Past exam of the physics 1 paper of the University of Oxford / 2015 resit / 10

Use spherical coordinates about the fixed pivot, with fixed rod length $l$, polar angle $\theta$ measured from the downward vertical, and azimuth $\varphi$. The bob's position iswhen the Cartesian $z$ axis points upward. Differentiation gives kinetic energy $T=m{l}^2({\dot{\theta }}^2+{\sin }^2\theta {\dot{\varphi }}^2)/2$. Taking zero gravitational potential energy at pivot height gives $V=-mgl\cos \theta$. The spherical pendulum's Lagrangian is thereforeThe rod is light, rigid and of fixed length; pivot friction and air drag are neglected. A rigid rod, unlike a string, may sustain either tensile or compressive constraint force.

The azimuth $\varphi$ is a cyclic coordinate, since $\partial \mathcal{L}/\partial \varphi =0$. Its Euler-Lagrange equation gives conservation of the vertical component of angular momentum:This $h$ is the actual angular momentum, not specific angular momentum. The Lagrangian also has no explicit time dependence. The conserved energy isAlong solutions, $\dot{E}=-\partial \mathcal{L}/\partial t=0$. These are the conserved quantities associated with rotational symmetry about the vertical and time-translation symmetry, respectively.

The $\theta$ Euler-Lagrange equation readsHenceThe first term reflects the coupling to azimuthal motion; the second is the gravitational restoring contribution for an angle measured from the downward vertical.

Constant azimuth. If $\varphi$ is constant, $\dot{\varphi }=0$ and the motion is a planar simple pendulum:For the small-angle approximation, $\sin \theta \simeq \theta$, giving simple harmonic motion withThe harmonic angular frequency requires small amplitude. At finite libration amplitude ${\theta }_{\max }<\pi$, the exact oscillation period is $4\sqrt{l/g}K(\sin ({\theta }_{\max }/2))$, where $K$ is the complete elliptic integral of the first kind; the nonlinear pendulum does not have the same amplitude-independent period.

Constant polar angle. If $\theta ={\theta }_0$ is nonzero and constant, the bob traces a horizontal circle: this is a conical pendulum. Setting $\ddot{\theta }=0$ and dividing by $\sin {\theta }_0$ givesThe sign distinguishes the two senses of rotation. The exactly downward configuration ${\theta }_0=0$ is stationary; its azimuth is undefined and it must not be obtained by dividing by $\sin {\theta }_0$. A nontrivial constant-angle orbit of this gravity-only system needs $\cos {\theta }_0>0$ even though the supporting rod can also push.

Fixed-angular-momentum form. Eliminating $\dot{\varphi }$ using the conserved angular momentum $h$ givesEquivalently, the polar motion has effective potentialFor the steady conical pendulum at ${\theta }_0$, $\ddot{\theta }=0$, soThe sign of $h$ agrees with the sign of $\Omega$; substituting $h=m{l}^2{\sin }^2{\theta }_0\Omega$ verifies the constant-angle result in part (d).

Period of small polar oscillations. Put $\theta ={\theta }_0+\alpha (t)$, with $|\alpha |\ll 1$ and $h$ held fixed. This is the appropriate small nutation about a conical pendulum; keeping $\dot{\varphi }$ fixed instead would violate the angular momentum constraint during the oscillation. Ifthen $f({\theta }_0)=0$ andThe linearization is $\ddot{\alpha }+{\omega }_{\theta }^2\alpha =0$, givingSince $0<{\theta }_0<\pi /2$, the coefficient is positive and these small polar oscillations are stable. To first order, $\dot{\varphi }=\Omega (1-2\alpha \cot {\theta }_0)$, making the compensating change in azimuthal angular velocity explicit. The limit ${\omega }_{\theta }/|\Omega |\to 2$ as ${\theta }_0\to 0$ concerns radial modulation of a small nonzero circular orbit; the exactly planar $h=0$ pendulum is a different, degenerate limit of these polar coordinates.