After cosmological weak freeze-out, the surviving neutron fraction is , where is the initial neutron-to-proton ratio and is the mean lifetime. Baryon number is conserved because a decaying neutron becomes a proton. If almost all surviving neutrons enter helium-4, neutron-limited helium synthesis gives the displayed primordial helium mass fraction. Increasing the half-life increases survival. If the longer lifetime also represents uniformly weaker weak interactions, it raises the temperature of cosmological weak freeze-out and the initial neutron fraction, reinforcing the helium increase. That last conclusion requires specifying how the weak rates change, rather than treating lifetime alone as a complete microscopic model.
A moderately enhanced Hubble parameter raises the primordial helium mass fraction through earlier cosmological weak freeze-out and less free-neutron decay after freeze-out, provided nuclear burning still incorporates nearly all surviving neutrons into helium-4. This provision matters: if expansion carries the gas through the nuclear-burning temperature range faster than the reaction times, neutron-limited helium synthesis no longer applies. More neutrons surviving the bottleneck alone does not prove more final helium in that limit.
At a fixed temperature, the deuterium equilibrium abundance contains an explicit factor through . Two nucleons have to encounter each other to make one bound nucleus. Their capture rate per volume is proportional to , whereas nuclear photodisintegration competes through the very numerous thermal photons. The small baryon-to-photon ratio therefore delays stable deuterium formation until , producing the deuterium bottleneck. Changing the cosmological baryon density changes both its release time and the subsequent efficiency of nuclear burning. The residual primordial deuterium abundance is particularly sensitive to these rates: on the usual nucleosynthesis branch, increasing burns more deuterium into heavier nuclei and lowers the remaining D/H. The positive dependence of the instantaneous equilibrium expression and the negative dependence of the final relic D/H are different statements.
By contrast, once nuclear reactions are efficient, nearly every surviving neutron ends in helium-4. Two neutrons make each helium-4 nucleus, so and
This primordial helium mass fraction is mainly neutron limited: is set by weak conversion, cosmological weak freeze-out and free-neutron decay after freeze-out, rather than by the absolute baryon density. There is a weaker dependence because a higher releases the deuterium bottleneck earlier and allows fewer neutrons to decay. Thus is comparatively insensitive, not exactly independent, of . At such exceptionally small baryon densities that nuclei never form efficiently, the neutron-limited approximation would fail.
At neutrino decoupling, the interaction rate is comparable with the Hubble parameter. Equating the supplied rates gives
Here the Planck mass is the unreduced in natural units, , and the effective number of relativistic energy degrees of freedom is . The supplied rate gives an order-of-magnitude neutrino decoupling estimate; a precise neutron-proton conversion temperature uses its own weak-rate coefficients.
The chemical equilibrium condition for is . With negligible lepton chemical potentials, . The nonrelativistic Maxwell--Boltzmann number density therefore gives
because and the small mass difference can be neglected in the prefactor. This is the neutron-proton chemical equilibrium relation.
For the deuterium equilibrium abundance, because photons have zero chemical potential. The sign convention in the paper is important: , while the positive nuclear binding energy is . Using spin multiplicities , gives
With , , and photon number density , this becomes
Here is a number fraction; the fraction of baryons bound in deuterium is . The formula estimates the onset of the deuterium bottleneck opening while depletion of free neutrons and protons remains small. Because , stable deuterium becomes abundant only far below the positive nuclear binding energy, not simply at .
Let denote cosmological weak freeze-out of the neutron-to-proton ratio, , and let mark efficient nuclear burning. Free-neutron decay after freeze-out gives
Almost every surviving neutron enters helium-4, whose atomic nucleus contains two neutrons and four baryons. Thus neutron-limited helium synthesis gives
A longer neutron half-life leaves more neutrons available, increasing the primordial helium mass fraction. If the longer lifetime reflects weaker weak interactions, the accompanying earlier cosmological weak freeze-out can reinforce that effect.
During radiation domination, whereas the weak conversion rate is proportional to . Hence . Increasing the effective number of relativistic energy degrees of freedom raises , increasing , and shortens the interval for free-neutron decay after freeze-out. Both increase the primordial helium mass fraction while nuclear burning remains efficient. The same reasoning gives the primordial helium response to a varying gravitational constant: larger over this interval produces more helium, with fixed microscopic rates and the approximate Friedmann equation unchanged. Smaller has the opposite effect. A particular varying- model must specify its background expansion and time history; the simple trend must not be extrapolated to changes so large that nuclear burning itself fails.
