For three real scalar fields with field interaction term and mediator mass , the connected tree-level Feynman diagram for has one exchanged and Mandelstam invariant . Each vertex has a factor : its two identical-field Wick contractions cancel the factor . Thus . There is no - or -channel at this order because the interaction has no mixed vertex. Distinguishable external particles also require no exchange symmetrization.
The leading scattering amplitude is the sum of two tree-level Feynman diagrams, with the outgoing photons attached in either order to the fermion line. The Dirac propagator carries momentum or for incoming electron momentum . Their sum obeys the two-photon fermion Ward identity, although individual diagrams need not. Crossing symmetry relates this amplitude to Compton scattering.
The four-point tree-level Feynman diagram has two cubic vertices joined by one propagator. The three ways to divide four labeled external legs into vertex pairs give the , , and channels. For interaction , the amplitude is , with the Feynman i-epsilon prescription understood. All channels interfere in its modulus squared.
All three fields have mass . In the interaction picture the quantum fields evolve with the free Hamiltonian operator, so their equations are
The interactions evolve the states instead. For the appropriate mode expansion of a free field is
Independent species have commuting creation and annihilation operators. The full set of canonical commutation relations is
These follow from the separate equal-time canonical commutation relations for the three real scalar fields. For comparison, in the Heisenberg picture the full Euler-Lagrange field equations contain interactions: , , and . These are distinct from the free equations used in the interaction picture.
There are no derivative couplings, so the interaction Hamiltonian is . The interaction picture evolution operator obeys
Iterating its integral equation gives the Dyson series
The ordered integration region is equivalent to the unrestricted region with time ordering and the factor . Taking the scattering limit , , with the usual adiabatic prescription for perturbation theory, therefore yields the S-matrix
All fields inside this expression are interaction picture fields.
Use relativistic normalization of a one-particle state and take , . Define the connected scattering amplitude by . The identity contribution describes no scattering; the term linear in cannot connect these four external particles. At quadratic order, the connected term in the Dyson series is
By Wick theorem, a connected Wick contraction must attach the two external legs to at one vertex, the two external legs to at the other, and contract the remaining two fields. The two assignments of species to cancel the Dyson factor . At either vertex, the assignments of its identical fields to the incoming and outgoing particle cancel the interaction factor . Equivalently, the coefficient is multiplied by , giving . Therefore, writing ,
Insert the Feynman propagator . The two vertex integrals impose and . With the Mandelstam invariant , this gives
This is distinguishable scalar scattering by a shared mediator with mediator mass . In physical elastic kinematics , so the denominator has no pole for . There is only the displayed -channel tree-level Feynman diagram: an - or -channel would require an absent mixed vertex. Each vertex contributes and the exchanged contributes , agreeing with the direct Wick contraction calculation.
Figure 1.
Tree-level elastic scattering of distinct scalar particles through a shared scalar mediator
. Details.
Use throughout. Vary the Maxwell action with respect to the electromagnetic four-potential. Antisymmetry of the electromagnetic field tensor gives . After integration by parts, the Euler-Lagrange field equation is
A gauge transformation leaves unchanged because partial derivatives commute. It therefore leaves the Maxwell action and observable electromagnetic fields unchanged: different potentials represent the same physical field. This redundancy matters for canonical quantization: before gauge fixing, the momentum conjugate to vanishes and the four potential components cannot be treated as four independent physical oscillators.
Choose the Lorenz gauge , attainable by solving with suitable boundary data. The Euler-Lagrange field equation then reduces to
Residual Lorenz gauge symmetry consists of transformations with . The gauge condition and this residual redundancy ultimately leave two transverse polarizations of a free photon.
For the specified kinetic density , one has . Its Euler-Lagrange field equation is therefore . This density is the Feynman-gauge Maxwell kinetic density after a boundary-term subtraction, since
The divergence follows by expanding both sides and commuting the second derivatives. Thus the wave equation follows from a Feynman gauge action; the additional physical-state condition will implement the Lorenz gauge. One must not impose inside the original action before varying it.
