to any root. Define the positive roots by positive inner product with this vector. The simple roots are those positive roots that cannot be expressed as sums of two positive roots. Root-system theory shows that they form a basis , and each root is an integer combination of them with coefficients all of one sign. Distinct simple roots have nonpositive inner product.
Use the standard Cartan matrix convention
There is one diagram vertex for each simple root. For , the integral off-diagonal entries are nonpositive and
Connect the two vertices with respectively zero, one, two or three edges. The corresponding angles are . A multiple edge carries an arrow toward the shorter root. For joined vertices, the length ratio is determined by ; hence the diagram records both angle and relative length.
For example, has simple roots and , giving two equal-length vertices joined by one edge: type . For , take and . Then
so the two vertices have a double edge directed toward , the shorter root: type .
Finally, orthogonal irreducible components of the root system correspond to the simple ideals of a Lie algebra in the semisimple Lie algebra, so its diagram is the disjoint union of their connected diagrams. Conjugacy of Cartan subalgebras and the Weyl group action on choices of positive roots make the resulting diagram independent of these choices up to isomorphism. Thus the vertices, edge multiplicities, arrows and connected components encode the simple-root geometry and the simple-ideal decomposition.
Choose a fundamental system of a root system . Distinct simple roots have nonpositive inner product. Their Cartan matrix has diagonal entries two and off-diagonal entries , where either , or are positive integers. The root-system finiteness lemma gives . After exchanging the simple roots, the possibilities are
Their angles and relative lengths determine the two simple roots up to an orthogonal transformation and common scaling, except that the two orthogonal components can be scaled separately.
To see that no extra roots remain unspecified, write a positive root with nonnegative integer coefficients. If it is not simple, some simple root has : otherwise . The root reflection in subtracts a positive integer multiple of . The other coordinate stays nonnegative; since is not proportional to , it is positive, so the reflected root must still be positive by the defining sign property of a fundamental system of a root system. Its height decreases. Repeating reduces to a simple root. Thus every root is in a Weyl group orbit of a simple root.
For the four matrices, applying their simple reflections gives, respectively, the following positive roots:
where in the last two rows is long, short. For example, and for the displayed matrices when the convention is . The sets comprising these positive roots and their negatives are invariant under both reflections, as direct substitution verifies. The height argument therefore shows they are the whole root system. This proves the classification of rank-two root systems:
For a root , choose normalized root vectors , and the coroot element with
The requested sl2 subalgebra associated with a root is
These bracket relations identify its basis with the standard sl2 triple. The notation here denotes this subalgebra, not the root reflection used for the Weyl group.
The weight diagram of the Adjoint representation of has its six roots , , each of multiplicity one, and zero of multiplicity two, from the Cartan subalgebra.
Restrict to the root subalgebra generated by , and . The explicit decomposition into irreducible modules is
The first summand has weights . The second has weights , since . The third likewise has weights , since . The last commutes with all three generators and is trivial. These subspaces are stable under the sl2 triple, are independent and have dimensions totaling eight, so they exhaust the Adjoint representation.
Figure 1.
Adjoint sl3 weights coloured by their irreducible summands under the root sl2 subalgebra, with the two zero-weight vectors distinguished
. Details.
The Killing form value is the trace of . By the formula just proved, the four summands contribute . Therefore
Identify the real span of the roots with its dual using the invariant inner product, and put . The weight lattice is
The Weyl group is generated by the root reflections . Each reflection permutes the finite set of roots and preserves their lengths, hence also permutes their coroots. Thus, for ,
Every generating reflection therefore maps the weight lattice to itself, and so does every product. Since the inverse product has the same property, every Weyl-group element acts bijectively on . The roots span the ambient space, so the action on the finite root set is faithful; in particular the Weyl group is finite.
Choose simple roots . For the orbit statement one must use the Closed dominant Weyl chamber
Its interior, defined using strict inequalities, is the open Weyl chamber. Weights on reflecting walls, including zero, cannot be moved into that interior, so closure is necessary here.
Choose strictly inside the chamber, for example the sum of the fundamental weights. The finite Weyl group orbit of contains an element maximizing . If for some simple root, then
contradicting the maximum. Thus every simple-root pairing of is nonnegative, and . Consequently some sends every integral weight into the closed fundamental chamber. The argument in fact works for every vector in the real weight space.
For take the diagonal maximal torus
The spectral theorem for unitary matrices says that every element is conjugate to an element of . A diagonal element with pairwise distinct eigenvalues has centralizer exactly . Its conjugates therefore determine its eigenvalues up to permutation, and the normalizer quotient is . The character lattice of a torus is , with . Conjugation on the matrix unit has weight , so these are the roots. Choose positive for ; then
Dominant integral weights are precisely the integer tuples . Negative entries are allowed: they correspond to determinant twists, so polynomial representations alone do not exhaust the irreducible representations of .
Normalize Haar measure on and to have mass one, and put
The Weyl integration formula for U(n) for a continuous class function is
For a general continuous function, replace in the torus integral by , using the normalized invariant quotient measure.
To prove the formula, consider the conjugation map , . On regular torus elements its fibres have exactly points: the possible orderings of the distinct eigenvalues. Equip the group with an invariant inner product on its Lie algebra and split . After translating the derivative back to the identity, its torus directions contribute the identity, while its transverse directions contribute . Each pair supplies a real two-dimensional off-diagonal plane. On that plane is multiplication by , regarded as a plane rotation, so the absolute real determinant of the transverse derivative is
The change-of-variables theorem, divided by the covering multiplicity, now gives the desired weighted integral up to the constant relating the normalized invariant measures. The nonregular locus has measure zero: repeated eigenvalues are the zero-set of the nonzero discriminant, and the torus coincidence sets likewise have measure zero. Thus its omission causes no change to the integral. To determine the normalization, expand as a sum of distinct torus characters. Fourier orthogonality gives . Applying the formula to fixes the coefficient to . This proves both the class-function and conjugacy-averaged forms.
We can now derive the character formula from integration, rather than merely quote it. Use the basic highest-weight theorem: a finite-dimensional irreducible representation has a unique highest weight with a one-dimensional highest-weight space; all its other weights are minus a nonnegative sum of positive roots. Its character is Weyl invariant. Also, character orthogonality for compact groups gives . This orthogonality follows by averaging the representation on : the integral projects onto intertwining operators, whose dimension is one by the Schur lemma.
Let and, for a strictly decreasing integer tuple , put . The finite Laurent polynomial is alternating. Every alternating Laurent polynomial is a linear combination of the : collect its monomials by permutation orbits, and observe that an orbit with repeated exponents has zero coefficient by antisymmetry. Different are orthogonal on and each has squared norm .
The coefficient of in is exactly one. Indeed, a contribution from the term would require a weight in . For , the vector is a nonzero nonnegative combination of the positive simple roots, so that weight lies above and is impossible. The identity permutation supplies the highest-weight coefficient one. Consequently
Apply the integration formula to . Torus orthogonality gives
All the other coefficients vanish, proving
The quotient extends across repeated eigenvalues because its product with the denominator is the already defined continuous character. Equivalently, alternant divisibility makes it a Laurent polynomial invariant under permutations; multiply by a determinant power if negative exponents must first be removed.
Finally, is fixed by the Weyl group, so its common factor cancels in the quotient. Since , the determinant expression is exactly
Using in the derivation avoids treating a possibly half-integral as an actual character of the torus. At the identity, taking the leading Vandermonde term of the two determinants gives the accompanying dimension formula
The anti-Hermitian operators represent the compact real form; its complexification also contains the Hermitian and the raising operators and lowering operators , with . Define the roots in the two-dimensional Cartan plane by
Each has squared length one. For each , set
The displayed commutators give and . Thus these are the three root SU(2) subalgebras of SU(3).
The commuting Hermitian operators can be simultaneously diagonalized. A weight of a representation is a pair for which
where labels independent states of that representation weight. The weight multiplicity is the dimension of this simultaneous eigenspace. Commuting past a ladder operator proves
with zero image allowed when the raised or lowered representation weight is absent.
Choose as positive simple roots. A highest-weight vector is a nonzero simultaneous eigenvector annihilated by ; the third condition follows from the first two and their commutator. In an irreducible representation, its highest weight has multiplicity one and repeated lowering generates the representation. The three root SU(2) subalgebras of SU(3) give nonnegative integer Dynkin labels
Equivalently, with and ,
These are the SU(3) highest-weight coordinates in the normalization used here.
The Weyl group is generated by the reflections . The SU(2) Lie algebra root-string symmetry makes these reflections preserve both representation weights and their weight multiplicities. They generate the symmetries of an equilateral triangle: rotations through and three reflections. The outer polygon is the convex hull of the Weyl group orbit of . When it is a hexagon with alternating side lengths in root-step units; when exactly one is zero it is a triangle; when both vanish it is a point. The representation conjugate to has labels and negative representation weights. For , this gives an additional inversion symmetry and a regular hexagon with rotations. A general unequal-sided hexagon need not have that extra symmetry.
