Artin automorphism of a braid Created 2026-10-14 Updated 2026-11-05
A positive elementary braid acts on the free group of punctured-disk meridians by the displayed substitution, fixing other generators. The inverse sends to and to . Applying Seifert-van Kampen theorem at the crossings and closing the braid gives the knot-complement presentation .
In the standard free basis of a group for the fundamental group of a once-punctured torus, its oriented boundary loop represents up to orientation and conjugation. The square model proves this: radial deformation retraction takes the inner boundary once around the four sides, whose orientations read . Attaching a simply connected space along that boundary kills the normal closure of the commutator of group elements, whenever the hypotheses of the Seifert-van Kampen theorem hold.
Every finitely presented group is the fundamental group of a closed connected smooth manifold in dimension at least four. Build a compact zero/one/two-handle manifold with the generators and relators of the presentation. Disjoint attaching loops can be embedded in its boundary of dimension at least three. The Seifert-van Kampen theorem gives , and the dual relative handle structure makes surjective. Doubling along its boundary gives the amalgam of two copies of along that same surjection, which is again . This construction underlies binary families of nonhomeomorphic Sunada quotients.
Four-manifold realization of finitely presented groups Created 2026-10-07 Updated 2026-10-14
Every finitely presented group is the fundamental group of a closed connected smooth oriented four-manifold. Build a compact four-dimensional handle decomposition with one zero-handle, a one-handle for each generator of a group and a two-handle for each relator. Turning the handle decomposition upside down shows that its boundary surjects on the fundamental group. Its double of a manifold has the same fundamental group by the Seifert-van Kampen theorem.
The fundamental group of a bouquet of circles is the free group on generators, represented by the oriented circles. For finite , iterated Seifert-van Kampen theorem proves the claim by attaching one circle at a time. Nontrivial reduced words in a free group distinguish based loops, while free homotopy classes correspond to conjugacy classes.
Attach a closed interval to a sphere at two distinct endpoints, with its interior disjoint from the sphere. The fundamental group is infinite cyclic group. Remove a point of the sphere away from the endpoints: the remaining plane has a deformation retraction onto an arc between the endpoints, keeping the added closed interval fixed. This gives a circle. An open cap about the removed point is simply connected, and its punctured overlap has trivial map into the first fundamental group because it lies in the plane. The Seifert-van Kampen theorem therefore adds no further relator.
To form the connected sum of knots , remove a short unknotted arc from each oriented knot in two disjoint balls and join the remaining endpoints by a pair of parallel arcs respecting the orientations. Equivalently, a sphere meeting a knot in two points cuts it into two one-string tangles; close each by an arc in the sphere to recover its summands. Sliding the small joining balls along the knots shows that the isotopy type does not depend on these choices. The unknot is the identity for this operation. A prime knot is a nontrivial knot such that every expression has an unknot summand.
We first prove additivity of Seifert genus, which also supplies a terminating measure for decomposition. Joining minimal Seifert surfaces along their boundary arcs gives . For the reverse inequality, let be a minimal-genus Seifert surface for the sum and a splitting sphere of a knot. Arrange transverse intersection so that consists of one arc joining the two boundary-intersection points and some circles, with the number of circles minimal among genus-minimizing surfaces.
Each circle separates the sphere into two disks; since it is disjoint from the intersection arc, one disk contains neither marked endpoint. Choose an innermost such circle and its disk , whose interior misses . If its boundary were essential in , compressing along would lower the genus of its component with boundary K: for a nonseparating curve genus drops by one, and for a separating essential curve the removed boundaryless side has positive genus. This contradicts minimal genus. Its boundary therefore bounds a disk in . Replace that disk by a small push-off of , removing the intersection circle without changing genus or boundary, again contradicting minimal intersection. Thus no circles remain.
Cutting along its single intersection arc gives two connected surfaces with boundaries the two summand knots after the closing arcs are added. Euler characteristic shows that their genera add to . Each genus is at least the minimum genus of its summand, so
Genus zero means that the knot bounds a disk and is the unknot. Every nontrivial knot therefore has positive genus. Induct on this nonnegative integer: a nontrivial nonprime knot splits into two nontrivial summands, each with strictly smaller genus by the equality above, and induction decomposes both into primes. This proves every knot is a finite connected sum of prime knots, with the unknot the empty sum. Uniqueness is not needed here.
