The appropriate invariance is invariance of the action element , including the change of the time measure. Under and , differentiation of gives . Therefore
Using the Euler-Lagrange equations and , this becomes
An action symmetry therefore yields the Noether charge
For this reduces to the usual spatial form of Noether's theorem. The same on-shell calculation permits velocity-dependent generators when they define a legitimate variational symmetry. Merely preserving the numerical value of is insufficient for transformations of time: the Jacobian matrix and determinant matters. If the action changes by a boundary term , the conserved quantity is .
Hamilton's principle states that the physical path makes the action stationary under differentiable variations vanishing at the fixed endpoints. Its conventional “least action” name does not guarantee a minimum. Expanding to first order and integrating the velocity term by parts gives
The endpoint term vanishes. By the fundamental lemma of the calculus of variations, the coefficients of the independent interior variations must vanish, yielding
For example, the zero path of a harmonic oscillator with endpoints zero can have both positive and negative second variations when the elapsed time exceeds a half-period; stationary action then need not be a least value. The Euler-Lagrange condition is the local statement that the variational principle actually supplies.
Hamilton's principle makes the action stationary under variations vanishing at the endpoints. It need not be a strict minimum. Varying the action and integrating the velocity variation by parts gives
The endpoint term vanishes. Since the interior variations are arbitrary, the fundamental lemma of the calculus of variations yields
In Cartesian components, and . The Euler-Lagrange equation therefore gives
Thus the minimally coupled particle Lagrangian yields the Lorentz force.
For an arbitrary smooth gauge function , take and . Both fields are unchanged, while
The action changes only by an endpoint term, so fixed-endpoint variation gives the same motion. Canonical momentum shifts by , whereas kinetic momentum and the Lorentz force are gauge invariant. This is the relevant gauge invariance of the classical particle dynamics.
Noether's theorem associates a continuous one-parameter differentiable symmetry of the action with an on-shell conserved current. If a first-derivative Lagrangian density varies by , the current is . The integral of is conserved when the spatial boundary flux vanishes. This connects symmetries to conservation laws; time translation, spatial translation and internal phase symmetry furnish familiar examples.
For the strict fixed-coordinate invariance in the question, . In one space dimension, integration by parts at the density level gives
The bracket vanishes by the field equation. Thus yields
In four spacetime dimensions the same identity gives with . In particular, for the usual scalar kinetic term the spatial current has the minus sign inherited from .
For the quartic density in dimensions,
To evaluate the displayed dilation current, abbreviate and . Product differentiation gives
Here makes the differentiated kinetic terms cancel, and . On shell, the on-shell divergence of a quartic scalar dilation current reduces to
Hence this current is conserved for generic solutions in four spacetime dimensions. Special field configurations with vanishing density do not alter the generic dimensional statement.
The subtraction has a symmetry explanation: for , direct variation gives . At the action is invariant up to a boundary term, so . Strict invariance of the density is not required. This is a classical result; no claim about quantum scale invariance is needed.
Removing the hinge mass gives the exact Lagrangian
The stated equations again concern its small-angle quadratic approximation. In the sum and difference coordinates this becomes
Consequently
For unequal squared frequencies, : the rods remain aligned to first order and the end mass swings like a pendulum of length . This degenerate Lagrangian gives the difference coordinate no quadratic kinetic term, so its equation is an algebraic constraint, not a second oscillator. If , the quadratic action loses all dependence on . Its motion is then undetermined at this order; nonlinear terms or a small hinge mass must resolve the degeneracy. For larger spring stiffness the straight constrained branch is not a minimum of the bending potential, despite the absence of a finite-inertia growing mode in this strictly massless quadratic description.
For a real scalar triplet, with metric signature , differentiating the Lagrangian density gives and . Hence
For a constant internal rotation parameter, the variation is
Each bracketed tensor is symmetric in , so its contraction with the antisymmetric symbol vanishes. This rotates the three field components, not the space coordinates; both the kinetic term and common mass term are invariant.
