Use for a product of the two individual spin-one spin eigenstates, with magnetic quantum numbers . Total requires , leaving preciselyHere these are product labels, not labels of the total angular momentum. Write their coefficients in this order as . With physical spin ladder operators , each nonzero individual step has amplitude , soBoth must vanish for a singlet state. The independent product states therefore require . Wavefunction normalization gives the spin-one singlet stateup to an overall quantum phase. Conversely, implies through , so these conditions really select total spin zero. Distinguishability imposes no additional exchange restriction. The ladder hint uses dimensionless angular momentum units; restoring its common factor does not change the coefficient ratios.
For physical spin ladder operators, . Operators at distinct sites commute. Expanding the two products cancels their cross terms and givesAdding the remaining component provesFor spin one-half, , , and raising an up spin or lowering a down spin gives zero. These formulas restore the physical factors implicit in the dimensionless ladder hint.
Let abbreviate the state with the only down spin at site , keeping for the fully up state. If lies on neither end of bond , that bond contains two up spins. The ladder terms vanish, while gives . ThusFor a down spin at , the product is instead , and moves it to with amplitude . For a down spin at , the other ladder product moves it back. ThereforeEvery bond in is aligned, so summing its bond energies givesThis is indeed a ground-state energy: a pair of spin-one-half particles has eigenvalues and , so each ferromagnetic bond is bounded below by , simultaneously attained by the fully aligned state. The isotropic Heisenberg model has a whole maximum-total-spin ground multiplet, not a unique all-up ground state.
In the single-excitation subspace, only the two bonds adjacent to the down spin differ from the aligned background. Their diagonal energy increase is , and each neighboring hop has amplitude . Hence, with periodic site indices,This is an exact finite-dimensional hopping problem. Choose the active one-site translation convention . A periodic plane-wave coefficient pattern requires , soThere are independent such wavevectors, for example one set of consecutive integers in a Brillouin zone. The normalized one-magnon Bloch states on a ring are . Reindexing with the periodic coefficient condition gives and hence .
There is a logical qualification to the condition stated in the paper. On an -site ring already holds for every state. In particular, the finite sum written with an arbitrary real also returns to itself after translations; that condition alone does not quantize . The displayed allowed values are the ones for which the ansatz is a single one-site translation eigenstate, equivalently a consistently periodic plane wave. This is the additional condition needed for the subsequent energy-eigenstate argument. Other values generally describe superpositions of the allowed momentum modes.
Apply the hopping Hamiltonian operator and shift the summation index using periodic boundary condition. The coefficients from and are respectively and times the original coefficient. Thusand the nearest-neighbour ferromagnetic magnon dispersion isThe unnormalized state in the question has the same energy. Distinct allowed momenta are orthogonal, since over one set of representatives.
For large the sampled wavevectors become dense, and the requested sketch is the periodic curve over . It has a zero at and tends to the equivalent zero at either open endpoint; maxima occur at . Near any equivalent zero,using measured from that zero. The low-momentum ferromagnetic magnon is quadratic, with group velocity . The state is proportional to the total spin lowering operator acting on , so it belongs to the same ground multiplet and has exactly zero excitation energy. Extending the plot beyond one reciprocal period repeats states rather than adding new independent modes. The lattice spacing is the nearest-neighbor chord length specified in the paper; is the translation length in this lattice description, not necessarily the continuous circumference of a circular arrangement.
The Holstein–Primakoff transformation realizes a spin algebra using bosonic creation operators and bosonic annihilation operators. A boson counts a unit of spin deviation from the local positive quantization axis: with . The square root in supplies the correct spin-ladder matrix elements. In particular,Their commutator is on every physical number state, reproducing the Spin commutation relations. Although the oscillator Fock space is infinite, the physical subspace is onlyThe order of the square root and oscillator operator matters in obtaining these coefficients.
When the spin deviations are dilute, expand the square root in . The leading transverse operators are linear in the bosonic creation operators and bosonic annihilation operators and turn exchange interactions into a quadratic Hamiltonian, which can be diagonalized. Higher powers describe interactions between spin waves. The method therefore organizes corrections by inverse powers of about an ordered classical configuration. Large alone is insufficient: the average depletion must remain small compared with . Possible problems include the occupation constraint after truncation, noncollinear order requiring site-dependent axis rotations, zero modes, and infrared fluctuations that destroy the assumed dilute expansion.
