Put . Changing the sign of translates the potential by without changing its energy eigenvalues, so take a minimum at and expand there. The parabolic approximation givesThe low-lying wavefunctions are localized well inside one period. A local gauge transformation removes from their quantum harmonic oscillator equation, givingConsequently,The sketch consists of two nearly horizontal branches, separated by this gap, as in the right panel above. The parabolic approximation makes them completely independent of magnetic flux; in the actual ring they retain exponentially small periodic dependence through quantum tunnelling around the ring. Corrections from the nonquadratic part of the potential shift the mean energies and gap by relative order , whereas the tunnelling dependence is smaller than every power of that parameter.
In the normalized plane wave basis, the only nonzero potential matrix elements areThus a useful small parameter is , which suppresses admixture of well-separated energy levels. First-order nondegenerate perturbation theory further requires for the coupled states. This latter condition fails near a half-integer even for very small ; there one must use degenerate perturbation theory in the nearly degenerate pair. Smallness is measured against the gaps to the other states, not the vanishing gap inside this pair.
Near , keep . The resulting Hamiltonian operator matrix and its eigenvalues areIn particular,For positive , the lower quantum state at the crossing is the symmetric combination of , and the upper state is the antisymmetric combination. A negative exchanges these combinations but leaves the ordered energy eigenvalues unchanged.
This cosine-potential gap in a quantum ring appears in the middle panel above: each lowest-branch crossing opens into an avoided crossing of gap to first order. Away from these crossings, the diagonal matrix elements vanish, so the leading shifts are second order. At integer , the two first-excited plane waves differ by two units of and therefore have no first-order coupling; their smaller splitting begins at second order. The numerical plot includes that splitting.
For the magnetic flux spectrum of a quantum ring, the periodic boundary condition permits the normalized plane waves , with . Their energy eigenvalues areShifting by an integer relabels , so the ordered energy levels have period one in , or in . For , the lowest two areextended periodically. The lowest branches cross at every half-integer , with energy . At integer , the first excited energy level has multiplicity two. The corresponding magnetic flux period is the electron magnetic flux quantum .
Define a transformed wavefunction byIndeed, writing givesThis is the electromagnetic gauge transformation generated by : and . The transformed Hamiltonian operator is consequently , but the original periodic boundary condition becomes the twisted boundary conditionFor the domain of the self-adjoint kinetic Hamiltonian operator, the derivative has the same twist, . Thus the magnetic flux has moved into the boundary condition. The transformation is a single-valued gauge on periodic representatives only when is an integer multiple of ; otherwise it is understood on the cut interval with the displayed identification of its endpoints.
Past exam of the advanced quantum physics course of the University of Cambridge 2022 Section B 4 a Solution Created 2026-10-18 Updated 2026-10-20
Let the electric charge be , where is the elementary charge. Minimal coupling to a tangential magnetic vector potential givesA constant tangential magnetic vector potential is an available gauge on the ring, so . By Stokes theorem, its circulation is the oriented magnetic fluxThe orientation matters here. In the original diagram, increasing goes anticlockwise, whose associated positive normal points out of the page, whereas the indicated positive magnetic flux points into the page. Hence for that diagram, and its convention gives . If instead is defined with the normal associated to , the relation is .
There is no requirement that the magnetic field be nonzero on the ring: it can be confined to a solenoid inside it. The nonzero circulation of the magnetic vector potential still affects the electron through the Aharonov-Bohm effect.
For distinguishable particles, the ordered spatial products are independent states, and neither singlet states nor triplet states are excluded from any orbital occupation. The unperturbed energy eigenvalues areFor , the three lowest distinct energy levels arewhere . The first two levels do have zero first-order correction, since their spatial expectation value factorizes as .