For a first-principles Noether current derivation, temporarily let depend on spacetime. The terms proportional to still cancel, leaving
On a solution of the field equations, the action variation for a compactly supported vanishes after integration by parts. Thus . To match the charges printed in the question, use the equivalent overall sign convention for the SO(3) Noether current of a real scalar triplet
Arbitrariness of gives three continuity equations. Their charges are exactly
An overall reversal of all currents is immaterial; the minus sign above keeps the generator convention distinct from the supplied charge convention.
Direct verification is also short:
The mass term and the products of equal-type derivatives cancel by antisymmetry; integration by parts produces the boundary term. The charges are conserved when these integrals exist and the net boundary flux vanishes: sufficiently decaying fields on all space, periodic boundary conditions, or suitable symmetry-preserving no-flux boundaries suffice. Arbitrary open boundaries do not. A common constant is necessary for this internal symmetry; its positivity is a stability issue, not needed for the algebraic conservation proof.
The assumed relation makes the old and new actions differ by the endpoint term . Fixed endpoint values of both coordinate sets make its variation zero. Therefore stationarity of the old action is equivalent to stationarity of
Varying independent and integrating by parts gives
Both coefficients vanish: the new variables satisfy Hamilton's equations, so a locally invertible transformation with this action identity is canonical.
When the Hamiltonians agree, exactness of the one-form gives
The action argument of part b then proves canonicity. Equivalently, exterior differentiation preserves the symplectic two-form. For a time-dependent transformation, the exact differential must supply the full action identity; a fixed-time check alone would not establish that the new Hamiltonian equals the old one without a time-dependent correction.
The general action identity is
Treating as independent and comparing coefficients gives
Choose a complete integral of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation,
Then , and Hamilton's equations become . Completeness and local invertibility are needed: a solution with too few independent parameters cannot generate an arbitrary trajectory.
Adding a constant to changes neither its time nor space derivatives, so the action is invariant. The associated Noether density and flux are
The wave equation gives . Therefore
This is total physical transverse momentum. It is conserved for a whole isolated infinite string with vanishing boundary flux, periodic boundary conditions, or endpoints exerting no net transverse force. For a finite subsystem momentum can flow through its ends, and fixed supports can exchange momentum with the string. Thus the local conservation law always holds in this model, while constancy of the integrated charge requires the stated boundary condition.
For fields and a continuous infinitesimal internal symmetry , suppose the density changes by a divergence, . Varying the action and using the Euler-Lagrange equations gives the Noether current
The conserved charge is when the flux through the boundary vanishes; more generally . If the Lagrangian is exactly invariant, . Treat a complex field and its conjugate as independent variables during variation, imposing conjugacy on physical solutions. Time and space translations give energy and momentum through the corresponding spacetime version of the theorem. Continuous global symmetry gives an ordinary charge; local gauge redundancy requires additional care and is not an independent conserved charge for every arbitrary function.
Use natural units and the Minkowski metric , with and . Then , , and . The electromagnetic field tensor is an antisymmetric tensor, which gives gives
integration by parts in the action, with the variation vanishing on its boundary, yields . Independent variations of the four components therefore give . The time component is ; the spatial components are . These are the two source-free Maxwell equations obtained dynamically. The other two, and , follow identically from , through the Electromagnetic Bianchi identity. They are not additional Euler-Lagrange field equations.[ref]
The transformation leaves both derivatives unchanged, so the Lagrangian density and action are invariant. For infinitesimal unit field variation, the Noether current for a first-derivative scalar field is the shift current of an elastic rod,
Its divergence vanishes by the equation of motion. The charge is the total longitudinal mechanical momentum to this order in the displacement field.
For , put . Each derivative gains a factor , so . Changing integration variables to contributes , proving exact invariance of the full-space action.
Set . At fixed coordinates, with . Since the density is quadratic in derivatives,
The variation is a divergence, so subtract its boundary term in the Noether current:
Thus the dilatation charge of a one-dimensional elastic wave is
An overall sign change would give the same conservation law. Unlike , this charge has units of action, . Its explicit factor of is balanced by transport of the weighted momentum density; an explicitly time-dependent charge can still be conserved.
Position-dependent density. The density remains independent of itself, so the shift Noether charge survives with its altered canonical momentum:
A prescribed generic function supplies a fixed spatial scale and breaks scale invariance. For the dilation-current candidate with the corresponding and , the scale-breaking sources in derivative field theories give
Thus is generally not conserved. Constant density recovers the earlier case; specially scale-invariant profiles and suitably invariant domains would require separate treatment.
