For , the functions and are bounded. Hence and belong to . For a test function , the classical product rule and the weak derivative identity for , tested with , give
Therefore
In fact has compact support in and belongs to the corresponding zero-boundary Sobolev space, by mollification within that support.
For arbitrary , the same identity still proves the local product rule for weak derivatives, but membership in the global Sobolev space can fail. To give a counterexample for every dimension and every in the question, take
Here and is a smooth function on the open ball, while polar coordinates show
Thus , and the global assertion is false. Boundedness of and its first derivatives would suffice without compact support.
A locally integrable function has weak derivative in direction when is locally integrable and
The test functions have compact support inside the domain, so no boundary values enter this definition. Such is unique almost everywhere and is denoted .
For , the first-order Sobolev space consists of the Lp space classes whose first weak derivatives are also in that Lp space:
This Sobolev norm is equivalent to ; either convention is acceptable. When , this is the Hilbert space .
Use the continuous representative of furnished by the one-dimensional Sobolev embedding theorem, and define on . The one-dimensional Sobolev representative is absolutely continuous; Holder inequality applied to its fundamental theorem of calculus gives
Also : select a point where is no larger than its norm on the unit-length interval and apply the same fundamental theorem of calculus. Thus the one-dimensional Hölder norm is controlled by .
The two Hölder seminorms must be compared using the correct distances. By the reverse triangle inequality,
Conversely, take and for any fixed unit vector . Then , so taking suprema yields equality of the two Hölder seminorms. Their supremum norms are equal as well. Part (i) now gives
The representative agrees with almost everywhere, and the assignment is linear and injective on the radial Sobolev space. This proves the requested continuous embedding. The inner radius being positive makes the radial profile Sobolev norm comparable to its weighted radial version.
Write , , and let be the radial profile of the radial derivative , which may be assumed to be a radial function here. The spherical coordinate system gives
Since , both and belong to the Lp space . It remains to identify the weak derivative of the radial profile directly.
For , each component of is a test function on . Sum the three defining weak derivative identities, using the stated divergence formula:
Given an arbitrary test function , choose . Dividing by gives , exactly the definition of the weak derivative. We have proved
This radial Sobolev profile on an annulus estimate follows from the two weighted integrals above and equivalence of the usual Sobolev norms.
Here Morrey's inequality has Hölder exponent . Every has a unique continuous representative such that
We use the Hölder norm , where the Hölder seminorm is . The second bound is the homogeneous form of Morrey's inequality; the first includes control of the values themselves.
Let be the mollifications from (i). They converge to in the Sobolev norm. Apply the assumed smooth version of Morrey's inequality to the differences :
Thus is a Cauchy sequence in the complete Hölder space and converges there to a function . In particular the convergence is uniform. On every bounded set of finite volume,
Exhausting by balls proves almost everywhere. Set . Taking limits in the smooth Hölder norm bound gives the first boxed estimate. For any fixed , taking limits in
gives the second boxed estimate after taking the supremum. Finally, two continuous representatives equal almost everywhere must coincide everywhere, since a nonzero continuous difference would remain nonzero on an open ball of positive volume.
Choose a nonnegative mollifier with , and put . Sobolev approximation by mollifiers in the Sobolev space under consideration states
In particular, it gives density of smooth functions in a Sobolev space. We prove convergence of both the function and all its first weak derivatives.
The usual smoothing properties of convolution give . For a test function and , Fubini's theorem and the definition of a weak derivative give
The integrals are absolutely convergent: the compact supports of and restrict to a compact set, on which and are integrable by Holder inequality. Consequently
The approximate identity theorem in the Lp space applies separately to and . Thus
Each convolution belongs to by Young's convolution inequality. With the componentwise Sobolev norm, the sixth power of the required difference is the sum of these four sixth powers, proving the boxed claim. Any equivalent Sobolev norm gives the same convergence.