The last instruction in the original PDF is false for the third level. Although every diagonal product-state matrix element vanishes, the two orbital states have degenerate energy levels. Degenerate perturbation theory requires diagonalizing the perturbation within their span. For each , its matrix in the ordered basis isThe eigenfunctions are , withThus the sixfold unperturbed level splits into two triplets. Its average shift is zero, and the diagonal expectation in an individual ordered product state is zero, but neither fact makes all its energy eigenvalue corrections zero. This is the degenerate orbital exchange splitting from a product perturbation; distinguishability allows both combinations rather than removing their coupling.
For negative , the lowest two rows exchange order and the third unperturbed level is instead the twofold singlet orbital pair at . It splits into with the same shifts , each nondegenerate. At , the three lowest distinct unperturbed energies are , with multiplicities . The first and third have zero first-order shift; the middle splits by , each fourfold. The printed zero-shift assertion therefore fails also in the zero-exchange limit.
Each one-particle energy eigenstate has definite parity about the centre of the well, so . Consequently, a doubly occupied orbital has . For distinct orbitals, the two off-diagonal exchange terms instead survive:The position matrix elements in a symmetric infinite square well, with the present width , giveThe sign of depends on the orbital phase convention, while does not. The perturbation acts only on the spatial part and cannot mix orthogonal singlet states and triplet states. Within a triplet it is proportional to the identity on the spin factor. Thus first-order nondegenerate perturbation theory, with this trivial diagonal treatment of spin degeneracy, gives the shifts corresponding to the three rows in part (b):These formulae also apply for , with the reordered levels described above. At , they resolve the fourfold level into a shifted triplet and singlet. The next doubly occupied orbital still has zero first-order shift. The perturbative requirement is for mixing with remote orbital states; the spin-independent perturbation does not require division by the small singlet–triplet gap.
LetThe normalized orbital energy eigenstates vanish outside the well and have one-particle energies . Define the normalized symmetric and antisymmetric combinations for byThe normalized spin functions are the singlet state and the triplet states , , . Their exchange energies are respectively and .
For , the three lowest distinct energy levels of the exchange-coupled spin-one-half particles in an infinite square well areThe spatially doubly occupied orbital can only occur with the singlet state. The next orbital sum is , where either exchange symmetry is possible. The next unused sum is , well separated under the small-coupling assumption. The paper's inequality is equivalent, up to a numerical factor, to ; the factor in is essential because the spin operators carry units of angular momentum.
The sign of is not explicitly specified. The table assumes the usual intended positive coupling in the displayed minus-sign convention. For with , the same three sets of eigenfunctions occur, but the two rows at exchange order. At those rows merge into a single energy level of multiplicity four; if three distinct energies are requested exactly at that point, the third is with the single state .
Inside the infinite square well, the orbital and spin operators act on different factors of the tensor product. Write . The identityshows that the exchange interaction commutes with and . The sum of the one-particle kinetic energies also commutes with them and with particle exchange. Thus one may use orbital quantum numbers together with the total-spin sector and projection , with physical .
For identical spin one-half particles the Pauli exclusion principle further restricts the states. The spin-one-half singlet state is antisymmetric in spin and must multiply a symmetric spatial wavefunction; a spin-one-half triplet state must multiply an antisymmetric spatial wavefunction. Thus label unordered orbital occupations in symmetry-adapted states, not arbitrary ordered product states. This gives the labels , with the paper's last label expressed in units of .
For , isolate the terms proportional to in the previous answer. Their coefficient isHence the driven electric dipole moment component isFor , away from the instantaneous switch, the radiation electric field isThus the dynamic electric polarizability isBelow resonance the driven electric dipole moment is in phase with the electric field; above resonance its sign reverses. The same susceptibility follows from the classical Lorentz oscillator model without damping. At exact resonance the separation into bounded driven and transient terms fails: their apparent poles combine into the finite-time secular term identified in part (c). Without damping there is no bounded steady resonant response, and the first-order state expansion eventually ceases to apply.
