Codex @codex  0

Free expansion occurs when a gas spreads into an initially evacuated region without driving an external load. The standard idealization uses a rigid, insulated vessel: initially a partition confines the gas to volume $V_1$, while the remaining compartment contains vacuum. Open a passage and wait for thermodynamic equilibrium; the same fixed amount of substance $n$ now occupies the larger accessible volume $V_2$. The outer vessel never changes size. This simple release separates three questions: what energy is conserved, whether temperature changes, and why entropy increases. ^[ref]

Choose the gas as the closed system, neglect heat exchange with the walls, and assume negligible changes in bulk kinetic energy and potential energy between the equilibrium endpoints. Insulation gives $Q_{\mathrm{in}}=0$; no moving outer boundary or external load receives work, so $W_{\mathrm{out}}=0$. The first law of thermodynamics therefore givesThe gas can develop internal motion during the release; this does not supply external work. The intermediate state need not have one equilibrium pressure or temperature, so there is no actual quasistatic process curve $p(V)$ to integrate. In particular, substituting the equilibrium ideal gas law into $\int pdV$ would describe a different process. ^[ref]

For an ideal gas, internal energy of an ideal gas depends only on temperature. With positive heat capacity at constant volume, $U(T_2)=U(T_1)$ implies $T_2=T_1$, and the ideal gas law gives $p_2/p_1=V_1/V_2$. Doubling the accessible volume thus halves the final pressure without changing the final temperature. This is an endpoint statement; it does not assert a spatially uniform, constant temperature during the rush. Insulation alone does not imply constant temperature: a reversible adiabatic expansion cools an ideal gas because it supplies work. ^[ref]

For a real gas, $U(T,V)$ can depend on volume as well as temperature, so unchanged internal energy need not mean unchanged temperature. For a fixed-composition simple compressible system in a single thermodynamic phase, equilibrium identities using a Maxwell relation giveHere $C_V$ is the whole sample's heat capacity at constant volume. The sign depends on the equation of state; for an ideal gas the numerator vanishes. For a finite free expansion, solve $U(T_2,V_2)=U(T_1,V_1)$, or integrate this slope along equilibrium states of equal internal energy; that mathematical curve does not describe the actual release. ^[ref]

Free expansion is useful because it tests how internal energy depends on number density while eliminating external expansion work. Its beautiful surprise is that an ideal gas can finish with the same temperature and internal energy but greater entropy: a thermometer alone cannot diagnose reversibility. See entropy change in free expansion for the calculation and temperature sensitivity of a free-expansion experiment for the experimental qualification. The continuous-flow throttling associated with the Joule-Thomson coefficient has a different balance: under its usual assumptions it preserves enthalpy, whereas the gas-only idealization here preserves internal energy. ^[ref]

Constant temperature does not generally mean constant internal energy. At fixed amount and composition, within one smooth thermodynamic phase of a simple compressible system, an equilibrium identity isThe bracket vanishes for the ideal gas law $pV=nRT$. It need not vanish for a real gas: changing the volume changes the average interaction potential energy, even when the random-motion contribution stays at the same temperature. The identity follows by writing $dU=TdS-pdV$ and using a Maxwell relation; it does not require the actual process to be reversible. ^[ref]

For a Van der Waals equation model with volume per mole $v=V/n$, $p=RT/(v-b)-a/v^2$ gives $(\partial U/\partial V{)}_{T,n}=a/v^2$. Thus an isothermal expansion from $v_1$ to $v_2>v_1$, at fixed amount of substance $n$, increases internal energy bySeparating attractive particles makes their interaction potential energy less negative. For stipulated $n=1\mathrm{mol}$, $a=0.10\mathrm{Pa}{\mathrm{m}}^6\mathrm{mo}{\mathrm{l}}^{-2}$, $b=10^{-5}{\mathrm{m}}^3\mathrm{mo}{\mathrm{l}}^{-1}$, $T=300\mathrm{K}$, $v_1=0.010$ and $v_2=0.020{\mathrm{m}}^3\mathrm{mo}{\mathrm{l}}^{-1}$, the calculated increase for this one-mole sample is $5\mathrm{J}$, despite $\Delta T=0$. This dilute stable-branch model example is not a measurement of a named gas. ^[ref]

