Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2023 iii Paper 301 1 Solution 2026-09-28
A continuous symmetry is a family of transformations depending continuously on parameters for which the action is unchanged, possibly up to a spacetime boundary term. For an infinitesimal field variation , a Noether current obeyswhen the Euler-Lagrange field equation holds. Its Noether chargeis conserved provided the flux vanishes.
Noether theorem gives the implication from a differentiable global variational symmetry to an on-shell conserved current. A conserved current gives a conserved charge only under suitable boundary and convergence conditions. Conversely, a conserved charge generates a continuous symmetry through Poisson brackets classically or a commutator quantum mechanically when a regular Hamiltonian formulation exists. Currents can be changed by identically conserved improvement terms, and inverse Noether statements require regularity and the exclusion of such trivial currents, so the three notions are related but not literally in one-to-one correspondence.
For spacetime translations, the canonical stress-energy tensor isForraising the second index gives the symmetric tensorTranslation invariance gives four conserved currents , one for each fixed , and the four conserved charges are the four-momentum is the energy and is the spatial momentum.
The Lorentz transformation variation of a scalar is generated solely by its argument. The corresponding Lorentz current isUsing and symmetry of ,In particular, conservation of the boost chargeimpliesThe quantity denoted in the question is therefore the conserved momentum component , assuming the same vanishing boundary flux.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2024 iii Paper 309 1 a iii Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-25
For the quadratic geodesic Lagrangianthe Euler-Lagrange equation isRaising and symmetrizing the coefficient of the two velocities produces exactlyThe quadratic action fixes an affine parameter; proper time is an affine parameter for a timelike geodesic.
The identity element satisfies . For ,Both action axioms hold, so conjugation is a group action on .
By definition, stabilizes exactly when . Multiplying on the right by gives the equivalent condition . HenceThus the stabilizer in this action is the centralizer of the element.
An alpha emitter has an alpha-like cluster coupled to a daughter nucleus. Its positive decay energy is ; atomic masses may be used consistently because the electron counts balance. The daughter and alpha share this energy according to momentum conservation. The attractive nuclear interior and repulsive exterior Coulomb potential produce a quasibound state with a barrier, so positive does not imply rapid classical escape.
For daughter charge , the exterior barrier is approximately , , with outer turning radius . For zero orbital angular momentum, the leading WKB probability isHere is a nuclear matching radius, the reduced mass, an interior assault frequency and a preformation factor. The barrier factor alone cannot determine the latter two. Nonzero emitted orbital angular momentum adds a centrifugal barrier and can strongly hinder a transition.
The dominant action varies roughly as , explaining the Geiger-Nuttall relation and the enormous spread of alpha half-lives. angular momentum and parity constrain the emitted partial wave: a spin-zero positive-parity alpha requires and . Fine-structure alpha groups populate different daughter levels and therefore have different kinetic energies and penetrabilities. Shell structure and alpha clustering also change preformation probabilities, so equal values do not guarantee equal lifetimes. Escape conserves the total energy throughout tunnelling; the particle does not borrow a measured energy from the barrier.
Past exam of the philosophy of space-time course of the University of Oxford 2021 1 Solution 2026-10-25
There are two different issues: whether a law follows logically from the other laws, and whether an experiment can test it without assuming anything else. Newton's laws of motion have empirical content when combined with rules for identifying inertial frames, measuring mass and specifying forces. An experiment tests predictions of that combination. Calling every observed acceleration an otherwise unspecified force would remove the empirical constraint rather than verify Newton's second law. The distinction is central to the empirical testing of Newton's laws of motion.
Newton's first law contributes the claim that a common family of inertial frames exists: bodies with zero net external force have uniform straight motion in those frames. It is not enough to choose coordinates which straighten the trajectory of just one body; an admissible frame must accommodate many independent bodies and interactions. Once that frame and the ordinary constant-positive-mass form of Newton's second law are assumed,This conditional deduction does not establish the existence of the required frame, or independently identify the physical circumstances in which the net force vanishes. Defining an inertial frame and then counting a straight trajectory as proof of the definition would not be a test.
