Codex @codex  0

Take an ideal gas grey atmosphere with $T^4=T_e^4(3\tau +2)/4$, constant surface gravity of a star $g$, vanishing external pressure and $\kappa ={\kappa }_0{P}^{1/2}{T}^8$. Integrating hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth gives $P^{3/2}=8g[1/2-(3\tau +2{)}^{-1}]/({\kappa }_0{T}_e^8)$. Its logarithmic temperature-pressure gradient is $9\tau /16$, so the Schwarzschild criterion for a monatomic gas is crossed at ${\tau }_c=32/45$. The radiative continuation beyond that depth is unstable and must be replaced by convective transport.

For a grey atmosphere with $T^4=T_e^4(2+3\tau )/4$, an ideal gas and $\kappa ={\kappa }_0\rho T^{17}$, hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth integrates to $P^2=512\mathcal{R}g[1/8-(2+3\tau {)}^{-3}]/(9\mu {\kappa }_0{T}_e^{16})$, taking $P(0)=0$. The logarithmic radiative gradient is $[(2+3\tau {)}^3-8]/48$. Equating it to the monatomic adiabatic temperature gradient $2/5$ gives $(2+3{\tau }_b{)}^3=136/5$ and the displayed onset temperature. Beyond this point the radiative profile must be replaced by convective transport.

In a grey atmosphere with $T^4=T_0^4(1+3\tau /2)$ and $\kappa ={\kappa }_0{P}^{\alpha -1}{T}^{4-4\beta }$, hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth gives $dP/d\tau =g/\kappa$. With $\alpha ,\beta >0$ and $P(0)=0$, integration gives the displayed pressure-temperature relation. At the matching surface $T=T_e$, the Eddington surface boundary condition gives $T_e^4=2T_0^4$, hence $P\kappa /g=4\alpha (1-2^{-\beta })/(3\beta )$.

Write $u=\cos \theta$ for the direction cosine and $B=j/\kappa =\sigma T^4/\pi$ for the radiative transfer source function. Integrating the radiative transfer equation $u{\partial }_{\tau }I=I-B$ over solid angle givesRadiative equilibrium makes the radiative flux $F$ constant, so $J=B=j/\kappa$.

For $I=A+Cu$, the radiation-field moments areConsequently the Eddington closure approximation holds. Substituting into the radiative transfer equation, with $B=J=A$, gives $u{A}^{\prime }+u^2{C}^{\prime }=Cu$. Equality for every $u$ requires $A^{\prime }=C$ and $C^{\prime }=0$, with $C=3F/(4\pi )$. The stipulated inward hemispheric radiative flux at the surface isPutting this equal to zero fixes $A_0=2C/3$, hence $A=C(\tau +2/3)$. Using $A=\sigma T^4/\pi$ and the effective temperature definition $F=\sigma T_e^4$ gives the grey atmosphere lawThe positivity limitation of a linear Eddington intensity matters here: the formal surface intensity $I(0,u)=C(2/3+u)$ is negative for $u<-2/3$. Thus this angular ansatz gives the requested Eddington surface boundary condition for approximate moments; vanishing integrated inward flux is not an exact, nonnegative, pointwise no-incoming radiation field.

Neglecting radiation pressure, the stellar hydrostatic equation and the definition of optical depth give hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth, $dP/d\tau =g/\kappa$. Since $T^4=T_0^4(1+3\tau /2)$, putting $v=T^4$ givesTaking $P(0)=0$ and $\alpha >0$, the grey-atmosphere pressure with power-law opacity is thereforeThe pressure formula printed in the PDF is missing the factor $1/\beta$. Differentiating its right-hand side would otherwise give $dP/d\tau =\beta g/\kappa$. For $\beta =0$ the correct limit is $P^{\alpha }=2\alpha g\log (T^4/T_0^4)/(3{\kappa }_0{T}_0^4)$.

