The official notes, PDF pp. 7–8, handwritten pp. 1–2 calculate both elapsed proper times and their weak-field ratio for satellite A and the polar station.
The official notes, PDF p. 7, handwritten p. 1 derive the affine choice of coordinate time and the circular-orbit angular velocity from the geodesic equations.
Put , , , and . The primitive cubic and quintic root identities give , . These elements therefore provide the following six generators:
- , degree two.
- , degree two.
- , degree two.
- , degree four.
- , degree four.
- , degree four.
The three quadratic fields are distinct because are distinct rational square classes. To justify the fifth entry, the two quadratic fields and are distinct, so their compositum has degree four. Moreover andThus their sum alone generates the compositum.
The field has degree four by the quintic cyclotomic polynomial. Its Galois group is and its unique quadratic subfield is , so it cannot contain . It is therefore different from . The final field has degree four by part (b) and is real; the preceding two quartic fields contain nonreal and , respectively. Thus all three quartics are distinct, and the count in part (i) proves the list exhaustive. This gives the subfields of the fifteenth cyclotomic field without relying on a choice of square-root signs.
Irreducibility of the cyclotomic polynomial gives . The extension is Galois, since is the splitting field of in characteristic zero. The injection in part (a) is consequently an isomorphism, and the Chinese remainder theorem givesThe Fundamental theorem of Galois theory identifies proper intermediate fields strictly above with proper nontrivial subgroups. Such subgroups have order two or four. The two-torsion subgroup is , with three nonidentity elements and hence three order-two subgroups. There are also three order-four subgroups: they are the kernels of the three nonzero group homomorphisms . Distinct such maps have distinct kernels because the target has only one nonidentity element. Therefore
Past exam of the further quantum theory course of the University of Oxford 2023 3 a iii Solution 2026-10-25
Beyond the outer classical turning point, let and . The bound state condition removes the growing branch at positive infinity, leavingHere is an arbitrary common amplitude pending the matching and wavefunction normalization. For the confining potential energy in the native diagram, the decaying branch gives the required exterior square-integrable function.
Past exam of the further quantum theory course of the University of Oxford 2023 3 a ii Solution 2026-10-25
In the right-hand classically allowed region, put and . A convenient form of the general WKB approximation isThe phase origin is a choice of basis for the two oscillatory solutions, anticipating the Airy turning-point connection formula. Equivalently, one may use independent and branches. The coefficients have not yet been related to those in either forbidden region.
Past exam of the further quantum theory course of the University of Oxford 2023 3 a i Solution 2026-10-25
In the central classically forbidden region, define the positive decay momentum and the dimensionless action integral . The general leading WKB approximation isBoth coefficients are allowed: this interval has finite length, so the exponential that grows towards the barrier centre cannot be discarded by a condition at infinity. The WKB validity condition holds away from the classical turning point ; a local Airy function solution supplies its continuation there.
At an equilibrium , set . The Jacobian matrix, its trace and its determinant areThe eigenvalues and their discriminant areThus the complete local linear stability test isIn the last two cases, gives a node, while gives a focus; the sign of distinguishes inward and outward trajectories. At , a nonzero repeated eigenvalue gives a degenerate node. At the eigenvalues are purely imaginary, so linear stability analysis alone does not decide asymptotic stability; with the required crossing and nondegeneracy this is a Hopf bifurcation. At there is a zero eigenvalue, requiring a nonlinear test and generically marking the saddle-node bifurcation in the preceding answer.
For a unique simple equilibrium, , so it can be a sink equilibrium or a source equilibrium. The number of equilibria alone does not decide stability. If , the unique simple equilibrium is always a sink equilibrium. If , it can become a source equilibrium where . The same conclusion follows particularly simply if : the trace is negative at every nonsaddle equilibrium.
For three simple equilibria ordered by their coordinates, the middle one has and is a saddle equilibrium; the two outer ones have . When both outer equilibria are sink equilibria, each has an attracting neighborhood, giving bistability. In the usual two-basin portrait, the stable manifold of the saddle equilibrium separates their basins. Each branch of its unstable manifold initially leaves towards a different side; its eventual destination requires a global argument. If , both outer equilibria must be sink equilibria. If , either or both outer equilibria can instead be source equilibria; the same test applies separately to each. The three lower panels illustrate all three possibilities up to exchanging left and right.
The arrows in the phase plane follow directly from the nullclines: below the horizontal component points right, and above it left; below the vertical component points up, and above it down. Near a stable focus trajectories spiral inward; near an unstable focus they spiral outward. Near a saddle equilibrium they approach along its stable manifold and leave along its unstable manifold. These directions, together with the local tests, determine the sketches.