Use throughout. Let , and . Operators belonging to different boson species commute. The proposed Schwinger boson representation givesConsequently the first of the spin commutation relations isThe number operator commutators , and their counterparts giveThus all the spin commutation relations hold. Also : each fixed- sector is invariant. To identify its spin, calculate the Casimir operator:The irreducible spin representation with prescribed therefore requires , and its normalized Fock basis correspondence isConversely, and . The nonnegative integer occupation numbers give precisely , and there are such states. As a check, the spin raising operator acts aswhich is the usual spin ladder operator coefficient .
For a lattice of fixed spins, the local spin constraint in the Schwinger boson representation is essential:The full two-species bosonic Fock space also contains other local irreducible spin representations; fixing only the total boson number does not remove them.
Take , so neighbouring operators act at distinct sites. The identityexpresses the Hamiltonian operator of this quantum XY chain in spin ladder operators. Substituting the Schwinger boson representation gives the requested quartic expression:Operators at different sites commute, allowing normal ordering without a correction here. For the first quartic term, the inverse discrete Fourier transforms giveHere is one when its two momenta agree modulo and zero otherwise; it expresses lattice momentum conservation. The other quartic term has the same ordered operators with phase . On the support of this Kronecker delta, modulo , so the two phases sum to . Thus the Fourier vertex of a Schwinger boson chain isAn equivalent three-sum expression sets modulo , so its coefficient is . The factor comes from four factors and one site sum, while the factor of two from the two exchange terms cancels the original . The formula is Hermitian: conjugation exchanges with and with , and the coefficient is unchanged after imposing lattice momentum conservation. It also preserves each local total boson number in its real-space form, hence preserves the physical constrained subspace.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 48 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Set and let . A concrete irreducible spin representation is the symmetric powerStart with copies of the defining SU(2) doublet and restrict their tensor product representation to the completely symmetric subspace. Its orthonormal basis consists of symmetric states with up components and down components, where . There are such states. The total generators are , acting on this subspace, where are the Pauli matrices. This also constructs the trivial representation when .
The spin ladder operators satisfyThe Casimir operator commutes with every generator. On the highest-weight vector , the identity gives its eigenvalue . With phases chosen to make the lowering coefficients positive,The squared norm of the lowered state follows from . The ladder stops exactly at . Every weight is connected to every other by these operators, and has distinct eigenvalues. Hence any invariant subspace contains a weight vector and then the whole ladder: the representation is irreducible.
For , successive lowering has squared normThus the normalized highest-weight lowering formula isAll factorial arguments are nonnegative integers, including for half-integral .
The unitary representation of an isospin rotation isIts matrix in the weight basis is . Insert the completeness relation between two operators to obtainThese verify the group representation and unitarity properties, and the ladder argument gives irreducibility. Here rotations carry their SU(2) lifts: . Integer descends to the ordinary SO(3) group; half-integral is a representation of its double cover, not a single-valued representation of .
For , order the basis as . The lowering and raising coefficients give the spin-one half-turn matrixMultiplication shows . Reduce the matrix exponential using this identity:At it becomesThus its matrix elements are . In the pion phases , , this isospin rotation exchanges the two charged states with positive coefficients and negates the neutral state.
Charge conjugation is linear and unitary here. Similarity preserves commutators, soConsequently the conjugated generators obey the same Lie algebra. The specified signs also give . Since and the neutral state has positive charge conjugation eigenvalue,The signs depend on the chosen charged-state phases, which have been fixed by the ladder convention.
Conjugation by changes to , exactly as charge conjugation does. Their product, the G parity operator, therefore satisfiesThe Schur lemma makes scalar on each irreducible isospin multiplet, hence independent of . On the neutral pion, . Therefore the pion G-parity is
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2015 iii Paper 81 1 a Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-06
Each bond of the classical Heisenberg antiferromagnet is minimized when its two spins are antiparallel. Since the periodic chain has an even number of sites, all bonds can be minimized simultaneously:The ground-state degeneracy is a continuous sphere of orientations . Choose the Néel state with even sites in and odd sites in .
This product state is not an energy eigenstate. The spin ladder operators inproduce states with both neighboring magnetic quantum numbers changed. On an up-down bond, has a nonzero matrix element , hence coefficient in the Hamiltonian. These orthogonal spin configurations show explicitly why the classical minimum is not an exact quantum eigenstate for .