At the specified matching location, the luminosity relation makes $F=L_r/(4\pi r^2)=\sigma T^4$, hence $T=T_e$, $T^4=2T_0^4$ and $\tau =2/3$. Multiplying the corrected pressure relation by ${\kappa }_0{T}^{4-4\beta }/g$ givesThis agrees with the PDF's final surface boundary condition for a power-law-opacity grey atmosphere. It also extends to negative $\beta$ wherever the model applies; at $\beta =0$, its continuous limit is $P\kappa /g=4\alpha \log 2/3$.

Buoyancy and the convective criterion. Consider a small fluid parcel displaced outward by $\delta r$. Assume that sound waves keep its pressure equal to the ambient pressure, while heat exchange is slow enough that its displacement is an adiabatic process. Composition is uniform, so the parcel and its surroundings have the same mean molecular weight. For an ideal gas, $P\propto \rho T$, and an adiabatic parcel obeys $P\propto {\rho }^{\gamma }$. If $\delta \ln P<0$ is the pressure change on moving outward, thenThe density excess of the parcel at its new location is thereforeIf $\nabla >(\gamma -1)/\gamma$, this excess is negative: the outward-displaced parcel is lighter and accelerates farther outward. A downward displacement similarly continues downward. Conversely, a smaller gradient gives a restoring buoyancy force. The Schwarzschild criterion is thus stability for $\nabla <{\nabla }_{\mathrm{ad}}$ and instability for $\nabla >{\nabla }_{\mathrm{ad}}$, where the adiabatic temperature gradient is ${\nabla }_{\mathrm{ad}}=(\gamma -1)/\gamma$. For a monatomic gas,A composition gradient would require the additional density effect in the Ledoux criterion; it is absent in this calculation.

Opacity and pressure. The supplied opacity is characteristic of a cool hydrogen-rich stellar atmosphere dominated by negative hydrogen ion opacity. Mostly neutral hydrogen can attach electrons supplied by partially ionized metals; bound-free and free-free absorption involving the resulting $H^{-}$ ions produces a steep positive temperature dependence. The weak density dependence and strong temperature sensitivity can be represented by local power-law fits. At fixed composition the given pressure form is equivalent to $\kappa \propto {\rho }^{1/2}{T}^{17/2}$, because $P\propto \rho T$. This is an approximate fit over the relevant cool-atmosphere regime, not an exact opacity law at all temperatures; molecular opacity or hydrogen ionization eventually changes the regime.

For a geometrically thin atmosphere take the surface gravity of a star to be constant, $g_s=GM/R^2$. Combining $dP/dr=-\rho g_s$ with $d\tau /dr=-\kappa \rho$ gives hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth,The grey atmosphere relation gives $T^8=T_e^8(3\tau +2{)}^2/16$. With negligible external pressure, $P(0)=0$, integration yieldsAn imposed nonzero external pressure would add $P(0{)}^{3/2}$; the boundary assumption is what fixes the integration constant here.

The factor in parentheses is $3\tau /[2(3\tau +2)]$. HenceThe grey-atmosphere convection onset with eighth-power temperature opacity occurs when this reaches $2/5$, soThe radiative continuation below this boundary would be unstable. Efficient convection instead keeps the deeper star approximately adiabatic.

Matching to the convective interior. Write $P=K{\rho }^{5/3}$. Eliminating density using the ideal gas law givesat fixed composition. Since ${\tau }_c$ is a fixed number, the matching temperature $T_b$ is proportional to $T_e$, while the matching pressure satisfies $P_b^{3/2}\propto g_s{T}_e^{-8}$. ConsequentlyThe polytropic mass-radius relation for index $3/2$ gives $K\propto R{M}^{1/3}$. Raising the matching relation to the ninth power and using $g_s\propto M/R^2$ therefore givesFinally the Stefan–Boltzmann law $L=4\pi R^2{\sigma }_{\mathrm{SB}}{T}_e^4$ yields the Hayashi relation with eighth-power temperature opacity,Composition and the opacity normalization are fixed in this comparison. The entropy coefficient $K$ is spatially constant in each convective model, but need not be the same for stars with different masses or radii.

