Box Feynman diagram 2026-10-05
A one-loop Feynman diagram with four vertices joined into a box. Two W bosons and two internal quarks give a short-distance contribution to neutral D-meson mixing.
Charged current 2026-10-14
The weak charged current couples a W boson to two members of a left-handed electroweak doublet. In the quark mass basis its flavor coefficients are entries of the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa matrix.
Fermi interaction Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-05
The Fermi interaction is the low-energy four-fermion approximation to the weak charged current. Integrating out a W boson gives its coefficient at tree level.
Helicity suppression Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-14
A spin-zero parent decaying through a chiral weak charged current to a charged lepton and a massless neutrino cannot supply the helicities selected by a massless interaction. A charged-lepton mass insertion makes the amplitude proportional to and the decay width proportional to . A spin-one W boson does not suffer this suppression.
The tree-level two-body decay width from is
above the on-shell threshold. The charged pair is distinguishable, so no identical-particle factor divides this result. Below threshold, physical multi-particle decays through virtual W bosons require a different Lorentz-invariant phase-space measure.
The chiral weak charged current vertex gives the spin-averaged squared matrix element for an on-shell W boson decaying to a massless charged lepton and antineutrino. Integrating two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space gives . The massive-vector spin average divides by three; an extra neutrino-helicity factor would incorrectly double count the chiral projector.
Muon decay 2026-10-14
A weak charged current decay described at energies much below the W boson mass by a four-fermion interaction with coefficient given by the Fermi constant. At leading order with negligible final-state masses, its width is .
Neutral kaon mixing 2026-10-06
The neutral flavour states and can mix through second-order weak interactions. Box diagrams with W bosons and internal up-type quarks induce a strangeness-changing-by-two four-quark operator. The GIM mechanism removes its flavour-independent part.
Work with canonically normalized real components of the scalar field; a complex representation can first be written in terms of its real and imaginary components. At a vacuum expectation value , expansion of the scalar potential gives
The linear term vanishes by stationarity. Thus the scalar mass matrix is the Hessian matrix of the scalar potential. Invariance under each Lie algebra generator gives the identity . Differentiating this identity with respect to and evaluating at the stationary point removes the term containing , leaving
The kernel of the map is precisely the Lie algebra of the stabilizer subgroup H. Consequently its restriction to a complementary space of broken Lie algebra generators is injective: a linear combination that annihilates would belong both to the stabilizer algebra and its complement, and hence would vanish. There are therefore independent Goldstone directions in the scalar mass matrix, tangent to the vacuum manifold. There are symmetry-protected massless scalars.
This Goldstone theorem guarantees at least that many zero quadratic masses. The claim that these are all the massless scalars additionally requires nonzero curvature transverse to the vacuum orbit. For example, , with , has an ordinary spherical vacuum manifold but its entire Hessian matrix vanishes there. These accidental massless radial modes beyond Goldstone modes are not excluded by the hypotheses. For the indicated orthogonal group breaking, the protected number is
For the Higgs doublet, put and wherever . If , then
This explicitly exhibits the three angular coordinates as an SU(2) transformation of a real radial field. In particular, the polar coordinates for the electroweak Higgs doublet can locally be chosen in the form
At the vacuum the three variations generated by , , and acting on are independent over the reals. They span the three broken directions; the remaining generator annihilates the vacuum. This proves that the exponential supplies local angular coordinates. An inverse local gauge transformation, applied also to the gauge fields, removes these three fields in unitary gauge. They supply the longitudinal polarizations of the massive W bosons and Z boson through the Higgs mechanism. The parameterization is local about a nonzero vacuum, rather than a coordinate system through every possible zero of the Higgs doublet.
Use the metric and define the charged W bosons and neutral gauge fields by
where , , and . Direct substitution into the gauge-covariant kinetic term gives
and hence
The electroweak doublet gauge-boson mass matrix in the basis is
Its normalized zero direction is and its massive direction is . Thus the scalar-vector terms in physical fields are
with the tree-level electroweak gauge-boson masses
These are also charge eigenstates. The unbroken U(1) gauge symmetry has generator ; on the Higgs doublet, . Since , the combinations have charges , while Z, the photon, and H are neutral. The photon disappears from the displayed scalar-vector terms because . The photon is massless and has no direct tree-level coupling to the remaining radial scalar in this sector. This does not remove its interactions with charged W bosons, or exclude a scalar-to-photon interaction generated by loops.