For coprime integers p,q, define the torus knot as the oriented parametrized curve
Coprimality makes it an embedded single circle: two parameters with both coordinate phases equal differ by a multiple of . It lies on the standard unknotted torus separating the two solid tori. Negative exponents change the slope/orientation convention; they are allowed. If an exponent is zero, coprimality forces the other to be plus or minus one, giving an unknot.
Assume now . We give a group-theoretic proof that torus knots are prime, making the peripheral ingredient explicit. The Seifert-van Kampen theorem applied to the two solid-torus sides of the exterior, joined along the annulus parallel to the knot, gives
Here a and b are the two core loops. The element is central. Under the abelianization , choose , ; these generate the target because p,q are coprime. Thus , so z is nontrivial. A meridian has, up to conjugacy, the form with . This follows by tracing the meridional disk across the two torus sides, using a dual primitive slope intersecting the knot slope once. Different Bezout solutions change u by a multiple of p and v by the opposite multiple of q, leaving the same word because z is central.
Quotienting by z gives . Neither u nor v is zero modulo the corresponding cyclic order, by . Hence the image of m is a cyclically reduced word of two syllables. All its nonzero powers remain reduced, so it has infinite order. In particular G is nonabelian and the knot is not an unknot.
We use the Loop theorem in its usual form: a noninjective boundary fundamental-group map of a three-manifold supplies an embedded compression disk. For a nontrivial knot, its boundary torus is incompressible. To see why, every sphere in its exterior bounds a ball on the side not containing the knot, by the Schoenflies theorem. A compression of the boundary torus would produce a sphere and make the exterior a solid torus. The compression disk has zero homology class in the exterior, so its boundary is the preferred longitude; attaching the annulus from that longitude to the knot gives a spanning disk and an unknot. This proves that nontrivial knot exteriors have incompressible boundary. Their peripheral groups inject as , so their groups strictly contain the cyclic meridian subgroup.
If the torus knot were a connected sum of two nontrivial knots, van Kampen on the decomposing annulus would give , with the meridian subgroup proper in each factor. The center of a proper amalgam lies in the amalgamated subgroup. One proof uses its Bass-Serre tree: a central elliptic element fixes a vertex orbit and its convex hull, which is the whole tree; a central translation would force the minimal tree to be its invariant axis, but a nontrivial vertex reflection reverses that translation. Thus a central element fixes every edge and lies in the edge subgroup.
The central element z would therefore equal . Its image in would give , forcing because that image has infinite order. This contradicts . Consequently
The Sunada theorem is the following. Let be a finite normal Riemannian covering of a connected closed Riemannian manifold, with finite deck transformation group . If satisfy Gassmann equivalence, meaning
then and have the same scalar Laplacian spectrum, with multiplicities. Equivalently, an epimorphism yields isospectral covers corresponding to the inverse images of .
Here is the representation-theoretic proof. Every finite-dimensional Laplacian eigenspace of is a group representation of , since isometries commute with the Laplace-Beltrami operator. Eigenfunctions on identify with . Averaging gives the projection , so
The two subgroup orders agree, and the character of a representation is constant on conjugacy classes. The displayed multiplicities are therefore equal for every . This proof also applies when has fixed points on , provided the two subgroups act freely, so their quotients are smooth manifolds. We shall use this extension for an orbifold base in Question 4.
The precise geometric test for an isometry uses the full isometry group of a common universal cover. Equip the simply connected cover of with the lifted metric and let be the subgroups of its deck transformation group corresponding to the two covers. Then
Indeed, such an descends to an isometry of the quotients. Conversely an isometry of the quotients lifts to their simply connected covers; lift its inverse with compatible basepoints to see that the lift is bijective. Since it preserves the lifted metrics locally, it is a global isometry, and equivariance of the covering maps shows that it conjugates the deck subgroups. This proves the criterion, rather than assuming that an isometry must preserve the map to . In particular, nonconjugacy inside alone does not establish nonisometry; the full covering space may have additional isometries. Nonisomorphic fundamental groups are a sufficient topological obstruction, and length-identified geometric configurations provide another.