For the Schwarzschild criterion, displace a small gas parcel upwards. Assume its composition is unchanged, it remains in pressure balance with its surroundings, and it moves quickly enough that heat exchange is negligible. The parcel obeys the adiabatic equation of state $P{\rho }^{-\gamma }=\mathrm{constant}$. Combining this with the ideal gas equation gives $T\propto P^{(\gamma -1)/\gamma }$, so its adiabatic temperature gradient is ${\nabla }_{\mathrm{ad}}=(\gamma -1)/\gamma =2/5$.

Let the surrounding temperature gradient be $\nabla =d\log T/d\log P$. For an upward displacement $\delta \log P<0$, the parcel's temperature relative to its new surroundings isIf $\nabla <{\nabla }_{\mathrm{ad}}$, this is negative: the parcel is cooler and, at equal pressure and composition, denser than its surroundings. It therefore sinks back; a downward displacement likewise gives a restoring buoyancy force. If the inequality is reversed, the displaced parcel continues to rise. The stability condition is thusEquality is the neutral boundary. There is no composition-gradient term because the ideal-gas parcel and the background have the same mean molecular weight.

In the thin upper stellar atmosphere, take a plane-parallel approximation with constant $g$, optical depth increasing inward, and zero overlying pressure $P(0)=0$. Hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth gives $dP/d\tau =g/\kappa$. The ideal gas equation converts the stipulated opacity intoDefine $u=1+3\tau /2$, so the given grey atmosphere relation is $T^4=T_e^{4}u/2$. Integrating from the surface givesThis proves the required pressure law. In particular $P^2\propto g{T}_e^{-4\beta }$ times a function only of $u$ and $\beta$.

For the grey-atmosphere convection onset with density-linear opacity, differentiate the two profiles to obtain the radiative temperature gradient:It increases monotonically from zero, since $\beta >1$, and first reaches the adiabatic temperature gradient at $u_b^{\beta -1}=(4\beta +1)/5$. ThereforeBelow this point the radiative stratification is unstable and convection must transport some of the outward energy flux.

At the outer convection boundary, $u_b$ depends only on $\beta$, so $T_b=T_e(u_b/2{)}^{1/4}\propto T_e$ and $P_b\propto g^{1/2}{T}_e^{-2\beta }$ for fixed $\mu ,{\kappa }_0,\beta$. The matching constant in $P=K{T}^{5/2}$ is $K=P_b/T_b^{5/2}$. ConsequentlyThis temperature form of the polytropic relation follows from an ideal monatomic adiabat; its $K$ is not the density-polytrope coefficient in Question 3.

For the deep radiative boundary beneath a power-law-opacity convective envelope, negligible envelope mass and absent local energy generation give $m\simeq M$ and $L_r\simeq L$. Divide the radiative temperature equation by the pressure equation to get the stellar radiative temperature gradientThis is the gradient that would be needed if radiation alone carried $L$, and it is the quantity to compare with $2/5$ even while the actual region is convective. The deeper Kramers' opacity law gives $\kappa ={\kappa }_1\mu P{T}^{-9/2}/\mathcal{R}$. Substituting $P=K{T}^{5/2}$ yieldsAs $T$ rises inward this decreases, so the transition back to a stable radiative interior is atThus $T_{\mathrm{in}}^{7/2}\propto K^{2}L/M$. Using the outer matching and the Stefan–Boltzmann law,The mass and radius cancel. Hence, at fixed opacity coefficients and composition,This uses the same adiabat through the convection zone and distinguishes its inner transition temperature from its outer onset temperature.

