Insert the component-density laws into the Friedmann equation, using and . Multiplying by gives
The radiation in cosmology and pressureless matter contributions add; the printed first formula has lost the plus sign between them. In the Friedmann acceleration equation, , so
Evaluating the first equation today gives .
Now remove dark energy and assume a positive pressureless matter or radiation in cosmology density, starting on an expanding branch. Let . It decreases from infinity to zero, and , while . This immediately distinguishes all three cases of spatial curvature of an FLRW universe.
The early small- solution has if radiation in cosmology is present, and for pressureless matter alone. The figure isolates the effect of curvature in three matter-only examples, rather than comparing models with the same present density parameters.
Figure 1.
Matter-only scale-factor evolution: closed recollapse, flat power-law expansion, and open expansion tending to a constant speed.
Put with . Linearizing the cosmological density parameter flow gives . For constant equation-of-state parameter,
For variable , the correct replacement is . The printed power assumes constant .
For pressureless matter, the departure from flatness grows as ; for radiation in cosmology, it grows as . Hence in a conventional decelerating expanding history, maintaining at a late epoch requires extremely small departures at early times. This is the Flatness problem, not an assertion that exact flatness is inconsistent: is an exact solution, but it is unstable to small departures in spatial curvature of an FLRW universe during these eras. With the perturbation instead decays, which supplies the inflationary solution of the flatness problem.
The Hubble parameter is the fractional expansion rate
Here is the homogeneous energy density, records the sign of the spatial curvature of an FLRW universe, and is the fixed curvature length scale used with the dimensionless scale factor .
Energy-momentum conservation in a homogeneous expanding universe gives the continuity equation
Differentiate the Friedmann equation
Using and the continuity equation gives
Eliminating the curvature term with the Friedmann equation yields
Since , this is the Raychaudhuri equation
Under the strong energy condition , one has . Thus is concave, and for it lies below its tangent at the present time:
The right side vanishes at . A positive scale factor therefore cannot extend regularly to that time; it must reach the Big Bang singularity at some . Equivalently,
A round three-sphere of radius embedded by has metric for . Multiplying by gives a scale factor and normalized positive spatial curvature of an FLRW universe . This radial chart covers a hemisphere; gives the global polar description.