Use the intended space of Hilbert-Schmidt operators, with the given Hilbert-Schmidt inner product linear in its first argument. It remains to prove completeness in its Hilbert-Schmidt norm. Let be a Cauchy sequence in that norm. The bound makes it a Cauchy sequence in operator norm. The space is a Banach space, so in operator norm for some bounded linear operator .
For completeness, that last standard fact follows by taking for each : the Cauchy sequence is uniformly bounded in operator norm, so its limit is linear and bounded, and the uniform Cauchy estimate on the unit ball gives operator norm convergence.
Given , choose so that for . Fix and any positive integer . Since for each , passage to the limit in a finite sum gives
Taking the supremum over gives . Also,
Thus , and for . This proves Hilbert-Schmidt operators form a Hilbert space:
Under the literal unrestricted “linear mappings” definition, the nonzero from part (i) satisfies . The form would fail positive definiteness and would not be an inner product; the boundedness correction is needed here too.
As in the preceding part, take to be a bounded linear operator. For , the Hilbertian basis expansion and continuity of give
The triangle inequality, the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality for finite sums, and the Parseval identity for a Hilbertian basis give
Passing to the limit and taking the supremum over the unit ball proves
Thus the Hilbert-Schmidt norm controls the operator norm. Without the boundedness interpretation, the nonzero constructed in the preceding part has zero printed column sum and makes the requested inequality false.
Here the intended space must consist of bounded linear operators, namely Hilbert-Schmidt operators. The printed restriction to “all linear mappings” is insufficient. To see this, choose outside the algebraic linear span of , for example . Extend the linearly independent family to a Hamel basis. Define a linear functional on this Hamel basis by and zero on every other basis vector, and extend it linearly. Then the everywhere-defined linear operator satisfies
Its printed column sum is zero although . More explicitly, but for every . Thus is discontinuous; it has no everywhere-defined adjoint operator of the bounded kind used in the question. This proves finite column sum does not imply boundedness. We use in the intended argument below.
By the Parseval identity for a Hilbertian basis for , followed by the adjoint operator identity and then the Parseval identity for a Hilbertian basis for ,
The interchange is valid by Tonelli's theorem for nonnegative double series, even before finiteness is known. Repeating with shows that the right side also equals . Hence
In particular the Hilbert-Schmidt norm is independent of the Hilbertian basis, and .
Again put . Surjectivity gives, by image-kernel orthogonality for an adjoint,
If is real, , so . If is nonreal and , then ; reality of again implies . Thus is injective as well as surjective, without needing to assume separately that is not an eigenvalue.
Since is a bounded linear operator on the Banach space , the bounded inverse theorem makes bounded. Therefore
This is exactly membership in the resolvent set of an operator.
Put . Since is a self-adjoint operator, . Applying the preceding image-kernel orthogonality for an adjoint identities to gives
If is real, and because is not an eigenvalue. If is nonreal and , then . The scalar is real by self-adjointness, while it equals . Its imaginary part forces . Thus in both cases, and
The conjugation on in the adjoint operator is essential when is nonreal.
Let send a continuous function to its almost everywhere equivalence class. The domain with the supremum norm and the target with the L1 norm are Banach spaces, and
Thus is a bounded linear operator, and the requested vector subspace is .
To show this image of a linear map is not closed, consider the continuous functions
and . Their L1 norm difference is the area of one triangle:
But has no continuous function representative. Indeed, a continuous function equal to zero almost everywhere on must be identically zero there: any nonzero value would persist on an open interval of positive Lebesgue measure. Likewise any continuous representative would be identically one on . Continuity at makes these requirements incompatible. Therefore , although it lies in its closure.
The preceding operator range category dichotomy proves continuous functions are meagre in L1:
For put , with closure taken in . Then
If every has empty interior, then each is a nowhere dense set, because it is closed. Each is then a nowhere dense set too. Consequently is a meagre set, that is, a set of the first category in .
Otherwise some has nonempty interior. Scaling gives nonempty interior of . The geometric correction for approximate surjectivity proved in the preceding part gives an open ball about zero inside . Since is a vector subspace, it then equals : scale any into this ball and scale its preimage back. Hence is a closed set.