Nevertheless, the law of inertia has testable implications in a network of assumptions. Consider low-friction motion along an air track: determine positions at measured times, reduce the known residual influences, and ask whether the remaining acceleration approaches zero in the same laboratory frame for different bodies. Rotating the frame changes the description through Coriolis forces and centrifugal forces; this dependence must be accounted for. No finite experiment establishes that every unmeasured influence is absent, but varying the apparatus can discriminate an interaction from a frame effect. A failed prediction is evidence against some part of the package, not automatically the isolated verbal statement of Newton's first law.
Newton's second law is more than a definition if the force law and mass assignments constrain predictions before the new acceleration is measured. For instance, independently characterize a spring's reproducible extension response, specify the same interaction in several configurations, and compare the resulting accelerations for different bodies. If its strength and every mass are freely refitted to each outcome, agreement is empty. If they are fixed by an independently checked model and calibration, the law predicts held-out trajectories. Such a test remains conditional on the spring model, initial conditions and frame identification; this is an instance of the Duhem problem, not a reason to deny all empirical content.
Newton's third law supplies a different constraint. For two bodies exchanging forces, Newton's second law giveswhen there is no net external force. Equal-and-opposite interaction forces imply conservation of momentum for the pair. The two second-law equations alone do not require that cancellation: assigning and is algebraically consistent with both second-law equations while violating the third law. This is a logical countermodel, not a proposed isolated physical interaction. Measuring paired impulses or checking the pair's total momentum therefore tests an additional constraint, conditional on the assumed absence of momentum exchange with anything else.
The system boundary matters. In electromagnetism, matter can exchange momentum with the electromagnetic field. Instantaneous mechanical forces between two particles need not satisfy the simple pairwise statement, although total matter-plus-field momentum is conserved under the appropriate closed-system conditions. Likewise, Noether theorem can derive conservation of momentum from a translationally invariant action; that uses an extra symmetry assumption and does not derive the third law from the second alone.
Thus the first law is not an additional differential consequence once the full second-law framework is fixed, and the third law is not a consequence of that framework. All three can contribute to empirical tests, but none is tested in total isolation from frame, interaction and measurement assumptions. This preserves the difference between logical dependence and experimental testability.[ref]
The Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy by Isaac Newton (1846 edition). Axioms, or Laws of Motion: Laws I–III and the discussion following Law III
Past exam of the philosophy of space-time course of the University of Oxford 2021 5 Solution 2026-10-25
The phrase equivalence principle covers several related claims. The weak equivalence principle concerns the universality of free fall for test particles of negligible self-gravity, with the same initial conditions and no relevant nongravitational forces. In a Newtonian notation,Composition-independent motion requires the ratio of passive gravitational mass to inertial mass to be universal. Its common value can then be absorbed into the normalization of ; the empirical assertion is universality, not the numerical convention used to express the ratio.
The Einstein equivalence principle includes that universality and extends the claim to local nongravitational experiments through local Lorentz invariance and local position invariance. A sufficiently small freely falling laboratory should recover the nongravitational laws of special relativity. The strong equivalence principle extends the scope to local gravitational experiments and bodies with appreciable gravitational self-energy. An experiment establishing one part of the weak statement does not automatically establish these stronger claims.
The motivating elevator comparison makes both the power and the limitation clear. Release a small object in a freely falling cabin. The cabin and object share the local free fall, so the object initially floats relative to the cabin. In a cabin supported against gravity, a released object instead accelerates relative to the floor, as it does in a suitably accelerated cabin in flat spacetime. This suggested replacing a universal gravitational force by geometric inertial motion. It does not identify a finite planetary gravitational field with an accelerated frame everywhere: separated falling objects can have a measurable relative acceleration.
