Use the Fourier transform convention . First observe that satisfies the differential equation, decay, and normalization, using the Gaussian integral. The uniqueness allowed in the question identifies it with . In particular it is a Schwartz function, so the derivative and multiplication rules below are justified.
Taking the Fourier transform of the differential equation gives
The Riemann-Lebesgue lemma gives decay of . Every decaying solution of this equation is proportional to : setting gives , and integration yields
The term with grows like as , so decay forces . Thus for a scalar . This establishes proportionality before using Fourier inversion to calculate the scalar.
The integral is the convolution of the positive-half-line kernels and . The convolution theorem for Laplace transforms therefore gives, for ,
On the other hand, the substitution gives , where is the beta function. Applying part (i) again yields . Comparing the two expressions proves
All integrands used in the real- convolution argument are nonnegative, so Tonelli's theorem justifies the interchange; the endpoint singularities are integrable because .
For real , substitute in the Laplace transform:
The Gamma function integral is finite because . For complex , absolute convergence holds exactly when : the modulus of the integrand is . On this half-plane the same answer holds with the branch whose logarithm is real on the positive axis, by holomorphic continuation of the two sides.
If “exists” permits conditionally convergent ordinary improper integrals, there are additional boundary points when : for , the Dirichlet test gives convergence, with value . For these boundary integrals do not converge in that sense. At , and for , the integral diverges. Thus is the region of absolute convergence of a Laplace transform, with the stated conditional boundary qualification.
The linear map is the projection onto the space of symmetric matrices, with kernel . Define on . Since is invertible everywhere on and is onto, is onto everywhere. By part (ii),
The regular level set theorem makes this a submanifold of codimension , and hence
This neighborhood is around ; the source's final occurrence of in this step is a neighborhood-label slip. For any , left multiplication by is an invertible linear map of the ambient matrix space and carries onto . These translated charts establish the submanifold property at every group element.
Part (b) already shows . Conversely, if and , then
Both and lie in , where the matrix exponential is injective. Therefore , proving the reverse inclusion. The restricted map is a bijection, indeed a diffeomorphism between these local sets.
The matrix exponential is smooth, and part (a) identifies its derivative at zero as the identity. The inverse function theorem therefore gives a local diffeomorphism from an open neighborhood of zero onto a neighborhood of . Choose a sufficiently small operator norm ball and let . This is again a diffeomorphism onto an open set, since it is a restriction of the original one.
The ball is preserved by and . Since and , is preserved by adjoint and inversion. For its local inverse , injectivity also gives
If is a smooth curve of orthogonal matrices with , differentiating gives . Thus each tangent velocity is a skew-symmetric matrix.
Conversely, if , the curve satisfies
using commutation of and . By part (a), . Both inclusions prove
The curve-based tangent space at consists of velocities of smooth curves satisfying . For an arbitrary subset these velocities need not form a vector space; for a smooth submanifold they do, and this is its usual tangent space. This definition suffices for the direct computation at the identity.
The identity shows that generate the same group. Direct multiplication gives
Consequently their images in the quotient group satisfy and . The universal property of a group presentation gives a group homomorphism taking , from the stated presentation. It is surjective because these images generate the target. Injectivity is not needed here.
After the reduction in part (b), multiply by . The new bottom-left entry is , whose absolute value is strictly smaller than the previous :
Repeated Euclidean division must terminate because the nonnegative integers decrease strictly until zero. Thus a word in and their inverses gives a matrix with bottom-left entry zero. Its determinant is one, so the diagonal entries are equal and are either both or both :
Since , this final matrix belongs to . So does , proving
For , a root modulo the odd prime is nonzero because . Its derivative is therefore nonzero modulo . Part (i) gives exactly one lift of each root. A nonzero quadratic residue modulo an odd prime has two distinct roots, and ; a nonresidue has none. Hence
Let be a root modulo . Every lift to a residue modulo is uniquely with . The polynomial expansion gives
Because is a root and there are no common roots of and , is nonzero modulo . Thus precisely one solves
Every root at one level therefore has exactly one lift, and every root at the next level reduces to a root at the previous level. Induction proves equality of the counts from to . This is simple-root Hensel lifting by successive residues at finite precision; completeness is unnecessary for this finite-level assertion.