Use natural units and the unreduced Planck mass . Neutrino decoupling occurs when the weak interaction rate falls below the Hubble parameter. The weak-decoupling temperature estimate equates the given rate with the radiation-era expansion rate:
Here counts the effective number of relativistic energy degrees of freedom, and the Fermi constant is . The omitted reaction-rate coefficients make this an order-of-magnitude estimate: decoupling occurs at a temperature of order one MeV.
The charge-conserving channel is , together with . The positron sign in the printed neutron-capture channel violates electric charge conservation. Chemical equilibrium requires . Negligible lepton chemical potentials therefore give . Since neutrons and protons are nonrelativistic particles, their Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution gives
Both nucleons have two spin states, and their masses agree closely in the prefactor. Thus neutron-proton chemical equilibrium implies
The heavier neutron is suppressed by a Boltzmann factor.
For the deuterium equilibrium abundance, retain the paper's convention ; the positive nuclear binding energy is . Chemical equilibrium of gives because the equilibrium photon chemical potential vanishes. Using the nonrelativistic Maxwell--Boltzmann number density for each species and dividing gives
Here and . With the baryon-to-photon ratio , the photon number density , and , , this becomes
In this convention counts nuclei, so its contribution to the fraction of baryons in deuterium is .
The deuterium bottleneck explains why helium-4 formation waits until is far below . At higher temperature, there are vastly more photons than baryons; even the dilute energetic tail can destroy newly formed deuterium. A crude estimate balances against one, giving for of order . The power-law factors in the deuterium equilibrium abundance and the nuclear reaction rates refine this estimate. Once stable deuterium accumulates, further reactions can efficiently place nearly all surviving neutrons into helium-4.
Write at the onset of nuclear burning. Each helium-4 nucleus requires two neutrons and contains four baryons. Neutron-limited helium synthesis therefore gives the primordial helium mass fraction
For a realistic rough cosmological weak freeze-out estimate, is about and free-neutron decay after freeze-out reduces it to about , giving roughly one quarter of the baryonic mass in helium-4. The survival relation that conserves baryon number is ; the corresponding is .
The rough neutrino decoupling rate by itself does not determine that one-quarter value. Substituting literally into would give and before neutron decay. Neutron-proton chemical equilibrium persists to a lower temperature, approximately -- once the actual conversion rates are included. The rate scaling fixes the MeV scale; accurate abundances need the conversion coefficients and the delay through the deuterium bottleneck. This sequence is described in David Tong's discussion of nucleosynthesis.
Increasing reduces the equilibrium neutron-to-proton ratio, so the primordial helium abundance decreases. Holding the freeze-out temperature and the decay survival factor fixed, the primordial helium response to the neutron-proton mass difference is
For and -- this is about --, a reduction of roughly fifteen percent. A larger also changes neutron decay and detailed weak rates; their quantitative effects require more microscopic information. The sign from the Boltzmann factor is already clear.
The main abundance parameter is the baryon-to-photon ratio , often expressed as . For the measured mean cosmic microwave background temperature, . Standard Big Bang nucleosynthesis also depends on the expansion rate, the effective number of neutrino species, the neutron lifetime and the nuclear reaction rates.
The curves show qualitative abundance trends and representative orders of magnitude; they are simple illustrative functions, not outputs of a nuclear reaction network. Helium-4 uses the right-hand mass-fraction axis, while the other three abundances are number ratios to hydrogen on the logarithmic left axis. The lithium valley and its rising high-density branch are important and must not be replaced by a monotone curve.
At higher , two-body reactions proceed more rapidly relative to cosmic expansion and burn deuterium more efficiently, so D/H falls strongly, approximately as near the favored density. Helium-3 decreases more gently. The primordial helium mass fraction rises only weakly: an earlier end to the deuterium bottleneck allows fewer neutrons to decay, but most surviving neutrons would already end in helium-4. Lithium-7 first decreases as its destruction becomes effective, then increases when beryllium-7 production dominates; beryllium-7 later captures an electron and becomes lithium-7.
A faster expansion changes both freeze-out and the time available for reactions. In units , weak neutron–proton conversion has rate , whereas ; consequently . Since the equilibrium neutron-to-proton ratio is , additional radiation raises it; the shorter subsequent decay interval also raises . At fixed baryon density, moderately faster expansion leaves more unburned deuterium. A longer neutron lifetime similarly increases neutron survival. These trends assume ordinary efficient burning and no independent modifications of the nuclear or weak rates.