Thus, in fact, the stronger operator range category dichotomy holds:
In particular is closed or of the first category, as required. The only substantive theorem used here is the preceding geometric correction for approximate surjectivity: for a bounded linear operator from a Banach space to a normed space, nonempty interior of the closure of the image of the unit ball implies nonempty interior of the image itself. Its series proof was given there, so this proof does not require the Baire category theorem or completeness of .
Use the closed unit ball first, and put . This is a convex set symmetric about zero. If , then , so taking midpoints gives
Write . By scaling,
Fix with . Starting with , recursively choose such that
At each step the previous residual lies in the open ball on the left of the scaled inclusion, so the definition of closure permits this approximation. The series converges to some because is a Banach space, and the triangle inequality gives . Continuity of gives , since . Thus
Scaling by now gives the slightly smaller open ball
This proves the assertion whether the original unit ball is taken open or closed. Only completeness of was used; the normed space need not be complete. The argument is geometric correction for approximate surjectivity.
The open mapping theorem states that a surjective bounded linear operator between Banach spaces is an open map: is an open set in whenever is an open set in . Equivalently, there is such that
where both displayed balls are open. In particular, a bijective bounded linear operator between Banach spaces has a bounded inverse, the bounded inverse theorem.
Composition with preserves continuity, so maps the space of continuous functions on a compact space into itself and is linear. Since maps onto itself,
For , the mean value theorem applied to gives
The same bound holds at . Each has uniform continuity by the Heine-Cantor theorem. With its modulus of continuity , we obtain
Alternatively, the bound proves convergence on every polynomial; the Weierstrass approximation theorem makes these a dense subset of , and the Banach-Steinhaus convergence theorem with gives the same conclusion.
The Banach-Steinhaus convergence theorem can be stated as follows. Let be a normed space, a Banach space, and . If
and converges in for every in a dense subset , then converges for every . The pointwise limit is a bounded linear operator and
If is also a Banach space, the uniform operator norm bound is necessary: pointwise convergence implies pointwise boundedness, so the Banach-Steinhaus theorem, namely the Uniform boundedness principle, supplies it. The limit is convergence in the strong operator topology; it need not be convergence in operator norm.
To see the sufficient direction, write . For the triangle inequality gives
First approximate by , then let . Completeness of gives the limit. Linearity passes to limits, and gives the displayed bound. If a candidate bounded linear operator is already given and on , the same approximation proves convergence to even when is merely a normed space.
The orthogonal complement is infinite-dimensional: otherwise would be finite-dimensional. Inductively choose an orthonormal sequence in , each new vector being orthogonal to the preceding finite linear span. The Bessel inequality gives for every , so . Thus is a weakly null orthonormal sequence.
Set
By orthogonality, , while for every . Hence . When , this formula simply gives the constant sequence . In particular, the weak closure of the unit sphere contains the whole closed unit ball.
First suppose the convex set is closed in the norm topology, and satisfies . Apply the weak Banach–Saks theorem in a Hilbert space to the weakly null sequence . Along the resulting subsequence,
in norm. Each is a convex combination of points in , so . Since is a closed set in the norm topology, .
Conversely, suppose is a sequentially weakly closed set. If in the norm topology, choose with . The Cauchy-Schwarz inequality gives for every , hence weak convergence to . The assumed closure property gives . The empty set satisfies both properties too. Thus
By weakly convergent sequence is bounded, is finite. Choose any . Once have been chosen, put . Since is fixed, weak convergence to zero gives . Choose with . This gives the required one-sided inequality as well.
The useful estimate is for the squared norm. Indeed, , and the inner product expansion gives
By mathematical induction, . Hence
This proves norm convergence of the averages, the weak Banach–Saks theorem in a Hilbert space. The printed inequality omits the square on its left side. Our stronger estimate also proves that printed bound, since for , but the printed bound alone only bounds the averages and cannot imply their norm convergence to zero.

There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.