Take the covariant components as canonical coordinates. The canonical momentum computed from is
The equal-time canonical Poisson brackets are , with coordinate-coordinate and momentum-momentum brackets zero. Applying canonical quantization gives
In particular . The negative temporal sign is the source of the indefinite state-space norm in covariant photon quantization.
The spatial Fourier transform of the wave equation gives an oscillator of frequency for each component. The Hermitian adjoint condition on the electromagnetic four-potential then yields the mode expansion of a free field
These are massless on shell modes. Consistently with the preceding equal-time canonical commutation relation,
The normalization is the same as for the scalar modes, with replacing the species identity matrix.
Gupta-Bleuler quantization starts with the Fock vacuum annihilated by every and imposes only the annihilation, or positive-frequency part of a quantum field, of the Lorenz gauge condition:
Imposing the entire Hermitian field divergence as a strong operator identity would be incompatible with the four-component canonical commutation relation. The weaker condition suffices: between two physical states its positive-frequency part vanishes on the ket, and its negative-frequency part vanishes on the bra. Hence .
For a one-photon state , commuting the constraint through the creator gives
Thus the allowed photon polarization vectors satisfy . Their state inner product, with the common momentum-normalization factor suppressed, is . Momentum eigenstates are delta-normalized; the same statements hold with finite norms for normalizable wave packets.
Rotate the spatial axes so that . The constraint is , so the complete allowed family is
The first vector is the allowed longitudinal gauge polarization, proportional to the null four-momentum . Its state has zero norm because ; it is also orthogonal to every constrained state because . A purely spatial vector alone is not an allowed physical polarization: its time component must accompany it to satisfy the constraint. The other two vectors are transverse polarizations, perpendicular to , with positive unit norms. For the displayed family,
The timelike negative-norm excitation has been excluded by the constraint, and the remaining form is positive semidefinite. The Gupta-Bleuler null-state quotient identifies and , removing the null direction. It leaves exactly two transverse physical photon polarizations with a positive inner product; their bosonic Fock space is the physical photon state space.
Finally use Feynman slash notation, , and impose four-momentum conservation . The external Dirac spinors obey
Set and . Replacing by in the first term of the electron-positron annihilation into two photons amplitude, the rightmost contracted vertex obeys
Since the Clifford algebra implies , that term becomes
For the second term, four-momentum conservation gives . The contracted vertex is now adjacent to the outgoing positron spinor on the left, so
Consequently
The two terms cancel, proving the two-photon fermion Ward identity
Exchanging the two photon labels proves the same result for . By linearity the amplitude is invariant under on either external photon leg. Therefore the null longitudinal gauge polarization has zero production amplitude: physical scattering produces only the two transverse photon polarizations. This cancellation also shows why both photon orderings in the tree-level Feynman diagrams are essential; either term alone fails the Ward identity.
Fix the phi-fourth theory convention , with mostly-minus Minkowski spacetime and . Define the scattering amplitude by stripping the overall momentum-conserving delta function from . If instead the coupling is defined by , every vertex coupling below must be replaced by ; the question does not specify this factorial convention.
The momentum-space Feynman rules are a Feynman propagator for each internal scalar line, a Feynman vertex with four scalar legs, and four-momentum conservation at each vertex. Integrate each independent loop momentum with and divide by the Feynman-diagram symmetry factor. For an amputated scattering amplitude there are no external propagators; external states have the usual relativistic normalization. Sum the connected diagrams and all inequivalent assignments of the labelled external momenta. The overall delta function is .
These Feynman rules follow by expanding the Dyson series and applying the Wick theorem to the free-field correlation functions. A Wick contraction gives the free Feynman propagator; the ways of contracting a vertex cancel its factorial denominator. The expansion's cancels permutations of identical interaction insertions, while any remaining automorphisms give the Feynman-diagram symmetry factor. Fourier transformation produces momentum conservation, and the LSZ reduction formula amputates external propagators to obtain the scattering amplitude.
For six-point amplitudes in phi-fourth theory, an original pair of diagrams is:
Figure 1.
