Let . Using Lagrange multipliers with givesThe third equation fixes . The first two then reduce to and . If , their solution and the constraint giveAt , the second equation requires and makes the first inconsistent; at , it requires and gives the same inconsistency. Thus there is no constrained stationary point when . The constraint gradient never vanishes because its vertical component is one, so the multiplier condition has not excluded any regular constrained stationary points.
At , the first equation gives , and the second then gives . All nonzero solutions areAt , the first equation gives . The second then gives , and the third is twice the second. Choosing an integer direction vector, all nonzero solutions areEach full null space, including the zero solution, is a line through the origin. Geometrically, the three homogeneous constraint planes have that common intersection; in each case only two of their equations are independent.
Subtract twice the second row from the third row when computing the determinant. The last row becomes , soIts zeros give exactly the parameter values with a nontrivial null space:
For , a nonzero coefficient vector with is precisely a linear dependence of the three columns. Three vectors in three dimensions are linearly dependent exactly when the determinant of their column matrix, or their scalar triple product, is zero. ThusFor this square homogeneous linear system, the condition is also sufficient.
Take the outward orientation of the complete closed surface, including its flat base. The constant part of the vector field has zero divergence, and the radial part has divergence . The divergence theorem gives its flux as that constant times the solid hemisphere's volume, :The constant field may have nonzero flux through the curved part alone, but its curved and base contributions cancel on the closed surface.
Use the orientation induced by the boundary order . The triangle's vector area element integrates to . Every point in its plane is a linear combination of , so . The radial term of the field therefore contributes no flux. The constant term givesReversing the orientation reverses this sign. If and are collinear, the triangle has zero area and the displayed value is zero by the degenerate-area convention.
The vector triple product rewrites the field as . Its first term has divergence , while the second contributes . Therefore
The curl of the constant vector field vanishes. The curl of the position field also vanishes, since all its cross-coordinate partial derivatives are zero. Thus
The characteristic polynomial factors as , so the homogeneous solution is . The forcing already occurs in that solution, so a constant multiple of cannot be a particular solution. Use instead. Its derivatives are and , so substitution gives and fixes . ThusThe extra factor of accounts for the repeated forcing exponent in the method of undetermined coefficients.
For the homogeneous linear differential equation, the characteristic equation is , with polynomial roots . Its homogeneous solution is therefore .
Use the method of undetermined coefficients for a particular solution . Substitution givesEquating coefficients yields , and . Hence the general solution is
There are possible stopping points, so the equal defective-ball probabilities are . With , the desired conditional probability givesThus, for a fixed good-ball stopping law,Since , the smallest possible production probability over admissible stopping laws isIf strict positivity of every is additionally imposed in this general case, then and one only has the infimum , approached as . The paper states that strict-positivity assumption explicitly for part (a), not for the general case in part (b). Without choosing or bounding , the exact fixed-law answer remains .
The event includes stopping positions zero through . Applying Bayes' theorem to their joint and marginal probabilities givesThis conditional probability is defined whenever its conditioning event has positive probability. At , it reduces to .
For , sum the marginal stopping probabilities over the selected tail:Equivalently it is . At , both empty tail sums are zero, as required.
The condition selects positions and . Their combined good-ball joint probability is , and their total probability is . Thus
Divide the relevant joint probability by the marginal stopping probability. By Bayes' theorem,The denominator is positive under the stated assumptions.
The good and defective cases are disjoint and exhaustive. The law of total probability therefore gives
Distinguish the production type as well as the stopping position. The sample space has the six outcomesHere in an event means . Their joint probabilities are and , respectively. The conditional stopping laws obey ; with the stated strict positivity all six outcomes are possible.
There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.