For a concrete nonisomorphic Gassmann equivalent regular subgroups example, fix an odd prime and take . Embed and through their regular permutation actions. Both have order . Every nonidentity element of has order . For , write its elements as with ; then
over , including , so its nonidentity elements also have order . In a regular action, each nonidentity order- element has cycle type . Thus each subgroup meets the identity class in one element, the class of that cycle type in elements, and every other conjugacy class in zero elements. They are Gassmann equivalent. They are not isomorphic: is abelian, whereas the Heisenberg group has .
To obtain arbitrarily many examples in dimension five, choose distinct odd primes with . For each prime use the preceding pair . Set
A conjugacy class in a direct product is a product of conjugacy classes, and its intersection count with is the product of the individual counts. Thus all subgroups are Gassmann equivalent. They are pairwise nonisomorphic: the unique Sylow -subgroup of is abelian precisely when , and an abstract group isomorphism preserves this property at each prime.
We use the closed-manifold realization of a finitely presented fundamental group in dimension five. Its construction here is short. From a finite presentation of with generators, start with the connected sum of copies of . Its fundamental group is free on those generators. Represent the finitely many relators by disjoint embedded circles, which is possible by general position for curves in a manifold in dimension five. Their oriented normal bundles are trivial. Perform framed circle surgery, removing and inserting . The Seifert-van Kampen theorem shows that each surgery kills exactly the normal closure of the corresponding relator: the attaching circle bounds the new disk, and the new factor contributes no fundamental group. The resulting closed connected five-manifold has .
Choose any smooth Riemannian metric on and lift it to its universal cover . Since is finite, is a compact simply connected five-manifold on which acts freely and isometrically. The Sunada theorem makes all isospectral, while
shows that they are pairwise nonhomeomorphic, hence nonisometric. Taking any members proves for every positive integer , there are pairwise nonisometric closed five-manifolds with the same Laplacian spectrum.
We use . To obtain a Wirtinger presentation, choose an oriented regular knot diagram, cut its strands at undercrossings, and give each resulting arc a positively oriented meridian of a knot. The complement of the arcs above the projection plane has a free fundamental group on these meridians. At a crossing, pushing an understrand meridian past the overstrand conjugates it by the overstrand meridian. Thus, if is the overstrand generator and are the incoming and outgoing understrand generators, the relation is , where is determined by the crossing orientation. Applying the Seifert-van Kampen theorem while adjoining the crossing neighborhoods gives one such relation per crossing. The remaining three-dimensional region adds no fundamental-group relation. For a connected diagram one crossing relation is redundant. This derives a group presentation from any tame knot diagram, rather than just specifying a recipe without its topological justification.
For the Borromean rings, choose three meridians and call the other three arc meridians . Base paths and orientations can be chosen so the six crossing relations read
Eliminate the primed generators with the first row. The second row says respectively that commutes with , that commutes with , and that commutes with . The last relation is redundant, just as one crossing relation is redundant in the Wirtinger presentation. Alternatively the Hall-Witt identity, after conjugating its three factors, shows that any two of these cyclic relations imply the third. Hence the Borromean link group is
Both relators have zero exponent sum in each generator. Passing from the free group to its abelianization therefore imposes no relations beyond commutation, and
Equivalently the three linking-number maps to independently detect the three meridians.
Here is an explicit representation, followed by a faithfulness argument:
Each determinant is one. Direct multiplication verifies the two relators. For example , which commutes with . Merely checking those relators would not prove faithfulness, so we identify the image's complete group presentation.
Write , the Gaussian Bianchi group, and use its four generators from the allowed presentation. In the three proposed generators are
The last equality is in , so an overall minus sign in matrix multiplication is immaterial. Reduce matrices modulo in , and then quotient by . The finite image has order : the residue field is , has order six, and each of the three subsequent local-ring layers has a kernel of order , before the final quotient by . Elementary elimination over this local ring shows that the images of generate it. The subgroup has order , as multiplication in this finite ring verifies. Let be its inverse image in ; then .
For completeness the following gives the coset computation needed to check the subgroup presentation explicitly. Cosets are right cosets ; columns record right multiplication by . Representatives are words in the allowed generators.
