The embedded acts on the first three coordinates and fixes the fourth. This immediately gives the branching rules
Distribute the tensor product of group representations over these direct sums and split by taking the trace:
One can locate every summand using the block matrix
The traceless part of is , is , is , and are independent trivial representations. Removing the overall trace instead gives . The dimension check is .
Write for a Young diagram with row lengths , and depict an empty box by . Appending the box of the fundamental representation to another single box gives a row or a column:
The corresponding symmetric tensors and antisymmetric tensors have dimensions and , so
For the conjugate representation, the invariant volume tensor identifies , represented by a column of three boxes. Adding one box gives
A column of four boxes is the determinant representation, which is trivial on . The remaining Young diagram has Dynkin labels and dimension fifteen. For example the hook-content formula gives
Equivalently, a mixed tensor transforms by and splits into its trace and traceless matrix parts. Therefore
where is the Adjoint representation.
Use the Hermitian from a to record real weight coordinates: . Reading off the diagonal entries gives
These are weights in the simple-coroot coordinate system, not coordinates in an orthonormal basis. In the skew-Hermitian convention they mean . Intrinsically, the weight on is the functional , with .
The conjugate representation acts by , so a diagonal transformation with entries becomes one with entries . Thus its four weights are
All have multiplicity one. In both representations the sum of the weights is zero, consistent with the vanishing trace of every Lie algebra generator.
Use the mathematical Lie algebra convention . Differentiating and at gives and . Conversely, for such an , the matrix exponential is unitary and has determinant . Thus
The four diagonal entries are purely imaginary, and the six entries above the diagonal are arbitrary complex numbers determining the entries below it. This gives real parameters before imposing the one real trace constraint, so .
A Cartan subalgebra of this compact Lie algebra is a maximal commuting Lie subalgebra; choose
A simple basis is , where
Any matrix commuting with every diagonal element is itself diagonal, which proves maximality. Commuting skew-Hermitian matrices can also be simultaneously diagonalized, so no larger commuting Lie subalgebra is possible. Consequently
The Hermitian quantum generator convention instead uses the Hermitian and . The two conventions describe the same Lie algebra.
The scalar fields commute, so a degree- expression in one doublet belongs to a symmetric power, rather than an arbitrary tensor product. Put , . The generators of a group and act by
A monomial is fixed by precisely when is divisible by three. Imposing then pairs the exponents. Through degree four the resulting holomorphic polynomial invariants are
In particular, two explicit invariant terms are and . Their invariance follows directly from and the interchange of the two components. A quartic example is .
For a physical real scalar potential, complex conjugate fields are allowed as well. The Hermitian inner product and its square are also invariant, while a holomorphic term can enter with its complex conjugate, for example . There is still no invariant linear term, because neither the doublet nor its conjugate representation contains a trivial representation. Thus the possible nonconstant total degrees are
The constant term is unrestricted.
For the fundamental representation of the special unitary group , its central element sends and . Every odd-degree polynomial changes sign, excluding degrees one and three. Further, acts transitively on the unit sphere in : a unit vector is the first column of
An invariant polynomial must therefore depend only on . Through quartic order the general real scalar potential is
Hence the possible nonconstant degrees are ; the cubic term permitted by is excluded by .
If the notation is instead read as restricting to holomorphic polynomials alone, the distinction matters: a single commuting doublet has no nonconstant holomorphic polynomial invariant. The candidate contraction vanishes identically. The quadratic and quartic terms above require complex conjugate fields. This also explains why counting a trivial representation in alone would give an incorrect holomorphic answer.
All three displayed transposition matrices have trace zero. Multiplying two of them gives
since . Their traces are , whereas . Therefore
By character orthogonality, is the irreducible representation from c.
There is also a direct invariant subspace argument. The two distinct eigenvalues of force any invariant line to be one of the two coordinate lines. But exchanges those lines. Neither is invariant under the whole group, so this two-dimensional representation is irreducible.
