Use the integer norm lower bound for rational approximation to a quadratic irrational. The integer is nonzero, since is irrational. If , then
because . If , the difference is at least . Thus
In particular, is a badly approximable number.
To estimate the prime-weighted exponential sum, let . The Dirichlet approximation theorem gives a reduced fraction with
Combining this with the lower bound gives . Thus ; the approximation cannot have a small denominator.
The relevant analytic input is the prime exponential-sum estimate from Vaughan identity:
Here is the structure behind that estimate. With Dirichlet convolution and cutoffs , the Vaughan identity is
It follows from , , and . The first two Dirichlet convolution terms become type I sums with one short factor; the last becomes a bilinear type II sum with both factors bounded below. Split these sums into dyadic blocks and use . For the type I sums, the inner finite geometric series has bound . For the type II sums, the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality followed by expansion introduces analogous sums in differences of indices. Rational approximation separates the phases into blocks of length comparable to , bounding these reciprocal-distance sums. The Dirichlet convolution coefficients are divisor-bounded, producing the logarithmic factors. These steps give the displayed estimate; no unproved cancellation of arbitrary weighted sums is being assumed.
With and , the two denominator-dependent terms are . Consequently
The final passage absorbs the logarithm using the positive exponent margin .
The Von Mangoldt function is supported on prime powers:
Write . A convenient form of the Siegel–Walfisz theorem is: for every fixed , uniformly for and ,
The implied constant can be ineffective because of possible Siegel zeros; the modulus bound is logarithmic, not an unrestricted uniformity assertion.
Apply this to modulus five and separate the reduced residue classes:
The last sum is : only powers of five can contribute in the zero residue class. By the orthogonality of roots of unity,
since two is coprime to five and the sum including vanishes. As , the Siegel–Walfisz theorem yields
The sum is complex-valued, but the displayed error controls its absolute difference from the real main term.
A fixed zero-free strip changes the zero contribution qualitatively. If every nontrivial zero satisfies , with fixed , the same zero-count estimate and partial summation give
The truncated explicit formula for the second Chebyshev function then yields
Take , or an admissible height of this size. The two contributions are bounded by the same order, proving the prime number theorem error from a fixed zero-free strip:
In particular this is for every . It is a power saving, stronger than the decay obtained from the logarithmic zero-free region. The triangle-inequality estimate of the zero sum explains the two logarithms; removing them would require additional information or cancellation, not merely the asserted zero-free strip.
The permitted zero-count bound implies, by partial summation,
Indeed, the zeros with contribute a bounded amount since ; the rest contribute . For every zero in the sum, the preceding zero-free region of the Riemann zeta function gives
The supplied truncated explicit formula for the second Chebyshev function therefore implies
Choose , with any fixed positive and then, for example, . Both terms have exponential decay in , and the logarithmic factors can be absorbed by slightly decreasing its coefficient. Hence, for some absolute ,
If the truncated formula is taken only at admissible heights and non-prime-power endpoints, choose such heights of the same size and first apply it at half-integers. Monotonicity and the jump of at an integer transfer this bound to all ; these convention choices do not change the conclusion.
To pass from prime powers to primes, let . The higher prime-power contribution satisfies
Thus . Apply partial summation again:
The integral is : use and split at . It is therefore smaller than the first term, which is asymptotic to . This proves the Prime number theorem in the requested form
Put . The Euler product gives for . The elementary nonnegative polynomial
therefore gives the three-four-one zero-free-region argument:
The coefficients are nonnegative; applying the identity with justifies the inequality term by term.
Take real parts in the global partial-fraction expansion of the zeta logarithmic derivative. For , the digamma function bounds yield
All terms in the zero sum are nonnegative, because the Euler product and completed functional equation locate the nontrivial zeros in the closed critical strip. The constant terms are bounded: in particular converges. Near the real pole, .
First exclude zeros on the line one. If , , were a zero of multiplicity , the selected zero term would give
Inserted into the positivity inequality, this yields , impossible as . At , zeta has a pole, with a punctured neighbourhood containing no zeros. Thus the line one has no zeros.