Apply the Reidemeister–Schreier theorem: for a transition , use generator , omitting the 23 tree transitions. Rewrite each of the eight allowed ambient relators starting at each of the 24 rows. There are 73 remaining Schreier generators. Adjoin the names , , and eliminate the Schreier generators using relations in which they occur once. The remaining relations, with an uppercase letter denoting the inverse of the corresponding lowercase one, are the words
This table and the rewriting rule determine every relation without an appeal to a guessed presentation. In this notation cyclically reduced versions of the two desired relators are and . Elementary substitutions of relator segments, with cyclic reduction at each step, give
using ; conversely using . These substitutions show equality of the two normal closures. For example the first substitution replaces in the cyclic rotation of by , as allowed by , and then the initial is replaced by using . Thus has exactly the presentation of , with represented by . In particular these three matrices generate , and
To identify the actual link complement as a hyperbolic three-manifold, rather than only on a manifold with an isomorphic group, cut along the projection-plane regions, making the usual small crossing detours above and below. The octahedral projection graph has eight triangular regions. The upper and lower pieces are ideal octahedra; corresponding faces are matched with one-third-turn corner permutations, with opposite directions on adjacent checkerboard faces. Reversing these cuts reconstructs the link complement. Give both pieces the regular ideal hyperbolic space octahedron metric. All triangular face maps are isometries and each edge cycle has four dihedral angles , so the metric has no edge singularity. Equal horospherical truncations match in Euclidean squares and assemble into three flat tori, giving complete torus cusps. The compact truncated remainder and these cusps show completeness and finite volume. Thus the Borromean complement is a complete finite-volume hyperbolic three-manifold. This also supplies a geometric discrete faithful holonomy, independently of the subgroup calculation.
The Loop theorem converts a nonzero kernel of , for a boundary surface , into a properly embedded compression disk. It is stronger than simply producing a singular nullhomotopy, and does not assert that every original self-intersecting loop is the boundary of the final disk.
The proof outline uses a strengthened version: keep the boundary class outside a prescribed normal subgroup . Begin with a singular disk in general position. Local cut-and-paste removes branch points; when a disk splits, at least one boundary stays outside , since otherwise their product would lie in . Take a regular neighborhood of its image and lift the disk through connected double covers of successive neighborhoods. Each lift decreases a finite lexicographic singularity complexity, so the tower terminates. At the top no double cover remains; mod-two duality forces its boundary components to be spheres. A boundary curve of the disk neighborhood lying outside the pulled-back then bounds an embedded disk on such a sphere, pushed inward. Project down one stage at a time. Exchange disk sectors along double curves, retaining a boundary outside , to remove the projection's double intersections. Repeating yields an embedded disk downstairs. Taking proves the Loop theorem; controlling a prescribed simple boundary gives Dehn's lemma. The key points are termination of the covering tower and preservation of an essential boundary during surgery, not an unjustified removal of all intersections by general position alone.
Two classification applications are particularly useful. First, a two-sided embedded surface is incompressible precisely when its inclusion is fundamental-group injective, with the usual exclusion of inessential sphere components. A compression disk immediately supplies a nontrivial kernel element. In the other direction, cut along the surface and use the Seifert-van Kampen theorem: if both boundary-copy maps were injective, the amalgamated-product or HNN normal-form theorem would make the original inclusion injective. Hence a nontrivial kernel appears on one cut side, and the Loop theorem produces a compression disk. This is what makes algebraically detected essential surfaces usable in three-manifold splitting and incompressible hierarchies.
Second, consider a compact orientable irreducible three-manifold with one torus boundary. If that boundary is not fundamental-group injective, the Loop theorem supplies a compression disk. An essential simple curve on a torus is nonseparating, so compression changes the torus into a sphere. Pushing this sphere into the manifold, irreducibility gives a ball on the side away from the original torus boundary; the region between the sphere and the torus is the compression neighborhood. Undoing compression therefore attaches one one-handle to a ball. This proves the solid-torus recognition by a compression disk criterion:
As a concrete consequence, a knot with knot group is the unknot. Its exterior is irreducible: a sphere disjoint from a connected knot bounds a ball on the side not containing the knot. The map from its boundary group to cannot be injective, so its exterior is a solid torus. The boundary of a meridian disk of this exterior lies in the kernel of the linking-number map; it is therefore the primitive preferred longitude. Joining that longitude to the knot through its tubular neighborhood makes an embedded spanning disk for the knot. This proves the cyclic-knot-group unknot criterion, rather than merely identifying a familiar consequence by name.