Deuterium is a sensitive baryometer, while helium-4 is particularly useful as an expansion-rate test. Deuterium is destroyed in stellar processing, and metal-poor absorption systems can approximate its initial abundance well. Helium's weak dependence on limits its precision as a baryometer, and its spectroscopic corrections matter. Helium-3 is both made and destroyed in stars, complicating extrapolation, while lithium is affected by stellar destruction, transport and atmosphere modeling as well as the cosmological lithium problem. Accurate comparisons therefore require nuclear-rate and astrophysical uncertainties, not merely narrow instrumental error bars. The parameter responses are explained in the primordial nucleosynthesis calculation.
A larger baryon-to-photon ratio favours bound nuclei at a fixed temperature through the equilibrium factor . In particular it helps deuterium survive photodissociation sooner: there are fewer energetic photons per baryon, and nuclear reaction rates per baryon also rise. A schematic deuterium bottleneck condition is , suppressing slowly varying powers of temperature. It gives
Thus higher permits burning at a higher temperature. During radiation domination that means earlier cosmic time, , leaving less time for free-neutron decay after freeze-out. More neutrons enter helium, so the final helium-4 mass fraction increases, ordinarily rather weakly. This is the baryon-density effect on primordial helium.
The equilibrium helium factor indicates the direction of the change but is not a prediction that the final helium abundance grows without bound as . Once almost all surviving neutrons are captured, the final primordial helium mass fraction is limited by their supply, as the shared neutron budget shows.
The small baryon-to-photon ratio suppresses nuclear equilibrium abundances through the factor . Cooling eventually makes the binding-energy exponential favourable, but the deuterium bottleneck delays substantial nuclear burning until well after cosmological weak freeze-out. In ordinary Big Bang nucleosynthesis, nearly every neutron surviving that delay ends up in helium-4. This makes the final primordial helium mass fraction chiefly a neutron budget rather than an unrestricted equilibrium abundance.
Let be the neutron-to-proton ratio at freeze-out, let be the delay until effective nuclear burning, and let be the neutron mean lifetime. The initial fraction of baryons which are neutrons is . Because neutron decay converts a neutron into a proton, total baryon number remains constant, while the neutron fraction becomes . Each helium nucleus uses two neutrons and four baryons. Hence neutron-limited helium synthesis gives
Equivalently, with . This accounts for the extra protons produced by neutron decay; multiplying alone by the survival factor would miss their contribution. The following responses refer to ordinary neutron-limited burning, without exotic particle injection or a change to the nuclear network.
In standard Big Bang nucleosynthesis, with the radiation content and reaction rates fixed, the main adjustable abundance parameter is the baryon-to-photon ratio . The baryon-density consistency between nucleosynthesis and the microwave background uses
Increasing cosmological baryon density makes deuterium burn more efficiently, so D/H falls steeply. The primordial helium mass fraction grows only slowly, because its dominant control is the surviving neutron fraction. Near the observationally favored density, lithium-7 production, much of it initially as beryllium-7, rises with density. At lower densities the full lithium curve has a valley; the sketch focuses on the branch relevant to the baryon-density comparison.
For the historical meaning of “current” in this 2008 paper, representative 2007–2008 fits near are
These local fits, with nuclear-rate uncertainties, and representative D/H and lithium ranges are documented in Steigman's 2007 nucleosynthesis analysis. They are not a replacement for a nuclear network outside their calibrated range.
The cosmic microwave background acoustic peak pattern measures baryon loading at recombination, independently of the abundance measurements. For example, the five-year WMAP cosmological analysis gives from WMAP alone, corresponding to . For , this is . Galaxy-cluster baryon fractions combined with independent total-matter density provide another, more astrophysically model-dependent cross-check.
At , the fitted predictions are D/H , , and . A representative observed D/H range around overlaps the prediction; its inferred density is compatible with the cosmic microwave background. The helium result from the 2007 helium analysis also agrees. Other helium analyses had lower central values, illustrating why ionization and temperature systematics matter.
In contrast, a representative plateau estimate corresponds to roughly –, a factor of several below the prediction at the same density. This is the cosmological lithium problem. The three abundance ranges therefore should not all be described as exact simultaneous agreement: deuterium and helium broadly support the independently measured baryon density, while lithium has a substantial discrepancy. The plotted ranges explicitly refer to the 2007–2008 comparison, not present-day parameter estimates.
Under the usual interpretation that the extra force simply slows otherwise adiabatic expansion, without changing reaction rates or injecting particles, the primordial hydrogen mass fraction would be larger. A smaller Hubble parameter makes cooling slower, delays the end of the deuterium bottleneck, and permits more free-neutron decay after freeze-out before nuclear assembly. If the reduced expansion also keeps weak conversions effective longer, the lower eventual cosmological weak freeze-out temperature further reduces the neutron-to-proton ratio. Both effects lower the primordial helium mass fraction and raise the remaining hydrogen mass fraction.