Now let with and put . Select this zero in the formula at and discard every other nonnegative zero kernel. The pole terms at heights are bounded. Consequently
Choose a fixed positive small enough that and , and set , . Rearranging gives
This is the required logarithmic gap at large height.
For , zeros with already have a fixed gap. The remaining compact region contains finitely many zeros, none on the line one; the pole at one cannot be an accumulation point of zeros. Hence those zeros also have a fixed positive distance from that line. Reduce the absolute constant to cover this bounded-height region and to make the preceding weak inequality strict. The zero-free region of the Riemann zeta function is therefore
This proof has established boundary nonvanishing as well as the quantitative gap, rather than assuming the former implicitly.
A precise endpoint version of the Perron formula is as follows. If converges absolutely on , then, for ,
When is not an integer, the left side is simply the sum over .
Prove first the scalar kernel formula, with symmetric vertical limits:
For , close the contour to the left and apply the residue theorem at ; the exponential makes the closing integral vanish. For , close to the right, where there is no enclosed pole and the exponential decreases. The usual semicircle estimate, or integration by parts on the closing arcs, justifies these limits. At the truncated integral is , tending to .
One also needs a uniform bound to pass through the Dirichlet series. Pairing the two halves of the vertical integral gives, with ,
The cosine term is absolutely bounded. The sine term is uniformly bounded by integration by parts against the bounded sine integral , since is increasing from zero to one. Thus , independently of .
For finite , absolute convergence permits termwise integration, giving . The uniform bound dominates this by . The dominated convergence theorem and the scalar kernel formula now prove the boxed Perron formula, including its half-weight endpoint convention.
For the link with primes, the logarithmic derivative of the Euler product gives
Applying Perron formula therefore expresses the second Chebyshev function , with half weight at a prime-power endpoint, as the vertical integral of . Shift this contour left, choosing heights away from zeros and using the partial-fraction expansion to control the integrand. The pole at one contributes , a nontrivial zero of multiplicity contributes , the trivial zeros contribute , and the pole from contributes . Thus the resulting Riemann–von Mangoldt explicit formula is
with zeros summed symmetrically in height. A truncated contour gives the corresponding truncated formula and remainder. The pole at one gives the main term for primes; zeros farther left give smaller oscillating corrections. Zero-free regions therefore translate into error bounds for and, by partial summation, for the prime-counting function.
With the normalization of the preceding completion, the super-completion is the Riemann xi function
The pole-subtracted theta integral for the completed zeta function gives the particularly useful expression
It proves directly that is an entire function, with and . Here “integral function” means entire, not integer-valued.
To prove the order-one growth of the Riemann xi function, put . For , the exponentially decreasing theta integrand bounds both and by
Multiplication by the quadratic factor in and the Stirling formula imply . Hence the order of an entire function is at most one. On the positive real axis, , and the defining formula and Stirling formula give
This lower bound proves that the order is at least one. Consequently is entire of order exactly one, generally not of finite exponential type.
Its zeros are precisely the Nontrivial zeros of the Riemann zeta function, counted with multiplicity. The values at zero and one are nonzero; the Gamma function has no zeros; and the completed functional equation together with the Euler product shows that there are no further completed zeros outside the closed critical strip. By Hadamard factorization for entire functions of order one,
The genus-one factors give , and the logarithmic derivative converges locally normally away from the zeros:
Differentiate the defining product of , the gamma factor, and . Rearranging proves the global partial-fraction expansion of the zeta logarithmic derivative:
The summands must be kept together: each is for large , whereas separating the two complex reciprocal sums need not preserve absolute convergence. The gamma term accounts for the trivial zeros as well as cancellation at zero.
Absorption says ; commutativity also gives . Iterating this inequality shows that a monomial with larger exponents is smaller in the natural order. This is the link from exponent vectors to the reverse-inclusion well-quasi-ordering of monomial ideals in solution.
Idempotence gives the join order . Reflexivity follows from ; antisymmetry follows from commutativity; if and , associativity gives . Thus it is a partial order.
Distributivity makes multiplication order-preserving for the natural order: if , then , so . It also expands every generated expression into a finite join of monomials, as used in solution.