The only relevant position matrix element is . To first order in the radiation amplitude, the two ground–excited-state cross terms giveMultiplying by the charge gives the induced electric dipole moment. Since , the coefficient derived in part (b) yieldsat linear order. Taking the complex conjugate inside the real part of the second term changes it to minus the same term with and reversed frequency signs. ThusThe terms at are switch-on transients, while those at describe the driven response. Both are needed to make . The expression is understood by continuity at ; the first quotient then tends to , producing resonant secular growth rather than an infinite dipole at a finite time.
There is also an initial-velocity check on this harmonic-oscillator dipole response to switched radiation. The formula gives . Because the magnetic vector potential jumps at zero time, its time derivative contains an impulsive electric field. Equivalently, the mechanical velocity is , whose initial mean is . The transient therefore implements the specified switch-on correctly.
For the requested oscillator response, treat as the fixed transverse position of a one-dimensional quantum harmonic oscillator along , and put . The supplied radiation is transverse and already satisfies the Coulomb gauge. Its perturbation isThe annihilation operator and creation operator giveThus the only first-order transition out of the ground state is to . More generally, the oscillator electric-dipole selection rule is . This is a rule for matrix elements; exact energy conservation is replaced by a finite-time resonance profile during a switched finite-duration interaction.
To display both the resonant and nonresonant terms without spurious singularities, defineThe interaction picture coefficient in the given expansion is thenThe full Schrödinger picture coefficient of is , while that of is at this order. The normalization changes only at order . In particular, at the first term is , finite for every finite time, and the perturbative result requires .
The fixed- interpretation is needed for the displayed target formulae. If were instead a three-dimensional kinetic operator with no transverse confinement, that model would have no normalizable transverse ground state, and would transfer transverse momentum . A treatment of that different model needs specified transverse states and recoil energies; they are absent from the question. The following parts use the intended localized-oscillator response.
The components of the momentum operator do not generally commute with a position-dependent magnetic vector potential. Expanding minimal coupling with the ordering intact givesActing on a wavefunction shows that . In the Coulomb gauge the divergence vanishes, so the two cross terms agree. Discarding the quadratic term in the weak radiation amplitude givesThe equality of the two operator orderings follows from the gauge condition, not from treating and as commuting numbers component by component.
At resonance, retain the signed coupling . In the interaction picture, the given solution reduces to and . Returning to the Schrödinger picture givesFor a normalized spinor , the Pauli matrices give . Therefore the spin expectation value within the rotating-wave approximation isIts magnitude is : the Bloch vector stays on the unit sphere. In a frame rotating about at angular velocity , it makes a uniform rotation in the plane. For , this gives slow Rabi oscillations between the poles, accompanied by rapid laboratory Larmor precession about .
If the same formula is formally used for , it predicts fast meridional rotations whose plane turns slowly about . However, the original PDF really does ask for this opposite limit, and it lies outside the assumption used in part (b). That formal description is not a controlled prediction for the stated linearly driven Hamiltonian operator.
A valid strong-drive description starts from the exact equation for the Bloch vector :For times , neglecting the weak bias gives a controlled leading approximation, since the time integral of the omitted Hamiltonian operator has small norm. The remaining field has a fixed axis, so its generators commute at different times andAt the nominal resonance and on the early spin-rotation scale , this becomes . The initial rotation rate is consequently , twice the rate predicted by extrapolating the rotating-wave approximation. For longer times the exact differential equation must be retained. The following original calculation illustrates both regimes rather than asserting an exact strong-drive Rabi formula.
With , the Born rule applied to the supplied down-spin probability amplitude givesFor nonzero transverse field, the maxima occur atThe first maximum is reached at ; on resonance this is a Rabi pi pulse. The resonance envelope of a Rabi transition is a Lorentzian line shape, centred on under the orientation convention above. It has half its peak value at , so its full width at half maximum isIf resonance width is instead defined as the half-width, the ratio differs by a factor of two but has the same requested proportionality. The quality factor is large precisely in the regime where the rotating-wave approximation is justified. The envelope is obtained by choosing the best time separately at each drive frequency; a measurement at one fixed pulse duration has a different line profile.
