On , take and . Then with uniform convergence, because there is no error, and with uniform convergence, with error . Their products converge pointwise to zero, but for every the choice gives . Thus the products do not converge uniformly. Here the first family consists of unbounded functions, exactly the missing hypothesis in the preceding estimate.
Write and with uniform convergence. The triangle inequality gives
Hence with uniform convergence.
If every is a bounded function, part iii gives constants bounding the two families. Their pointwise limits satisfy and . Consequently
Thus both sums and products have uniform convergence under the stated hypotheses. The product estimate is the uniform convergence product rule for bounded functions.
Assume, as required for the displayed integrals, that the are Riemann integrable on . Their uniform limit is also Riemann integrable: if , the upper and lower Darboux sums for a partition of an interval differ for by at most the corresponding difference for plus . Choosing and then a sufficiently fine partition of an interval proves the Riemann integrability criterion for .
The integral estimate then gives
This proves that uniform convergence preserves integrals on a compact interval. Some integrability hypothesis is necessary: uniform convergence alone cannot make the integral of an arbitrary starting function exist.
No: the unbounded length of the domain matters. Let and define on . These are continuous functions with compact support, and , so the sequence has uniform convergence to zero. However, the change of variables gives
The integral of the limit is zero. The supports widen as the heights decrease; a uniform bound on the heights gives no bound on the total area over an infinite interval.
Figure 1.
Concentrating bumps, spreading bumps, and a one-sided approximate identity
. Left: the examples in part (b)(i) converge pointwise to zero while their integrals remain one. Middle: the examples in part (b)(iii) have uniform convergence to zero but retain integral one by spreading across the real line. Right: the nonnegative functions in part (c) concentrate their mass at zero and recover the endpoint value of a continuous function. Details.
Take on . Each function is continuous, and the pointwise limit is for , while . Nevertheless
The limiting function is Riemann integrable, since changing a value at one point does not change its Riemann integral. There is no uniform convergence: for every , , with the supremum approached as from below. Equivalently, the uniform limit theorem would require the limit to be continuous.
The truncated Fourier cosine series gives the better approximation over the whole closed interval. Its Fourier coefficients obey , so absolute convergence and the tail bound
give uniform convergence. The even periodic extension is continuous; its slope changes only cause corners.
By contrast . The odd periodic extension has a jump at , giving slower coefficient decay and the Gibbs phenomenon near that endpoint. Every truncated Fourier sine series satisfies , so
It therefore cannot converge uniformly to on , although it converges at every point of . This comparison concerns approximation across the interval; it does not assert that the cosine truncation has smaller error at every individual interior point for every .
Write . The transient satisfies the heat equation and homogeneous mixed boundary conditions
The left condition is a Neumann boundary condition and the right one a Dirichlet boundary condition. Separation of variables, , gives
The condition removes the sine term. The condition then selects
There is no nonzero mode with , because a linear satisfying both conditions is zero. There is no growing mode either: integration by parts gives , so every nonzero mode has .
These Sturm-Liouville eigenfunctions have orthogonality and squared norm
Expand the initial transient in this half-integer Fourier cosine series. Its coefficients are
The integration formula follows by integration by parts; the cosine at the endpoint is zero. Thus the half-integer cosine expansion of a linear profile gives
At the Fourier series reproduces everywhere, including the endpoints; its coefficient decay gives uniform convergence. For every the exponential factors allow termwise differentiation and verify the heat equation and both boundary conditions. The sudden switch-on of nonzero heat flux is incompatible with the spatial derivative of the constant initial temperature at the corner . Accordingly, the positive-time boundary derivative must not be inferred by differentiating the initial Fourier series term by term at that corner.
On the basic interval the graph is the pair of straight segments joining , and . Its periodic extension is an even triangular wave.
Figure 1. . Original plot marking the basic interval and the repeated linear pieces. Details.