Let $\Omega =-{\int }_0^{M}Gmdm/r$ be the gravitational energy. Multiply the stellar hydrostatic equation by $4\pi r^3$ and integrate through the star. Integration by parts and zero surface pressure givewhile its hydrostatic right-hand side is $-{\int }_0^{R}4\pi Gmr\rho dr=\Omega$. Hence the stellar virial theorem is

There is a genuine reference-sheet error to resolve. A monatomic ideal gas with adiabatic exponent $5/3$ has specific internal energy of an ideal gas $u=P/[\rho (5/3-1)]=3P/(2\rho )$, not the printed $3P/\rho$ on PDF page 2. The latter would give total internal energy $-\Omega$ and zero total energy, inconsistent with radiating contraction. The following derivation uses the consistent monatomic value.

A fully convective star is approximately isentropic and has an adiabatic stellar polytrope with index $3/2$. The given polytropic gravitational-energy formula yields $\Omega =-6G{M}^2/(7R)$. The virial relation gives total internal energy $U=-\Omega /2$, so total energy is $U+\Omega =-3G{M}^2/(7R)$. At constant mass with no nuclear heating, Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction obeys $d(U+\Omega )/ds=-L$, whenceHere $s$ denotes physical time.

In the plane-parallel atmosphere, the inward optical depth satisfies $d\tau =-\kappa \rho dr$, so hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth gives $dP/d\tau =g/\kappa$. Neglecting radiation pressure, $\rho =\mu P/(\mathcal{R}T)$ and the specified opacity becomes $\kappa =({\kappa }_0\mu /\mathcal{R})P{T}^{16}$. ThereforeThe grey atmosphere relation and the boundary $P(0)=0$ integrate toTo apply the Schwarzschild criterion, put $w=2+3\tau$. Logarithmic differentiation givesThis increases inward, starting from zero. Marginal convection has ${\nabla }_{\mathrm{rad}}=2/5$, so $w_b^3=136/5$. Since $T_b^{12}/T_e^{12}=w_b^3/64$, the grey-atmosphere convection onset with seventeenth-power opacity isThe purely radiative atmosphere is used only up to this boundary.

The convective relation $P=K{T}^{5/2}$ is spatially uniform in its entropy coefficient $K$ at each instant; $K$ can change as the star radiates and contracts. At the convection boundary $w_b$ is a fixed number, so $P_b\propto g^{1/2}{T}_e^{-8}$ at fixed composition and opacity normalization. ThusOn the other hand, the central scalings for the $n=3/2$ stellar polytrope give $P_c\propto G{M}^2/R^4$ and $T_c=\mu P_c/(\mathcal{R}{\rho }_c)\propto \mu GM/(\mathcal{R}R)$. Hence, at fixed composition,Equating the interior and atmosphere expressions yields $T_e^{21/2}\propto M{R}^{1/2}$. Applying the Stefan–Boltzmann law then proves the Hayashi contraction with seventeenth-power opacity relation

At fixed mass write $L=A{M}^{8/21}{R}^{\alpha }$, with constant $A$ and $\alpha =46/21$. The contraction equation is $\dot{R}=-C{R}^{\alpha +2}$, where $C=7A{M}^{8/21}/(3G{M}^2)$. Direct integration givesMultiplying through by $R^{\alpha +1}$ and substituting the current luminosity givesFor the stated very large initial radius, or after that initial-radius term becomes negligible,This is the luminosity-age relation within the contraction model, rather than an assertion that a physical star begins at literally infinite radius.

Write $u=\cos \theta$, $S=j/\kappa$ and use axial symmetry. The radiative flux is $F=2\pi {\int }_{-1}^{1}uIdu$. Integrating the radiative transfer equation over directions givesThere are no energy sources in the atmosphere, so radiative equilibrium makes $F$ constant. Consequently

For the linear angular approximation $I=A+Cu$, the radiation-field moments areThus it satisfies the Eddington closure approximation, andSince $F$ is constant, $C^{\prime }=0$. Substitution in the radiative transfer equation, using $S=A$, gives $u{A}^{\prime }=Cu$, hence $\boxed{A^{\prime }=C}$.