The homotopy fibre is the homotopy pullback of the path fibration over the target sphere along . The Sullivan fibre-model theorem computes it by taking a relative acyclic model of that path fibration and tensoring it over the target model with the source model. Here the construction can be written out and checked directly.
Adjoin of degree and of degree to the sphere model, with
This is a differential, because . It is an acyclic relative Sullivan algebra: putting makes its two pairs and . The first is a polynomial generator killed by an odd generator; the second is an odd generator killed by an even polynomial generator. Each pair has cohomology only , the second by the ordinary polynomial antiderivative calculation in characteristic zero. Hence this models the contractible path space, and its augmentation models the chosen basepoint.
Tensoring with the projective-space model via the map in part (i) gives
The last differential is necessary: using only would give . Make the invertible generator change , of degree . Since is even,
For , all nonzero differentials are decomposable and the generator ordering is Sullivan. Thus no further minimization is needed:
For example at this is .
The indecomposable generators of a simply connected finite-type minimal model are dual to its rational homotopy groups. Therefore, for ,
These four degrees are distinct. The exact homotopy sequence provides an independent check: has rational homotopy only in degrees , while has it in degrees . For these source and target degrees do not overlap, so the source classes survive in the fibre and the target classes contribute their one-degree-lower connecting classes, giving the same four groups.
At , the displayed relative fibre algebra is not minimal: and are linear pairs. Cancelling both acyclic pairs leaves . Accordingly
This agrees with and the degree-one map being a homotopy equivalence. The case distinction is required before reading homotopy groups from the generators.
Use cohomological degree, and write the Sullivan minimal models as
and
The subscripts indicate degrees. The even generators generate a polynomial ring and the odd generators an exterior algebra. Their cohomology rings are respectively and , since each odd differential kills exactly the indicated non-zero-divisor polynomial relation. These are the usual projective-space and even-sphere minimal models.
Orient the top classes so that the degree-one condition is . A representative model map must send to . It must send to an element of degree with differential . The element has exactly these properties. Thus
The differential check is . In these degrees there is no other available monomial: even powers of have even degree, and an odd monomial is a power of times . Hence the coefficient is forced by the differential. For the two models coincide and the map is the identity model map.
Put and let be the identity class of . With the product-cell orientation used in part (i), form the folding map , which is identity on each summand. The top cell of is attached by the product of the two inclusions, so folding gives the attaching map . Thus there is a cellular map
which is the fold on the lower skeleton and degree one on the top relative cell.
Let be the classes from the two factors, and let restrict to the generator of the bottom sphere. Orient the top class so that . Then . Since and is even, graded commutative algebra gives
The map is an isomorphism in degree , because of its degree-one top-cell map. Therefore . By the definition of the Hopf invariant this proves
The shifted Lie convention in part (i) multiplies the geometric bracket by , so it gives the same square and the same invariant. Reversing the orientation chosen for the attached top cell would reverse both its generator and the numerical sign convention; with the standard orientation the value is the stated positive two.
For based maps and , use the standard cell decomposition
The attaching map is obtained from the boundary of , collapsing the appropriate coordinate boundaries. The geometric Whitehead product is the homotopy class
Orient the product cell consistently with the ordinary product orientation. Its class depends only on the two homotopy classes, and it is natural: .
For it is additive in both variables:
Thus it is bilinear over , and after rationalization of a topological space over . In the geometric convention its symmetry is
For a genuine graded Lie convention, put a class in in shifted degree and set . Equivalently transport the Samelson product through reduced suspension and loop space adjunction. Writing , this bracket has degree zero, satisfies
and has the graded Jacobi identity
These are two equivalent sign presentations of the same Whitehead product. In particular the square of an odd-dimensional geometric class is two-torsion, whereas an even-dimensional sphere class can have a nonzero rational square. Reduced suspension kills Whitehead products, since the suspended attaching map of the product cell is null-homotopic. No proofs of these remaining algebraic properties are needed here.
Bilinearity has a specific fundamental-group exception. If both inputs lie in , the attaching loop of the torus is the commutator, so the operation is , with the possible inverse corresponding to reversal of its boundary orientation. This is not a homomorphism in either input in a general nonabelian group.
