In polar coordinates,
With the change of radial coordinate , the detection functional becomes
It is therefore times ordinary path length in the -plane. The shortest path is the line segment from to , so
Returning to gives the logarithmic spiral
Its minimum detection probability is
The functional depends only on the geometric path and not its parametrization, so tiptoeing and running give the same probability.
For the improved sensor, omit the irrelevant positive factor and use the Lagrangian
The coordinate is cyclic, so its conjugate momentum is conserved. Equivalently,
is constant. Because has no explicit time dependence, the associated conservation of energy gives the constant
Multiplying by and using gives the required equation
Let each mass be and each spring constant be , with the denoting longitudinal displacements from equilibrium. The Lagrangian is
The inverse coordinate transformation is
Substitution gives
Thus the Euler-Lagrange equations separate into a symmetric pair,
and an antisymmetric pair,
The symmetric normal modes are:
  • , corresponding to and the translational frequency
  • , corresponding to and
For antisymmetric modes, the squared dimensionless frequencies are the eigenvalues of
namely . They give
and
In the original coordinates their mode shapes are respectively
and
The coordinates and are cyclic, so their canonical momenta are conserved:
Because the Lagrangian has no explicit time dependence, the conserved energy is
These are the three integrals of motion requested.
If is measured in the rotating frame, its inertial velocity is . The masses producing the gravitational field are stationary in this frame, so their potential energy is a time-independent function . Thus kinetic minus potential energy gives the stated Lagrangian
Put . Then
Substitution in the Euler-Lagrange equation yields
The extra terms are the Coriolis acceleration, Euler acceleration, and centrifugal acceleration of a rotating reference frame.
The canonical momentum and Hamiltonian are
Accordingly, Hamilton's equations are
For a regular Lagrangian, define the canonical momentum and invert this relation for . Its Legendre transform is the Hamiltonian
Since , the action is
For independent variations with ,
Stationarity for arbitrary and gives Hamilton's equations and .
The kinetic energy of the two equal masses is
The extensions of the left, coupling, and right springs are respectively , , and . Their potential energy is therefore
Thus the mechanical Lagrangian has the requested quadratic form with the symmetric small-oscillation mass and stiffness matrices
For the equality constraint, the Lagrangian and dual function are
and the Lagrangian dual problem is . Weak duality says for every . Strong duality means the dual supremum equals the primal infimum, usually with a dual maximizer. A sufficient convex constraint qualification is that be proper, closed and convex and that some satisfy .
The functional derivative of the action is
For the Hamiltonian function
and a time-independent Lagrangian,
Therefore
The gravitational three-body Lagrangian is
Put and . Solving the definitions of the Jacobi coordinates for three particles gives
Substitution into the kinetic energy makes all cross terms cancel:
where
The pair separations are
Hence the gravitational potential energy is
which is independent of . Thus is an ignorable coordinate and
The center of mass moves uniformly because the isolated system has no external force.
Finally, substituting the inverse coordinate transformation into
again cancels every cross term and yields
This is the angular momentum decomposition in three-body Jacobi coordinates.
Taking downward distance as positive, the Lagrangian is
At equilibrium the lower spring supports only the lower mass, while the upper spring supports both masses:
Hence
Let . The linear terms cancel by the equilibrium equations, and the quadratic Lagrangian is
with the small-oscillation mass and stiffness matrices
The generalized eigenvalue problem for small oscillations is
Its characteristic equation is
so
Corresponding displacement eigenvectors are
They are not orthogonal in the ordinary Euclidean inner product. They are orthogonal in the kinetic-energy, or mass-matrix, inner product:
This is mass-matrix orthogonality of normal modes.
For a general Lagrangian,
Along an Euler-Lagrange trajectory,
so energy is conserved when has no explicit time dependence.
For the given Lagrangian, write . At points where ,
The Euler-Lagrange equation is therefore
In expanded form its left-hand side is
The momentum has fixed magnitude,
so this is constant without needing to solve the equation of motion. The Hamiltonian is
The singular Legendre transform of a degree-one velocity Lagrangian applies here: determines only the direction of , not its magnitude, and the velocity Hessian is not invertible. Thus the usual inverse Legendre transform cannot reconstruct the Lagrangian from this Hamiltonian.