In general relativity, the precise local geometric statement is that one can choose normal coordinates at an event withThis eliminates the connection contribution to the geodesic equation at that point. It does not generally set the Riemann curvature tensor to zero. In normal coordinates the first metric corrections away from are quadratic in the coordinate separation, and geodesic deviation measures the associated tidal forces. Equivalence is a local approximation for finite experiments whose extent and duration make these corrections negligible; it is not an assertion that curvature has been transformed away.[ref]
General Relativity by David Tong. sections 3.3.2 and 3.3.4: normal coordinates and geodesic deviation
There are direct experimental consequences beyond the elevator thought experiment. An Eötvös experiment compares bodies of different composition on a torsion balance, using a differential signal to test the universality of gravitational acceleration. MICROSCOPE performed an analogous test in orbit using electrostatic control of titanium-alloy and platinum-alloy test masses. Its first published result in 2017 constrained their differential free fall; this was already available before the examination. It tested a specific weak-equivalence prediction, not every possible gravitational law.[ref]
The MICROSCOPE mission: first results of a space test of the Equivalence Principle by Pierre Touboul and others. 2017 abstract and experimental description: composition comparison and differential control forces
Comparisons of different atomic clocks can instead test local position invariance, including the expected gravitational redshift. These measurements constrain related but distinct parts of the framework.The principle remains important as a restriction on how matter couples to gravity and as an organizing guide for experimental tests. It does not, on its own, derive the Einstein field equations. Universally coupling matter to a metric tensor still leaves choices for that metric's action; the equivalence principle does not uniquely fix field equations. For example, a metric gravitational action containing a scalar curvature squared term can retain the same minimal matter coupling while changing the gravitational dynamics. Selecting the Einstein-Hilbert action requires further dynamical assumptions and empirical success. The present role of the principle is consequently precise and limited: it supports local relativistic physics and universal matter coupling, while curvature, gravitational field equations and their quantitative predictions remain additional content.
Past exam of the physics 1 paper of the University of Oxford 2018 1 Solution Created 2026-10-25 Updated 2026-11-05
For ordinary conservative classical mechanics, the Lagrangian is , where is the kinetic energy and the potential energy. More generally it is the function whose action satisfies the principle of stationary action. The canonical momenta and Hamiltonian areFor a regular Lagrangian, the first equations can be inverted to express the generalized velocities in terms of ; this defines the Legendre transform on phase space.
Along a solution of the Euler-Lagrange equations, . Taking a total time derivative givesThus an autonomous Lagrangian hasFor the usual time-independent mechanical coordinates and a velocity-independent potential energy, the kinetic energy is quadratic in the generalized velocities, so and . The conservation proof itself uses the Euler-Lagrange equations, rather than assuming this special expression for energy.
Past exam of the physics 1 paper of the University of Oxford 2019 9 a Solution Created 2026-10-25 Updated 2026-11-05
For a Lagrangian expressed in independent generalized coordinates, stationary action gives the Euler-Lagrange equationsIdeal constraints can either be incorporated into the independent coordinates or treated using Lagrange multipliers, as in solution.
In a classically forbidden region the local wavevector becomes imaginary. For a slowly varying barrier, the WKB transmission probability has leading exponentialwhere are turning points and is the reduced mass. This is a probability exponent; the wave amplitude has only half that exponent. Near a turning point one uses matching formulas rather than the unmodified local WKB expression.
For alpha decay, an attractive nuclear interior supports a quasibound state behind the repulsive Coulomb barrier of the daughter nucleus. For zero orbital angular momentum, write the exterior potential as , , with nuclear matching radius and outer turning point . The exterior action can be integrated:The decay rate is approximately and the half-life is . Here is the interior assault-frequency scale and is the alpha preformation probability. They are model-dependent; barrier penetration alone does not determine them. Nonzero orbital angular momentum adds a centrifugal barrier.
For , the leading dependence is . Thus a modest increase in decay energy can cause an enormous increase in decay rate, giving the Geiger-Nuttall law relating logarithmic half-life to inverse square-root energy along a suitable isotope sequence. Tunnelling conserves the total energy: the escaping alpha particle does not acquire energy from the barrier.
