James H. Christenson, James Watson Cronin, Val Logsdon Fitch and René Turlay reported the result in 1964. At Brookhaven's AGS, 30 GeV protons struck beryllium; collimators selected a neutral particle beam at 30 degrees. A downstream helium decay volume reduced interactions.[ref]
The flight distance suppressed the short-lived kaon component. Each arm of a two-arm magnetic spectrometer had spark chambers before and after its magnet. Cherenkov detectors and scintillation counters triggered photographic recording in coincidence.[ref]
Figure 1.
From a neutral kaon beam to a two-track invariant mass
. Original functional schematic, not a scale drawing. The apparatus functions follow the 1964 paper p.138 and Fitch's lecture pp.598–600. The lower example is dimensionless synthetic four-momentum conservation, not a historical event. Details.
The helium sample yielded signal events; was the ratio to all charged decay channels.[ref] That denominator must be retained when comparing this result with a total branching fraction.
The evidence was kinematic. Later regenerated-beam quantum interference established that the short- and long-lived states reached the same two-pion final state, excluding alternatives such as distinct pion-like particles.[ref] The 1964 observation established evidence for CP violation; it did not determine every parameter of the CKM matrix. Inferring time-reversal symmetry violation from CP violation invokes CPT symmetry, rather than a direct comparison of time-reversed transitions in that experiment.
The ATLAS experiment and CMS experiment searched proton-proton collisions at the Large Hadron Collider at collision energies of and . The ATLAS experiment used silicon tracking, a solenoid, liquid-argon electromagnetic calorimeters and an external muon spectrometer. Its July 2012 paper reported a combined local statistical significance of standard deviations near ; this paper result is distinct from the initial 4 July announcement.[ref]
The CMS experiment used silicon tracking in a solenoid, lead-tungstate electromagnetic calorimeters and external muon chambers. Electrons combine tracks and particle showers; muons combine tracking and chamber hits; photons supply shower energies and directions. Selected and candidates, with , yielded invariant mass peaks. It checked lepton efficiencies with Z boson decays, estimated fake-lepton backgrounds from control samples with relaxed identification, and fitted the smooth diphoton background from data. Its combined local statistical significance was standard deviations near .[ref]
The ATLAS experiment compared signal-plus-background and background-only hypotheses with a profile likelihood, accounting for systematic uncertainties and correlations between decay channels. Diphoton and four-lepton candidates gave precise invariant masses; decays supplied additional evidence with poorer mass reconstruction because of escaping neutrinos. A local p-value concerns one specified mass; scanning masses requires a look-elsewhere effect correction.[ref]
Two-photon decay excludes spin one under the usual assumptions, but does not prove spin zero. A mass peak does not determine every Higgs boson coupling. Production rates, branching fractions and angular correlations require additional tests.[ref]
For a coherently prepared state proportional to , evolve each component with . The proper time is , and . Since both components reach the same final state, their decay amplitudes add before squaring. Factoring out and a common beam normalization gives the two-pion intensity
The last term is quantum interference. It vanishes upon averaging over an independently random preparation phase, but cannot be discarded from a coherent preparation. Summing the two positive contributions alone would lose the phase-sensitive information.
Figure 1.
Chosen kaon lifetimes and coherent two-pion intensity
. Original dimensionless illustration with , , , and . Upper curves are separate single-state survival factors; lower curves are intensities in an arbitrary common scale. This is not a historical fit or a normalized set of decay channel probabilities. Details.
At late proper time, the short-lived contribution and the quantum interference term die away, leaving the long-lived tail . Such a tail is easier to identify after the initially abundant short-lived component has disappeared. The useful experimental balance is between eliminating that component and retaining enough long-lived decays to observe a rare decay channel.
The 1964 report exposed Brookhaven's 80-inch hydrogen bubble chamber to a mass-separated negative-kaon beam. A photographed decay chain, track momenta and bubble density supported the particle identification. Two converted photons helped reconstruct a neutral pion. Alternative assignments were tested kinematically. The authors reported an Omega baryon candidate with , and mass , reserving a detailed systematic-error discussion for further events.[ref]
This is an inference from several linked observations. A charged particle can leave a visible bubble-chamber track, while a neutral segment must be reconstructed from its production and decay products. Agreement between possible decay channels, electric charge, momentum conservation and the reconstructed mass is stronger evidence than a suggestive track shape alone. The event tests a predicted hadron pattern; it does not photograph the three strange quarks individually.
For example, an independently constructed two-body kinematic check uses
In a parent rest frame with equal and opposite daughter momenta, the momentum sum vanishes, giving . In units , stipulated daughter masses , and momentum magnitude give , and . A common Lorentz boost changes the daughter energies and momenta while preserving this reconstructed invariant mass. These chosen units and numbers are an illustration, not a reanalysis of the 1964 event.
A two-track invariant mass and a direction test answer different questions. In units , assign each track the pion mass and reconstruct its momentum before magnetic deflection. With and opening angle ,
This follows by expanding the squared sum of the two four-momenta. The angle between the reconstructed parent momentum and the neutral particle beam direction satisfies
A fully reconstructed two-body decay channel gives the parent mass and , within experimental resolution. A three-body decay channel with an unseen neutrino generally misses both constraints; an accidental correct invariant mass alone is insufficient. Notice that the track opening angle need not be small even when the parent direction angle vanishes.
The 1964 analysis selected MeV and remeasured events with , comparing adjacent mass bands.[ref]
For an original dimensionless example, take , and . Each energy is ; the opening angle is degrees since . Yet points exactly along the beam, and . Thus a parent of mass passes both ideal tests. These chosen numbers illustrate four-momentum conservation, not detector performance.