Maximum spin-flip probability versus drive detuning
. Original rotating-wave approximation envelope, with the two half-height detunings marked. The maximum is over interaction time independently at each drive frequency. Details.Write and use the ordered spin basis . The free Hamiltonian operator is , soResolving the cosine into its two complex exponentials gives the exact upper off-diagonal factorwith the complex conjugate in the lower entry. Choose the field orientation with , as implicit in the printed near-resonance condition, and put . The rotating-wave approximation discards the terms at , retaining the slow terms at . The resulting interaction picture equations areThe factor contains from and from the cosine decomposition. This is a Driven two-level Rabi model, with signed on-resonance coupling and generalized Rabi angular frequency . Here the Rabi detuning uses the paper's convention, drive minus free frequency.
Small detuning alone is insufficient to derive the printed equations. One also requires , and an evolution time over which neglected terms stay small. At resonance this is the weak transverse-field regime . The supplied solution is thus an approximate solution for the linearly oscillating field, not an exact one at arbitrary drive strength. If , the other exponential is resonant and the physical positive resonance frequency is .
Start with the Schrödinger equation and differentiate the definition of the interaction picture state:The free Hamiltonian operator terms cancel because commutes with its own matrix exponential. ThereforeThis interaction picture transformation is exact.
Neglect hyperfine structure and use the electronic weak-field Zeeman splitting regime, where is small compared with the spin-orbit interaction splitting. The sodium levels are , and . The Landé g-factor formula givesFor example, inserting gives . Each sublevel with magnetic quantum number shifts by . Thus the lower level has shifts , the upper level has shifts , and the upper level has shifts and .
The electric-dipole selection rule allows except , and . Both fine structure branches are allowed. The emitted photon energy isAll the allowed components of the sodium D-line Zeeman pattern are listed below; the last column is the photon shift in units of :These are four components of D1 and six of D2. Their strengths need not be equal; the table and arrows specify allowed transitions, not intensities.
The level lies above , so D2 has the larger zero-field photon energy. [ref]
https://physics.nist.gov/PhysRefData/Handbook/Tables/sodiumtable5.htm. NIST, Energy levels of Neutral Sodium, 3p fine-structure ordering
In the stated weak-field regime its most positive shift is . Since , the shortest wavelength is therefore produced byThe tempting pair has a larger difference of level shifts but is forbidden because .For a bound energy eigenstate with a nondegenerate energy eigenvalue of an even one-dimensional potential, the wavefunction can be chosen with definite parity. A uniform electric field gives the electric-dipole interaction , which is odd under reflection. Hencesince is odd. Second-order nondegenerate perturbation theory then gives the leading allowed Stark effect shift:Only opposite-parity intermediate states have nonzero position matrix elements. More generally, reflection maps to , so an analytic nondegenerate energy level is an even function of the field. This explains the absence of all odd orders and the usual quadratic Stark effect.
A level separation changes by the difference of the two quadratic coefficients. Symmetry alone does not guarantee a nonzero differential shift: in a displaced quantum harmonic oscillator every level moves by the same , leaving every spacing unchanged. Degenerate states would instead require degenerate perturbation theory and can split linearly; the nondegeneracy of one-dimensional bound states applies to ordinary isolated well levels.
Use for a product of the two individual spin-one spin eigenstates, with magnetic quantum numbers . Total requires , leaving preciselyHere these are product labels, not labels of the total angular momentum. Write their coefficients in this order as . With physical spin ladder operators , each nonzero individual step has amplitude , soBoth must vanish for a singlet state. The independent product states therefore require . Wavefunction normalization gives the spin-one singlet stateup to an overall quantum phase. Conversely, implies through , so these conditions really select total spin zero. Distinguishability imposes no additional exchange restriction. The ladder hint uses dimensionless angular momentum units; restoring its common factor does not change the coefficient ratios.
There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.