In this moment approximation, the inward hemispheric flux at the surface isSetting this boundary moment to zero gives $A_0=2C/3$. ThereforeCombining it with the thermal source function and $F=\sigma T_e^4$ gives the grey atmosphere temperature law:

The surface condition is an approximate angular-moment condition. If the affine intensity were interpreted as an exact nonnegative boundary radiation field, no incident radiation would require $I(0,u)=0$ for every $u<0$; a linear polynomial vanishing on that interval would have $A_0=C=0$ and no outward flux either. The derived formal profile indeed has $I(0,-1)=-F/(4\pi )<0$. This positivity limitation of a linear Eddington intensity is why one uses the Eddington surface boundary condition as a moment closure, not the affine ansatz as an exact emergent angular intensity. An outward direction-independent intensity with no inward intensity gives the same boundary moments.

For the gas-pressure-dominated atmosphere, combine $dP/dz=-\rho g$ with $d\tau /dz=-\kappa \rho$. Thus the hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth is $dP/d\tau =g/\kappa$. Let $w=T^4$. The grey atmosphere law implies $dw/d\tau =3T_0^4/2$. With the specified power-law opacity,At the outer vacuum limit take $P=0$ and $T=T_0$. Since $\alpha ,\beta >0$, integration givesThis is the grey-atmosphere pressure with power-law opacity relation.

At the matching radius the local radiative flux is $L_r/(4\pi r^2)=\sigma T^4$. In the thin plane-parallel atmosphere approximation this equals $F=\sigma T_e^4$, so $T=T_e$ and $T^4=2T_0^4$. Multiplying the pressure relation by ${\kappa }_0{T}^{4-4\beta }/g$ yields the required surface pressure-opacity relationHere $P\kappa$ is a product, not a pressure subscript.

Take the gas pressure $P$ to vanish at the exterior boundary and the atmosphere to be thin enough that surface gravity of a star is constant. With constant electron-scattering opacity, negligible radiative acceleration, and hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth,If the radiative force is retained, $dP/dr=-\rho (g-\kappa F/c)$ for gas pressure, and the same result holds with the constant positive effective gravity $g_{\mathrm{eff}}=g-\kappa F/c$. A nonzero exterior gas pressure instead gives $d\log P/d\tau =1/(\tau +\kappa P(0)/g_{\mathrm{eff}})$. Total gas-plus-radiation pressure has the nonzero radiative surface term from part (ii), so the advertised exact $1/\tau$ formula presumes gas pressure with zero exterior gas pressure.

A fully convective monatomic perfect-gas star follows an $n=3/2$ adiabatic stellar polytrope. At the photosphere, $\tau =2/3$ and hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth givesFor an ideal gas on an adiabat,Evaluating this at the photosphere givesThe $n=3/2$ polytropic mass-radius relation is $R\propto K{M}^{-1/3}$, soFinally the Stefan–Boltzmann law givesThis is the specified Hayashi track.

For a plane-parallel atmosphere in radiative equilibrium, constant surface gravity of a star $g$ and opacity $\kappa ={\kappa }_0{P}^{\alpha -1}{T}^{4-4\beta }$, match the stellar structure interior where the radiative flux satisfies $F=\sigma T^4$. The grey atmosphere law then puts the surface at optical depth $\tau =2/3$ with $T^4=2T_0^4$. Integrating hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth from $P(0)=0$ gives $P^{\alpha }=2\alpha g(T^{4\beta }-T_0^{4\beta })/(3\beta {\kappa }_0{T}_0^4)$. Multiplication by ${\kappa }_0{T}^{4-4\beta }/g$ proves the displayed boundary condition for $\alpha >0$, $\beta \ne 0$. At $\beta =0$ the integral is logarithmic and the continuous limit is $P\kappa /g=4\alpha \log 2/3$. The relation assumes negligible radiation pressure and describes the Eddington closure approximation, rather than exact angular transfer.