Phase portraits of the FitzHugh-Nagumo model with one or three equilibria, including changes of linear stability
. Details. There is also a useful global conclusion when the unique equilibrium is a source equilibrium. Withthe leading term in is , so sufficiently large ellipses are trapping regions. A small repelling neighborhood of the hyperbolic source equilibrium can be removed to form an invariant annulus. The Poincaré-Bendixson theorem then guarantees at least one periodic orbit in that annulus. The numerical sketch illustrates the resulting sustained oscillation; this argument does not assert uniqueness of a limit cycle. A stable equilibrium can instead represent a resting membrane potential, with perturbations producing damped relaxation; near a threshold, a sufficiently large perturbation can produce a large excursion before recovery. Global basin boundaries and coexistence of periodic orbits need more information than the number and local stability of equilibria.
Past exam of the further mathematical biology course of the University of Oxford 2023 2 a i Solution 2026-10-25
Put . The nullclines of the space-clamped FitzHugh-Nagumo model areThe first nullcline is a downward-leading cubic polynomial, shifted vertically by ; the second nullcline is a line through the origin with slope . Their intersections satisfyWriting , differentiation givesIf , increases strictly, so there is exactly one equilibrium. If , is still strictly increasing, although its derivative vanishes at one point, so the equilibrium is again unique. If , defineHere has a local maximum at and a local minimum at ; thereforeAt either endpoint there are two distinct equilibria, one a double root. These are the saddle-node bifurcation boundaries omitted by the generic one-or-three wording. At and there is one triple root. This is the Cubic FitzHugh-Nagumo nullcline criterion.
One and three intersections of the FitzHugh-Nagumo model nullclines
. Details. The zero extension of H01 makes an element of . The chain rule and change of variables give the exact scaling identitiesIndeed inside the expanded ball, and there is no boundary jump because the Sobolev trace is zero.
First take the printed convergence assertion as an assumption, as the question requests. It would imply . The strict inequality follows because an function with zero weak gradient is constant almost everywhere, and the only constant in is zero; this contradicts the asserted positivity of . If converged strongly in , its limit would have to be its weak limit zero from (iii), forcing . The first scaling identity contradicts this. Thus the intended answer is
There is nevertheless a substantive printing error: the asserted strong convergence of in the full is false for these positive sources. Here is a check that does not rely on any assertion about the limiting profile. Put and . Rescaling the weak formulation givesThe spherical mean of a Poisson solution outside its source provides an exact obstruction. The total source is . Let be its spherical mean. On the function is a harmonic function. The radial flux identity, obtained by testing against radial test functions or by the divergence theorem, gives , while the zero boundary value gives . HenceCauchy-Schwarz inequality on each sphere, followed by spherical coordinates, now yieldsThus the printed sequence is not even bounded in the full norm. The result on Poisson convergence on expanding balls in a homogeneous Sobolev space gives the appropriate corrected convergence in the homogeneous Sobolev space , which controls the gradient in and the function in , without requiring it to belong to .
For completeness, the desired nonconvergence of has a direct proof that needs neither the incorrect claim nor its correction. Choose a nonnegative nonzero test function , which exists since is a domain containing the origin. The rescaled weak formulation and Cauchy-Schwarz inequality giveConsequently, for every ,Together with (iii), this rigorously proves failure of strong convergence for the actual sequence defined in the paper.
Take the weakly convergent subsequence in (i), with limit . For each , the weak formulation givesThe left side tends to by weak convergence in . The zero-boundary Sobolev inequality gives , so (ii) makes the right side tend to zero. Taking in the limiting identity yields . The zero-boundary Poincaré inequality then gives .
The same argument applies to a weakly convergent subsequence of any subsequence of , because all remain bounded as in (i). To see why this proves convergence of the full sequence, suppose a continuous linear functional on did not satisfy . Some subsequence would have . Its boundedness gives a further weakly convergent subsequence, whose limit has just been proved to be zero; then tends to zero along it, a contradiction. ThereforeUniqueness of a possible limit alone is not enough without the weak sequential compactness in a Hilbert space used to extract a further subsequence.
The Lp norm of the forcing at the critical exponent is constant:To prove weak convergence in , the duality of Lp spaces says that we must test against an arbitrary . Holder inequality, restricted to the shrinking measurable set , givesThe last step is absolute continuity of the Lebesgue integral, since and is integrable. ThusTesting only bounded or smooth functions would not by itself establish this weak convergence; the restricted Holder inequality handles every member of the full dual space.