For fixed initial neutron fraction , the post-freeze-out estimate is , where is the onset of efficient nuclear assembly. Thus decreases when cooling delays . The extra time is the time to reach the nuclear-assembly temperature, not an increase in the specified clock interval seconds. An unspecified force that also reheats the plasma, changes weak rates or causes recollapse would require additional information; the simple expansion-only interpretation is essential to this expectation.
Let and count the available neutrons and protons immediately before their incorporation into nuclei. In the usual neutron-limited helium synthesis approximation, all surviving neutrons go into and the remaining protons form . Each helium nucleus contains two neutrons and two protons, so
Using the equal-nucleon-mass approximation and neglecting trace nuclei and binding-energy corrections, the primordial helium mass fraction is
The ratio is the pre-assembly nucleon ratio, not the number ratio of free hydrogen nuclei to helium nuclei afterward. The derivation assumes enough protons to bind all the neutrons, as in standard Big Bang nucleosynthesis. The familiar gives and hydrogen mass fraction .
At temperatures above a few MeV, weak interactions such as and maintain neutron-proton chemical equilibrium. Negligible lepton chemical potentials give the neutron-to-proton ratio , where . At high temperature this ratio is nearly one.
During radiation domination, the interaction time grows as , faster than the expansion time . Their crossing therefore produces cosmological weak freeze-out. If , equating the displayed order-of-magnitude times gives , so
Using instead of changes only the order-one coefficient. Before electron-positron annihilation, the usual effective relativistic count is . The factor weights fermionic relative to bosonic energy density.
After freeze-out, free neutrons decay while protons increase correspondingly. Define the neutron baryon fraction . In the instantaneous-freeze-out estimate,
where is the neutron mean lifetime. Hence the ratio at the onset of nuclear synthesis is
This expression accounts for the protons produced by neutron decay.
Nuclear burning initially waits at the deuterium bottleneck: although deuterium is bound by about , the many photons per baryon can still photodissociate it. Roughly, sets the bottleneck temperature, with refinements from reaction rates and phase space. Around , deuterium survives, reactions through deuterium, tritium and helium-3 rapidly build tightly bound helium-4, and nearly all surviving neutrons are captured.
Thus and the primordial helium mass fraction is
For the standard estimate , neutron and proton constituent fractions are and , respectively, and . Free neutrons are negligible after capture. The remaining hydrogen mass fraction is about , and the helium-to-hydrogen number ratio is about .
The printed numerical time coefficients are schematic, not a precision prediction of this quarter fraction: their literal crossing with gives . Keeping physical weak-rate coefficients and the gradual freeze-out instead gives an effective freeze-out around –, followed by decay over a few minutes. The abundance formulas above explain the standard quarter fraction and its parameter dependence without treating the rounded time formulas as exact nuclear-rate data.
At weak freeze-out, photons, electrons, positrons and all four neutrino flavors are relativistic and approximately at the same temperature. The effective number of relativistic energy degrees of freedom changes from
The expansion rate at fixed temperature is larger by . Equating the supplied weak interaction time with the supplied age gives when is measured in MeV. Therefore
Earlier cosmological weak freeze-out at a higher temperature leaves more neutrons. With negligible chemical potentials, the neutron-to-proton ratio in equilibrium is , where . If almost all surviving neutrons enter helium-4, the primordial helium mass fraction before neutron decay is . Literal use of the given rate normalizations yields
Equivalently, the leading response is . This is a roughly one-percentage-point absolute increase in the helium fraction, rather than a one-percent relative increase.
The deuterium bottleneck delays nuclear burning, allowing free-neutron decay after freeze-out. If its end temperature is , and is the neutron mean life, a sharper instantaneous-freeze-out estimate conserves total baryon number and gives
This formula evolves the neutron fraction, not just the neutron-to-proton ratio, because each neutron decay also creates a proton. After electron annihilation, let . The radiation counts relevant to the age at fixed are
Consequently . Less time is available for neutron decay, adding to the helium increase. As an explicit illustrative completion, and give an increase of approximately in this toy model. The precise helium fraction requires the nuclear-burning temperature, baryon abundance and properly normalized weak rates; the question supplies only approximate time laws. In particular, the large no-decay fractions in the table must not be interpreted as precise predictions for the observed primordial abundance. The robust effect is extra relativistic energy raises the primordial helium fraction, with an absolute change of order for one thermally populated flavor.