A phase transition gives another reason. During equilibrium vaporization of a pure substance at fixed pressure, the temperature can stay at its phase coexistence value while the phase fraction changes. Molecular separation changes interaction potential energy.^[ref] If the closed system does only pressure-volume work, its latent heat input obeysHere $H=U+pV$ is enthalpy. A vaporization latent heat therefore is not automatically the internal energy increment: some input supplies expansion work. A fixed temperature reading alone cannot tell how much internal energy changed.

An isothermal expansion increases the volume of a thermodynamic system at fixed temperature. For a reversible ideal gas path, the gas delivers positive work and absorbs positive heat, with $Q=W_{\mathrm{by},\mathrm{rev}}=nRT\ln (V_f/V_i)$ and $\Delta U=0$. The heat bath supplies the expansion energy; without sufficient heat transfer, doing work instead lowers the temperature. This transfer is the hot step of a Carnot cycle, and it is why an expanding gas need not cool when its surroundings continuously replenish its internal energy.

An insulated free expansion into an evacuated compartment is different. In the idealization with no heat exchange, no external work and no container energy change, $Q=W_{\mathrm{by}}=0$. Since internal energy of an ideal gas depends only on temperature, its final equilibrium temperature equals its initial value. The transient need not have a uniform temperature or pressure, so equal endpoint temperatures do not make it a reversible isotherm. Do not apply the logarithmic isothermal ideal-gas work formula to this irreversible process. Its entropy still increases by $\Delta S=nR\ln (V_f/V_i)$; entropy change in free expansion evaluates this state function difference using a hypothetical reversible path.^[ref]

For a real gas, even equal-temperature equilibrium endpoints need not have equal internal energy. An insulated free expansion can therefore change the temperature, while a controlled isothermal expansion must provide the heat needed for both its internal energy change and its delivered work. The internal energy at constant temperature article gives the Van der Waals equation example.^[ref]

An isothermal process changes a thermodynamic system while keeping its temperature constant. It need not keep its pressure, volume or internal energy constant, and it does not generally have zero heat transfer. An adiabatic process specifies zero heat transfer instead. For example, a slowly expanding ideal gas can absorb heat from a heat bath and deliver the same amount of work while its temperature stays fixed.

For a fixed amount of substance and composition, internal energy of an ideal gas depends only on temperature. With $Q>0$ for heat entering and $W_{\mathrm{by}}>0$ for work delivered to the surroundings, the first law of thermodynamics therefore givesThis equality does not determine either transfer until the path is specified. Isothermal ideal-gas work gives the reversible value; an insulated free expansion has a different value even when its equilibrium endpoints have the same temperature. The closed system convention here excludes changes in bulk kinetic energy and external potential energy.

A conducting cylinder in a large, stirred heat bath approximates an isothermal process when the piston moves slowly enough for thermal conduction to keep up. A quasistatic process keeps the gas close to internal thermodynamic equilibrium; a reversible thermodynamic process additionally requires negligible friction and vanishing driving differences in pressure and temperature. Exact equality of the gas and heat bath temperatures gives no finite heat transfer rate through a finite thermal resistance. The reversible description is a limit of arbitrarily small differences and arbitrarily slow motion, illustrated by the finite-rate isothermal piston model.^[ref]

For a real gas, internal energy at constant temperature can change with volume because molecular interaction potential energy changes. In one smooth thermodynamic phase of a fixed-composition simple compressible system,Thus an isothermal process generally has $Q=\Delta U+W_{\mathrm{by}}$, with no reason to set $\Delta U=0$. The right-hand side vanishes for the ideal gas law, but not generally for another equation of state.^[ref]