Let . By linearity of the weak formulation, is the zero-boundary weak solution with forcing . The estimate in (a)(iii) therefore givesThe change of variables gives , so the division is legitimate. Since is a Hilbert space, weak sequential compactness in a Hilbert space now gives a subsequence and some such thatIn fact : the Sobolev trace operator is continuous and linear, so its zero kernel is preserved by weak convergence.
By the definition in (i), itself is an admissible test in the weak formulation. HenceThe absolute value makes a proof of positivity unnecessary. Holder inequality with exponents and , followed by the zero-boundary Sobolev inequality, givesTaking square roots of both estimates proves exactly the requested chain:If , the zero-boundary Poincaré inequality gives and the conclusion follows. Otherwise divide the first-to-last estimate by and square, obtaining . Finally the same Poincaré inequality givesAll constants depend only on the fixed unit ball and the dimension, and are independent of and . If , testing the homogeneous equation with gives the same zero solution directly.
As printed, the answer isThe constant function has zero gradient and positive Lp norm for every such , including its supremum norm when .
The missing assumption is a zero Sobolev trace, which is present for the weak solutions in the surrounding parts. With in place of , the intended answer isThis is the three-dimensional Sobolev inequality at , followed by Holder inequality on the bounded ball for smaller ; it includes the zero-boundary Poincaré inequality at . The subsequent parts use this zero-boundary version.
The zero Dirichlet boundary condition must be part of the definition. Thus is a weak solution precisely when , equivalently its Sobolev trace vanishes on , andHere is the indicator function of the measurable set . One may initially require the identity only for test functions : both sides are continuous in the Sobolev norm, and the definition of the zero-trace Sobolev space then extends it to all . This formulation uses first weak derivatives and encodes without assuming classical second derivatives.
Set , the positive part of . The allowed Sobolev chain rule givesUse the admissible zero-boundary Sobolev space function in the weak formulation, with a valid cutoff function as explained in (ii). Its gradient is , soIndeed the integrands vanish off , and on that set . The uniform ellipticity and Cauchy-Schwarz inequality estimates from (ii) now apply to and giveFixing the cutoff function gives the required constant independent of . This is a superlevel Caccioppoli inequality; it uses the positive part as a test and does not require the truncated function itself to solve the original equation.
First repeat the Caccioppoli inequality calculation on two concentric balls. If is a harmonic function on , choose a cutoff function equal to one on , supported in , and with gradient bounded by . The argument of (ii), with and , givesHere depends at most on the dimension. When is only known to be smooth inside and in , the weak formulation and all integrals involving the cutoff function are still legitimate, since its support is strictly inside .
Every classical partial derivative of the given smooth harmonic function is again a harmonic function, since constant-coefficient partial derivatives commute with the Laplacian. Choose indices representing the multi-index , and defineFor each , the preceding Caccioppoli inequality yieldsStarting with , these estimates also establish the integrability needed at each subsequent step. Iterating times givesThis is the desired interior derivative estimate for a harmonic function, with a constant depending only on and , uniformly over every multi-index of size .
There is a small incompatibility in the printed cutoff function assumptions. No can equal one on and satisfy : for a unit vector , choose beyond its support. Continuity gives , while the fundamental theorem of calculus would give . Replace the number by a fixed sufficiently large absolute constant ; such a cutoff function exists, and the requested Caccioppoli inequality is unchanged apart from its constant. We keep in the calculation, which also yields the formal bound under the printed assumptions.
The weak formulation is for test functions . Since is bounded, this extends by density of smooth functions in a Sobolev space to every . Part (a)(ii), followed by mollification inside the compact support, makes an admissible choice. The product rule givesPut and . The lower and upper uniform ellipticity bounds, together with Cauchy-Schwarz inequality, implyIf the conclusion is immediate. Otherwise divide by and square to obtain . Since on ,For a fixed valid cutoff function, , this has the required constant independent of . Formally inserting the printed value gives . No derivative of was taken, so differentiability of the coefficients is unnecessary.
Interpret the paper's unspecified as containing , the domain on which the coefficients are used. Write , a real symmetric matrix. The strict ellipticity condition is pointwise positive definiteness:The lower bound may depend on . By continuity, strict ellipticity gives a positive lower bound on each compact subset of , but does not require one bound throughout the whole open ball.
With the two-constant convention used in the next part, uniform ellipticity meansBoth constants are independent of . Some terminology uses uniform ellipticity for just the lower bound and states coefficient boundedness separately; here the paper supplies both constants. The spectral theorem for the symmetric matrix gives . For example, satisfies strict ellipticity in but has no uniform positive lower bound as .
There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.