The Fourier coefficients satisfy by evenness, and
For the second formula, integration by parts gives . Only odd indices survive, giving this rescaled Fourier cosine series of a triangular wave:
The pointwise convergence of a piecewise smooth Fourier series applies throughout the interval, including the continuous joined endpoints. The coefficients also imply uniform convergence by the Weierstrass M-test. At , the value is one, so
The periodically extended is even, so every sine coefficient is zero. With the convention , the Fourier coefficients are
For the second integral, two applications of integration by parts give . Consequently
The periodic extension is continuous even at the joined endpoints, where both one-sided values equal . The pointwise convergence of a piecewise smooth Fourier series therefore gives the displayed values throughout the interval; the coefficient bound also gives uniform convergence by the Weierstrass M-test. Setting and then yields
Evenness removes every sine coefficient. In the period-two Fourier cosine series convention , the constant coefficient is . Integration by parts gives
Thus the Fourier cosine series of a triangular wave is
The periodic function is continuous and piecewise smooth, so the Dirichlet-Jordan convergence theorem gives its value at every point. The summable absolute coefficient bound also gives uniform convergence by the Weierstrass M-test.
Use the real Fourier series convention . The function is an even function, so . For noninteger real ,
For , the product-to-sum identity gives
Thus the Fourier series of a noninteger-frequency cosine is
Its Fourier coefficients are , giving absolute convergence and uniform convergence. The periodic function is continuous at its joins because the two endpoint cosine values coincide, so the Dirichlet-Jordan convergence theorem gives this value at every point.
Putting gives
Evaluate at , where , and multiply by :
Comparing with the required form gives .
The power series for has uniform convergence on every compact interval, so termwise integration from zero to is valid. Thus
This power series converges for every real , including negative with the usual orientation of a definite integral.
Steady state. In the heat equation, time independence makes the second spatial derivative zero. The two endpoint temperatures therefore determine the linear profile
Insulation is along the sides; the endpoint reservoirs can still exchange heat with the rod.
Transient solution. Subtract the steady profile before applying separation of variables: let . Then , and for . Writing gives
The homogeneous Dirichlet boundary conditions exclude and select the eigenfunctions with eigenvalues , . Their orthogonality gives the Fourier sine series coefficients
Here integration by parts uses . Thus
Every summand satisfies the heat equation and the homogeneous endpoint conditions, while the steady profile supplies the prescribed endpoint values. The initial Fourier sine series equals in the open interval. At the initially cold rod and the suddenly imposed hot endpoint are incompatible; the formula describes the prescribed data for and the initial limit at interior points.
Heat absorption. Integrating in kills the even modes. With , the total heat relative to the initial state is
Consequently the net rate of heat absorption is
For each , any fixed number of differentiated modes is bounded by a polynomial in times . These bounds have finite sums, proving absolute convergence, uniform convergence on such time intervals and the validity of the integration and differentiation. In particular the displayed rate is finite for every , positive when , and tends to zero as equilibrium is approached. The same answer follows from the heat equation balance ; this subtracts loss at the cold endpoint from input at the hot endpoint.
Multiplication by puts the eigenvalue problem into Sturm-Liouville form, , with weight . If correspond to distinct eigenvalues , subtract their multiplied equations and integrate to get
The upper boundary term vanishes by the Dirichlet boundary condition. For a bounded solution near zero, has a limit because is integrable. A nonzero limit would force a divergence in , so that limit is zero; integration then gives . The lower boundary term therefore also vanishes, proving the weighted orthogonality.
Set . For , , and finiteness of gives . Thus with zero values at zero and . The radial Dirichlet spectrum in three dimensions gives
The zero and negative eigenvalues yield only the zero solution under these boundary conditions. Also .
For the forced equation, the same substitution gives . The Fourier sine series of on has coefficients
Expanding gives , hence
The value at zero is defined by a limit. In fact , so uniform convergence holds even there, by comparison with . An independent check comes from solving the constant-coefficient equation directly:
It satisfies both endpoint conditions and the forcing for , and its finite origin limit agrees with the series. For the homogeneous boundary value problem has no nonzero solution, so the solution is unique.
