Abel's identity Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-10-31
For , the Wronskian satisfies .
More precisely, let be solutions of a differential equation for the same homogeneous linear differential equation
on an interval where are continuous functions. For any , Abel's identity gives
Only the coefficient of enters the evolution of the Wronskian. In an unnormalized equation , first use on an interval where and the coefficient ratios are continuous functions.[ref]
The proof uses cancellation. Differentiating the Wronskian by the product rule and substituting the common equation gives
Multiplying this first-order linear differential equation by the integrating factor gives . Since , the constant is , proving Abel's identity. This argument also covers without dividing by .
The exponential function is positive for real , so a real Wronskian either vanishes everywhere or has a fixed nonzero sign throughout . In the preceding example, and give immediately. If , every Wronskian of two solutions of a differential equation for that same equation is constant, regardless of . Thus Abel's identity can certify linear independence and find the denominator used in variation of parameters without explicit formulas for both solutions of a differential equation.
Differentiate the Wronskian using the product rule and substitute the common homogeneous linear differential equation:
Multiplying this first-order equation by the integrating factor and integrating gives Abel's identity:
The exponential factor is finite and nonzero for every in the given interval, because is continuous on the compact interval between and . Hence implies everywhere in that interval. Using an integrating factor avoids dividing by , which would assume the conclusion.
Differentiate the Wronskian and cancel the mixed first-derivative terms:
This is the constant-coefficient form of Abel's identity. Hence , or . Since the exponential function is never zero, is either identically zero or nowhere zero on a connected interval of the homogeneous equation.
Where is nonzero, the Wronskian identity becomes the first-order equation
Its integrating factor is , giving . Integration proves the reduction of order formula
Taking gives the displayed representative in the question, with when . Changing the lower limit adds a multiple of and does not change the linearly independent solution modulo the known one. The scale of separately fixes the normalization of .
Differentiate the determinant and use the original second-order equation for each solution:
This proves Abel's identity rather than merely quoting it.
For the specific equation, substituting , , leaves . Away from zero its normalized first-derivative coefficient is , so
Although the equation is singular at zero, this expression extends analytically there. Near zero, is nonzero and the reduction of order integrand is regular. With the prescribed lower limit,
The integrand through degree three is
After integrating and multiplying by ,
The condition fixes , and the lower limit already gives . Therefore the first three nonzero terms are
The representation genuinely solves the second-order equation: writing , differentiating its Wronskian gives . Its left-hand side is zero and near zero. Analyticity then extends the original unnormalized equation to zero itself. Its Wronskian with is nonzero for sufficiently small , proving linear independence. The vanishing Wronskian at the singular point zero does not contradict linear independence on a regular interval. The integral representation is used locally near zero, before the zero of at one.
Two functions are linearly dependent if constants , not both zero, satisfy identically. Differentiating also gives . Since the determinant of these two equations is the nonzero Wronskian , both constants must vanish. Hence the two solutions are linearly independent.
Differentiating the Wronskian and substituting the homogeneous linear differential equation gives
Integrating proves Abel's identity:
For variation of parameters, impose on the proposed particular solution. Then , and substitution into the inhomogeneous differential equation leaves . Solving this two-by-two linear system gives
Arbitrary constants of integration merely add a homogeneous solution.
For the constant positive coefficient , take . Direct differentiation verifies that and solve the homogeneous linear differential equation; their Wronskian is . The requested integrands are
Taking yields
Thus grows with power one, whereas is bounded. Their combination simplifies to ; the final sine term is itself a homogeneous solution. The secular term is the response to resonance in a differential equation.
For the normal-form coefficient , Abel's identity gives the Wronskian
Use reduction of order: if , then . Absorbing a nonzero Wronskian constant into the second integration constant, the general solution is
This local representation applies on intervals where , in particular sufficiently near because .
Seek a Frobenius solution with . Since , its lowest coefficient gives the indicial equation
Thus the repeated indicial root is . Equating the coefficient of before setting gives
For this becomes the linear recurrence relation
Every coefficient is fixed by , since the denominator never vanishes for . In particular and then every odd coefficient is zero. Therefore there is , not two merely because the indicial root repeats. If "power series" means an ordinary Taylor series with nonnegative integer powers, the only such solution is zero: its coefficient equation starts with and inductively forces all coefficients to vanish.
A second independent local solution is a logarithmic solution from a repeated Frobenius exponent. Indeed, Abel's identity gives . For the normalized first solution , reduction of order gives
After choosing the harmless multiplicative constant in the numerator, its integrand is , so . The nonzero logarithmic coefficient proves that this second solution is not another pure Frobenius solution.
Define the Wronskian by . Differentiating and using the normal-form differential equation gives
Integrating this first-order linear differential equation proves Abel's identity:
Thus, on any interval avoiding zero and ,
Absolute-value signs from real logarithms can be absorbed into the constant on each such interval. For linearly independent solutions, .
Two differentiable functions can be linearly independent on a connected interval while their Wronskian vanishes everywhere. For example, let and . Both have a continuous first derivative, and their values and first derivatives vanish at zero. On either side of zero one of the functions is identically zero, so everywhere. Evaluating a constant linear combination at and forces .
The obstruction is that the two halves supply independent information without simultaneous nonzero value-and-derivative data at any point. For solutions of a common regular second-order linear differential equation, the uniqueness theorem for ordinary differential equations removes this possibility; Abel's identity gives the zero-or-nowhere-zero alternative for their Wronskian.
Wronskian Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-18
For two differentiable functions on an interval , their Wronskian is the function
The order matters: exchanging and reverses the sign. For sufficiently differentiable functions, the Wronskian is the determinant .[ref]
The Wronskian measures whether the vectors and supply independent value-and-derivative data at that point. For real-valued functions, its absolute value is the area of the parallelogram they span. If a constant linear combination is zero throughout , then too. A nonzero Wronskian at even one point makes this pair of linear equations invertible and forces . Thus a nonzero Wronskian somewhere always proves linear independence of the functions on .
For an explicit example, the exponential functions
solve the same homogeneous linear differential equation on the whole real line: substitution gives and , respectively. Their Wronskian is
For the initial value problem , , the linear combination requires and . Hence , , and . The nonzero Wronskian makes the two initial conditions independently adjustable.
Figure 1.
Independent exponential functions supply independent initial data, with Wronskian equal to the oriented parallelogram area
. Details.
The stronger converse requires a common equation. Suppose solve with continuous functions on one interval . Then the functions are linearly independent if and only if their Wronskian is nonzero at one point, equivalently at every point. If , choose constants , not both zero, making satisfy . The superposition principle makes a solution of a differential equation for the same equation, and the uniqueness theorem for ordinary differential equations forces to be identically zero. This proves linear dependence.[ref]
For arbitrary differentiable functions, an identically zero Wronskian need not imply linear dependence. Consider, on ,
Both functions have three continuous derivatives. On each side of zero, is a constant multiple of , so ; at zero their values and first derivatives are all zero, so the Wronskian is zero there too. Nevertheless evaluated at gives , while evaluation at gives . Hence : these functions are linearly independent on the whole interval. There is no single constant multiplier valid on both sides of the common zero.
Figure 2.
An identically zero Wronskian can coexist with linear independence when the common regular equation hypothesis is absent
. Details.
These functions cannot both solve any equation with continuous functions throughout : even alone would contradict uniqueness because but is not identically zero. They do solve the singular equation , whose leading coefficient vanishes at zero. Dividing by gives only away from zero; Abel's identity cannot be applied across that point. The example pinpoints why checking the equation and its interval is essential before using a zero Wronskian to infer linear dependence.