Past exam of the physics B course of the University of Cambridge / 2015 / Paper 1 / Section C / C10

For the attractive inverse-square force, choose zero potential energy at infinity, so $U=-A/r$. At either radial turning point $r_p,r_a$, the kinetic energy is purely tangential, with conserved angular momentum $J$. ThusIts two roots are the periapsis and apoapsis distances. Their sum is $r_p+r_a=-A/E$, whereas the ellipse has $r_p+r_a=2a$. Therefore $a=-A/(2E)$, with $E<0$ for a nondegenerate bound ellipse. The circular case follows by the double-root limit.

For the two-body problem, define $\mathbf{r}={\mathbf{r}}_B-{\mathbf{r}}_A$, total mass $M=m_A+m_B$, reduced mass $\mu =m_A{m}_B/M$, and center of mass $\mathbf{R}$. The relative equation is $\mu \ddot{\mathbf{r}}=\mathbf{F}$, while the isolated center of mass has $\ddot{\mathbf{R}}=0$. Once the relative orbit is known,The relative energy uses $\mu$ in its kinetic energy and $A=G{m}_A{m}_B$ in the gravitational potential energy.

In the equal-mass case the initial relative speed is $u$, $\mu =m/2$, and the center-of-mass velocity is half B's initial velocity. ThusNegative relative energy requires $u^2<4Gm/a_1$. The escape threshold is $u_E=2\sqrt{Gm/a_1}$; equality is marginal parabolic escape, so a strictly bound pair has $u<u_E$.

For $u=u_E/2=\sqrt{Gm/a_1}$, $E_{\mathrm{rel}}=-3G{m}^2/(4a_1)$ and the relative semimajor axis is $a=2a_1/3$. The initial transverse speed is below the relative circular value $\sqrt{2Gm/a_1}$, so the initial turning point is apoapsis. HenceChoose the initial separation along $+x$ from A to B, with B's initial velocity $+u\hat{\mathbf{y}}$. Conservation of angular momentum gives relative periapsis speed $3u$. At the opposite end of the ellipse the direction is $-\hat{\mathbf{y}}$, soThus B has the same speed as initially but the opposite velocity. A has $2u\hat{\mathbf{y}}$ at that instant. A value $3u/2$ for B would be its center-of-mass-frame speed, not the requested initial laboratory frame result.

The relative orbital period follows from Kepler's third law with total gravitating mass $2m$:In the center-of-mass frame each star follows an ellipse of semimajor axis $a_1/3$ and eccentricity $1/2$, with the center of mass at a focus; they remain opposite on their simultaneous position vectors. In the laboratory frame add the uniform drift $ut/2$ along $y$. The laboratory paths of an equal-mass binary are therefore not closed ellipses, even though their relative motion repeats.