Enneper surface 2026-10-06
The isothermal coordinates give the immersion . Its coordinate functions are harmonic and its metric is , so it is a complete immersed minimal surface with self-intersections.
If a smooth minimal surface equation for a graph solution on is homogeneous of degree one, with , then its graph extends to a plane through zero. Its gradient is homogeneous of degree zero, so attains a global maximum on the unit sphere. The strong maximum principle for elliptic operators makes it constant. The differentiated equation in the gradient maximum principle for a minimal graph then forces , and degree-one homogeneity removes the affine constant. This argument applies to cones that are graphs of smooth functions away from their vertex; it is not a claim that every minimal surface cone is flat.
Minimal surface equation for a graph Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-24
The graph of is minimal exactly when
Equivalently, it is the Euler--Lagrange equation
for the area functional .
The physical argument for the Penrose inequality combines weak cosmic censorship conjecture, the dominant energy condition, and relaxation to a stationary black hole. Work in geometrized units. Let and be the final Kerr black hole mass and horizon area. Positive energy radiated to infinity gives , where is the initial ADM energy. For a Kerr black hole with ,
If the initial apparent horizon obeys the necessary apparent-horizon area comparison with the enclosing event horizon, and Hawking's area theorem applies during the evolution, then
Consequently the anticipated answer, under those additional hypotheses, is
The bound is saturated by a nonrotating Schwarzschild black hole with no energy loss. Rotation or outgoing radiation makes the argument's inequalities stricter.
There is an essential qualification: inclusion inside an event horizon does not by itself compare areas. An arbitrary apparent horizon on general, non-time-symmetric initial data need not satisfy the displayed apparent-horizon area comparison; the unqualified version with its area is not universally true, even with the dominant energy condition. On time-symmetric data the relevant outermost minimal surface is an outer area-minimizing surface, as used in the Riemannian Penrose inequality, with nonnegative scalar curvature. In more general formulations an appropriate enclosing-area quantity is needed. The physical expectation is conditional on this area comparison, as well as on censorship, predictability, settling, and the energy assumptions; the mere presence of a trapped surface does not supply every step.
An immersion has differential of rank , equivalently linearly independent . It has isothermal coordinates when its first fundamental form has , . A minimal surface has zero mean curvature.
For an isothermal immersion, differentiation of and gives
and similarly its scalar product with is zero. Its normal component is . The given mean curvature formula reduces to , so
Thus an isothermal immersion is minimal exactly when each coordinate is a harmonic function.
An explicit example is the Enneper surface, parametrized on by
Every coordinate has zero Laplacian. Direct differentiation gives and . Thus it is an isothermal immersion and is minimal everywhere.
It is not an open subset of any of the three listed surfaces. The parameter points and both map to , but their tangent planes differ: while . A plane, catenoid, or helicoid is an embedded smooth surface with a unique tangent plane at each point. If our whole image lay in any one of them, both rank- tangent planes at this point would have to equal its tangent plane, a contradiction.
A regular surface is a minimal surface when its mean curvature vanishes identically, equivalently when its two principal curvatures sum to zero everywhere.
The catenoid
is an example. In part (a), take and , so . The formula there gives
A plane and a circular cylinder have zero Gaussian curvature, as does a flat cone away from its vertex. Because a local isometry preserves Gaussian curvature, the catenoid is minimal and is not locally isometric to any of those surfaces; this is the catenoid is a minimal surface.
The map is an immersion when has rank two, equivalently and are linearly independent. It is isothermal when its first fundamental form has
In general the mean curvature is
The surface is minimal when . In isothermal coordinates the Laplace-Beltrami operator identity is
Thus exactly when each coordinate function is harmonic.
For
the isothermal conditions are
and harmonicity gives
Consequently
and the isothermal equation reduces to
These are all the solutions for which never vanishes. When they parameterize a catenoid, up to translations, reflection and scaling. The limiting cases , , with exactly one of nonzero, parameterize a punctured plane.
The Gauss map sends to the chosen unit normal . Differentiating shows that maps into itself. The shape operator is self-adjoint because its associated second fundamental form is symmetric. Its eigenvalues are the principal curvatures. A point is umbilical when , and the surface is minimal when its mean curvature vanishes everywhere.
In an orthonormal principal basis, has diagonal matrix . It is conformal exactly when
which is equivalent to . At a nonumbilical point this says , exactly the condition . Hence, when there are no umbilical points, the surface is minimal if and only if its Gauss map is conformal.
The Ryu–Takayanagi formula gives the leading entropy of a static boundary region:
On the slice of Poincaré ,
The minimal surface anchored on a boundary circle of radius is the hemisphere
Cutting it off at , its area is
Therefore
The universal requirement was the perimeter-law divergence ; the finite constant depends on the stated pure vacuum geometry and equals here. Since , both terms are of order .
Use the convention
An embedded submanifold is minimal when its mean curvature vector vanishes identically. For a variation with velocity field , the first variation of area is
where is the outward unit conormal. For a boundaryless , only the first integral remains. This sign convention is consistent with the outward variation of a round sphere increasing its area, because its points inward.