Let be a finite normal Riemannian covering, so acts freely by deck isometries. With any lifts of , the heat kernel on a finite isometric quotient satisfies
There is no factor in this kernel formula. Simultaneous invariance of under isometries proves independence of the lifts, by reindexing . Each term solves the lifted heat equation. If is a fundamental domain and a function on , the integral of the right side against over equals
because the translates tile up to sets of measure zero. This converges to as , proving the initial condition. Uniqueness of the heat equation solution on the closed manifold gives the formula. For a noncompact finite cover, use the minimal heat kernels, or compatible Friedrichs heat realizations. The normalized pullback is unitary onto the deck-invariant subspace and preserves the Dirichlet energy, so it intertwines the heat semigroups and yields the same kernel formula. No uniqueness of unrestricted noncompact heat-equation solutions is needed.
Set for an isometry . Diagonal integration and the covering degree give
Unlike the kernel formula, the trace formula has an averaging factor: integration of a quotient function over is times integration over .
Suppose now , with any larger group of isometries of the closed manifold . Change variables and use simultaneous heat-kernel invariance to obtain
Thus is a class function, and the Sunada orbital heat-trace formula can be grouped by conjugacy classes of :
Only classes meeting the finite subgroup contribute, so this class sum is finite even if the larger isometry group is infinite.
For finite , Gassmann equivalence means for every conjugacy class. Summing these counts gives , so the displayed formula gives identical heat traces. Their spectra, with multiplicities, agree: as , the constant limit identifies the multiplicity of zero; after subtracting it, the slowest-decaying exponential identifies the least positive eigenvalue and its multiplicity. Repeating determines every subsequent eigenvalue. This proves the Sunada theorem in the stated covering situation.
There is an important convention when the universal cover has an infinite deck group . For compact quotient manifolds, the subgroups must have finite index; the appropriate generalized Gassmann condition is equality of the characters of the finite coset permutation representations, not equality of possibly infinite cardinalities of conjugacy-class intersections. Let be the intersection of the two subgroup cores. Each core is the kernel of the corresponding finite coset action, so is normal and of finite index in , and . The manifold is then a compact finite normal cover of . The finite group acts on , and have equal coset permutation characters in . For a finite group, the fixed-coset count is
Equality at the identity gives equal subgroup orders, and then equality for all gives almost-conjugacy. Applying the proved finite theorem to establishes isospectrality also in this finite-index interpretation. It avoids taking the divergent heat trace of a noncompact universal cover.
To realize a finitely presented group , begin with the closed smooth four-manifold , whose fundamental group is free on the . Represent the relator words by disjoint smoothly embedded circles; general position permits this in dimension four, including separating self-intersections of representatives. Their oriented normal rank-three bundles are trivial, so perform framed surgeries replacing by . Removing the circles' tubular neighborhoods leaves the fundamental group unchanged, by codimension-three general position. The Seifert-van Kampen theorem shows that each replacement kills exactly the normal closure of its relator. The resulting closed smooth has . This gives a concrete closed-manifold realization of a finitely presented fundamental group. Equip it with any smooth Riemannian metric and lift that metric to the universal and intermediate covers; all covering maps become local isometries.
To ensure nonisometry, one must choose nonconjugate subgroups. If , or they are conjugate, the quotients are isometric for every lifted metric, so Gassmann equivalence alone cannot imply nonisometry. For nonconjugate subgroups, choose the base metric to have no nonidentity local isometry between open sets, using the Sunada local isometry lemma in dimension at least two. If were an isometry, a local inverse of the first covering followed by and the second covering would be a local isometry of , hence the identity. Thus the covering maps satisfy everywhere. Classification of connected covers then forces to be conjugate in , a contradiction. Therefore nonconjugate almost-conjugate subgroups and a locally rigid base metric give isospectral nonisometric quotients.
The Seifert-van Kampen theorem states that if a space is covered by path-connected open sets with path-connected intersection containing a basepoint, then its fundamental group is the free product modulo the normal subgroup generated by identifying the two images of each loop in . More generally it is the corresponding pushout of groups.
A wedge of two circles has fundamental group , the free group on their two loops: apply the theorem to thickened circle neighborhoods whose intersection is contractible and use . Represent the torus by a square with opposite edges identified. Remove an interior disk; the remainder deformation retracts onto this wedge. Replacing the disk attaches a two-cell whose boundary follows . A disk neighborhood and the punctured torus have annular intersection, and van Kampen kills precisely that boundary loop. Hence
A torus with a point removed retracts to a torus with a small open disk removed, and then to the same wedge. Thus
For the connected sum, remove a disk from each torus and glue their boundary circles with reversed orientations. The two pieces have free groups and and their overlap is an annulus. Its boundary generators correspond to and , where . Therefore
The boundary relation is essential: this group is neither the free group on four generators nor the abelian group .