Set in the heat equation. Separation of variables gives . Zero endpoint temperatures impose Dirichlet boundary conditions , selecting for . The separated factors can therefore be chosen as
Zero and negative separation eigenvalues give only the zero spatial solution under these boundary conditions.
The initial profile is continuous and triangular, with midpoint height . Its Fourier sine series coefficients are
Consequently the heat flow from a triangular initial temperature is
For , each summand has magnitude at most . The Weierstrass M-test proves absolute and uniform convergence. The initial Fourier sine series equals the continuous piecewise smooth profile, and for the exponential factors justify termwise spatial and time differentiation on every time interval bounded away from zero.
Figure 1.
Cooling of a bar with a triangular initial temperature profile
. Original normalized solution snapshots, with horizontal coordinate , temperature divided by its initial maximum , and time . Both endpoints remain at zero while the midpoint corner is smoothed. Details.
Write . A rotationally symmetric fundamental solution of the Laplace equation is harmonic for . The Laplace equation in polar coordinates reduces to , so . Integrate over a disk of radius around the source. The divergence theorem gives
Taking therefore gives
Changing the reference length inside the logarithm merely adds a constant. Notice the sign convention: the potential equation in this question is , whereas this Green function satisfies . Thus the point-source potential used below is .
For the two insulating walls, successive Euclidean reflections in and generate sources of strength at for every integer . Only lies inside the physical strip. This is the Neumann image lattice for a point source in a strip. Set
The raw sum of logarithmic potentials diverges by additive constants. A well-defined potential is obtained by pairing opposite images and subtracting their constant reference terms:
Each paired summand is on compact subsets away from the source. The series therefore has local uniform convergence, as do the required derivative series. It gives
In the corresponding -derivative, the images pair as and at , and as and at . Their opposite horizontal separations make the derivatives cancel. Thus both homogeneous Neumann boundary conditions hold. The constructed solution is even in ; without a condition at infinity the side conditions alone would allow further homogeneous harmonic functions.
For fixed , uniform convergence on permits integration term by term. The th term has integral
Here is the ordinary real inverse trigonometric function, taking values in . Summing from to makes a telescoping series:
The source flux splits equally between the upper and lower parts of the strip. The next two parts give the single-wall constructions that underlie the image lattice.
Figure 1.
Equal-sign image sources and the physical strip between two insulating boundaries
. Details.
For the usual piecewise smooth complex path , let denote its finite length. The estimation lemma gives
By uniform convergence, the supremum tends to zero, so
The uniform limit is continuous on the path, so its integral exists. This is uniform convergence and contour integration; the path length is fixed while the functions vary.
Fix any bounded disk avoiding the integers, and choose with on it. For sufficiently large , say and ,
The convergent numerical series and the Weierstrass M-test give absolute and uniform convergence of the tails. The finitely many remaining summands are holomorphic away from their integer poles. Thus the partial sums converge locally uniformly on .
By part (a)(iii), the sum is a holomorphic function on . The term is and is harmless on this domain; it must not be omitted.
First verify that is a vector space. Sums and scalar multiples preserve continuity and the condition at zero. For every partition of an interval , the triangle inequality and absolute homogeneity of a norm of the absolute value imply
Taking suprema yields
For the second equality follows directly from . In particular, finite variation is preserved, so is closed under these operations.
Nonnegativity is immediate. For any , use the partition of an interval , omitting repeated endpoints if necessary, to get
Thus forces , and conversely has zero total variation of a function. These observations prove that is a norm on .
Applying the same bound to gives
Therefore convergence in the anchored variation norm implies uniform convergence on . The anchoring condition removes the nonzero constant functions which otherwise have zero total variation of a function.
Truncate the Chebyshev series at the full degree of precision of a quadrature rule:
Since on , the geometric series estimate gives
The same bound proves uniform convergence of the original Chebyshev series, so its sum and the tail estimate are justified. Gauss-Legendre quadrature is exact on . Its positive quadrature weights sum to , hence
Therefore one explicit choice proving exponential convergence of Gaussian quadrature is
Using exactness through polynomial degree doubles the exponent compared with truncating at polynomial degree .