Tree and one-loop triangle contributions to two-to-four scalar scattering
. Details.
In the tree-level Feynman diagram, let the internal four-momentum be . The labelled diagram has symmetry factor one, so its contribution is
This is one channel. The full tree scattering amplitude sums the ten unordered partitions of the six labelled external legs into two groups of three, since .
For the one-loop triangle Feynman diagram, set , , , so . A consistent routing has denominators
With the external labels held fixed, no nontrivial graph automorphism remains, so again the symmetry factor is one. The contribution is
There are other labelled assignments and other one-loop topologies in the full scattering amplitude; the displayed expression belongs to the particular drawn diagram.
One can also express this scalar triangle Feynman integral using Feynman parameters. With , completing the square in gives
The identity and the shifted momentum integral yield
Thus times the displayed parameter integral. It is ultraviolet finite in four dimensions, although physical threshold singularities must retain the Feynman i-epsilon prescription.
For the fixed-target production threshold, the incoming four-momenta are and , with . Their invariant mass obeys
In the centre-of-momentum frame, four final particles have total energy at least , attained when all four are at rest in that frame. Therefore , equivalently , and
This is the kinematic threshold for . Exactly at equality the final phase space has zero volume; a nonzero production rate requires a strict inequality.
Use the mostly-plus Minkowski metric, so , and the source term . Define the vacuum-normalized generating functional, connected generating functional, and quantum effective action by
The Legendre transform is taken after expressing in terms of , locally where this relation is invertible. Varying it gives and . The logarithm generates connected graphs; the Legendre transform removes graphs joined by a single propagator, leaving one-particle-irreducible vertices. This sign convention is important: its classical limit is , consistent with the positive vertices in this question.
For the free real scalar field, integration by parts puts the action into the form , where has Fourier symbol . Include the Feynman i-epsilon prescription . Completing the square yields
and consequently
The physical scalar propagator is , whereas the inverse quadratic kernel appearing in is . Differentiating this quadratic functional and Fourier transforming gives
The infinitesimal prescription specifies propagators and is dropped when quoting the local vertex kernel.
At the order represented by tree-level Feynman diagrams, stationary phase gives , with the classical field equation . The Legendre transform cancels the source term, so
Thus
Other connected tree graphs with several quartic vertices are one-particle reducible and belong to , not to the proper vertices of . This explains why no extra tree correction is hidden in these formulas.
The one-loop proper two-point graph is the tadpole diagram. The one-loop proper four-point graphs are the three bubble diagrams, with pairings , and of the external legs. Each has Feynman-diagram symmetry factor . The figure shows the topologies and every four-point channel; external momenta are incoming.
Figure 1.
One-loop scalar proper vertices: the two-point tadpole and all three four-point bubble channels
. Details.
The tadpole factor can also be counted directly: there are assignments of two labeled external legs to one quartic vertex, while its normalization leaves . For a fixed four-point partition, the interchange of the two internal lines gives the same factor ; there are three distinct partitions. Graphs with an external self-energy insertion are one-particle reducible and are not additional contributions to .
For the two-point divergence, perform a Wick rotation. The Euclidean tadpole contribution to the proper inverse kernel is
Assume to separate the ultraviolet calculation from infrared issues. A Schwinger parameterization gives . Using the supplied Gaussian integral, initially in the convergence region, gives
The last expression provides the meromorphic dimensional regularization continuation. Set . Since ,
If the coupling is written as , that factor multiplies the intermediate integral but does not change the displayed pole residue. The negative pole is a property of analytic continuation; it must not be inferred from the positive cutoff integrand without carrying out the continuation.
The added mass counterterm contributes to , because and its Lagrangian term is . Hence cancellation requires
up to an arbitrary finite subtraction specifying the renormalization scheme. No external momentum occurs in the tadpole, so no one-loop wave-function renormalization is needed. At the unregulated tadpole is scaleless and vanishes in dimensional regularization; the massive calculation identifies the mass-dependent ultraviolet pole without conflating it with a massless infrared limit.