If one input is and the other is , , the product records the action difference , up to the fixed overall boundary sign. Choose the action convention matching that boundary orientation and write . Then
The second formula is a crossed-additivity law, not ordinary additivity in . It follows by expanding . Consequently the higher-homotopy variable remains additive, while the fundamental-group variable is generally not. If the action is trivial the mixed product is zero. This explains exactly where the usual bilinearity statement fails.
Choose basepoints and replace the spaces and map by CW complex models. If the hypothesis is stated for unreduced represented homology theory, the basepoint coefficient summands split naturally, so it also gives an isomorphism in reduced represented homology theory. Let be the homotopy mapping cone of . Its reduced represented homology theory is zero in every degree, by the exact sequence of the corresponding cofiber sequence of spectra.
The mapping cone is a simply connected space: the mapping cylinder retracts onto , and coning off the path-connected space adds no fundamental-group generators; the van Kampen calculation gives the quotient of by the image of , which is trivial. Suppose some positive-degree integral homology group of were nonzero, and let be the least such degree. Then . Starting with , the Hurewicz theorem shows inductively that for : at each first possible degree , its homotopy group is identified with the zero group . It then identifies
Applying the result of part (a) to the -connected based space gives , contradicting the vanishing of its represented homology theory.
Thus is integrally acyclic, and the ordinary homology exact sequence says that is an integral homology isomorphism. The allowed homological Whitehead theorem for simply connected spaces makes the map of CW complex models a homotopy equivalence. Returning to the original spaces therefore gives
The simply connected hypothesis is used both in the first-nonzero-degree Hurewicz theorem argument and in the final homological Whitehead theorem.
Take a based CW complex model for . Since it is -connected and , its reduced ordinary homology vanishes below degree , with arbitrary constant coefficients. This also follows from a CW complex model with no non-basepoint cells below degree . The connective spectrum has for .
Filter by its skeleta. The quotients of consecutive stages are wedges of spheres, so the exact sequences in represented homology theory give the homological Atiyah-Hirzebruch spectral sequence
It is first quadrant because is a connective spectrum. In a fixed total degree it converges with a finite filtration: cells of sufficiently high dimension cannot contribute in that degree or affect it through a boundary, by the same connectivity bound.
In total degree , every term with is zero, and terms with are zero. The only possible term is
No differential can leave it: the target has spatial degree . No differential can enter it: its source would be , whose coefficient degree is negative for every . Thus it survives unchanged and is the only filtration quotient of ; there is no extension problem. The ordinary Hurewicz theorem now yields
The isomorphism uses the stated identification and is natural in . This is the bottom-degree generalized Hurewicz isomorphism.
Put and . The diagonal of and its map to a point induce
Here the identification explains the target of . These maps satisfy the coassociativity, cocommutativity and counit identities, since their underlying maps send to repeated copies of the same .
Use the defining adjunction of the function spectrum to define . Its adjoint is the composite
Define to have adjoint
Thus is pointwise multiplication, while is the constant unit. These are genuine stable maps, defined through the internal function spectrum, so the argument does not presume that stable functions have ordinary points.
To verify associativity, take the adjoints of and . Both are maps . Both use the triple diagonal , evaluate the three copies of , and multiply the three outputs. The triple diagonals agree by coassociativity; the output maps agree by associativity of the ring spectrum . The function spectrum adjunction therefore makes the original two maps equal. For the left unit, the adjunct of uses and , leaving exactly evaluation. Its adjoint is . The same calculation with proves the right unit. Hence
If is a commutative ring spectrum, cocommutativity of proves that this function spectrum is commutative as well.
In the stable homotopy category, a ring spectrum is a unital associative monoid object for the smash product of spectra. Thus it consists of a topological spectrum with multiplication and unit
where is the sphere spectrum, and the identities are
The canonical associativity and unit identifications of the symmetric monoidal category are understood in these formulas. All identities are identities of maps in the stable homotopy category.