There is one complex irreducible representation for each conjugacy class, hence three. The trivial representation and sign representation are distinct and one-dimensional. The sum of squares of irreducible representation dimensions leaves
Call the remaining irreducible representation . The permutation representation on has character equal to the number of fixed objects, namely on the ordered conjugacy classes . Removing its constant-vector trivial representation gives , whose character inner product with itself is one. This constructs and gives the character table
To obtain every Clebsch-Gordan decomposition of group representations, multiply the characters pointwise. In particular, , and
Thus all ordered pairs of irreducible representations are covered by
Compose permutations from right to left. The three transpositions are , and . In cycle notation, direct composition gives
The complete symmetric group is therefore
Conjugation relabels the entries of a cycle, so the conjugacy classes are precisely
Their sizes are , respectively. The differing orders of group elements also show that these three sets cannot merge under conjugation.
The character of a representation is . The cyclic property of the trace makes it a class function:
Thus a character is specified by one number per conjugacy class, much less information than all the representation matrices. Moreover,
Here character orthogonality says that is the multiplicity of the irreducible representation . Consequently characters determine finite-dimensional complex representations up to equivalence of group representations and compute tensor product of group representations decompositions without constructing a new basis explicitly.
Choose the first as and embed in the upper-left three-by-three block of . The fundamental representations then restrict as and . Thus the representation in solution, forgetting hypercharge, restricts to
This contains every required representation, with one extra singlet.
For the hypercharge embedding, let in the fundamental representation, and in the second . These commute with . The integer normalization in the paper is
Explicitly, this circle group embeds in the covering group by
Both nontrivial blocks have determinant one, and the map is injective since the first three entries of the block recover .
On , , so the branching of a representation gives . On , the U(1) charges under are on and on , while takes values . Hence
Combining the two summands gives
This is the Pati-Salam charge embedding, with . In terms of the common Standard Model convention , the paper's integer hypercharge is .
The extra neutral singlet can be interpreted as the left-handed charge conjugate of a right-handed neutrino. It is a sterile neutrino under the Standard Model gauge group, and completes the sixteen Weyl fermions of one family in this half-spin representation. Its neutrality permits a Majorana mass term without violating the remaining Standard Model gauge group.
The highest root of the D5 root system in our numbering is . Adjoin . The Extended Dynkin diagram has an extra bond . Deleting node leaves the two isolated nodes and the chain , hence the root subsystem .
This is a maximal Lie subalgebra, not merely a full-rank Lie subalgebra. In the orthogonal realization it is , acting on a decomposition. The remaining off-diagonal part transforms as the irreducible tensor product representation of dimension . Any intermediate Lie subalgebra containing one nonzero vector in that complement must contain the entire complement, because this representation is irreducible, and hence all dimensions. This proves maximality.
To apply the supplied projection, write a D5 root system weight as the column of Dynkin labels. Then
For example, the highest weight maps to , and maps to . Applying the same expression to all sixteen weights in solution gives exactly
where and are the four-element weight systems in solution. Each set has eight distinct weights, each of multiplicity one. Since an doublet has weights and an singlet has weight zero, the branching of a representation is
The highest weights of these two summands are and , and checks the dimensions. Here is the convenient covering group; its image inside has a common central identification. Both summands are trivial on .
For the D5 root system, take an orthonormal basis and simple roots for , together with . The Dynkin diagram has single bonds , , , , with the fork at node . Thus its Cartan matrix is
The fundamental weight has Dynkin labels . Its pairing with every positive coroot , , is zero or one. Hence its half-spin representation is a minuscule representation, so its weight system is a single Weyl group orbit with multiplicity one. The Weyl group of the D5 root system permutes coordinates and changes an even number of signs. Consequently its complete weight system is
There are such weights. Their Dynkin labels are , explicitly
Here the Lie algebra is , or its compact real form when discussing compact groups. Globally the half-spin representation is a representation of , and does not descend to ; the question only specifies the Lie algebra.
For the A3 root system, take simple roots for in the hyperplane of an orthonormal . Its Dynkin diagram is the single-bond chain . The Cartan matrix has entries , giving
For a weight , use Dynkin labels . The four weights of the defining representation have labels
They form the weight system with highest weight . Equivalently, subtract successive rows of from that highest weight. The dual representation negates every weight, so the weight system with highest weight is
All these weights have multiplicity one. The numbered Dynkin diagrams used in this solution and in solution are shown below.