The shell multiplicities in an SU(3) weight diagram can be stated precisely. Let be the convex hull of the Weyl group orbit of . For in the root lattice coset ,
representation weights outside this coset or outside the outer polygon are absent. This states that boundary representation weights have multiplicity one, each inward shell adds one, and the innermost triangular region has constant multiplicity . When the innermost region is a single point. All representation weights of a triangular diagram have multiplicity one. Counting the diagram gives . The examples below display both triangular orientations, a regular hexagon, an unequal-sided hexagon, a central multiplicity three, and the trivial diagram.
Figure 1.
SU(3) weight diagrams, including quark and adjoint weights and shell multiplicities
. Details.
First complexify the Clifford algebra in spacetime dimensions. Multiplying appropriate generators by converts the signature to the Euclidean form without changing the complex module dimension. Pair the generators into
The Clifford algebra relations give
The commuting occupation operators have eigenvalues zero or one. Choose a nonzero state killed by every ; repeated annihilation reaches such a state in any finite irreducible module. Acting with distinct creation operators produces the occupation states
Their distinct occupation patterns make them linearly independent, and their span is invariant under every Clifford generator. Irreducibility therefore makes it the entire Dirac module. This derives the even-dimensional Clifford spinor dimension:
The chirality matrix is a phase-adjusted product of all generators. It squares to one, anticommutes with each generator and acts as occupation parity up to an overall sign. Its two eigenspaces each have states. The even Clifford algebra, and hence the connected spin group, preserves them, giving irreducible Weyl spinors of complex dimension . A Majorana spinor imposes a reality condition only in signatures where it exists; simultaneous Majorana and Weyl conditions are not available in every even dimension.
In Lorentzian ten dimensions, the complex Dirac module has dimension , and a Weyl module dimension . A Majorana-Weyl spinor is allowed and has real components before its equation of motion. The massless Dirac equation leaves eight physical gaugino polarizations. A ten-dimensional massless gauge field also has physical polarizations. Thus ten-dimensional super Yang-Mills theory has eight bosonic and eight fermionic states per gauge generator, with sixteen real supercharges.
For dimensional reduction, take a flat six-torus with periodic fermions and retain fields independent of its coordinates. Split into and six internal components , . The latter are four-dimensional real adjoint scalar fields. Under the spin groups of the two factors, a ten-dimensional chiral spinor decomposes as
for , with . The Majorana condition relates these conjugate pieces, leaving four independent four-dimensional Weyl spinors. The supersymmetry parameters reduce in exactly the same fashion: sixteen real charges are four four-dimensional supersymmetries. The resulting field content is
The on-shell counts are bosonic and fermionic states, as required. The internal spin group supplies the R-symmetry of the reduced action.
To derive its scalar potential, use Hermitian gauge matrices and a positive trace inner product, with
If the internal volume is , integration gives . Since internal derivatives vanish,
With mostly-minus spacetime signature, has an extra minus sign and the double sum over mixed indices gives a factor two. Rescale and to canonical fields. The resulting bosonic Lagrangian is
where . A commutator of Hermitian matrices is anti-Hermitian, so the last term is minus a nonnegative scalar potential:
The sum is over ordered internal pairs; a sum over would instead have coefficient . Trace normalization merely changes the matched gauge-coupling convention.
The origin attains zero potential, so the global minima are exactly
For a compact connected gauge group, a commuting tuple is simultaneously conjugate into a Cartan subalgebra. Write , where is the rank. Every choice of the real numbers has zero potential. After the residual Weyl group identifications, the classical commuting-scalar vacua of four-dimensional N=4 Yang-Mills theory form in the four-dimensional theory. For one may describe them as six simultaneous diagonal matrices, with tracelessness and permutations of their common eigenvalue labels. Varying these eigenvalues changes gauge-invariant configurations while leaving , proving the existence of genuine flat directions of a scalar potential, not just gauge-equivalent directions. Generic values break the gauge group to its maximal torus; coincident eigenvalue vectors produce enhanced unbroken gauge symmetry. If one keeps a finite compact torus rather than the four-dimensional limit, large gauge transformations add periodic identifications of the Wilson-line coordinates.