Work in the rest frame of the hole and neglect stellar velocities compared with . In addition to , assume the galactic encounter speed is nonrelativistic, . Treat a star as a test particle with specific angular momentum . At its pericentre , its radial velocity vanishes. Conservation of energy and conservation of angular momentum give
The second term is gravitational focusing. For the rough Newtonian estimate in the question, assume capture when the pericentre reaches the Schwarzschild radius, . It follows that
The approximation keeps the focusing term because .
Let be the stellar mass density. Multiplying the geometric collision cross-section by the incoming mass flux gives the collisionless black-hole capture rate
For a supersonic gas with negligible sound speed, Bondi--Hoyle--Lyttleton accretion has capture radius and rate
Consequently
For comparable densities and , the suppression is approximately . Gas can collide, dissipate orbital energy, and be captured from a region of size ; collisionless particles generally leave on an unbound orbit unless their angular momentum is small enough for direct capture. Chandrasekhar dynamical friction can slow the hole by transferring energy to a stellar wake, but does not mean that the stars producing that wake are swallowed.
There is an important accuracy limitation in the requested numerical coefficient. Newtonian orbital mechanics evaluated at a relativistic event horizon cannot give the exact capture boundary. In Schwarzschild spacetime, a slowly incoming massive particle has dimensionless energy and timelike geodesic effective potential
The double turning point satisfying and occurs at and . The exact low-speed boundary is therefore , twice the rough value; it makes the rate ratio . The key suppression scaling is unchanged.
Direct capture of ordinary stars or dark matter is therefore an inefficient route to rapid growth of a supermassive black hole under these conditions. Tidal disruption events can capture stellar debris without swallowing an intact point-like star, and special dense environments can modify the supply. These qualifications do not make collisionless capture equivalent to dissipative gas accretion.
The central force conserves angular momentum. The initial impact parameter gives , while at closest approach the velocity is transverse and . Thus . Conservation of energy gives
Under , neglect the initial potential term and substitute :
Consequently
In polar coordinates,
With the change of radial coordinate , the detection functional becomes
It is therefore times ordinary path length in the -plane. The shortest path is the line segment from to , so
Returning to gives the logarithmic spiral
Its minimum detection probability is
The functional depends only on the geometric path and not its parametrization, so tiptoeing and running give the same probability.
For the improved sensor, omit the irrelevant positive factor and use the Lagrangian
The coordinate is cyclic, so its conjugate momentum is conserved. Equivalently,
is constant. Because has no explicit time dependence, the associated conservation of energy gives the constant
Multiplying by and using gives the required equation
At distance , isotropic luminosity produces radiative acceleration in material of opacity . In fully ionized hydrogen, one electron supplies a Thomson scattering cross-section for approximately one proton mass of material, so . Balancing radiation against the Newtonian gravitational field of the black hole gives the Eddington luminosity
Below this luminosity gravity can confine optically thin ionized hydrogen; above it, electron scattering alone accelerates the gas outward.
An electron--positron pair has mass and total scattering cross-section , so its opacity is . Therefore
The limit is lower because the radiative force per unit inertial mass is larger in a pair plasma.
For a cloud with arbitrary constant opacity per unit mass,
Suppose the luminosity jumps to a constant while the cloud is at rest at . With , its radial acceleration is
Multiplication by and integration from to infinity gives conservation of energy
This result assumes that and remain constant and that the cloud stays optically thin.
Ignoring the small radiative back-reaction, conservation of energy gives and Newton's equation gives . Integrating the Larmor formula with yields, for ,
If , the particle turns at defined by and traverses the accelerated region twice, so the same formula holds with twice the integral from to .
For a particle in the scalar potential energy ,
The canonical commutation relation gives
The Ehrenfest theorem with therefore gives
Since and direct action on a wavefunction gives ,
Finally has no explicit time dependence and , so
The first two equations are the expectation-value counterparts of momentum equals mass times velocity and Newton's second law; the last is conservation of energy. They become the classical equations directly when the force varies negligibly across the wave packet, so that . These conclusions are summarized by the classical equations from Ehrenfest theorem.
