Past exam of the short options paper of the physics Prelims of the University of Oxford / 2021 / S03 / 3

For a particle on a circle, the tangential speed is $v=r\dot{\varphi }$, the moment of inertia is $I=m{r}^2$, and the angular momentum is $L=I\dot{\varphi }=mrv$. Hence its kinetic energy isThere is no potential energy variation along the circle in the stated model.

Replacing $L$ by the angular momentum operator gives the Hamiltonian operatorThe time-dependent Schrödinger equation is thereforeFor a stationary state, separate variables as $\Psi (\varphi ,t)=\psi (\varphi )T(t)$. Dividing by the product separates a function of $t$ from one of $\varphi$:Thus $T=e^{-iEt/\hslash }$ up to a constant, and the time-independent Schrödinger equation is $-{\hslash }^2{\psi }^{\prime \prime }/(2I)=E\psi$.

Diagonalize the commuting angular momentum operator at the same time: $-i\hslash {\psi }^{\prime }=\ell \psi$ has solutions $A{e}^{i\ell \varphi /\hslash }$. A single-valued wavefunction requires $e^{2\pi i\ell /\hslash }=1$, hence $\ell =n\hslash$ with $n\in \mathbb{Z}$. Normalizing with the angular probability measure $d\varphi$ givesThese form an orthonormal basis under ${\int }_0^{2\pi }{\psi }_m^{\ast }{\psi }_{n}d\varphi ={\delta }_{mn}$. The periodic boundary conditions apply to both the wavefunction and its first derivative, ensuring the physical self-adjoint Hamiltonian operator. For probability per arc length $ds=rd\varphi$, the normalization instead reads ${\psi }_n=e^{in\varphi }/\sqrt{2\pi r}$; the two conventions describe the same probabilities. General states are superpositions of these energy eigenstates.

Applying the Hamiltonian operator to ${\psi }_n$ gives ${\psi }_n^{\prime \prime }=-n^2{\psi }_n$, and thereforeThe ground state $n=0$ has zero kinetic energy. Every positive energy level is of quantum degeneracy two, because $n$ and $-n$ correspond to opposite angular momenta with equal squared magnitude.

The confinement scale suggests a tangential momentum scale $\hslash /r$ and thus an excitation energy scale ${\hslash }^2/(m{r}^2)$, consistent with the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. More precisely the de Broglie wavelength must fit an integer number of times around the circumference: $2\pi r=|n|\lambda$, so $|p|=h/\lambda =|n|\hslash /r$. This explains both the $r^{-2}$ dependence and the $n^2$ sequence.

One must not infer a nonzero ground-state energy by applying $\Delta \varphi \Delta L\ge \hslash /2$ naively. Angle is periodic and is not a globally canonical position operator on the circle. The uniform $n=0$ wavefunction, with $\Delta L=0$, is a concrete counterexample to that naive inequality. The ordinary Cartesian Heisenberg uncertainty principle is not violated by the zero-angular momentum state.

The emitted photon energy is the difference of the two energy levels:Using $E_{\gamma }=hc/\lambda$ givesNo numerical mass or radius is supplied, so this is the determinate result. It is the wavelength conditional on the transition occurring. An isolated particle on a circle with no coupling would remain in its energy eigenstate; a charged particle coupled to electromagnetic radiation can emit subject to its transition selection rules. The $3\to 2$ change has $\Delta n=-1$, compatible with an electric-dipole angular factor for a charged ring particle.