Finally, retain the printed normalization of the Higgs field potential:
The kinetic term is , so the Higgs radial mass for a half-normalized quartic potential is . The extra factor of two familiar from a potential with prefactor , rather than , does not apply here.
The derivative convention uses hypercharge Y with . For each lepton family , the left-handed fields form an SU(2) doublet , with . Their weak isospin values are and their electric charges are . The right-handed charged lepton is an SU(2) singlet, with , and charge . The minimal model used here has no right-handed neutrino. A sterile right-handed neutrino, if added as a singlet with , would have no charged weak current interaction. Antiparticles carry the conjugate representations and opposite electric charges.
Expanding supplies . The off-diagonal entries of are and . With the chiral projector , one has . Thus the two W boson interactions are
For quarks, separate rotations diagonalize the up-type and down-type mass terms. If their left-handed rotations are and , the charged interaction contains the CKM matrix :
There is an implicit sum over color charge. This quark mixing permits transitions between different families, rather than just the paired fields in a single doublet.
Let and . At momenta much smaller than , neglect derivatives in the heavy W boson equation. Its mass and source terms can be completed to a square:
This explicitly performs integrating out a charged vector boson. The resulting Fermi interaction is
The omitted terms contain derivatives and are relatively suppressed by momentum squared divided by .
For the leptonic pion decay, Lorentz covariance restricts a vacuum-to-spin-zero current matrix element to a constant times . In the rest frame, rotations eliminate the spatial components. Under parity, the temporal vector current is even, whereas the vacuum is even and the pion is odd, so its temporal matrix element equals its negative and vanishes. The temporal axial current is odd and is allowed. This proves the vacuum-to-pseudoscalar current selection rule, rather than merely assuming an axial current. Define the pion decay constant by
Then the vector-minus-axial charged weak current has matrix element , up to an irrelevant overall phase convention. Consequently the scattering amplitude for the decay can be written
Use , the momentum-space Dirac equation , and for a massless neutrino. Since , the neutrino contribution vanishes, leaving
The fermion spin sum is, using the supplied gamma matrix trace identities,
Here , , and . The mass term in the trace vanishes; anticommuting reduces the remaining trace to twice . It follows that
Using two-body decay phase space, with final momentum magnitude , gives the leptonic pseudoscalar decay width
Thus the requested factor is already present in the squared amplitude, and the phase space supplies one more threshold factor.
The physical explanation is helicity suppression. In the pion rest frame the two momenta are opposite. The massless antineutrino has positive helicity; zero total angular momentum would require the electron to have positive helicity too. The charged weak current instead creates a left-chiral electron, whose helicity is negative when its mass vanishes. A nonzero electron mass admits the required opposite helicity with an amplitude proportional to . The decay amplitude vanishes for , and the rate is suppressed by .
Start with the Dirac equation . The equation for the Dirac adjoint is . Transpose it and multiply by the charge-conjugation matrix C to obtain
For this to be the original Dirac equation multiplied by minus one, the necessary matrix identity is
Using , the charge conjugation of the Dirac adjoint follows directly:
The final step uses and .
Let , , and . For anticommuting fields, or normal-ordered operator bilinears, the minus sign in the transformed Dirac adjoint cancels the minus sign from interchanging the two fields. The charge conjugation of fermion bilinears is therefore
The matrix identity just proved gives . Also , obtained by transposing its four gamma matrices and reversing their order. Hence
so and , where . Since the external vector V is odd under charge conjugation, becomes and is generally not invariant.
For parity symmetry in quantum field theory, write . The given spinor transformation gives , , and , with arguments evaluated at the reflected point. The contracted interaction again becomes . Each of parity and charge conjugation interchanges the two chiral contractions; applying both restores . This particular neutral current interaction is CP invariant, although neither P nor C is separately a symmetry. This conclusion uses the stipulated C-odd vector transformation; it is not a claim that all interactions of the Standard Model preserve CP symmetry.
For time reversal of a Dirac field, the gamma matrix adjoint and transpose identities give
With , anticommutation of with every gamma matrix yields
Equivalently, . Since time reversal is an antiunitary operator, the factor i in must also be conjugated. Thus
Using the stated transformations of the field and its Dirac adjoint, the transformed bilinear consequently is
The external vector has the same component signs. Their contraction is unchanged, proving time reversal of a real neutral chiral vector interaction. A real coupling is understood; an antiunitary operator also conjugates coefficients, and relative complex weak phases need not satisfy this invariance.