The force is central force, so its torque about the star vanishes. The specific angular momentum is therefore constant:
Taking the scalar product of with gives
Thus conservation of energy gives the second constant
Conservation of energy and Fourier's law give
At steady state is constant. Since ,
The two temperature boundary conditions therefore give
At the basal phase boundary, the Stefan condition is
The first term removes latent heat released by freezing, while the oceanic flux supplies heat to the interface. A steady shell has , hence and
Here must simultaneously satisfy the surface balance from part a with .
Assume the rod has constant cross-sectional area , no internal source of heat, no bulk motion, and no lateral heat flux. Assume also that each section has a uniform temperature, so that depends only on , and that Fourier's law applies with the stated constant thermal conductivity . The longitudinal heat flux density is then .
By conservation of energy, the rate of increase of internal energy in a slice equals incoming minus outgoing heat:
Divide by and take the limit . For a sufficiently differentiable temperature field this gives , and hence
Here is mass density, is specific heat capacity, and is thermal diffusivity.
In terms of the positive cylindrical radius , the conserved mechanical energy becomes
The effective potential tends to infinity at both ends of for , and . Thus its two turning points enclose the allowed radial motion. At a turning point, , so
Besides , the positive root of a polynomial is
the other root of a polynomial is negative. The quadratic polynomial is negative at zero and has just one positive root of a polynomial. Since , we have when , and when .
Height is , so its maximum occurs at the smaller positive turning point. Hence
Indeed, the initial vertical acceleration is
Below the critical speed the particle first rises to ; above it the particle initially descends, and its initial height is already its greatest height. At the turning points merge and the particle follows a horizontal circular orbit at . For zero initial speed the radial conservation of energy gives motion to the apex level ; if the hole excludes the apex itself, zero is the supremum of the heights before arrival at the hole.
These are the heights under the maintained mechanical constraint used in part (a). A unilateral contact with only one side of a cone would additionally require checking the sign of the normal reaction; the ideal constrained equations alone do not impose that condition.
For any fixed subregion , with no internal heat generation, conservation of energy says that the rate of stored thermal energy equals the incoming heat flux:
The minus sign is needed because denotes outgoing heat flux. Substitute Fourier's law and apply the divergence theorem:
Here differentiation under the integral uses a fixed region and sufficient regularity of . Since the identity holds for every , continuity of the integrands gives the local heat equation
For spatially varying thermal conductivity, the product rule gives ; the second term cannot generally be discarded.
Let be the constant cross-sectional area, and suppose that the temperature is uniform on each cross-section. Consider a slice . Its stored thermal energy is . Since the lateral surface is insulated and there is no internal heat generation, conservation of energy gives
where is the heat flux in the positive direction. By Fourier's law, , so
The slice is arbitrary; therefore the local heat equation is
The constant is the thermal diffusivity. The cancellation of uses a rod of uniform cross-section; the one-dimensional model assumes no transverse temperature variation.
Initially also gives . Thus the initial velocity is azimuthal, with . By conservation of energy, the supplied mechanical energy divided by gives
The first term is nonnegative. Consequently
For a positive launch speed , introduce twice the radial effective potential on a surface of revolution per unit mass,
It satisfies
so it is a strictly convex function. Also as . To justify the other endpoint carefully, convexity gives for . This supplies a finite lower bound near , and the positive term consequently forces there.
Thus has a unique minimum at some . Its derivative is strictly increasing and zero there, so decreases to and increases afterwards. Its sublevel set is a single interval , with . If , the two boundary equations have distinct solutions; if , both boundaries are . The conservation of energy identity therefore proves
The two radii coincide exactly when , equivalently . This gives
The equation in b then has the constant solution , with : this is a circular orbit.
A positive inner bound requires . If zero launch speed is allowed, and the displayed inequality only gives because is strictly increasing; one may take the limiting inner bound . For example, satisfies all the stated hypotheses but permits inward motion from rest all the way towards the excluded axis. The two-positive-turning-radii argument therefore uses the natural interpretation of “launched with speed ” as .
Take a bar of constant cross-sectional area , thermally insulated along its sides, with no internal heat production. Fourier's law says that the heat flux in the positive direction is
The thermal conductivity is positive. On a small slice , conservation of energy gives
Here is the volumetric heat capacity, the product of mass density and specific heat capacity. Divide by , take , and use . The resulting heat equation is
For differentiable , this is ; retaining the divergence form also expresses conservation of energy correctly across an interface where jumps.