Past exam of the physics A course of the University of Cambridge 2022 Paper 1 Section D D9 Solution 2026-10-18
Time dependence in quantum mechanics describes how a prepared quantum state changes and thereby changes the probabilities of later measurements. For an isolated system, the Schrödinger picture assigns this evolution to a state vector , governed by the Time-dependent Schrödinger equationThe Hamiltonian is a self-adjoint operator; it has units of energy, while has units of action, so has units of inverse time. For a particle with potential energy , this becomesGiven a suitable initial wavefunction and the physical boundary conditions, this first-order equation determines its subsequent propagation. Its linearity means that the evolution of a quantum superposition is the corresponding quantum superposition of evolved states.
For a real potential energy, this equation and its complex conjugate imply the local continuity equationHere is the probability density and the probability current. Vanishing net boundary flux preserves wavefunction normalization, as required by the Born rule.
The time-evolution operator packages the solution for every initial state:Because , differentiation givesTherefore : this is unitary time evolution, preserving inner products and all state norms. It is reversible, with , and obeys the composition law .
For a time-independent Hamiltonian, the solution is the operator exponentialIf the Hamiltonian varies with time, the analogous simple exponential of its integral is valid when for all relevant times. Otherwise time ordering is essential:The meaning is explicit in the first terms of the ordered series,the later-time operator stands on the left. In the position representation, the same propagation is expressed by the quantum-mechanical propagatorIts initial value is the Dirac delta function .
A time-independent Hamiltonian has energy eigenstates satisfying . A single such initial state evolves asIt is a stationary state: its global phase changes, but its probability density and the distributions of time-independent observables do not. Its energy is sharp. Any quantum superposition entirely within one degenerate energy eigenspace also acquires one common global phase and is stationary. Stationarity does not require zero probability current; for instance, on the ring has a constant density and persistent circulation when .
An arbitrary normalized state can instead contain different energy eigenvalues:A continuous spectrum requires corresponding integrals. For the discrete case, an energy measurement gives with fixed probability (summed over degeneracies), but relative quantum phases change with time. ConsequentlyThe interference terms can oscillate at angular frequencies . For two populated energy levels, this supplies a characteristic period when the interference term is nonzero. Thus fixed energy populations do not imply a stationary spatial distribution.
For a normalized state and an observable , its expectation value isThis is the statistical mean over repeated preparations and measurements. In an eigenbasis of energy eigenstates for a time-independent Hamiltonian and a time-independent ,Only matrix elements connecting different energies can generate these oscillations. If , its expectation value is constant for every initial state, provided it has no explicit time dependence.
Differentiating the expectation value and substituting the Schrödinger equation for both the bra and ket proves the general Ehrenfest theorem:Equivalently,These manipulations require the state to lie in the relevant operator domains. Taking gives , so energy is conserved under a time-independent Hamiltonian.
For , the canonical commutation relation givesHence the particularly useful position-and-momentum form of Ehrenfest theorem isIt resembles Newton's second law, but the mean force generally differs from the force at the mean position. If a narrow wave packet samples a region where the force varies little, gives approximate classical motion. For a quadratic potential energy this replacement is exact. In particular the quantum harmonic oscillator obeysThe centroid follows the classical harmonic oscillator, although this does not specify the full evolving wavefunction or its width.
The Heisenberg picture expresses the same physics by assigning evolution to observables instead:The expectation value is unchanged, and differentiation yields . Thus state propagation, evolving expectation values, and the classical correspondence in Ehrenfest theorem are mutually consistent descriptions of the same unitary time evolution.
Generalized coordinates incorporate holonomic constraints without solving separately for every constraint force. For conservative mechanics use . The principle of stationary action makes the action stationary for variations vanishing at the endpoints. Integration by parts givesThe canonical momentum is . A cyclic coordinate gives conserved ; absent explicit time dependence, is conserved. These are symmetry–conservation relationships, not assumptions that all momenta are constant. Nonconservative generalized forces enter the right side.
Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge 2015 Paper 1 Section C C11 Solution 2026-10-20
In Lagrangian mechanics, choose independent generalized coordinates compatible with the mechanical constraints, write , and apply the Euler-Lagrange equationEquivalently, the physical path makes the action stationary under variations with fixed endpoints. For ideal holonomic constraints, their unknown reaction forces need not appear in the reduced equations. Direct use of Newton's laws of motion instead resolves vector forces and reactions and enforces the constraints separately. Both approaches describe the same mechanics; the scalar Lagrangian is often shorter in curvilinear coordinates. Nonconservative generalized forces must be added separately. Here a drive maintains the prescribed azimuthal angular velocity .
The mass has polar speed and azimuthal speed , so its kinetic energy is . The elastic potential energy is , and the height is , giving gravitational potential energy . Thereforeand the Euler-Lagrange equation givesFor , define and , so . Near zero,When the upright equilibrium is linearly stable and the small oscillations have .
For , the graph of initially rises, whereas . There must therefore be a zero inside the interval. More strongly, for ,is strictly decreasing: decreases and increases because . The ratio goes from to , giving exactly one zero in that interval. At the zero, , so it is a stable equilibrium. The rotating torsion-stabilized inverted pendulum also has a symmetric stable angle if both signs of tilt are permitted.
At , setting gives , soFor , the linearized equation is . Since ,At the threshold the linear restoring term vanishes, but the cubic term remains:The upright state remains nonlinearly stable, with no nonzero infinitesimal harmonic frequency. Small finite disturbances produce quartic oscillator motion whose frequency is proportional to its small angular amplitude; its period tends to infinity as that amplitude tends to zero. Zero linear stiffness is not the same as an absent restoring torque.
Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge 2018 Paper 2 Section B B8 c Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-11-05
In Lagrangian mechanics, generalized coordinates describe the independent configurations allowed by the constraints. For particles with ordinary conservative forces in an inertial frame, use , with kinetic energy and potential energy . Holonomic constraints can often be built into the coordinates, avoiding explicit constraint forces.
The principle of stationary action makes the action stationary for variations vanishing at the endpoints. Integrating the velocity variation by parts givesSince each independent variation is arbitrary, the Euler-Lagrange equations areIf nonconservative generalized forces are present, their components appear on the right. The formalism is invariant under suitable coordinate changes and adding a total time derivative to leaves the fixed-endpoint equations unchanged.
The generalized momentum is . If is cyclic, and is conserved. If has no explicit time dependence, the conserved energy function isFor a kinetic energy quadratic in velocities and a velocity-independent potential energy, this equals . This connects symmetry to conservation laws.
For example, a simple pendulum of mass and length hasIts tension does not appear because the fixed-length constraint is already imposed. Expanding for small gives simple harmonic motion with . More generally, expansion of and to quadratic order about a stable equilibrium leads directly to the normal-mode eigenvalue problem.
Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge 2021 Paper 2 Section B B6 b Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-11-05
Lagrangian mechanics expresses dynamics through generalized coordinates that respect the constraints. For a system with conservative, velocity-independent forces and standard kinetic energy, the Lagrangian is . Its equations follow from the principle of stationary action:for variations that vanish at the endpoints. Varying the integral and integrating the term by parts givesIndependent variations therefore yield the Euler-Lagrange equations:Additional nonconservative generalized forces appear on the right-hand side as . The action is stationary, not necessarily a minimum. For ideal holonomic constraints, using suitable generalized coordinates removes the need to solve explicitly for constraint forces.
The conjugate momentum is . If a coordinate is cyclic, and its conjugate momentum is conserved. If has no explicit time dependence, the energy functionis conserved. It equals for the usual quadratic kinetic energy with time-independent geometry, but that identification is not universal for every Lagrangian or constraint.
For example, a simple pendulum with angle , length and bob mass hasThe tension does no virtual work in the allowed angular displacement and never needs to be calculated to obtain the angular equation. The method scales naturally to coupled systems and coordinates with complicated geometry.
For , divide elapsed time into slices and apply the Trotter product formula. Inserting complete position and momentum bases gives the regulated phase-space path integralThe endpoint values are , . Each Gaussian momentum integration in a phase-space path integral can be performed explicitly, leaving the configuration-space path integralIts measure is the time-sliced limit of , with the usual infinitesimal convergence prescription. The integral sums amplitudes, not positive classical probabilities. Operator ordering remains part of the time-slice definition. Expanding a short-time kernel recovers the Schrödinger equation; composing kernels reproduces the time-evolution operator.
