Let . If , use the constant path. Otherwise consider the countably many lines through and a point of , and through and a point of . Choose a line whose direction is not parallel to any of these lines; such a direction exists because there are uncountably many directions but only a countable set of forbidden ones. Every forbidden line meets in at most one point. Choose outside those countably many intersections and outside .
Neither segment nor meets : a forbidden point on either segment would put on the corresponding forbidden line. The piecewise linear path
lies in the complement. This proves that the plane minus a countable set is path connected.
If a homeomorphism existed, its restriction after removing a point would give a homeomorphism between and . The first is a path-connected space and therefore connected; the second consists of two separated intervals. Since homeomorphisms preserve connectedness, .
The conclusions of (b) and (c) remain true. Indeed, the unit circle is a path-connected space, and the upper semicircle supplies a path from to ; restricting the proposed closed cover or two-valued continuous function to that path reduces either claim to the corresponding result on .
The fixed-point conclusion (d) fails. For example, any nontrivial spatial rotation of the unit circle has no fixed point when ; the antipodal map is the simplest example.
A topological space is connected when it is not the union of two disjoint nonempty open subsets. It is path-connected when every two points can be joined by a path, meaning a continuous map with and .
To prove that is connected, suppose it had a separation with . Let
Whichever of or contains , its relative openness supplies an interval about that contradicts either the definition of the supremum or the fact that all points immediately below lie in . Thus no separation exists.
If is path-connected and were a separation, choose and . A path from to would make the union of the disjoint nonempty open sets and , contradicting the connectedness just proved. Hence
Now let be open. Every point lies in an open ball contained in , and an open ball is path-connected by straight line segments. It follows that every path component of is open. If there were more than one path component, one component and the union of all the others would separate . Consequently a connected open subset of Euclidean space is path-connected. The converse follows from the preceding implication.
The same argument answers the locally Euclidean question affirmatively. Every point has a neighbourhood homeomorphic to an open subset of , hence a path-connected open neighbourhood after restricting to a sufficiently small ball. Thus is locally path-connected, its path components are open, and connectedness forces there to be only one.
For the final example, put
The set is path-connected: each vertical segment meets the horizontal segment . The segment is also path-connected and lies in the closure of , because for every . A connected set together with a connected subset of its closure is connected, so
It is not path-connected. The image of the first coordinate of any path in lies in
but, while the path has positive height, its first coordinate lies in the totally disconnected set . A path beginning on cannot leave before reaching height zero, and contains no point with . Hence no path joins to , and
Given group homomorphisms and , their amalgamated free product is a group with maps and satisfying , such that every pair , satisfying factors through a unique homomorphism .
The Seifert-van Kampen theorem says that if , where , and are open and path-connected and , then the inclusion maps induce
Here is a direct proof of the requested generation statement. For a based loop in , the Lebesgue number lemma supplies a subdivision
such that every arc lies in one . Combine adjacent arcs assigned to the same set, so each transition point lies in . Since the intersection is path-connected, choose a path in it from to , taking constant. Then
is a loop in . In the product of their classes, each cancels by path reversal, leaving . Thus the two inclusion images generate , as summarized by generation of a fundamental group by two open sets.
Now let be the standard generators in the fundamental group of the torus. A Möbius band retracts to a core circle, while its boundary traverses that core twice. If and denote the core classes of the two attached bands, the Seifert-van Kampen theorem gives
The two attaching classes and commute. Their exponent matrix has determinant
so they form a basis of , with
Substituting and eliminates and leaves the two-generator one-relator presentation
This is the calculation in two Möbius bands attached to a torus.
Finally send to and to in the symmetric group . Both squares are the identity, so the relator is satisfied, and these transpositions generate . We obtain a surjective group homomorphism from onto the nonabelian group . Therefore is nonabelian.
No. Take
It contains more than one point and has the fixed-point property of a closed interval, but it is not homeomorphic to the closed unit disc. Indeed, deleting any point with disconnects , so such a point is a cut point. Deleting one point from a two-dimensional closed disc leaves a path-connected space. Since being a cut point is preserved by homeomorphisms, the two spaces cannot be homeomorphic. This gives the required counterexample.
Let . A tree has a unique geodesic segment . The isometry sends this segment to the segment . An isometry of a segment that fixes both endpoints fixes every point of it, so
Thus the fixed-point set of an elliptic isometry of a tree is a convex subtree, in particular it is path-connected.