For completeness, the signs of the four-point graphs in this effective-action convention can be read from the Euclidean one-loop functional . Its expansion has terms and . Differentiating four times gives
This is the Euclidean form, analytically continued to the physical external momenta. It confirms the three channel diagrams and their symmetry factors; evaluating its divergence is not needed for the requested mass counterterm.
Use metric signature and average over the four initial spin states, summing over final spins and the quark color charge states. The Electrons carry no color charge, so their initial color charge average is trivial. A final color charge average would not give the inclusive relativistic cross-section requested.
Photon exchange gives the tree amplitude, up to an irrelevant overall phase,
Massless spin sums give and . Therefore
The color charge multiplicity is , not . Each trace equals . Contracting them, the terms proportional to cancel, leaving . Thus
In the centre-of-momentum frame every energy is . Let be the angle between and . Then
Consequently .
The supplied two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space formula has a factor-of-two error. Deriving the normalization explicitly,
so the massless two-body scattering flux normalization is
For example, integrating the spatial Dirac delta in leaves ; its radial integral supplies the factor . The printed denominator would double the relativistic cross-section and cannot reproduce the requested result with the standard scattering amplitude.
The correctly normalized differential and total results for electron-positron annihilation into a quark pair are
and hence
At energies where photon exchange and the parton description apply, sum over kinematically accessible quark flavors. The produced quarks undergo hadronization, so the leading inclusive hadronic rate is
This is the hadronic R ratio. Perturbative QCD adds a leading relative correction ; thresholds, narrow resonances and, near the Z boson scale, electroweak exchange require additional treatment. The calculation is a photon-exchange, massless result from a tree-level Feynman diagram.
Take incoming electron momentum and positron momentum , with outgoing photon momenta , so . The leading electron-positron annihilation into two photons has two tree-level Feynman diagrams, differing by the order in which the two outgoing photons attach to the charged-fermion line.
The arrows indicate fermion flow. An incoming positron has the opposite flow direction to its physical momentum; the lower row uses an outgoing electron instead.
The required QED Feynman rules, with interaction , are a vertex , a Dirac propagator , an incoming electron spinor , an incoming positron adjoint , and an outgoing photon polarization . Here Feynman slash notation means , and the external Dirac equations are and .
Put , omitting only the propagator's overall factor . Multiplying the two vertices and the propagator gives
The diagrammatic expression is . The relative sign is plus because the two photons are bosons; exchanging their attachments does not exchange external fermions. The amplitude is of order .
A physical photon polarization vector obeys and , with the gauge equivalence . One can choose a transverse representative with and normalize . There are two physical transverse polarizations.
To prove the requested two-photon fermion Ward identity, replace by . Away from an internal pole, is the inverse of , with the boundary prescription understood. The first term simplifies because
For the second term, four-momentum conservation gives , so
The two contributions are therefore and , which cancel. Interchanging the photon labels proves the other contraction vanishes. By linearity, adding a multiple of either photon momentum to its polarization leaves the summed amplitude unchanged. This is gauge invariance: longitudinal gauge representatives do not describe an additional physical photon state. An individual diagram does not generally have this property.
For Compton scattering, let be incoming electron and photon momenta and the outgoing ones. The diagrams in the lower row have intermediate electron momenta and respectively. The same QED Feynman rules give
Their denominators are and , the - and -channel denominators. In annihilation the two exchanged-electron channels instead carry and . Crossing symmetry relates the two expressions by moving the positron to an outgoing electron and one outgoing photon to an incoming photon, with the corresponding momentum and polarization replacements. There is no two-photon contact vertex for the minimally coupled Dirac electron. Both processes require the sum of the two photon orders to satisfy the Ward identity.
Variation with respect to the Dirac adjoint, the Dirac field, and the real scalar field respectively gives
The derivative in the adjoint equation acts to the left; its sign follows by integrating by parts. The Yukawa interaction supplies a spacetime-dependent effective fermion mass and a scalar source.