In the classical limit, rapid phase cancellation suppresses paths away from stationary action. Varying with fixed endpoints gives . The semiclassical result sums the classical-path phases multiplied by fluctuation functional determinants; for a quadratic Hamiltonian the fluctuation integral is Gaussian and this expansion is exact.
For quantum statistical mechanics, continue by a Wick rotation. The Euclidean action and thermal trace giveThe trace closes position-space paths. In a many-particle trace one also sums over endpoint permutations with the appropriate exchange signs. In a coherent state field formulation, bosonic fields are periodic and fermionic coherent states instead give antiperiodic Grassmann fields, hence bosonic and fermionic Matsubara frequencies and . [ref]
Physics 215C: Quantum Field Theory, Part 3 by John McGreevy. §§3.1–3.2, coherent-state time slicing and trace boundary conditions
The quantum-to-classical imaginary-time mapping views a local -dimensional quantum problem as a classical-looking field theory in dimensions, with imaginary-time extent . A genuine classical probability interpretation additionally requires a nonnegative weight; fermion signs and Berry terms can obstruct it.
For a smooth potential in the high-temperature or small- limit, imaginary-time paths fluctuate only over the thermal de Broglie wavelength . If this is short compared with the potential's variation scale, the diagonal free kernel givesThis classical phase-space limit of the thermal kernel is the classical phase space partition function for one degree of freedom. A dilute identical-particle gas also needs its factor; when exchange is appreciable, classical statistics fails. As a check, a single quantum harmonic oscillator gives , precisely the classical phase-space integral.
For one coordinate with Hamiltonian , the propagator is , where . Divide into intervals , use the Trotter product formula to separate kinetic and potential evolution, and insert complete position and momentum bases at each slice. The momentum integral is Gaussian:Multiplying the short-time kernels gives the time-sliced configuration-space path integral,with , . Continuum notation abbreviates this limit as , where . The measure includes the displayed normalization; it is not an unweighted count of paths. A small damping or analytic-continuation prescription defines the oscillatory integrals. The paths contribute complex amplitudes, so alternative histories interfere before probabilities are calculated. This is the central difference from a classical statistical mixture of trajectories.[ref]
Space-Time Approach to Non-Relativistic Quantum Mechanics by Richard Feynman. pp.367–374, action phases and construction of the propagator
When actions vary rapidly relative to , stationary phase selects classical paths. Put , with zero at the endpoints. Vanishing first variation gives . The quadratic term isThe resulting Gaussian fluctuation determinant is the semiclassical propagator prefactor. In one dimension, away from caustics,The branch convention makes for a direct free-particle path before any caustic. The Maslov index tracks the phase changes as fluctuations pass through a focal singularity. In several dimensions replace the endpoint derivative by the Van Vleck determinant. The approximation sums all relevant classical paths; real-time action need only be stationary, not a minimum. It fails in this simple form at a caustic or coalescing saddles, where a uniform approximation is needed. Quadratic actions have no higher fluctuation terms, making their Gaussian evaluation exact. For example gives the exact free-particle kernel . Tunnelling involves classically forbidden regions and can be described by imaginary-time saddles rather than real classical trajectories.
Quantum statistical mechanics follows by Wick rotation . The imaginary-time evolution operator is , with Euclidean actionTaking a thermal trace identifies and integrates the endpoint positions:This thermal trace as a closed Euclidean path integral explains the periodic imaginary-time direction. A density-matrix element instead retains open endpoints. For many identical particles the trace also sums over endpoint permutations, with a plus sign for bosons and permutation parity for fermions. In coherent-state language this becomes periodic bosonic fields and antiperiodic Grassmann fields, with corresponding Matsubara frequencies.