In a steady state the heat equation says , so the positive- heat flux is the same constant in both materials. Assume perfect thermal contact: temperature is continuous at , and conservation of energy requires continuous heat flux there. Integrating from the right endpoint gives
The two formulas agree at the interface. Their slopes differ, but . The total temperature drop is , the sum of the two layers' contributions in steady heat conduction through layers.
For variations with , integration by parts gives . The fundamental lemma of the calculus of variations therefore gives the Euler-Lagrange equation
For the ramp, use conservation of energy from rest at the rim. The vertical drop is , so . The spherical surface arc length is . On a monotone segment described by , the travel time is consequently
For increasing this has the printed limits to ; for a descent, reverse the decreasing angular limits to keep time positive. The azimuth is a cyclic coordinate of this integrand. Its conserved derivative gives the first integral for the brachistochrone on a hemispherical ramp:
Solving for its square yields
For a regular stationary path with finite , this tends to zero as the rim is approached. The ratio of azimuthal to meridional displacements is , which also tends to zero. Hence the initial direction is along a meridian toward the bottom. This conclusion concerns the initial heading; the later route can turn before reaching the bottom when its rim endpoints require a nonzero azimuthal displacement.
For fixed endpoint values, stationarity requires the Euler-Lagrange equation . Differentiate along an extremal: its derivative is . Thus when the Beltrami identity makes that quantity constant.
Take as depth measured downward. Conservation of energy from rest gives , hence speed . With arc length , the travel time is . For , the Beltrami quantity is . Thus .
Put and take along the first arch. Since , one obtains . Integrating from the initial cusp gives the cycloid solving the brachistochrone problem:
For the equal-height target, the first complete arch has , so . Also and for . Therefore
The endpoint zeros of speed cancel the zeros of , leaving finite travel time. Global minimality follows from the maximum-depth bound for a brachistochrone: any competing track with maximum depth satisfies . The displayed cycloid attains both inequalities with .
Figure 1.
The equal-height brachistochrone is one complete cycloid arch
. Original curve with depth drawn downward. The maximum depth is , and markers equally spaced in the cycloid parameter are equally spaced in travel time. The bead starts and ends at rest in the ideal energy-conserving model. Details.
The downward drop from the starting rim to angle is . With no dissipative forces, conservation of energy gives , so . Dividing the line element by this speed yields
The endpoint singularities are integrable for the minimizing path. The integrand is independent of ; its Euler-Lagrange equation gives a constant , after absorbing the overall prefactor:
Solving for and taking the positive branch required by gives
The constant is fixed implicitly by
This integral is strictly increasing from zero to infinity as increases from zero to one, so every finite positive separation selects a unique . The time integrand has second derivative with respect to . Its supporting-line inequality, integrated between fixed endpoints with constant first derivative with respect to , proves this stationary path is the unique global minimum within the stated single-valued class.
As , . Therefore the skater should initially head directly down the curved ramp, perpendicular to the cylinder axis, and gain axial motion later. The path differs from the constant-pitch shortest route because extra distance is cheaper in time near the faster, lower part of the ramp. This is the brachistochrone on a horizontal half-cylinder.
Figure 1.
Shortest and fastest routes on the unrolled half-cylinder for
. Details.
The generalized momentum of this Lagrangian is
The Euler-Lagrange equation therefore gives
Because has no explicit time dependence, the energy form of the Beltrami identity gives a conserved quantity . Here
For a direct check of conservation of energy, differentiate:
This is the rest-plus-kinetic energy of a relativistic particle, in units with light speed one, plus its potential energy.
Write and , the initial Lorentz factor. The conserved energy from part (a) is . To emerge on the higher plateau with positive speed, the particle needs . Hence
Above this threshold, conservation of energy gives . The transmitted velocity is positive, so
Below threshold there is a turning point within the steep transition, where and . The particle returns to the lower plateau. Its final potential energy equals its initial value, so its final Lorentz factor equals but its direction is reversed:
At exact threshold the limiting speed on the upper plateau is zero. This is the marginal case, not passage with positive outgoing speed. The ideal discontinuous potential does not specify the detailed trajectory at equality; a smooth transition can make the particle approach the top asymptotically. The final-speed formulas above cover the strictly transmitted and reflected regimes requested.