A charged weak box contribution to kaon mixing is shown below. The incoming and outgoing connect through two charged W bosons and two internal up-type quarks. The black arrows are fermion flow, so the lower line's arrows oppose the momentum of the corresponding antiquark. The blue arrows specify the direction of positive charge carried by the charged propagators. Each vertex is a charged weak current vertex, with the appropriate CKM matrix element; the internal flavors are summed over .
Figure 1.
Charged weak box diagram converting a neutral kaon into its antiparticle
. Details.
Use precisely the printed exchange-positive CP convention for neutral kaon mixing. In the flavor basis, CP symmetry acts by . Write the restricted effective matrix as
Then , so CP invariance of this mixing operator is exactly . Therefore CP noninvariance in this neutral-kaon mixing block means . Violation elsewhere in a larger Hamiltonian would not, by itself, prove an inequality for this particular block.
For neutral-kaon mass matrix diagonalization, choose correlated roots , , and eigenvalues . The vectors and are the corresponding eigenvectors, as direct multiplication verifies. Taking orthonormal flavor states and writing the printed CP eigenstates as and , one finds
where the kaon CP mixing parameter is
Overall phases have been absorbed. The kaon mixing square-root branch convention must be chosen continuously so that in the CP-conserving limit for the eigenstate labeled plus. These formulas are exact in the nondegenerate case with ; the requested small admixtures follow if . Smallness is an additional weak-CP-violation assumption, not a consequence of alone. A Hermitian mass operator has ; the same algebra also applies to the effective non-Hermitian operator that includes decays, where the two eigenstates need not be orthogonal. At a fully degenerate , a CP eigenbasis can simply be chosen.
Adopt the phase convention and . Changing both phases changes the convention for the mixing parameter, not physical predictions. The flavor contents are and . A pair of charged weak currents changes strangeness by two units through the following box contractions, with summed over.
Figure 1.
Charged-current box contractions for neutral-kaon mixing; solid arrows carry quark number and wavy lines denote W bosons
. Details.
The drawing uses unitary gauge: the W boson gauge-boson propagator contains its longitudinal part. In a gauge of a renormalizable quantum field theory, charged Goldstone boson boxes must also be included to obtain the same gauge-independent result. The external lines represent the valence quarks; the meson matrix element also contains strong interaction binding effects.
Put , and . The charged weak box contribution to kaon mixing has the effective four-fermion interaction structure
Here is the Fermi constant, is the CKM matrix, and is a dimensionless loop function from a Feynman integral; the estimate suppresses convention-dependent numerical factors. Four weak interaction Feynman vertices and a one-loop Feynman integral give the coupling and loop order suppression. Unitarity of the CKM matrix gives , so the GIM mechanism cancels the mass-independent part. With a negligible up quark mass, the leading charm quark term has . Define by . Estimating the hadronic matrix element by , with the dimensionless kaon bag parameter of order unity, gives
The hadronic normalization includes division by when relativistically normalized states are converted to the effective Hamiltonian for neutral-meson mixing. Since , the Cabibbo suppression is explicit. Illustrative scales , , and give an order to estimate. The full sum includes charm quark-top quark and top quark-top quark terms, important for CP violation; long-distance strong interaction contributions prevent this dimensional estimate from being a precision prediction. A meson matrix element necessarily needs hadronic input in addition to electroweak parameters.
For the decaying kaon system write , where and are Hermitian matrices. The entries denoted in the question are entries of this effective Hamiltonian for neutral-meson mixing; they need not themselves form a Hermitian matrix. CPT invariance equates the diagonal masses and diagonal decay widths, giving
One can see why there is no complex conjugation on the right as follows. In the flavor subspace let and represent the antiunitary CPT operation by followed by complex conjugation. CPT changes a projected forward propagator into its adjoint. Indeed, if projects onto the flavor subspace and is the Hermitian microscopic generator, its invariance and the antiunitary reversal of give . In the time-independent two-state approximation, the effective generator this means , whose diagonal entries give ; the off-diagonal entries impose no further condition. Equivalently, apply CPT separately to the dispersive and absorptive Hermitian matrices. Treating the decaying effective Hamiltonian for neutral-meson mixing as a Hermitian matrix would incorrectly discard the absorptive part.
In the chosen flavor phase convention CP is represented by . Its invariance requires . Thus it gives diagonal equality and additionally
The normalized CP eigenstates are
Applying CP directly gives eigenvalues and respectively.