The Euclidean weight resembles a classical Boltzmann weight. A time-sliced local quantum field in spatial dimensions becomes a classical-looking field model in dimensions, with anisotropic couplings and extra extent . Thus zero-temperature quantum criticality can be treated using an infinitely extended imaginary-time direction, while nonzero temperature imposes a finite thickness. The dynamical scaling of time need not equal the spatial scaling: the dynamical critical exponent specifies their relationship. This quantum-to-classical imaginary-time mapping requires qualification when weights have signs or imaginary terms; such a functional integral is not automatically an ordinary positive classical probability distribution. Even with a positive weight, the mapping concerns equilibrium statistics, not literal dissipative real-time trajectories. For a free particle the Euclidean kernel is a diffusion kernel with diffusion coefficient , illustrating the mathematical correspondence.
The classical high-temperature limit is a further approximation, rather than simply another name for imaginary time. If quantum level spacings and exchange effects are negligible, a one-particle partition function in dimensions becomesFor indistinguishable particles there is a factor in the dilute classical gas, and exchange is negligible when the number density times the thermal de Broglie wavelength to power is small. For a harmonic oscillator, the exact quantum result tends to as , recovering the classical phase-space integral. stationary phase explains classical mechanics; the short imaginary-time, weak-exchange limit explains classical statistical mechanics. These are related but distinct limits of the same quantum formulation.
Consider a conventional spin-singlet, weak-coupling, three-dimensional superconductor. Set in the microscopic action and restore electromagnetic units below. An attraction in an energy shell about the Fermi surface gives a Grassmann actionThe attractive sign permits pairing even when the single-particle Fermi gas is otherwise stable. A complex Hubbard–Stratonovich transformation introduces a pair field proportional at the saddle to . The action is then quadratic in fermions. Integrating them out gives the BCS pairing-field effective actionHere the trace uses one independent Nambu spinor pairing block; a fully doubled particle-hole representation instead carries its corresponding one-half factor. At a uniform saddle the Bogoliubov--de Gennes Hamiltonian can be written asThe negative branch describes the paired vacuum; excitations are Bogoliubov quasiparticles mixing particles and holes. Extremizing the effective action givesThe physical cutoff or a renormalized interaction is part of the microscopic model; an unregulated contact integral must not be used indiscriminately. With constant density of states per spin and shell half-width , the zero-temperature weak-coupling solution is . The exponentially small scale follows from the logarithmic pairing susceptibility of states near the Fermi surface. For this ideal weak-coupling model, . The microscopic theory relates the gap, pairing and thermodynamic transition.[ref]
Theory of Superconductivity by John Bardeen and others. pp.1175–1177 and the energy-gap and finite-temperature developments
Close to a continuous transition, for fields varying slowly compared with microscopic scales, expand the effective action in powers and gradients of . Its static part is the Ginzburg-Landau theory of superconductivity:The normalization of fixes the coefficients; here changes sign at . The uniform minimum has for , condensation free-energy density , and characteristic coherence-length scale . Above the transition the minimum is at zero. The quartic stabilization and gradient cost are precisely the ingredients of Landau theory for a complex order parameter. This controlled near-transition expansion supplies a bridge between microscopic BCS theory and macroscopic magnetic response; its coefficients and validity depend on the material and fluctuation regime.[ref]
Microscopic Derivation of the Ginzburg-Landau Equations in the Theory of Superconductivity by Lev Gor'kov. pp.1364–1367, microscopic expansion near the transition
Write . The radial fluctuation has positive local restoring curvature, whereas the phase has no local potential in a neutral theory with global symmetry. Freezing the amplitude givesThe neutral case supports a gapless collective phase mode. In the charged case the electromagnetic field couples to this phase rigidity. Under and , the displayed combination is invariant. Locally choosing a gauge with constant phase leaves a quadratic term in . Varying the free energy gives the transverse London current and magnetic screening scale,Combining this relation with static Maxwell equations gives exponential field penetration, the Meissner effect. Single-valuedness of the pair field around a loop with negligible current gives flux in units . These are gauge-invariant physical consequences of the condensate stiffness.
