For sufficiently small, let be the geodesic with , , and define . The domain consists more generally of initial velocities whose geodesic exists through time one. Uniqueness and affine rescaling give near zero, so
Thus the differential is the identity under the natural identification of tangent spaces, and the inverse function theorem makes the exponential map a local diffeomorphism near zero.
A punctured plane has geodesics reaching its missing point in finite time, so its exponential map need not be global; adding the point remedies this example. But an extension cannot always remedy the failure. On the punctured circular cone , radial generators are geodesics and reach the missing point in finite intrinsic length. Any globally defined extension would have to include their limiting point . The cone's tangent planes have different limits as varies; no smooth embedded surface through that point can contain this punctured circular cone. Hence no such extension exists for this .
For an oriented surface and a closed topological disc with smooth positively oriented boundary, the Gauss-Bonnet theorem with boundary says
Here is signed geodesic curvature with the disc on the left. A smooth boundary has no corner terms; piecewise smooth boundaries require exterior-angle terms.
For the flat disc in the problem this gives . Conditions (i) and (ii) mean that the proposed replacement disc has the same boundary and agrees with the original smooth surface from the outside. Smoothness therefore gives the same tangent planes, metric derivatives and boundary geodesic curvature on the replacement, with consistent orientation. Applying Gauss-Bonnet to that disc forces
Thus these gluing conditions fix the total curvature of any smooth replacement disc, regardless of its detailed interior shape.
The nonnegative continuous Gaussian curvature on the compact replacement disc, together with its zero integral established by Gauss-Bonnet, forces it to vanish at every point of that disc. Outside it the replacement surface agrees with the original flat surface, so its curvature also vanishes there; smoothness covers the common boundary. Consequently no point of the replacement surface can have positive Gaussian curvature. Therefore no surface can satisfy all three conditions. A disc with some positive curvature could only have compensating negative curvature or alter the smooth boundary gluing, both excluded here.
Differentiate the parametrized surface. The coefficients of the first fundamental form simplify to
If , then . Moreover
Thus the second-fundamental-form coefficients satisfy and . The Gaussian curvature is consequently
For a local parametrization , write the first fundamental form and second fundamental form as
The Gaussian curvature is
To prove the Theorema Egregium, set and decompose
Differentiating and solving for the tangential coefficients gives
so every Christoffel symbol depends only on and their first derivatives. Equality of mixed third derivatives yields the Gauss equation
The Riemann curvature tensor is formed from first derivatives and quadratic products of the Christoffel symbols, and hence from the first and second derivatives of . Consequently
depends only on the first fundamental form.
Suppose that a connected smooth surface properly contains . Since and have the same dimension, is open in . Choose a point of its relative boundary. Inside a sufficiently small compact normal neighbourhood in , choose and a closest point . A minimizing -geodesic from to stays in before its endpoint, since encountering the complement earlier would contradict the choice of .
The restriction of this curve is consequently a geodesic of with a finite maximal endpoint at . On the other hand, the Gaussian curvature of is the restriction of the smooth Gaussian curvature of , so it remains bounded near . This contradicts condition . Hence
so is an inextendible embedded surface. This is the curvature-blowup criterion for inextendibility of a surface.
A smooth surface in is a subset locally parametrized by a smooth map of two variables whose derivative has rank two and which is a homeomorphism onto its image.
Writing , the first surface equation becomes
It is the torus of major radius and minor radius , with smooth parametrization
Since , this is an embedding. The Gaussian curvature of a torus is
For the second surface, use the orthogonal transformation
Its equation becomes the same torus equation . Orthogonal transformations are Euclidean isometries and preserve Gaussian curvature. Curvature vanishes where , equivalently . In the original coordinates the zero-curvature points are therefore exactly
Away from a zero of , the first Bogomolny vortex equation gives
Substitution into the second equation, with , gives
Now set . The Gaussian curvature formula gives
Therefore implies
which is exactly the vortex equation.
The metric
is the pullback of the Poincare disc model metric under . It consequently has away from the origin. Comparing it with gives the Witten hyperbolic vortex
Putting gives winding number . A gauge choice with positive radial factor is
and then
A regular surface is a minimal surface when its mean curvature vanishes identically, equivalently when its two principal curvatures sum to zero everywhere.
The catenoid
is an example. In part (a), take and , so . The formula there gives
A plane and a circular cylinder have zero Gaussian curvature, as does a flat cone away from its vertex. Because a local isometry preserves Gaussian curvature, the catenoid is minimal and is not locally isometric to any of those surfaces; this is the catenoid is a minimal surface.
The curve is symmetric in both coordinate axes and under interchange of and . Its shape, including its eight inflection points, is:
Writing , the surface of revolution has equation
Let
Its gradient is
If this vanished, then and , but at such a point , not five. Hence zero is a regular value, and the regular level set theorem shows that is a smooth embedded surface.
For a surface of revolution, the two principal curvatures are the curvature of the meridian and the normal curvature of a parallel. Along ,
so the normal is vertical in the meridian plane and the parallel principal curvature vanishes. Therefore the Gaussian curvature, the product of the principal curvatures, is zero there.
These are not the only zero-curvature points. The meridian itself has inflection points, at which its principal curvature vanishes. Setting and , their positive squared coordinates satisfy
Besides interchanging and , the solution is approximately
Each corresponding meridian inflection point sweeps out another circle on , so does not exhaust the zero set of the Gaussian curvature.
For an oriented smooth embedded surface, the Gauss map sends each point to its chosen unit normal. This surface is the ring torus with major radius two and minor radius one. Its outward Gauss map is
On the cross-section, the normal points radially away from the center of each generating circle, which gives this formula for and then rotational symmetry gives it for all .
