 Solution

Temperature as an equilibrium relation. Classical thermodynamics begins with the zeroth law of thermodynamics: thermal equilibrium is transitive. A thermometer can therefore assign a common empirical temperature to systems in mutual thermal equilibrium. Different thermometer properties initially give different monotone empirical scales; a resistance reading by itself does not define the absolute scale.

The Second law of thermodynamics provides a substance-independent thermodynamic scale. A reversible engine operating between reservoirs has a heat ratio depending only on their temperatures. One chooses absolute temperature so that $Q_h/Q_c=T_h/T_c$, with $Q_h,Q_c$ the positive heat magnitudes. Its reversible efficiency is $1-T_c/T_h$. Equivalently, reversible heat defines entropy through $dS=\delta Q_{\mathrm{rev}}/T$. For an equilibrium simple compressible system,Classical thermodynamics uses this relation without needing a microscopic account of entropy. A dilute-gas thermometer realizes an empirical scale approaching the thermodynamic scale after corrections for nonideal behavior.

Statistical meaning of the same derivative. In the microcanonical description, an equilibrium energy shell containing $\Omega (U,V,N)$ accessible states has $S=k_B\ln \Omega$. Its statistical temperature is consequentlyTo see why this is an equilibrium temperature, let two weakly coupled systems exchange a small energy while their total energy stays fixed. The combined multiplicity is ${\Omega }_A(U_A){\Omega }_B(U_{\mathrm{tot}}-U_A)$. Maximizing its logarithm giveswhich is equality of the two inverse temperatures. Stability requires the total entropy maximum, not only stationarity. The overwhelmingly dominant macrostate in a large system therefore realizes the thermodynamic equilibrium condition.

A large reservoir gives a small subsystem the canonical probabilities $p_i\propto e^{-\beta E_i}$, with $\beta =1/(k_{B}T)$. In that ensemble, $F=-k_{B}T\ln Z$ and $S=-k_B{\sum }_i{p}_i\ln p_i$ agree with macroscopic thermodynamic relations in their usual equilibrium regime. The equipartition identity for a classical dilute monatomic gas, $⟨p^2/(2m)⟩=3k_{B}T/2$, is a useful operational connection between microscopic motion and temperature, but is not a universal definition: quantum modes need not obey equipartition, and a system away from equilibrium need not have one temperature at all.

For finite systems one must specify the entropy convention and energy resolution; surface and fluctuation corrections can distinguish definitions that agree in the ordinary thermodynamic limit. Bounded-energy population-inverted systems can also have a negative entropy derivative and hence a negative statistical temperature. That possibility lies outside an ordinary positive-temperature ideal-gas thermometer; it does not mean temperature is merely an arbitrary average kinetic energy.

Obtaining the energy–temperature conversion. The Boltzmann constant connects entropy measured in $\mathrm{J}{\mathrm{K}}^{-1}$ with the dimensionless logarithm of a state count. Historically it could be determined from the ideal gas law $pV=N{k}_{B}T$: measure the molar gas constant $R$ and independently determine the Avogadro constant $N_A$, then obtain $k_B=R/N_A$. The independent particle-number determination matters; using $R$ alone would not fix energy per particle.

An electrical method uses Johnson-Nyquist noise. A resistor of resistance $R_e$ at known temperature has, in the classical range $hf\ll k_{B}T$, a one-sided open-circuit voltage-noise spectrum $S_V(f)=4k_{B}T{R}_e$. Over a calibrated flat bandwidth $\Delta f$,A practical measurement uses an equilibrium resistor, a calibrated low-noise amplifier and a known transfer function, subtracts or independently characterizes amplifier noise, and replaces a nominal bandwidth by the actual effective noise bandwidth. Varying temperature and fitting the mean-square voltage is more informative than treating one amplified voltage sample as the thermal variance. Other primary methods relate temperature to sound speed in a dilute gas or to calibrated particle diffusion and mobility.

There is a historically relevant unit-definition qualification: by the date of this exam, the revised SI had already taken effect on 20 May 2019. The kelvin is now defined by fixingThe same experiments now realize or compare thermodynamic temperatures using this fixed constant, whereas historically they measured the conversion constant on an independently defined temperature scale. The physical distinction between equilibrium temperature and microscopic state counting is unchanged.^[ref]