The objective is strictly convex, so the minimizer is unique. The Slater condition makes the Karush-Kuhn-Tucker conditions necessary and sufficient. Absorb the box constraints into the Euclidean projection onto a convex set and attach a scalar multiplier to . Stationarity over the box is equivalent to
while primal feasibility requires . Coordinatewise, these conditions are
They are also sufficient because they minimize the Lagrangian over the box and satisfy the equality constraint. Thus the projection onto a box-constrained hyperplane reduces to solving the displayed one-dimensional continuous, nonincreasing equation for . The multiplier need not be unique on a flat interval, but the projected vector is unique.
The area element is , so
For the Lagrangian , stationarity under every compactly supported variation gives the Euler-Lagrange equation
Multiplication by expands this into
recovering part (d).
Let be the angle from the downward vertical to the hoop's centre, measured at the suspension point, and let be the absolute angle from the downward vertical to the bead's radius from the hoop centre. The bead position is the sum of two vectors of length . Including the hoop's moment of inertia about the pivot gives
while
Thus one suitable Lagrangian is
Let and . Since
the Lagrangian depends on only through and , and on the velocity through . Rotations about the -axis preserve all three quantities, proving the invariance.
The axially symmetric isotropic-mass Lagrangian therefore conserves the axial angular momentum
up to an irrelevant normalization of . Since has no explicit time dependence, conservation of energy from time-translation invariance gives the second conserved quantity
Write . The geodesic Lagrangian is
Its equation is
Spherical symmetry lets us rotate the conserved angular-momentum plane into . Equivalently, initial data , solve this equation for all .
The cyclic coordinates give
Using the timelike normalization gives
After separating the constant terms,
The Lagrangian is
Writing , the center of mass is
All internal forces cancel, so and
If the molecule is released from rest, the middle term vanishes.
Fermat’s principle makes stationary. Writing the ray as gives a Lagrangian independent of , and its first integral is . At the origin . At , , so and the forward angle is .
For small oscillations with quadratic kinetic and potential energies, a normal mode has a fixed spatial amplitude pattern and one angular normal frequency. Its amplitude is a normal coordinate; choosing all modes diagonalizes the two quadratic forms and decouples their equations. A zero frequency describes a free symmetry motion.
Let be the small signed arc displacements, with cyclic indices . The springs follow arcs, so their extensions are . The Lagrangian of the normal modes of a four-bead spring ring is
The stiffness matrix divided by is the cycle graph Laplacian, with diagonal entries two, adjacent entries minus one, and zero opposite entries. An orthonormal basis of mode vectors and their frequencies is
The normal mode coordinates are , with equations . The zero mode rotates all beads together without stretching a spring and has . In each of the two degenerate middle modes, opposite beads have opposite signed arc displacements while the other pair remains stationary. Any fixed linear combination is another mode of that frequency. The last mode alternates the signed displacement of adjacent beads. The radius cancels from the frequencies because arc length supplies the same factor to the angular kinetic and spring energies.
Figure 1.
Tangential displacement patterns of the four normal modes of a spring ring
. Original mode diagrams, with arrows showing signed arc displacements in an arbitrary common scale. Filled beads move in the displayed phase; hollow beads have zero displacement. The two middle patterns have the same frequency. Details.
Take a variation with . Differentiating the functional at zero and using integration by parts gives
The boundary term vanishes. Since the remaining integral must vanish for every smooth endpoint-zero variation, the fundamental lemma of the calculus of variations gives the Euler-Lagrange equation .
For the mechanical problem put . The Lagrangian is independent of , a cyclic coordinate, so its conjugate momentum is conserved. Therefore is constant, including the factor of two between and the canonical momentum for this normalization of .
For the radial coordinate, and . Its Euler-Lagrange equation is
For a circular orbit , the radial velocity and acceleration vanish. Using and leaves , hence
This is the circular orbit condition for a radial kinetic Lagrangian applied to the coefficients here.