Now use CPT to put and take correlated square roots , . Its characteristic polynomial equation is , and direct multiplication shows
Expressing these two eigenvectors in the CP eigenstate basis gives, respectively, coefficients proportional to and . Therefore the kaon CP mixing parameter is
and, because the CP eigenstate basis is orthonormal, the normalized states at production are
The kaon mixing square-root branch convention correlates the roots continuously with the limit of conserved CP , where and . Reversing one root interchanges the two eigenstates. The labels short and long are fixed by their decay widths: their complex eigenvalues are , and subsequent evolution supplies . The displayed formula assumes nonzero mixing and , as in the physical kaon system; degenerate or defective matrices require a separate limiting treatment.
Use metric and the hypercharge convention . Then the Higgs doublet has and transforms under electroweak gauge invariance as
The covariant derivative sign consistent with the requested expression is
A convention that instead calls the doublet hypercharge one puts in the charge generator and derivative; the physical coupling is the same. Here and the matrix-valued connection transforms as , making transform like .
In unitary gauge, the upper component of the derivative comes from the off-diagonal Pauli matrices:
The lower component is
Writing , , inversion of the neutral rotation gives and . Since , the coefficient of the photon vanishes, whereas . Thus
The zero photon coupling expresses the neutrality of the surviving radial Higgs boson.
The scalar Lagrangian density is . Adding gives the complete bosonic electroweak Lagrangian density. Its scalar and vector mass terms, after electroweak symmetry breaking, are obtained directly as
Indeed, the shifted quartic Higgs potential normalization gives . Comparing with a canonically normalized real scalar mass term, a complex vector mass term and a real vector mass term yields
The extra factor one half in this paper's Higgs potential is why is , rather than in another common convention. The tree-level electroweak gauge-boson masses give : measure the two vector masses and take their ratio. Beyond tree level this extraction requires a specified renormalization convention and radiative corrections.
Expanding the vector terms gives the cubic and quartic Higgs couplings to electroweak gauge bosons:
The four elementary Feynman diagrams and their all-incoming Feynman rules are shown below. Differentiating with respect to two identical fields supplies a factor two; differentiating with respect to two identical Higgs fields supplies another factor two in the quartic rules.
Figure 1.
Tree-level Higgs vertices with charged and neutral electroweak gauge bosons
. Details.
There are no elementary , , or vertices in this tree-level Lagrangian density. Loop-induced photon interactions are a different order. The scalar self-interactions, if included, have rules and .
The prime LEP2 search used the Higgs boson coupling to Z bosons through Higgsstrahlung, , shown in the first panel of the process figure in Question 3. This identifies an associated-production interaction, rather than an on-shell decay of a single into a heavier Higgs. The channel's historical role is documented in the LEP2 Higgs-search account.
For the free charged W boson, take , with the conjugate field carrying . In the action, multiplying the two field strengths gives . Therefore
To invert it, separate the transverse and longitudinal projectors , . The operator is , so
Since the quadratic action kernel is , its Proca propagator is
For all momentum components small relative to , the low-momentum limit is , with corrections of relative order or . This local limit leads to the Fermi interaction, with for the charged-current normalization used here.
The middle panel shows the Feynman diagram for the leptonic W boson decay. With the charged-current Lagrangian density sign in the question, its vertex Feynman rule is
An overall field-phase convention can change the overall amplitude sign but cannot change the decay width. With the standard Dirac field current ordering, the amplitude is
The unusual order of barred fields in the printed description should be interpreted as this physical weak charged current matrix element.
For massless final fermions, the fermion spin sums are and . The massive-vector spin average divides by three. Thus
with the chiral trace
Anticommuting through the two following gamma matrices and using gives its symmetric part
Its remaining part is an antisymmetric epsilon tensor from the gamma matrix trace identities; it vanishes against the symmetric polarization tensor . Direct contraction gives and
Hence
No additional averaging over hypothetical right-handed neutrino states is appropriate: the chiral projector already enforces the physical helicity coupling.
On shell, , and , so and . The squared matrix element reduces to . In the parent rest frame, integrate the spatial momentum delta first in two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space. The remaining radial integral is
Consequently the massless leptonic W decay width is
Lepton universality gives in the same massless approximation. The muon and tau lepton masses produce small corrections if retained.
With an identity CKM matrix, the allowed quark channels are and . The corresponding third-generation channel is closed by the top threshold. Each open channel has three orthogonal matching-color final states, so the color multiplicity in a decay width gives . There is no initial color average because the W boson is colorless. The tree-level W branching fractions are therefore:
Final channelPartial widthBranching fraction, rounded
The rounded percentages sum to 99% because of rounding. The exact fractions sum to one, with total leptonic fraction and hadronic fraction . The total decay width is
As an illustrative numerical estimate, taking and gives , each open quark width and . These are tree-level model estimates with the stated illustrative inputs, not a fit to a measured width. Strong radiative corrections increase the inclusive quark widths.