Figure 1.
Numbered Dynkin diagrams for the A3 root system and D5 root system, with deletion from the Extended Dynkin diagram
. All bonds are single. In the Extended Dynkin diagram of the D5 root system, deleting node 2 separates nodes 0 and 1 and leaves the three-node chain 4-3-5, giving the root subsystem . Details.
Number the simple roots of the root system consecutively along its Dynkin diagram. For a Young diagram with row lengths , its highest weight has Dynkin labels . The three irreducible representations have the following Young diagrams, which can be filled increasingly down the column to give Young tableaux:
Here , , and . Contraction with the invariant alternating tensor identifies , giving the dual representation of . The dimensions follow from , , .
Use the centralizer and circle group normalization of solution. The first three components have U(1) charge and the last two have U(1) charge , so the branching of a representation is
For the dual representation, both U(1) charges reverse and the representation is conjugated; the doublet is equivalent to its conjugate. Taking the exterior square of the first decomposition gives three types of antisymmetric tensor components: , , and , where and . Their U(1) charges add, and , . Hence
The dimensions are . These product labels describe genuine representations of the quotient group in solution: every element of its kernel acts trivially on each summand.
Write and partition a matrix into blocks. The equation makes its off-diagonal blocks obey and for every . Choosing any with forces both blocks to vanish. Conversely, every block diagonal matrix commutes with every . Intersecting with the special unitary group gives the exact centralizer
Its Lie algebra is . At the group level there is a finite central identification. The surjective group homomorphism
has kernel . Surjectivity follows by choosing with for any target pair , and setting , . Thus
The six distinct kernel elements give a concrete reason the displayed map does not identify the centralizer with an unquotiented product.
The identity belongs to the centralizer . If , then for every ,
Also implies by multiplying on both sides by . Hence and belong to , proving by the subgroup test that . This argument works even when is any subset, giving the centralizer of a subset.
Partition into the same five-by-five blocks as . The equation for block is , so each block is an intertwiner. By Schur's lemma, blocks between the two inequivalent irreducible representations vanish, whereas blocks between identical copies are arbitrary scalar multiples of the relevant identity matrix. Thus the commutant of a semisimple representation is
Equivalently, , where and . Substitution proves every such matrix commutes with every . There is no invertibility requirement on , and its solution space has complex dimension , even if .
Schur's lemma states that an intertwiner between irreducible representations is either zero or an isomorphism. In particular, inequivalent irreducible representations have no nonzero intertwiners. For a finite-dimensional irreducible representation over the complex numbers, every commuting endomorphism is scalar:
Indeed, the kernel and image of an intertwiner are invariant subspaces, proving the first statement. For the second, choose an eigenvalue of . The intertwiner has nonzero kernel, so it must vanish. The scalar conclusion uses an algebraically closed coefficient field: over the real numbers, planar rotation through gives an irreducible real representation of and commutes with itself without being a real scalar matrix.
Use the realization from solution. Put , which identifies the three-dimensional scalar field with . The polynomial invariants of the standard S4 representation include the symmetric power sums
because every permutation merely rearranges their summands. In these coordinates,
Neither polynomial vanishes identically: at they equal and . Hence coefficients multiplying and provide nonzero invariant quadratic and cubic terms. A change of basis transports these polynomial invariants to any equivalent realization of . For a real scalar field, both are real. For a complex scalar field, a real scalar potential may contain ; the quadratic Hermitian form is another invariant.
As an independent character check, the symmetric square of a group representation has character , and the symmetric cube of a group representation has character . With these are and . Their character inner products with are both one, so each degree has exactly one independent polynomial invariant.
Only the character of the two-dimensional irreducible representation remains unknown. Write it as . The regular representation has character zero off the identity and decomposes with multiplicities equal to the irreducible representation dimensions. Thus, for a nonidentity element ,
For the four nonidentity conjugacy classes this gives , , , . The complete character table is consequently
For example, , agreeing with character orthogonality.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact