At wavelengths with , neglect the density-gradient term in the quadratic density-phase action. Complete the square in its remaining density terms:
The convergent Gaussian integral can be performed by a contour shift or by its Fourier-transform identity. Its determinant is independent of at this order. Combining that normalization with the saddle action into a constant gives
The saddle contribution to is ; the additional measure-dependent constant need not be assigned an invented numerical value. The density Gaussian extends the fluctuation integration beyond its exact positivity domain, which is justified only while fluctuations around are small. The smooth zero-winding assumption is also required as discussed above. A constant global phase zero mode gives a finite compact-group volume, handled separately from nonzero phonon modes.
Fourier transforming the Bose-gas phase-only action gives a kernel . Analytically continuing gives its real-frequency poles,
In the present units the excitation energy equals . Each real Fourier coordinate is a harmonic oscillator with inertia coefficient and spring coefficient , hence frequency equal to the square root of their ratio. This is the direct relation to a quantum harmonic chain. The mode is a gapless sound phonon; its finite speed reflects both the compressibility and the phase stiffness .
Retaining the density-gradient term provides a useful check. Its integration instead gives a temporal coefficient , so
This is the Bogoliubov spectrum. Its small- limit is the derived sound branch; at large within the contact model it crosses towards particle-like behaviour. The crossover in the squared dispersion is , precisely the scale beyond which the discarded density gradient is not small.
The same action checks the dimensional restriction in the saddle analysis. At nonzero temperature its zero Matsubara mode gives phase fluctuations proportional to ; at zero temperature integrating the frequency gives . Their infrared divergences invalidate uniform true long-range order for at nonzero temperature and for at zero temperature. The long-wave collective description can remain useful for correlations even where a global condensate saddle is not a literal symmetry-broken state. The contact coupling here is an effective low-energy parameter; this calculation does not determine ultraviolet renormalization or trap-specific surface modes.
Figure 1.
Original dimensionless Bogoliubov dispersion and its sound and particle limits
. Details.
Under the finite dilation, the volume element transforms as , whereas . Thus the kinetic term and quartic interaction both acquire the factor . Their factors cancel the Jacobian determinant, proving
A mass term would instead acquire a net factor in the action and break this scale invariance.
For the Noether current, use the variation at the same coordinate, rather than comparing values at different coordinates:
At , the corresponding Lagrangian density variation is . Thus , and the stated Noether current convention gives
The frequently used dilatation current is ; this is solely an overall parameter convention. In the convention , the virial current is .
Using solution and the trace computed in solution gives the useful identity
It follows that in the massless theory on shell. Equivalently, is a conserved current, since its divergence is the trace of the improved stress-energy tensor on shell. These are classical scale invariance statements; the nonzero beta function in solution explains why the interacting quantum theory need not retain them.
Let brackets denote mass dimension. In natural units, and , so a dimensionless action requires . The kinetic term fixes
The cubic scalar field theory interaction then requires , giving
The coupling constant is dimensionless at this critical dimension of a monomial scalar interaction. For it has positive mass dimension, while for it has negative mass dimension, the usual power counting distinction between super-renormalizable and non-renormalizable cubic interactions.
Let . The conjugate momentum fields are and . Inserting the given mode expansion of a free field into produces spatial Dirac delta factors. The and terms vanish after integration: they contain on , and . The number-conserving terms instead add their two frequency factors, cancelling the mode normalization. The un-subtracted ordered expression is
The last term is an infinite vacuum constant, not a finite physical vacuum charge. Choosing the Fock vacuum to have zero Noether charge, equivalently using normal ordering, gives
A state containing quanta created by and by has Noether charge . Thus the two families describe opposite unit Noether charges; with this source's current the quantum has positive Noether charge and the quantum negative Noether charge. This is an internal Noether charge; identifying it with electric charge requires a specified electromagnetic coupling. The vacuum subtraction of a complex scalar charge leaves all commutators unchanged.[ref]
Scope of the expansion: a fixed-frequency expansion with time-independent oscillator coefficients is the free-field or asymptotic-field form. For arbitrary interacting , it can be used as canonical oscillator coordinates at a chosen time, rather than as the exact interacting time dependence. For example, gives , which a generic free plane-wave superposition does not satisfy. The Noether charge and its generator action remain valid in the interacting theory; the symmetry does not depend on using a free Hamiltonian.
In spacetime dimensions, and a dimensionless action requires . Since , the canonical kinetic term fixes . The cubic and quartic terms then give
These brackets denote mass dimensions. The cubic coupling is dimensionless at , whereas the quartic coupling is dimensionless at . Hence there is no single dimension in which both nonzero couplings are dimensionless. For example, at the cubic coupling still has mass dimension one.[ref]
The scanned cover establishes Hilary Term 2018, despite the containing bundle's 2017 filename. Use , the Minkowski metric signature outside question 2, which uses Euclidean space, and . The phase and normalization conflicts in question 4 are identified in a; its path integral is evaluated with the normalization of its displayed action.
Use mass dimensions with , and dimensionless action. The Lagrangian density in Euclidean space has dimension , and the kinetic term fixes . Thus
A dimensionless coupling constant is therefore
Here is a positive regularization scale with mass dimension one. The interaction is marginal at its upper critical dimension , relevant below it and irrelevant above it by this engineering-dimension test. In particular, , while near . At this stage is the dimensionless version of the displayed bare coupling; after introducing counterterms one may use the same scale factor for the renormalized coupling.
The displayed oscillator expansion and the displayed action require two separate corrections to describe one conventional positive-energy theory. First compute what the oscillator algebra literally implies. Assume the two oscillator species commute with each other and annihilate the vacuum. Same-charge contractions vanish, so
For the two mixed contractions the printed phases give the same kernel, with :
Thus . In dimensions replace and by and ; the source's explicit three-dimensional spatial measure is the specialization. The covariant integral is manifestly Lorentz invariant. With
we have . This reversed-frequency scalar contraction has the opposite pole prescription to the usual positive-energy Feynman propagator. For a single zero-momentum mode at positive time separation, the printed contraction is , while is : this is a concrete phase counterexample, rather than an immaterial change of integration variable.
There is also a normalization of a complex scalar propagator conflict independent of those phases. The displayed Lagrangian density gives the canonical momentum . Substituting the printed modes yields
instead of the canonical . Reversing the mode phases repairs the sign but leaves , so it does not repair the normalization. The complex scalar field convention with unit mixed propagator normally has no in its quadratic action.[ref]
To retain the actual action in the paper, use with canonically normalized real components, or equivalently replace its mode expansion by
The corresponding path integral with the usual Feynman i-epsilon prescription has
with the two same-charge propagators still zero. This action-consistent kernel is used in b and c. Keeping conventional unit modes instead would require removing the quadratic factors from the action as well as reversing the phases. Those are distinct theories unless the field and its coupling are rescaled together.
A real scalar field suffices to describe one neutral species of bosonic quasiparticle. Let be its canonical momentum. In three spatial dimensions, choose the positive classical Hamiltonian
The same construction works in any number of spatial dimensions by replacing appropriately. Under a spatial Fourier transform, becomes , so the Hamiltonian is a collection of independent quantum harmonic oscillators with squared angular frequency . The usual reality condition pairs opposite momenta; it does not introduce a second species.
The canonical action is . Varying gives ; eliminating it by the Legendre transform gives
This Lagrangian density is local: only the field and finitely many derivatives at the same point occur. It contains second spatial derivatives but only first time derivatives, so no extra canonical time data are needed. A square root of a differential operator in the classical Hamiltonian is unnecessary. The fourth-order spatial term breaks Lorentz invariance while preserving spatial rotations and translations. This is a free scalar field with quartic spatial dispersion.
For a Lagrangian density depending on , , and , direct variation gives
Take to have compact support, so every boundary term vanishes. One integration by parts for the first-derivative terms and two for the second-derivative term yield the Euler-Lagrange field equation with second derivatives
The plus sign on the last term is essential. For the action in a, it is particularly transparent to vary the Laplacian directly:
Thus the classical equation of motion is
Here is the biharmonic operator. Substitution of the plane wave gives
A real classical solution combines complex-conjugate plane waves. Quantization assigns the positive branch to the excitation energy, giving the required dispersion relation. The negative-frequency branch supplies the creation operator part of the field, rather than negative excitation energy. Independently, the Hamiltonian in a gives , , confirming the same sign.
Variation of the action with respect to the independent Dirac adjoint gives . The gamma matrices chosen in a make the Dirac equation
Multiplication by gives the equivalent Dirac Hamiltonian form
For a plane wave , where is the signed one-dimensional momentum, the equation is
A nonzero spinor exists precisely when the determinant vanishes:
For , one possible unnormalized spinor solution is . Alternatively, follows from the Pauli matrix multiplication law, proving the same relativistic energy-momentum relation. Acting on the Dirac equation with also shows that each component satisfies , the Klein-Gordon equation.
A continuous Lorentz transformation in one spatial dimension must preserve . In the component connected to the identity, take the image of the time axis to have velocity , with , and write . Preservation of the Minkowski norm gives , so . The spacelike column must be orthogonal to the timelike column and have squared Minkowski norm ; continuity fixes it to . Thus
Here denotes the coordinate pair. This is the positive off-diagonal convention in the source; describing a passive frame moving at instead reverses the sign of .
Define the rapidity . The hyperbolic function identities give
In light-cone coordinates, and . Therefore the derivatives transform oppositely:
Use the field-transformation convention . The component action in c is invariant under
Indeed, the right-component kinetic term gains , and the left-component kinetic term gains . The two factors in each Dirac mass term cancel as well. Finally , so and the whole action is unchanged. These are the chiral boost weights in two spacetime dimensions.
In spinor notation, satisfies and , so . These identities directly verify covariance of the Dirac equation and the Lorentz invariance of its action. The matrices are not unitary with respect to the ordinary component norm; the Dirac adjoint supplies the invariant bilinear.
The statement about there being only Lorentz boosts applies to the identity component of the One-dimensional Lorentz group. The full Lorentz group also has discrete transformations: the concrete spatial reflection preserves the Minkowski metric but has determinant , so it cannot equal any displayed , whose determinant is .
Here three means the total spacetime dimension. A dimensionless action requires in mass dimensions. The kinetic term gives , so . Matching the mass dimensions of both field interaction terms gives
Thus has units of mass and is dimensionless. The quartic interaction is superrenormalizable by power counting, and is a marginal coupling by power counting.
A dimensionless action in six spacetime dimensions requires the Lagrangian density to have mass dimension six. The kinetic term then fixes , and each field interaction term must have the same mass dimension. Therefore
Equivalently, in powers of a length unit , has units , has units , and has units . Thus literal length exponents would be ; the 's in the supplied superficial degree of divergence formula must instead mean mass dimensions, namely . This distinction resolves the wording's convention mismatch.
To check the convention independently, let count internal lines, cubic interaction vertices, quartic interaction vertices, and independent loop momenta. A connected Feynman diagram obeys and . Hence its superficial degree of divergence is , agreeing with the supplied formula only with the mass dimensions above.
Use , the Minkowski metric , and . The momentum-space Feynman rules for the real scalar field are
At each interaction vertex impose two-dimensional momentum conservation; before removing the overall conservation factor this is . Integrate each independent loop momentum with , and divide a Feynman diagram by its symmetry factor. External lines carry the same scalar propagator in an unamputated two-point correlation function; they are removed in an amputated scattering amplitude.
The quadratic action is inverted with the Feynman i-epsilon prescription to obtain the scalar propagator. Expanding the Dyson series gives per insertion; the attachments in the Wick theorem cancel the factorial. Fourier integration over the insertion point supplies the momentum conservation factor. Automorphisms that leave the labelled external attachments fixed account for the remaining symmetry factor. In two spacetime dimensions the mass dimensions are and .
Put and . Since and , the Dirac adjoint transforms as
The chain rule gives , with and no sum in this formula. The Clifford algebra gives
Multiplication by therefore restores each kinetic term:
However, the Dirac scalar bilinear changes sign because :
Changing variables in the action has unit absolute Jacobian determinant. Hence
A nonzero Dirac mass term for this single two-component field breaks parity symmetry in quantum field theory with the specified transformation.
The specified time reversal includes complex conjugating ; omitting that operation changes the answer. Put , , and . As in c, the Dirac adjoint in the source's transformed bilinear is . The conjugated Dirac operator has coefficient matrices
Combining these coefficients with the chain rule signs and the Clifford algebra gives, without summing over ,
For example the time coefficient is , and the second spatial coefficient is . Thus the kinetic term is invariant. The real Dirac mass term again reverses sign since . The spacetime integration has unit absolute Jacobian determinant, so
Each operation reverses the sign of the mass, while their composition reverses it twice and preserves the kinetic term. In an operator formulation the complex conjugation of coefficients expresses the antiunitary operator character of time reversal; the transformation must not be treated as an ordinary unitary substitution with all 's held fixed. These statements concern the stated free action.
First conjugate the Dirac equation: . A matrix taking into another solution of the same Dirac equation must obey
Because anticommutes with the real and commutes with the purely imaginary , a unitary choice is
Any constant overall phase is equally valid. To verify invariance of the action, rather than only of its equation, keep the fermion exchange signs. Define the charge-conjugation matrix . It obeys
For a classical Grassmann field, interchanging two components contributes a minus sign; equivalently use normal ordering for quantum fermionic operators. Thus
and
The last term integrates to a boundary term, vanishing with the usual decay or compatible boundary conditions. Both the kinetic term and the Dirac mass term therefore leave invariant under charge conjugation. Treating the components as commuting numbers would give the wrong mass-bilinear sign; the fermion statistics is essential.
In spacetime dimensions, the dimensionless action gives and . The scalar kinetic term requires , whereas the fermion kinetic term requires . Thus the engineering dimensions of relativistic fields are
Matching each interaction to mass dimension three gives
Here the brackets mean exponents of mass in natural units. The coefficients are marginal couplings by classical power counting, and is a relevant coupling.
The mass dimensions are , , . Up to total derivatives, power counting allows local counterterms of mass dimension at most four. A convenient basis for the counterterm Lagrangian compatible with the actual parity symmetry in quantum field theory and Dirac fermion number conservation is
The optional constant renormalizes the vacuum energy density. The wavefunction renormalization, mass counterterms and Yukawa coupling renormalization correct the terms already present. The quartic interaction must also be included: the fermion loop with four external bosonic legs is logarithmically divergent, even if the renormalized quartic coupling is set to zero at one chosen renormalization scale. The displayed original interactions alone do not form a closed set of counterterms.
If “most general” is interpreted before imposing the parity symmetry in quantum field theory examined in d, Lorentz invariance, a Hermitian action and Dirac fermion number conservation also allow
Here all coefficients can be real in the paper's gamma matrix convention; the last term is Hermitian in the action up to a total derivative. It is an axial kinetic normalization, which could alternatively be removed by a suitable perturbative field redefinition. Every term in is odd under the actual parity symmetry in quantum field theory, so its coefficient vanishes in a symmetry-preserving renormalization scheme. Listing these terms makes explicit which assumption excludes a tadpole counterterm, a cubic scalar term, a scalar Yukawa interaction, a pseudoscalar Dirac mass term and an axial kinetic term.