The upper hemisphere condition is , hence . For this torus, the Gaussian curvature and area element are
Therefore the positive outer and negative inner contributions cancel:
Put . The Jacobi equation in geodesic polar coordinates and the initial conditions from part (b) are
Inside a geodesic polar coordinate ball, . If , then , so and therefore . The Riemannian area element is , whence
Thus nonpositive Gaussian curvature makes such a ball at least as large as the Euclidean disk of the same radius.
For a compact oriented regular surface without boundary, the Gauss-Bonnet theorem states
Here is the Gaussian curvature, the product of the two principal curvatures; is the area element induced by the first fundamental form; and is the Euler characteristic. If is connected and has genus , the classification theorem for surfaces gives , so
Take the ring torus with minor radius and major radius . With angular coordinate around the generating circle, its Gaussian curvature is
and hence
Thus the displayed condition holds, while every has genus one and is not diffeomorphic to the sphere.
For an oriented smooth surface , the Gauss map sends to the chosen unit normal vector . Since , differentiation shows that is perpendicular to and hence lies in .
In a local parametrization with , differentiating
gives
Thus the bilinear form is symmetric, so is self-adjoint. The Gaussian curvature is
Writing the coefficients of the first fundamental form as
and those of the second fundamental form as
one obtains
At an umbilic point, the self-adjoint map has a repeated eigenvalue, so it is a scalar map. If every point is umbilic, there is a function with
Equality of mixed partial derivatives gives
The two tangent vectors are linearly independent, hence . Since is connected, is constant.
If , then is constant and
so lies in a plane. If , then
Thus is constant, and
Therefore lies in a sphere of radius . This proves that the surface is part of a plane or part of a sphere.
For a geodesic triangle with interior angles , the local Gauss-Bonnet theorem is
because its geodesic sides have zero geodesic curvature.
Triangulate a closed oriented surface into geodesic triangles, with edges and vertices. Summing the local formula, the angles around each vertex total , so
Since every triangular face has three edges and every edge belongs to two faces, . Hence
which is the global Gauss-Bonnet theorem.
For the sphere , the unit normal is . Its shape operator is, up to the conventional sign, on each tangent plane. Both principal curvatures therefore have magnitude , and the Gaussian curvature is
An octant has one eighth of the sphere's area:
Thus . Its three great-circle sides meet at three right angles, so
The two sides of the local Gauss-Bonnet formula agree directly.
For a chosen unit normal field , the second fundamental form is
In a local parametrization , its coefficients, up to the equivalent simultaneous sign convention, are
The Gaussian curvature is the determinant of the shape operator, hence
Theorema Egregium states that is determined entirely by the first fundamental form. In particular, it is intrinsic and is preserved by every local isometry.
With
the coordinate tangent vectors satisfy
Thus the first fundamental form is
Geometrically, is the half of a helicoid with positive radius, winding upwards indefinitely.
Consider the upper half of the catenoid, parametrized as the surface of revolution
It has the same first fundamental form, so defines a local isometry. By the invariance of Gaussian curvature under local isometry, the curvatures agree; directly, the conformal metric above gives
For an oriented regular surface with unit normal , the Gauss map sends each point to . The outward normal to the catenoid is
Its image is the open southern hemisphere, apart from its limiting equator and south pole. The Gauss map is one-to-one after taking modulo and reverses orientation. Since the Jacobian of the Gauss map is the Gaussian curvature, its signed spherical area is the total Gaussian curvature:
Equivalently, , whose integral over and is .
The tangent vectors of
are
Hence the first fundamental form has coefficients
Put
The upward unit normal is , so the second fundamental form has coefficients
Thus the two forms are
The Gaussian curvature is
Since , the graph formula is
as in Gaussian curvature of a graph surface.
For the final claim, fix a point of and make a rigid motion taking to the plane . The common tangent plane is horizontal, so locally is the graph . Along the projected curve of tangency,
Differentiating the second identity gives
Because is a smooth curve, , so the Hessian is singular. Its determinant is zero, and the graph formula gives at every point of . This is tangency to a plane along a curve forces zero Gaussian curvature.
The tangent plane
cuts the hyperboloid in
so its intersection is the pair of straight lines
Their accelerations vanish, hence are normal to the surface, so both lines are geodesics. Their tangent vectors at their intersection are and , whose inner product is zero. They therefore intersect at a right angle, giving the second case of plane-section geodesics of the unit one-sheet hyperboloid.
There are also geodesics entirely contained in . In the coordinates
the metric is
For a unit-speed geodesic, the Clairaut first integral for a surface of revolution is , and the constant-speed equation becomes
Choose and initial height . The geodesic initially tangent to the parallel has , and the displayed identity prevents it from entering . Since the parallel at is not itself a geodesic, the curve turns there and otherwise has . Hence it remains entirely in ; this is a geodesic trapped in one half of the unit one-sheet hyperboloid.
Finally, the waist
is a geodesic and is preserved setwise by every isometry of the hyperboloid. Indeed, its Gaussian curvature is
The value occurs exactly at . Since Gaussian curvature is intrinsic and therefore preserved by isometries, every isometry preserves the waist. Thus the answer to the final question is also yes, with the isometry-invariant waist geodesic of the unit one-sheet hyperboloid as an example.
Figure 1. . Blue meridians are disjoint geodesics in the plane y equals zero, red ruling lines are geodesics meeting orthogonally in the tangent plane x equals one, and the purple waist is an isometry-invariant geodesic.