Use and the convention . The momentum-space Feynman rules are: a scalar internal line contributes ; an oriented fermion line contributes ; and each scalar-fermion vertex contributes times the identity in spinor space. Impose four-momentum conservation at each vertex. Incoming and outgoing fermions supply and , while incoming and outgoing antifermions supply and ; scalar external legs supply one. Loop momenta are integrated with , a closed fermion loop contributes a minus sign, and graph symmetry factors are included. Relative signs between distinct contractions of identical external fermions follow from their anticommutation relations. These specify the Feynman rules also beyond the tree approximation.
Label incoming momenta and outgoing momenta , with all external particles on shell. Write the Mandelstam variables as , , , and abbreviate . Spin indices on are implicit. The six required tree-level Feynman diagrams are:
Figure 1.
The six Yukawa tree diagrams for fermion, antifermion and scalar scattering, with momentum labels and fermion-number arrows
. Details.
For two incoming fermions, the two diagrams exchange a scalar in the and channels. With external state ordering and , the result is
Each scalar-exchange contraction has two factors and one scalar Feynman propagator. Exchanging the final fermions reverses the sign, as required by their identical-particle statistics.
For a fermion and antifermion, there is -channel scalar exchange and -channel annihilation. Take both initial and final states ordered as fermion creator followed by antifermion creator. Then
The relative minus is not optional. One way to track it is the antifermion sign of a normal-ordered bilinear: the antifermion scattering part of is , whereas its annihilation part is . Thus the exchange contraction has the opposite fermionic sign to the annihilation contraction before multiplying by . A different overall phase convention for external states changes the common sign of this amplitude, but cannot change the relative sign.
For fermion-scalar scattering, the fermion can absorb the incoming scalar before emitting the outgoing one, or emit first and absorb afterwards. The internal momenta are and respectively, giving
Both orderings have the same sign: there is only one open fermion line and no exchange of identical external fermions. There is no scalar-exchange diagram because this Yukawa interaction has no three-scalar vertex. These amplitudes describe tree scattering in Yukawa theory.
The conjugate complex scalar field has the opposite charge. Thus the derivative on in the kinetic term must mean , while the derivative on is . This is the conjugate gauge covariant derivative. Applying the same plus-charge differential operator to both fields would not give the stated gauge-invariant theory. For example, take , and ; the literal plus-charge kinetic product changes from to . The opposite-charge interpretation removes this term.
For an arbitrary real function , take
Then and the conjugate derivative transforms oppositely. Also because mixed derivatives commute. The kinetic contraction and are unchanged, proving local U(1) gauge symmetry.
Expanding the covariant kinetic term identifies the interactions:
The first term gives the scalar electrodynamics three-point vertex, and the second gives the seagull vertex. For scalar charge flow from an incoming particle of momentum to an outgoing one of momentum , the factors are
The factor two in the second rule comes from the two identical photon fields. Equivalently, with all momenta incoming, the three-point rule is for a leg of momentum and a leg of momentum . An antiparticle line has the opposite charge-flow sign. The vertices are shown with dashed scalar lines and wavy photon lines:
For particle-antiparticle scattering, use incoming and outgoing , with particle momenta. At order , there are exactly two tree-level Feynman diagrams: -channel photon exchange and -channel annihilation. The seagull vertex has only two scalar legs and cannot alone provide four external scalar legs.
Figure 2.
The leading t-channel photon exchange and s-channel annihilation diagrams for scalar particle-antiparticle scattering
. Details.
Set and . The external currents are
All are transverse to the corresponding exchanged momentum: for instance and . This is the on-shell scalar quantum electrodynamics Ward identity. With the vertex convention above,
The relative sign comes from the opposite particle/antiparticle charge in the exchange diagram and the two equal annihilation-vertex signs.
To see how the Coulomb gauge expression becomes covariant, let be either pair, , and initially take . The displayed photon propagator gives
Current conservation gives and the same identity for . Since , the temporal coefficient simplifies as
Therefore
The common Feynman pole prescription is understood in these formulas. This Coulomb-gauge propagator between conserved currents identity proves equality of the physical amplitudes despite the noncovariant individual propagator components. It should be formed before taking limits such as : individual instantaneous and transverse terms can be undefined separately in that limit while their sum has a finite covariant limit away from a physical pole.