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2018 ii Paper 4 33D Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
The angular momentum commutation relations implyThus has the same total-spin eigenvalue and magnetic quantum number . Its squared norm follows fromChoosing the conventional positive phases gives the spin ladder operator formula
The incident state is the spin coherent state obtained by rotating through about the axis. Its amplitudes in the basis areup to an irrelevant phase convention. The Born rule therefore gives
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2019 ii Paper 4 32B Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-03
The spin raising operator and spin lowering operator areThe angular momentum commutation relations implyso is proportional to . Sinceits squared norm isChoosing the conventional positive phase gives
Using the spin ladder operators,and thereforeIn the ordered product basis of the tensor product of quantum systemsthe matrix representation isThe two parallel-spin states are already eigenvectors. Diagonalizing the central block gives the four energy eigenvaluesThis is the spectrum of the Two-spin Heisenberg Hamiltonian in an opposing longitudinal field.
The asserted ground-state ordering requires the antiferromagnetic case . As ,The corresponding state at is the unique spin-one-half singlet statewhereas the three states at the first excited energy form the spin-one-half triplet state.
Indeed, for the total angular momentum operatorone has at The Hamiltonian then has rotational symmetry, so energy depends only on the total-spin sector. The singlet has total spin and multiplicity one; the triplet has and multiplicity . This rotational symmetry explains why the triplet energy eigenspace has dimension three.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2023 ii Paper 4 33B a i Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-25
On the tensor-product Hilbert space, addition of angular momentum givesSuppressing the identity operators, its components and ladder operators are
The phases of the three basis vectors can be chosen so that and are nonnegative real numbers. Matrix multiplication then givesThe angular momentum commutation relations require this to equal . Equating diagonal entries yieldsHenceThese are also the special case of the normalized spin ladder operator coefficients .
The Holstein–Primakoff transformation realizes a spin algebra using bosonic creation operators and bosonic annihilation operators. A boson counts a unit of spin deviation from the local positive quantization axis: with . The square root in supplies the correct spin-ladder matrix elements. In particular,Their commutator is on every physical number state, reproducing the Spin commutation relations. Although the oscillator Fock space is infinite, the physical subspace is onlyThe order of the square root and oscillator operator matters in obtaining these coefficients.
When the spin deviations are dilute, expand the square root in . The leading transverse operators are linear in the bosonic creation operators and bosonic annihilation operators and turn exchange interactions into a quadratic Hamiltonian, which can be diagonalized. Higher powers describe interactions between spin waves. The method therefore organizes corrections by inverse powers of about an ordered classical configuration. Large alone is insufficient: the average depletion must remain small compared with . Possible problems include the occupation constraint after truncation, noncollinear order requiring site-dependent axis rotations, zero modes, and infrared fluctuations that destroy the assumed dilute expansion.
The Holstein–Primakoff transformation maps the finite spin basis to bosonic Fock states with . Thus is the fully polarized reference state, and creating a boson lowers by one. The physical subspace has the Holstein–Primakoff occupation constraint , not the whole infinite oscillator Hilbert space.
The specified ordering of the square root givesThese are the exact spin ladder operator matrix elements; in particular, the lowering amplitude vanishes at . The underlying oscillator obeys its usual canonical commutation relation on the enlarged space, while the spin operators preserve the constrained physical subspace. Projecting the oscillator operators themselves to a finite space would change their commutator at its upper endpoint.
Expanding converts an ordered spin problem to approximately free magnons, with interactions in higher orders of . Two complications are the nonpolynomial, order-sensitive square roots, which generate interacting bosons, and loss of the occupation bound when a truncated expansion uses the full bosonic Fock space. Large depletion, high temperature, or soft modes near a phase transition can invalidate the assumption even when is large.
Spin commutation relations Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-14
Spin ladder operator Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-11-05
A spin ladder operator changes the magnetic quantum number within a fixed spin multiplet. For simultaneous eigenstates of and , the labels satisfy and .
The operators satisfy
The angular momentum commutation relations give . Its expectation value is the squared norm of the raised or lowered state, fixing the square-root factors by normalization. For spin one half, . At the spin raising operator gives zero. A spin ladder operator is therefore not a unitary operator or, by itself, a deterministic physical rotation. [ref]
Quantum Mechanics by David Tong. Section 4.1.1, angular momentum commutator algebra; the norm argument here is explicit
Transverse spin order in a number eigenstate 2026-10-25
For a two-species uniform boson number state, set . A single spin ladder operator changes the species occupation numbers, so its expectation value vanishes. At distinct sites, , proving the displayed transverse two-point correlation function. For tending to nonzero constants, this correlation function has a nonzero large-distance limit despite the global U(1) symmetry. This diagnoses long-range order in the auxiliary state; its interpretation as a state of fixed physical spins still requires the Schwinger boson constraint.
