By part (a), the Paris model is well-founded. Let be an automorphism of a first-order structure of . External epsilon induction shows that every element is fixed: if for every , then preservation of membership and extensionality give
Hence is the identity function. This is Paris models are rigid when their complete theory has a well-founded model, so every Paris model of is a rigid first-order structure.
This can fail. Let and , put , and let . Then the function composition is the identity function on , hence is a surjective function, although is not surjective.
Take
Now
so
The recurrent pieces of this covering graph are the two-cycle and the loop at ; neither contains two competing closed routes. Also
so this ordering forces no 3-cycle.
The bound is attained by the piecewise-linear function
Indeed,
is a 4-cycle with the required spatial order. On , the fourth iterate is the identity function. Within , the fixed point is and
so every other point eventually leaves and enters . The map therefore has no horseshoe in any iterate and is not chaotic. The minimum number of distinct 3-cycles is consequently .