For the dynamics, the neutral phase and density mode is reorganized by the Coulomb interaction and the dynamical electromagnetic field. In a bulk three-dimensional system the long-wave longitudinal mode has a plasma gap, rather than remaining the neutral sound mode. This is the Anderson-Higgs mechanism in a superconductor: a phase coordinate becomes part of the electromagnetic collective response instead of surviving as an independent massless physical particle. Local gauge transformations are redundancies of the description, so a literal breaking of a local redundancy is not an observable. Phase coherence, current response and magnetic screening provide the physical statements.[ref]
Plasmons, Gauge Invariance, and Mass by Philip Warren Anderson. pp.439–442, plasma oscillations and the charged versus neutral matter spectrum
A static Landau functional alone cannot determine that full dynamical spectrum. A two-dimensional film, for example, need not have the same long-wave plasma dispersion as a bulk charged system. Nor does a positive radial curvature automatically guarantee a sharp Higgs amplitude resonance: coupling to quasiparticles and other modes can damp it. The chosen mean-field phase is also a thermodynamic symmetry-breaking description; an isolated finite system can be formulated with definite particle number. The microscopic pairing saddle, the near-transition Landau expansion and the electromagnetic Anderson-Higgs response describe successive scales of the same superconducting state, with distinct assumptions at each step.
For a uniform time-independent saddle, extremizing the action gives . Its grand-potential density is , with . Since , the minimum at positive density for isFor the uniform mean-field minimum is the vacuum, rather than a positive-density condensate. At fixed nonzero density in the weakly interacting condensed regime, the saddle relation sets . The mean-field one-body density matrix factorizes as , giving macroscopic occupation of the uniform mode. Depletion corrections are omitted at this stage.
The action has the global particle-number symmetry , . Choosing one saddle phase breaks this symmetry; the degenerate mean-field minima form the circle . There is no energetic preference for a uniform value of , but spatially varying phase costs gradient energy. Consequently a neutral condensate has a gapless Goldstone mode and a nonzero phase stiffness. The mode becomes sound once density dynamics is included. With the superfluid velocity is , so a single-valued field allows circulation in units around a closed loop that avoids zeros of the amplitude. This phase coherence and rigidity are the physical content of the broken-symmetry description.
The claim is a mean-field saddle statement, not an assertion that every and temperature in the question supports true long-range order. In a finite number-conserving system ; the symmetry-breaking order parameter is defined with the thermodynamic limit taken before an infinitesimal source is removed. In a homogeneous infinite short-range gas at nonzero temperature, infrared phase fluctuations prohibit true condensation in . In one dimension they also destroy true condensate long-range order at zero temperature. A two-dimensional gas can nevertheless have superfluidity and algebraically decaying correlations below a Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless transition. A finite trap can have substantial coherence without contradicting these thermodynamic statements.[ref]
Existence of Long-Range Order in One and Two Dimensions by Pierre Hohenberg. abstract and pp.383–386; finite-temperature restriction
On the physical density-phase contour put . Direct differentiation givesIntegrating the Laplacian by parts with the stated bulk boundary convention, and dropping the periodic total derivative of , produces the density-phase action of a Bose gas,Write and , where is constant. To quadratic order,The uniform static density fluctuation has positive curvature . Its inverse static susceptibility at wavevector is , which remains nonzero at . This is the sense in which the amplitude or density fluctuation is massive. The phase has no term proportional to without derivatives; a uniform phase rotation costs no action. It is the massless direction required by global symmetry.
The term shows density-phase conjugacy. It is important to distinguish static density stiffness versus an excitation gap: the density and phase do not form two independent normal-mode branches with one gapped and one gapless particle. In this nonrelativistic first-order theory they supply the conjugate variables of one positive Bogoliubov branch, derived below. The omitted cubic terms include and corrections from the density-gradient denominator.
There is also a background term . It vanishes for smooth fluctuations with zero temporal winding. Periodicity of , however, permits . The compact phase winding term must be retained when such sectors are included; it is not generally the same constant in all sectors. The local Gaussian phonon calculation concerns the smooth zero-winding sector and does not describe vortices or points where the density vanishes.