The sphere in is nonseparating: its complement is , which is connected. A sphere bounding a ball separates, so this product is not an irreducible three-manifold.
To show it is prime, suppose a separating sphere cuts it into compact pieces with one spherical boundary each. The Seifert-van Kampen theorem gives
A free product of two nontrivial groups is nonabelian: choose nonidentity elements in the two factors; their products in the two orders are distinct reduced words. Hence one factor, say , is trivial. The inclusion of this simply connected compact piece lifts to the universal cover . The lift is an embedding: equality of lifted points would imply equality of their projections in . Its image is compact with boundary the lifted sphere.
Use the three-dimensional Schoenflies theorem: a locally flat embedded sphere in bounds a ball, and its compact side is that ball. The interior of is both open and closed in the corresponding complement component, and compactness rules out the unbounded component. Thus is the bounded ball, and itself is a ball. Capping gives , so every connected-sum decomposition is trivial. Therefore is prime but not irreducible.
Now let a prime closed connected orientable fail irreducibility. A sphere not bounding a ball cannot separate: if it did, primeness would make one capped side , and the three-dimensional Schoenflies theorem would make its uncapped side a ball. Thus there is a nonseparating sphere . Its two-sided neighborhood is . Since the complement is connected, join its two boundary spheres by an embedded arc in that complement and thicken the arc. The union is a punctured : the thickened arc joins the two ends of the sphere-cylinder, and the remaining boundary is one sphere. This is the nonseparating sphere gives a sphere-circle summand construction and yields
The product is not , since its fundamental group is . Primeness forces , so
The background results used are van Kampen, the explicit universal cover of the product, and the locally flat three-dimensional Schoenflies theorem; no Poincaré-conjecture argument is needed.
Use the braid from part (c). Put meridians around its three strands at one end. At a positive crossing, the Wirtinger presentation relations induce the Artin automorphism of a braid
For the inverse crossing on strands two and three, they give
The first formula is the usual crossing conjugation, and the second is its inverse on the relevant pair. Following one block gives :
The four-crossing braid induces . Closing it identifies each ending meridian with its starting meridian. Applying the Seifert-van Kampen theorem to the crossing regions and the closing arcs therefore gives
where
Both elementary crossing automorphisms preserve . Hence , and the first two closure relations imply the third: after substitution , so cancellation gives .
The first remaining relation can be solved without adding any relation:
Substitute this expression into . Free cancellation and multiplying the two sides by inverse words give
These are Tietze transformations, eliminating a generator defined by one relation and retaining the other. Thus the figure-eight knot group has the requested one-relator presentation
The polygon presentation of the Klein bottle, or Seifert-van Kampen theorem applied to its cell structure, gives
Send to and to in . Conjugation by inverts , so this defines a surjective group homomorphism. Since is nonabelian, the fundamental group is nonabelian.
Use integral cellular homology. All three vertices become a single vertex, and all three oriented edges become one oriented circle, with generator . The face goes round that circle three times in the same direction. Thus the quotient has a CW complex structure with one cell in each of dimensions zero, one and two, and cellular chain complex
The degree-two boundary is injective and its cokernel is . Therefore
The attaching word is , so the Seifert-van Kampen theorem also gives . This is the degree-three circle-attachment model of a Moore space.
False. Take and , with their standard product and connected-sum orientations. They are closed simply connected four-manifolds. For the connected sum, removing a four-ball leaves the fundamental group unchanged, and the Seifert-van Kampen theorem across the separating three-sphere preserves simple connectivity. The Mayer–Vietoris sequence computes integral cohomology in degrees zero, two and four, and zero in other degrees. The Künneth theorem gives the same groups for . Thus their Betti numbers agree and all their integral cohomology is torsion-free.