Substitution gives the final scattering amplitude
Here are the Mandelstam variables for the equal-mass external scalars. This is scalar particle-antiparticle tree scattering; overall external-state phases do not affect its relative channel sign.
The tree-level Feynman diagram contains one weak charged current vertex. Fermion arrows point along fermion-number flow, so the outgoing antiquark arrow points toward the vertex.
Figure 1.
Tree-level W-plus decay into an outgoing quark and antiquark with fermion-flow arrows
. Details.
For one fixed matching color, the scattering amplitude is
An overall phase from the vertex has no effect on the width. The fermion spin sums give , in the massless approximation. For the three initial polarizations, use a spin average of . The gamma matrix trace identities give
The sign of the last term follows the PDF's convention and does not affect this decay: the polarization sum is symmetric. Since and the daughter masses vanish, and . Therefore
In the rest frame, the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space integrates to : after the spatial delta function sets , its radial delta function fixes . Explicitly,
The decay formula consequently gives
This is the printed expression, interpreted for one color. For a physical quark-flavor channel there are three orthogonal final color states. Their probabilities add; no initial color average is present for a colorless W boson. Thus
The PDF's formula omits this color multiplicity if read as the ordinary inclusive flavor width. It is also the familiar normalization for a colorless lepton channel.
The six physically accessible quark combinations are . A real on-shell W boson cannot produce a top quark; the massless approximation is applied to the accessible daughters and does not open a physically forbidden top channel. CKM matrix unitarity gives . Therefore the physical color-summed hadronic width at this order is
If the printed one-color convention is retained for every channel, its sum is instead . In the artificial theory where all three up-type flavors, including the top, are kinematically massless, there would be nine channels and the physical sum would be ; that is not the on-shell Standard Model channel list.
The two tree-level Feynman diagrams have t-channel W boson exchange. The antiquark process reverses the fermion-flow arrows on the lower line.
Each vertex contributes multiplying a chiral current. At momentum transfer , the gauge-boson propagator is approximated by its momentum-independent term , up to the overall phase. The longitudinal term does not contribute to these conserved massless currents. Thus the coefficient is , giving the Fermi interaction. For the quark and antiquark amplitudes, apart from irrelevant overall phases,
and
The low-energy operator form is ; its external spinor matrix elements are the displayed products.
For an unpolarized initial parton, average over its two spin states. There is no factor for the incoming active neutrino, which has one allowed helicity. The initial color average cancels the final color sum, so there is no surviving color multiplicity in this parton cross section. Define
The symmetric and antisymmetric parts have zero cross contraction. Their separate contractions are and . Thus the given Levi-Civita symbol identity yields
Including the coefficient and the initial-parton spin average gives
Massless kinematics and imply . From , . Therefore
To reduce the supplied phase-space formula, use the massless center-of-mass flux and . This gives . In that frame , so . Hence
The antiquark channel's angular factor is a consequence of the chiral current and the reversed lower-line spinor order, rather than a color factor.
Take , , metric , and a Higgs potential with , . The gauge-scalar electroweak interaction is
Here . With the printed plus-sign convention for , define ; thus . The minus sign in the nonlinear gauge field strength follows from this convention.
The minima have , with . A gauge transformation rotates the vacuum to . In unitary gauge, the three angular Goldstone bosons are removed, leaving and one real Higgs boson. The generator annihilates the vacuum, because its lower component has and hypercharge . This identifies the unbroken electromagnetic gauge group.
The quadratic terms from the Higgs field kinetic term are
Define the Weinberg angle and physical fields by
The neutral combinations are
The neutral gauge-boson mass matrix is . It has eigenvalues zero and , with the zero eigenvector giving . Expanding the Higgs potential about its minimum gives . Therefore the tree-level electroweak gauge-boson masses and scalar mass are
Also and . The three removed Goldstone bosons supply the longitudinal polarization vector degrees of freedom of the massive electroweak gauge bosons.