The produced quark and antiquark radiate gluons, generating a parton shower. As their virtualities fall towards the strong-interaction scale, perturbation theory gives way to hadronization: confinement converts the colored partons into color-neutral hadrons, typically seen as two particle jets, with additional radiation sometimes producing resolved extra jets. Unstable hadrons subsequently decay; the primary quarks are not observed as free particles.
Including the CKM matrix, the charged current couples an accessible up-type flavour to every kinematically accessible down-type flavour . Therefore
The sums over remain by row unitarity, so the massless tree-level total remains . Quark mixing redistributes the hadronic branching fractions; it does not create a new total color factor. If a family is above threshold, only its accessible channels enter, and the unitarity sum must not be applied to an incomplete set of final flavours.
For completeness, CKM parameter counting starts with real degrees of freedom of an unitary matrix. This follows by counting real entries and independent Hermitian constraints in . The real-orthogonal subclass has mixing angles; the remaining parameters can be viewed as phases. Rephasing each up-type and down-type mass eigenfield changes by . Of the phases, the common phase does nothing, so are removable. Thus
For three generic nondegenerate families this is three angles and one CP-violating phase. Degenerate masses can allow additional changes of basis and reduce the count.
Define and . In a conventional intrinsic-phase choice, the charged W boson transforms under CP symmetry as
Thus its time component maps to minus the conjugate time component, and its spatial components map to plus the conjugate spatial components. Charge is exchanged, the Lorentz index undergoes parity, and the overall minus sign is a consistent phase convention shared with the charged-current transformation. The analogous formula exchanges with .
An experimentally observed example of CP violation is the long-lived neutral kaon decay . The two-pion spin-zero final state is CP even, whereas would be the CP-odd neutral-kaon state in the CP-conserving limit. Its two-pion decay reveals CP violation. The historical experimental account is cern-courier.web.cern.ch/a/cp-violations-early-days/ .
For the CKM matrix, diagonalize the up- and down-quark mass matrices independently by biunitary transformations. Write
with and positive diagonal matrices. Only the left transformations enter the weak charged current, because its chiral projector removes the right-handed fields. Substitution gives
The matrix is unitary but need not be diagonal: the two left mass diagonalizations generally differ.
Using the field transformations in the subparts and reordering the anticommuting Dirac fields, the charged bilinear transforms as
where the fields on the right are both evaluated at . The W boson contributes its second minus sign and Lorentz parity factor, so the product maps into its Hermitian-conjugate product. Crucially CP symmetry acts unitarily: it does not separately complex-conjugate the numerical coefficient . Thus the transformed interaction is
Comparing with the original interaction requires in this canonical CP convention. The physical condition is quark rephasing and CP conservation:
A merely complex-looking matrix in an arbitrary mass-eigenstate phase convention is not itself proof of CP violation.
For CKM parameter counting, a unitary matrix has real parameters: mixing angles and phases. Rephasing the up and down mass eigenfields removes phases, since their common phase cancels out of . For generic nondegenerate masses this leaves
There is one physical phase for three families and none for one or two. Degenerate masses would permit additional transformations, so the generic count need not apply unchanged.
For the QCD part of the gauge covariant derivative, define the Hermitian colour matrix and choose
This sign convention agrees with the field-strength definition in the source. The kinetic term contains . A vector bilinear under CP changes sign, gains the Lorentz parity matrix, and transposes its colour matrix upon exchanging quark and antiquark. Invariance of this interaction therefore requires the CP transformation of a non-Abelian gauge connection:
Both the time/spatial distinction and the colour transpose are essential; individual colour components need not all share one charge-conjugation sign.
The same gauge covariant derivative gives
Apply the transformation above and the chain rule . The transpose reverses commutator order, , so the nonlinear term transforms with the same overall minus sign as the derivatives. This proves the CP transformation of non-Abelian field strength:
Finally rewrites the theta density as . The two minus signs cancel, and transposition followed by cyclicity leaves the colour trace unchanged. But the four parity matrices acting on the Levi-Civita symbol contribute . Hence
The density is C even and P odd, therefore CP odd. A generic fixed nonzero theta coefficient violates CP symmetry. This is the source of the Strong CP problem, separate from the charged-current phase in the CKM matrix.