Their cohomology rings nevertheless differ. In , let come from the two projective summands and let generate degree four. The cohomology ring of the connected sum of two complex projective planes has
These relations follow by using cycles in the separate summands and the degree-one pinch projections onto them. In , the sphere-factor generators satisfy
Consequently every degree-two class of has square
an even multiple of the top generator, whereas in is a primitive generator. An integral graded-ring isomorphism cannot change this property, since it sends a generator of to its positive or negative. A homotopy equivalence induces a graded-ring isomorphism, so none exists. Equivalently, their intersection forms are and , an odd form and an even form respectively.
Take a finite presentation . For a closed-manifold realization of a finitely presented fundamental group, begin with a five-dimensional ball and attach one-handles, giving a compact oriented five-manifold with fundamental group the free group on the . Represent the relators by disjoint embedded circles in its four-dimensional boundary. General position allows them to be embedded and disjoint, and their oriented normal bundles admit framings. Attach a two-handle along each such circle. The resulting compact five-manifold has
by the Seifert-van Kampen theorem. Now set . It is a compact connected smooth four-manifold without boundary. Turning this handle decomposition upside down gives a relative handle decomposition of with handles of indices three, four and five only. Attaching such handles does not change the fundamental group: there are no new one-handles or two-handle relations. Thus is an isomorphism and
These are the differential-topological handle facts used in the construction; the dimension-five thickening ensures the boundary retains the prescribed fundamental group.
Now assume finite. Choose any smooth Riemannian metric on and lift it to its universal cover . This cover is compact, since its degree is , and simply connected. Its deck transformations give a free isometric -action. For the two Gassmann equivalent subgroups put
Each is a closed Riemannian manifold, and is its simply connected universal cover, with deck transformation group . Consequently .
Here is the complete spectral argument behind the Sunada theorem in this situation. Each finite-dimensional upstairs eigenspace is a representation of , because the action is isometric and commutes with the Laplace-Beltrami operator. Functions downstairs correspond exactly to invariant functions upstairs, so their multiplicities are . Averaging the representation matrices over a subgroup is a projection onto its invariant subspace. Taking its trace gives
The character is constant on each conjugacy class of . Gassmann equivalence means for every such class ; summing these equalities also gives . The two averages are therefore equal for every . The quotients are isospectral, with .
If , the map is well defined, invertible and isometric because acts by an isometry upstairs. Conjugate subgroups give isometric quotients.
For an explicit example with different fundamental groups, use the order-sixteen Gassmann pair
Embed each in by left multiplication on its own sixteen elements, identified with the same sixteen-point set. These regular representations are faithful. Both groups have one identity element, three elements of order two, and twelve of order four: in the elements of order dividing two are precisely its four even-coordinate elements; in they are the four elements in . Every remaining element has order four.
In a regular action, an order- element is a product of disjoint -cycles. Thus each subgroup intersects the identity conjugacy class of in one element, the class of type in three, the class of type in twelve, and every other class in zero. They are Gassmann equivalent. However is abelian and is nonabelian, so they are not isomorphic. Apply the preceding construction with fundamental group and these subgroups. It produces
In particular they cannot even be homeomorphic, and therefore cannot be isometric.
Each Möbius strip deformation retracts onto its core circle. Its boundary travels twice around that circle. Thicken the two strips slightly across their common boundary to obtain an open cover whose intersection deformation retracts onto that boundary circle. The Seifert-van Kampen theorem therefore gives
Depending on the boundary orientation the relation may first read ; replacing by its inverse gives the displayed presentation.
The map respects the relation and surjects onto the infinite cyclic group , so the fundamental group is infinite. It also surjects onto the infinite dihedral group: map and to the reflections and of the real line. Both squares are the identity, but and differ. An abelian group cannot have this nonabelian quotient. The fundamental group is infinite and nonabelian.
Take a CW complex with one vertex, loops labelled , and one two-cell attached along . The Seifert-van Kampen theorem gives the required fundamental group. Connected double covering spaces correspond to index-two subgroups, equivalently kernels of surjective homomorphisms . The relation imposes modulo two, so the unique nonzero possibility sends both to one. Thus there is a unique connected double cover up to covering isomorphism.
Construct it with two vertices; both labelled edges switch sheets, and attach the two lifts of the two-cell. Contract one of the edges to a spanning tree. With coset representatives , the remaining Schreier generators can be taken as , and . Reading the two lifts of the attaching word, starting on the two respective sheets, gives and . Thus
For example, a letter contributes nothing on the first sheet and on the second; a letter contributes on the first and on the second. Both letters then switch sheets, which directly verifies the two relators.