Quartic strain. The extra term in again preserves a uniform field shift. Its time momentum is unchanged, while its spatial current becomes . Therefore
The new Hamiltonian density is . Under waveform dilation, the quartic term scales with rather than , and
Hence there is no corresponding conserved for nonzero generic , even if the energy in its candidate expression is updated.
Field-dependent quadratic stiffness. In , the term breaks the uniform field shift:
when spatial flux vanishes. Thus is not generally conserved. However all terms still contain exactly two derivatives in total, with a field of zero dilation weight. The factor gains no extra power of , so waveform dilation remains an action symmetry. Its charge is
Here as before. Relative to the original charge, the energy term changes; the symmetry survives despite the nonlinear field dependence. These statements concern symmetry conservation, separately from any restrictions on parameters needed for positive elastic energy.
Use the downward direction of the PDF diagram. The bob's Cartesian coordinates are
Thus
The hinge and rod are massless, so only the bob contributes kinetic energy:
Because gravity points along positive , its gravitational potential energy is . The zero-rest-length spring has elastic potential energy . Put and divide by the positive constant . The equivalent Lagrangian is
Multiplying the action by a nonzero constant leaves its stationary paths unchanged. This derivation is a direct use of kinetic energy from Cartesian position vectors; no independent kinetic term should be assigned to the massless support.
If , the action changes by an endpoint term:
In the principle of stationary action with fixed endpoints, and the endpoint times are fixed. Therefore , and the two actions give the same bulk Euler-Lagrange equations.
For a Lagrangian density, adding changes the action by , by the divergence theorem. Its variation vanishes for compactly supported field variations, or when the appropriate boundary data are held fixed. These total divergences in a variational principle can therefore be discarded when deriving bulk equations under those conditions.
The qualification about boundaries matters: if depends on field derivatives, their variations on the boundary must also be controlled. A total derivative can change the canonical momenta or the chosen representative of a Noether current, even while leaving the bulk dynamics unchanged.
With constant , the bulk action is invariant under time translations, translations in the two spatial coordinates, and rotations or reflections within the substrate plane. The Laplacian has no preferred direction, giving the planar symmetry. It also has scalar-field shift symmetry , expressing the arbitrary origin of height, and the discrete symmetry because its residual is squared.
There is an additional exact tilt symmetry : the added slope is time independent and has zero Laplacian. More generally, adding any function satisfying leaves the residual unchanged. Such bulk transformations need not preserve prescribed boundary conditions or a restricted physical interpretation of the height.
In two spatial dimensions the action also has the anisotropic scale invariance
The spacetime measure scales as and the squared residual as . The time and length scales are therefore related diffusively, rather than by a Lorentz transformation.
Ordinary time reversal needs a boundary qualification. The identity
shows that the density is time-reversal invariant up to a total divergence. Thus the bulk stationary equation is invariant under , although the printed density is not pointwise unchanged. The time reversal of the squared diffusion-residual action exchanges the growing and decaying branches; the selected first-order diffusion equation alone is not time-reversal invariant at fixed positive .
There is a sign inconsistency in the original PDF: varying its action gives a plus sign for the spatially projected magnetic term, whereas its displayed target equation has a minus sign. The following Lagrange multiplier for antisymmetry calculation derives the result of the action as printed.
Temporarily vary all sixteen entries independently and add
Variation of the symmetric Lagrange multiplier imposes . Define
On this constraint surface, . Differentiating the original contractions before imposing the constraint gives
and
In particular, the reversed order in the last factor of the action matters. The unrestricted Euler-Lagrange field equation, evaluated on the antisymmetry constraint, is
Subtract its index-transposed equation to eliminate the symmetric multiplier:
A direct check is to restrict the action to a rest-frame magnetic component , : its quadratic contribution is , whose derivative has a positive sign. To obtain the PDF's target equation instead, one must reverse the sign of that quadratic term in the action, or replace its last by . These are alternative repairs; changing conventions cannot make the printed action and printed equation agree.