The primes both work, with the zero residue as a solution. For every other prime, multiplicativity of the Legendre symbol and quadratic reciprocity give
The first factor is positive for ; the second is positive for . They must have the same sign. The Chinese remainder theorem therefore yields
For odd , quadratic reciprocity has no sign factor because :
The nonzero squares modulo are , so the answer for odd primes is . The excluded-prime wording also allows , where has a square root. Thus the full answer is
For , quadratic reciprocity gives
The second Legendre symbol is when and when . Combining it with the sign determined by shows that a quadratic residue occurs precisely for
If , the field property forces , giving exactly one solution. Otherwise, if is any solution, multiplication by is a bijection from the solutions of to those of . Part (i) therefore gives
The two possibilities in the second line distinguish an empty fiber from a coset of the kernel of the power group homomorphism on .
The multiplicative group is a cyclic group of order , so choose a primitive root . Every nonzero residue is uniquely , with taken modulo . The condition becomes . Writing , its solutions are . Zero is not a solution. Therefore the number is
This includes . The cyclic group argument gives the exact count, whereas the bound of roots for a nonzero degree- polynomial over a field would only give an upper bound.
For , . When , the roots of are real and lie strictly between zero and one. When , they are a complex-conjugate pair of modulus . Thus the positive steady state is linearly asymptotically stable exactly when , and unstable when . Since increases strictly with , the crossing occurs at
At the crossing,
Every nonzero real linearized perturbation has period six. This establishes the intended linear stability threshold and linearized period six.
The nonlinear period-six claim in the printed paper does not follow, and is false as a local bifurcating-branch claim for this map. One can check this directly rather than infer a nonlinear period from the eigenvalues. At normalize , . The exact planar map is
Its cubic Taylor expansion is
Here is a concrete check of the sixfold return. Put , , and
Composing the displayed cubic expansion six times cancels all quadratic terms and gives
In particular
The quartic coefficient is strictly negative. Hence, sufficiently near the equilibrium, every nonzero point has smaller after six iterations: the critical nonlinear map has no nearby nontrivial period-six orbit, and the equilibrium itself is locally attracting despite its neutral linearization.
One can also rule out a branch of small period-six orbits on either side of the crossing. Normalize about the positive equilibrium at each nearby , and put . The derivative of the sixth power of at is . Smooth dependence on therefore gives
The leading matrix has determinant . Both terms could vanish with only if , but
Thus its norm on nonzero is bounded below by a positive constant times , and the smaller remainder cannot cancel it. There is no nearby nonzero solution of . The eigenvalues satisfy the nonresonance conditions through order four, their moduli cross outward with increasing , and the cubic radial coefficient is negative. The standard Neimark–Sacker bifurcation theorem therefore gives a supercritical invariant closed curve. Its rotation is near the linear resonance ; it is not a local branch of exact period-six orbits.
Finally, the discrete population map does not preserve nonnegativity for arbitrary large lagged populations: can be negative. The positive-equilibrium stability conclusions above are local and do not assume a global positivity property that the formula lacks.
Let . At the positive steady state, , where . The two partial derivatives are
The first-order Taylor expansion with therefore gives
Equivalently, the linearization on has matrix and characteristic polynomial .
At a constant steady state , the discrete equation reduces to
Write . For , no nonzero real root is possible, so zero is the only real steady state. For the real roots are
Thus there is exactly one strictly positive steady state, . There are three real steady states in total, two of them nonnegative. At the only one is zero. This distinction keeps the positive-population statement separate from the count over all real numbers.

There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.