Replacing by in the neutral mass term gives all the Higgs boson couplings to Z bosons in unitary gauge:
There are exactly the cubic and quartic elementary tree-level Feynman diagrams. Differentiating with respect to the identical fields gives Feynman rules and , respectively. There is no elementary vertex for the real neutral radial field.
Figure 1. . The two elementary Higgs boson couplings to Z bosons, with dashed scalar legs and wavy vector legs. Details.
The three allowed tree-level Feynman diagrams are shown below, using physical-particle Feynman propagators in unitary gauge. Solid arrows follow fermion number and the wavy lines denote the charged vector Feynman propagator.
Figure 1.
Charged-current interaction diagrams
. The allowed s-channel, t-channel and semileptonic weak charged current graphs. Details.
Allowed through a t-channel W boson. Along one fermion line the up quark becomes a down quark by emitting a virtual ; along the other the charm antiquark absorbs it and becomes a strange antiquark. The middle panel shows this weak charged current exchange. Both electric charge and baryon number are conserved at each vertex, and the relevant CKM matrix entries are nonzero.
This is the unique physical-particle tree-level Feynman diagram. A neutral exchange would require a flavor-changing neutral current on each line, absent at tree level in the Standard Model. An annihilation into a neutral boson would likewise require an off-diagonal up-type neutral current. The different generations do not forbid the charged-current graph.
Allowed through an s-channel W boson. The initial up quark and down antiquark annihilate into a virtual , which produces the final charm quark and strange antiquark. The two weak charged current vertices contain the nonzero CKM matrix elements and , with complex conjugations determined by fermion-flow conventions.
The left panel shows the unique physical-particle tree-level Feynman diagram. A neutral exchanged gauge boson cannot connect these charged annihilation currents, and flavour-diagonal neutral vertices cannot turn an up quark into a charm quark. There is no additional elementary charged scalar in the minimal Standard Model.
Allowed through a virtual W boson. The charm quark emits a and becomes a down quark through the nonzero CKM matrix element . The virtual W boson produces a positive muon and a muon neutrino through the leptonic weak charged current. The right panel is the unique physical-particle tree-level Feynman diagram.
Its total electric charge is , equal to the initial charge, and its final lepton number is . The decay is Cabibbo suppressed, rather than forbidden. These diagram counts use unitary gauge: in covariant gauges charged unphysical Goldstone bosons can supply gauge-dependent pieces of the same physical amplitudes, not additional physical channels.
At this order there is one annihilation tree-level Feynman diagram. The squared-amplitude diagram is its product with its complex conjugate, with the same external momenta and spin labels in both factors:
 e-(p,s) --->\          /---> mu-(p',s')
             o ~~~~~~ o
 e+(q,r) <---/          \<--- mu+(q',r')

                     times

 e-(p,s) --->\          /---> mu-(p',s')
             o ~~~~~~ o                       *
 e+(q,r) <---/          \<--- mu+(q',r')
A wavy line is the virtual photon; the arrows show fermion-number flow. The star means complex conjugation of the entire second graph, including its external spinors. This represents for fixed spins, without adding a new physical loop to the amplitude.
For the spin sum in part (iv), identify each external spin label between the two copies and sum it. The fermion spin sum sews each spinor chain into a gamma-matrix trace. The two incoming unpolarized spin states are then handled by a spin average, giving the factor . In particular, the diagrammatic contraction becomes
In phi cubed theory, each vertex has three legs. A connected four-point tree-level Feynman diagram therefore needs two cubic vertices and one internal propagator. There are exactly three ways to partition the labeled external legs between these vertices:
       s channel               t channel              u channel

 p \          / p'         p ---o--- p'            p ---o--- q'
    o--------o                  |                       |
 q /          \ q'         q ---o--- q'            q ---o--- p'

 internal: p+q             internal: p-p'          internal: p-q'
Solid lines denote the real scalar field propagator. The labels specify which external pair meets at each vertex, so the last two graphs are different even though their unlabeled shapes agree. This is the four-point tree amplitude in phi cubed theory:
There is no four-point contact vertex in the given cubic interaction.