The density bound on a relativistically decoupled massive relic is already decisive for a conventional near-critical cosmological density budget: the thermal pair alone gives . The same additional relativistic pair increases the effective number of neutrino species by one during nucleosynthesis and raises the primordial helium mass fraction, so its expansion effect supplies another constraint. Thus a stable, fully thermalized MeV-decoupling neutrino pair of this mass is incompatible with the usual cosmological density budget.
This conclusion is not a prohibition on every particle with that mass. Earlier decoupling followed by entropy dilution, a reduced production abundance, or interactions that change the assumed thermal history can alter both tests. At fixed mass, requiring this pair to contribute no more than the supplied critical density would demand a number density at most of the standard value, or a thermal temperature at most of the standard neutrino temperature. No numerical abundance or exclusion independent of these assumptions follows from the mass and equal particle-antiparticle counts alone.
Two effects must be distinguished in Big Bang nucleosynthesis. The positive extra neutrino energy density increases the Hubble parameter through the Friedmann equation. Holding weak rates fixed, faster expansion causes earlier neutron-proton cosmological weak freeze-out, leaving more neutrons, and leaves less time for neutron decay before nuclear reactions begin. Both tendencies increase the primordial helium mass fraction.
Electron-flavor degeneracy also changes the charged-current balance directly. Chemical equilibrium for gives, with negligible electron chemical potential,
This is the primordial helium response to electron-neutrino degeneracy. Positive favors conversion of neutrons to protons and reduces the neutron abundance; negative favors the opposite balance. When neutrons are the limiting ingredient and nearly all surviving neutrons enter helium-4, the neutron-limited helium synthesis estimate is
In this usual proton-rich regime, the direct electron-neutrino effect lowers for positive degeneracy and raises it for negative degeneracy, other conditions held fixed. At sufficiently large negative degeneracy the equilibrium ratio can instead exceed one; protons then become limiting. The corresponding ideal complete-capture estimate is , so the neutron-limited trend is not a universal monotonic law at arbitrary negative chemical potential. Degeneracy in the other flavors primarily affects helium through the expansion rate in this simplified discussion.
For very large degeneracy the weak reaction rates themselves also change, so a quantitative freeze-out calculation must include both the altered distributions and the altered expansion rate. The two effects can compete for a positive electron-neutrino asymmetry. The primordial helium mass fraction change is not determined by alone: its flavor and sign matter as well as its energy density.
Let be the present primordial helium mass fraction. If is the helium-nucleus density and the hydrogen-nucleus density, then
Since ,
This retains the correction from neutrons bound in helium. Charge neutrality requires one electron per proton, including bound electrons, so with the baryon-to-photon ratio ,
If the Friedmann equation remains approximately , radiation domination and fixed weak microphysics give and a neutron-proton conversion rate proportional to . Cosmological weak freeze-out then occurs at . Increasing during this era raises the neutron-to-proton ratio at freeze-out and shortens the time for free-neutron decay after freeze-out. Both increase the primordial helium mass fraction when neutron-limited helium synthesis remains efficient. Arbitrary variation of over time requires its history and the full gravitational field equations; this scaling is a controlled background approximation, rather than a complete model of gravity with arbitrary time dependence.
Primordial helium response to electron-neutrino degeneracy Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-07
Chemical equilibrium of , with negligible electron chemical potential, gives the stated neutron-to-proton ratio. Positive electron-neutrino degeneracy reduces the neutron fraction, whereas negative degeneracy increases it. The primordial helium mass fraction then responds through neutron-limited helium synthesis while protons outnumber neutrons; a sufficiently neutron-rich mixture instead becomes proton limited, so that trend must not be extrapolated indefinitely. Extra neutrino energy density also accelerates cosmic expansion, changing weak freeze-out and the time available for neutron decay. These effects can compete; a quantitative Big Bang nucleosynthesis calculation must account for the altered reaction rates as well as the altered expansion rate.
Primordial helium response to extra relativistic species Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-11-05
With a weak conversion time proportional to and a radiation-era age proportional to , cosmological weak freeze-out occurs at . Extra radiation therefore raises the freeze-out temperature and the neutron-to-proton ratio . Before decay, the primordial helium mass fraction is , giving . A shorter delay through the deuterium bottleneck also leaves more neutrons. After freeze-out, conserve baryon number and evolve the neutron fraction to obtain . A precise abundance requires the weak rates and nuclear-burning history, not merely the number of relativistic species.