A commutative ring spectrum also satisfies
where interchanges the two factors. This is the ring-object convention; a coherently structured ring spectrum has additional point-set or higher-homotopy data. In particular homotopy-category commutativity alone is not an assertion of such a coherent enhancement.
The associativity of twisted half-smash products follows from an actual isomorphism of the complement bundles. First work over compact parameter spaces, so that a common choice of flags can be made. Choose source, intermediate and target stages satisfying
For the two twisted half-smash products and their composite the relevant vector bundles have fibers
Pull the first two bundles back to . Since is a linear isometry, the decomposition of into and its orthogonal complement gives the fiberwise vector bundle isomorphism
Its inverse is given by the two orthogonal projections. The isomorphism varies continuously with , and the ranks agree:
The one-point compactification of an external orthogonal direct sum gives the smash product of its Thom spaces. Using to identify with , the isomorphism therefore gives
The left side is a stage of and the right side is the corresponding two-step prespectrum presentation of .
These stage comparisons commute with structure maps. Indeed, increasing a stage decomposes a suspension vector into its component in and the two residual complement components. In either construction the same source component is pulled back to and used in the same structure map of ; the residual components are left in the same final complement. Iterated orthogonal decomposition gives the same result whether the intermediate complement is separated first or last. They also commute with maps of , since the comparison only rearranges the suspension coordinates.
For clarity about the intervening spectrification, maps out of into a genuine indexed spectrum are precisely compatible prespectrum maps . At stage , adjunction from the Thom coordinate identifies such a map with a continuous family
where the last identification is the genuine indexed spectrum structure of . Compatibility between stages is exactly compatibility of this family with the source structure maps. Thus maps out of the twisted construction are continuous families of maps over the specified linear isometries. A family of such maps over out of is, by applying this universal property a second time, exactly a family of maps out of over . This is the same orthogonal-coordinate correspondence just constructed; it respects the identifications imposed by each spectrification. Consequently it descends from the prespectrum presentations to the associated spectra. Common cofinal refinements remove any incompatibility between the independently chosen flags.
The printed hypothesis does not require to be compact. For an arbitrary compactly generated parameter space , use the same construction on compact test spaces mapping into . Each such family admits the common flags above, and the comparisons agree under restriction because their formula is the canonical orthogonal projection. They therefore assemble into the continuous global comparison in the compactly generated point-set construction. Equivalently, the preceding universal-property correspondence is valid for arbitrary and does not impose a uniform finite target stage on all of it. Passing to cellular models for the derived construction gives the requested natural isomorphism
Write for the linear isometry specified at . Choose a cofinal sequence from the indexing family , and write the target part of the supplied subordinate flag for a family of linear isometries as . After a cofinal enlargement it has
Both flags exhaust their universe for spectra. Compactness of the parameter space ensures that a finite target stage can contain all images of each fixed source stage.
Let be the vector bundle on with fiber
Here is the orthogonal complement in the indicated ambient subspace. Its rank is . Let be its Thom space, the disk bundle modulo its sphere bundle, so that every fiber is compactified and all its points at infinity become the single basepoint. For the zero bundle this convention gives . Define a target indexed prespectrum on the flag by
The smash product here is of based spaces, not yet the derived smash product of spectra.
To specify all structure maps, for use the continuous fiberwise orthogonal isomorphism
Both sides identify with the complement of in . In particular this is the isometry obtained by orthogonally projecting onto and its complement; it is not an assertion that the displayed summands coincide separately. Pass to fiberwise one-point compactifications, identify the last summand with using , and apply the source structure map. This defines
More explicitly, decompose , where and , as with and . Send its pair with to the pair over . The notation for finite vectors extends to the compactifications, sending infinities and basepoints to the basepoint. Orthogonal decomposition and associativity of the source structure maps prove the prespectrum identities.
Extend the indexed prespectrum from the cofinal flag to the target indexing family and apply spectrification . The point-set definition is
On a map of topological spectra it is induced at stage by . Thus the prescribed isometry family, indexing family and flag have all been used. A common cofinal refinement identifies the resulting objects in the stable homotopy category; the point-set model retains the chosen flag. If is a constant standard inclusion, the complement bundles are trivial and this recovers the usual reindexed .

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact