The displayed age groups have fairly similar employment proportions, with no coherent monotone age trend. The printed test reports no evidence against age–employment independence; recomputing from the five visible rows reaches the same qualitative conclusion. Their totals and several auxiliary fields nevertheless do not represent one consistent table.
Each row percentage estimates an employment proportion within that age group. For example, of the youngest displayed group are employed. The employed proportions in the next four rows are , , and . The largest displayed proportion is in the 45–54 group and the smallest in the 55–64 group, a difference of about percentage points. These are conditional percentages, not the age distribution of employed people. The sequence rises and then falls; there is no simple increasing or decreasing pattern.
The null hypothesis for a Pearson chi-squared test of independence is that the joint category probabilities factor into their age and employment marginals. Its expected frequencies are , and its test statistic adds the standardized squared count discrepancies, . For a complete contingency table with positive margins, the large-sample reference chi-squared distribution has statistical degrees of freedom. Independent observations and an appropriate sampling scheme are essential; adequate expected counts make the approximation more plausible.[ref]
Reading only the printed test block, , statistical degrees of freedom and are mutually compatible. The printed likelihood-ratio test gives nearly the same p-value, about . At a prechosen 5% significance level neither rejects independence. This is a failure to find evidence, not proof of equal employment probabilities at every age. The printed Cramér's V around suggests a small sample association; the contingency coefficient around has the same broad message. The generalized phi coefficient is an unsigned chi-squared magnitude here, not evidence for a positive age trend. A small association magnitude and a large p-value answer different questions.
But only a table is actually visible. Those rows total , with employment column sums and , rather than the printed with columns and . Computing solely from the five visible rows gives
Its likelihood-ratio test statistic is about , again with statistical degrees of freedom. The smallest count-based expected frequency is about , comfortably large for this ordinary approximation, but different from the printed minimum . These figures are a labelled analysis of the visible subset, not a repaired full dataset. An unprinted sixth age row might explain some intended metadata, but neither its label nor a uniquely justified reconstruction is supplied. The oldest printed label also conflicts with Figures 1 and 8.
The ordinal measures look for an ordered tendency. Goodman and Kruskal's gamma compares concordant pairs with discordant pairs among pairs untied on both variables. The printed negative gamma, Somers' D, Kendall's tau-b and Stuart's tau-c therefore suggest, at most, a very weak tendency toward lower employment at higher age categories under the specified ordering. Their precise magnitudes are not reliable here. The ordinary unordered-pair partition for ordinal data fails for the printed pair counts, even when compared with the printed cases. On the five visible rows the respective count-based values are about , for employment conditional on age, and . None gives a substantial monotone pattern; a near-zero ordinal measure would not exclude a nonmonotone relationship in general.
Goodman and Kruskal's lambda is zero in both predictive directions on the visible table: knowing age does not improve the number of correct predictions made by always choosing the most common employment category, and knowing employment does not improve modal age-category prediction. Zero modal-prediction improvement does not mean every category distribution is identical. Both the reported test block and the separately recomputed visible-table test fail to reject independence; neither justifies asserting no association, a causal age effect, or a coherent full-sample calculation from the contradictory printout.
Employment is observed for all 2053 listed cases. Social media use is observed for 1424 cases, with 629 missing. The age percentages describe the five visible rows, whose counts total 1730; they cannot be treated as a complete age distribution for the stated 2053 cases.
A frequency table describes category counts and their relative frequencies. The full-sample percentage uses every listed case as denominator; a valid percentage excludes missing data for that variable. A cumulative percentage adds the valid percentages up to an ordered category. The denominator matters as much as the number: a statement about respondents with recorded use need not describe every respondent.
Employment is a binary categorical variable: 1216 cases are employed and 837 are not, or about and . Neither employment category is missing in this output. Employment labels have no intrinsic numerical spacing; codes zero and one identify the two categories under a chosen ordering convention. Cumulative percentages for a nominal categorical variable depend on the arbitrary display order and add little to this two-category description.
Age groups are an ordinal categorical variable because their intervals have a natural ordering, although the grouped representation loses exact ages. Among the five visible age rows, ages 25–44 form the largest group, with , and ages 14–24 the smallest, with . The other visible groups account for , and on that denominator. About of the visible five-row count is below 45. These percentages should not be silently applied to the stated total : for example, the same cases are only of .
The age variable key advertises six categories, whereas only five appear. Their counts sum to , leaving a difference of against the printed total; the table nevertheless prints zero missing values. This is an internal source discrepancy, not permission to label those cases as a particular unseen age group or as recorded missing data. The oldest row is labelled 65+ here but 65–74 in Figure 2. Even the age percentage total has a small display discrepancy: the five rounded percentages sum to , while the printed valid total and last cumulative percentage say . The much larger count inconsistency remains after allowing ordinary rounding.
Social media use is also an ordinal categorical variable. Its six ordered categories express increasing frequency, not equally spaced measurements: averaging category labels or claiming a one-unit change has a constant time meaning would require an additional scoring convention. Among the observed responses, the mode is never, at , followed by daily, at . Weekly use accounts for , use more than once a day for , less-than-monthly use for , and monthly use for . The first three categories together comprise about of valid responses. Consequently the middle ordered response lies in the weekly category: cumulative frequency first passes one half there.
Combining the two daily categories gives of valid responses using social media at least daily. The same recorded responses are of all listed cases. The second percentage is the fraction recorded as daily users, not an estimate that classifies all missing responses as nonusers. Missing social media responses make up . The directly calculated valid fraction is ; summing the individually rounded full-sample percentages produces the printed , a minor rounding difference. With no account of the missing-data mechanism, the observed valid distribution should not automatically be generalized to those with missing use. Employment being fully observed does not make social media missingness ignorable. The substantive distributional summary must retain both the valid-response denominator and the missing-data qualification.
Taken at face value, the printed two-sided p-value rejects equality of average political efficacy at the 5% level, with the non-employed group scoring higher. The effect magnitude and strength of evidence cannot be reported as one coherent result because the estimates, interval, test statistic and p-value contradict one another.
Let and be the expected political efficacy scores in the two employment groups in the target population. The null hypothesis is and the two-sided alternative hypothesis is . A Welch's t-test compares the difference of sample means with its standard error, estimating the two group variances separately:
The reference Student t-distribution has approximate, generally noninteger statistical degrees of freedom; it does not require equality of the two variances. Observations should be independent, with finite group variances; normal distributions give the usual small-sample rationale, while large samples permit an approximate normal sampling distribution under suitable conditions. A large sample cannot correct a biased sampling procedure or dependence between observations.[ref]
A p-value is a probability calculated under the null hypothesis and the sampling assumptions: for this two-sided test it measures the probability of an absolute test statistic at least as large as the observed one. It is not the probability that the null hypothesis is true, the probability that chance caused the observed difference, or a measure of the effect size. If the significance level was chosen in advance, the printed falls just below it. This would reject at 5%, but not at 1%. The significance level describes the long-run probability of a type I error, rejecting a true null hypothesis; a type II error instead fails to reject a false null hypothesis. Statistical power is the rejection probability under a specified alternative hypothesis. None of these errors for this particular realised study can be read as a posterior probability from .
Both the printed sample means and the positive confidence interval point toward greater political efficacy in group 0, the non-employed group. Their magnitudes disagree. Subtracting the printed sample means gives scale units. Yet the printed 95% confidence interval has midpoint , not . A two-sided Welch interval is centred on the difference of sample means. This violates the consistency identities for a two-sided t-test; the interval and estimates cannot describe the same reported comparison. If the interval alone were trusted, it would exclude zero and indicate an increase between about and units, but that is explicitly a conditional interpretation. A 95% confidence interval refers to repeated-sample coverage of a fixed statistical parameter, not a 95% posterior probability for that realised interval.[ref]
There are additional arithmetic warnings. The printed at statistical degrees of freedom gives a two-sided p-value about , not . Thus taking the test statistic as authoritative would imply much stronger evidence, not merely a marginal 5% result. The employment counts sum to , but their percentages are and , not and . If those counts also apply to the two political efficacy sample means, their weighted arithmetic mean would be about , not the reported overall ; separate complete-case group sizes are not supplied, so that last cross-output comparison is conditional on a common sample. No uniquely corrected difference, standard error or interval follows from these contradictory fields.
The political efficacy summary describes a bounded observed scale from to , with median and middle quartiles and . The interquartile range is ; the overall sample mean being below the median does not, by itself, establish a particular distributional shape. These descriptive statistics cannot supply the missing coherent group variances or a standardized effect size. Even a corrected small p-value would establish an association under a statistical model, rather than a causal effect of employment. Age, other background covariates, selection bias and the quality of the political efficacy measurement remain relevant. A defensible report gives the conditional 5% decision and direction, identifies the contradictions, and withholds a single numerical effect-and-uncertainty claim until the output is checked.
The fitted age slope is very small and negative, about efficacy points per year, with no conventional evidence against a zero linear slope: , . The model explains only about 0.0367% of the observed efficacy variation. These results concern a linear association, not proof of no possible age relationship or a causal effect of ageing.
The descriptive statistics report 2466 observed ages and efficacy scores, with no missing values for either variable. Age ranges from 14 to 97 years, with sample mean 52.689 years and sample standard deviation 19.064 years. Efficacy ranges from 0 to 16, with sample mean 9.348 and sample standard deviation 3.176 scale points. The standard deviations use different units and should not be compared as though their numerical ratio measured relative substantive variability. The efficacy mean retains the conflict with Question 1's group summaries; that conflict is not resolved by this separate regression output.
A simple linear regression models , where is efficacy and is age in years. Ordinary least squares chooses the coefficients to minimize the residual sum of squares. From the printed coefficients the fitted line is
Holding to this model, ten additional years correspond to fitted scale points. For example, the fitted mean is about 9.453 at age 20 and 9.261 at age 80, a difference of about points. These are fitted means, not exact predictions of individual scores. The line does not imply that every person's efficacy falls at that rate, nor that cross-sectional age differences identify within-person changes over time.
The intercept is the predicted mean at age zero, about 9.517. Since zero is outside the observed 14–97 age range, its direct interpretation requires extrapolation. The printed standard error of 0.188043 and yield the extremely small displayed p-value for a zero intercept. That test does not test whether age is a useful predictor. Recentring age at its observed sample mean would put the intercept near , the fitted mean at a substantively relevant reference age. This agrees with the rounded overall efficacy mean.
The age standard error is 0.003356 points per year. The coefficient divided by this standard error gives , agreeing with the printed t value. Estimating an intercept and one regression slope from 2466 observations leaves residual statistical degrees of freedom. Under a correctly specified normal linear model, the Student t-distribution provides the stated two-sided p-value. At 5%, or 1%, it does not reject . The p-value is not a 34.2% probability that age has no effect, and nonrejection does not establish a practically negligible effect size.[ref]
A 95% confidence interval calculated from the printed estimate and standard error is approximately
or about points per decade. It includes zero and gives the scale of slopes compatible with these summaries and assumptions. Assessing a practically negligible effect would require an explicit substantive tolerance and an appropriate equivalence test, not simply the fact that . A nonlinear association could also coexist with a near-zero overall linear slope.
The coefficient of determination is , meaning that the fitted line explains about of the sample's centred efficacy sum of squares compared with an intercept-only fit. This is not 36.7%, a fraction of people whose efficacy is predicted correctly, or the proportion of efficacy caused by age. The adjusted coefficient of determination, approximately , is slightly negative because its penalty for estimating the extra coefficient exceeds the tiny improvement in fit. It need not be constrained to be nonnegative and does not mean a negative amount of explained variation.
The overall on 1 and 2464 statistical degrees of freedom, with , tests the same zero-slope hypothesis as the age t test because there is only one predictor. The simple-regression output identities give and ; the printed numbers agree allowing their displayed precision. The signed Pearson correlation coefficient is consequently about . These are related summaries of the same weak linear association, not independent corroborating tests.
The residual standard error of 3.177 points estimates the typical unexplained error scale under the fitted model. It is close to the efficacy sample standard deviation, as expected when the line explains almost none of the variation. It is not a standard error of the slope or a guarantee that each individual's prediction error lies within 3.177 points. The residual summary spans roughly to , with sample median about 0.573 and central quartiles about and . An ordinary least-squares fit with an intercept has zero mean residual, not necessarily zero median residual. These few quantiles cannot establish normality, constant conditional spread, absence of outliers or linearity. The apparent last-decimal discrepancies among rounded error scales and other summary fields do not force an additional contradiction: their rounding intervals admit compatible regression summaries.
The conventional uncertainty calculations assume independent, mean-zero errors conditional on age, an appropriate linear mean, and homoscedasticity; normal errors give the usual exact finite-sample t and F calibration. Large samples can relax some distributional requirements but do not remove confounding, selection bias or dependence. A residual-versus-fitted plot could reveal curvature or changing spread, and a normal probability plot could assess error shape; neither plot can be reconstructed from the printed residual quantiles. A prediction interval for an individual includes residual variation and is wider than a confidence interval for the mean response. The supplied output supports a very weak, imprecisely signed linear association with little predictive gain from age alone, while leaving nonlinear, causal and design-based questions unresolved.
The White stratum retains the overall distrust–lower-efficacy pattern, the Asian stratum shows a stronger but irregular version of it, and the Black stratum has an opposite descriptive ordinal direction. This supports replication in the dominant stratum together with possible specification by ethnicity in the elaboration model. Sparse minority tables and different significance labels do not by themselves establish a population statistical interaction.
Each table fixes ethnicity and compares the efficacy conditional distributions across technology responses. The body percentages use the technology-response row total within that stratum. The same labels, coding direction and efficacy order apply as before. The strata contain 77, 57 and 2332 observations; they sum to 2466 and their cells reproduce the overall table exactly. Consequently the comparison is genuinely a stratification of the supplied overall counts, rather than a comparison of unrelated samples.
For Asian respondents, High efficacy is 78.95% among those who strongly disagree with the distrust statement, falling to 23.81% among those who disagree, 18.75% among neutral respondents and 19.05% among those who agree. The strong-disagreement versus agreement contrast is about 59.90 percentage points, based on 15 of 19 versus 4 of 21 respondents. This is a large descriptive contrast, but the rest of the table is not a simple monotone progression: Low efficacy peaks at 47.62% in Disagree, versus 10.53% in Strongly disagree, 18.75% in Neutral and 23.81% in Agree; Medium efficacy exceeds 57% in the last two rows. The striking first row is part of a more irregular categorical pattern.
The Asian Pearson chi-squared test of independence gives , 6 statistical degrees of freedom, . The likelihood-ratio test gives , ; its displayed 0.000 is a rounding convention. Cramér's V is about 0.430, compared with 0.148 overall. The generalized phi coefficient is 0.608 and the contingency coefficient 0.519. Two of twelve expected frequencies are below five, with minimum 4.156. This is a modest sparse-cell warning rather than a reason to delete the observed cells, but asymptotic calibration should still be qualified and could be checked by an exact or fixed-margin Monte Carlo test.
The Asian Goodman and Kruskal's gamma is about 0.323, from 1025 concordances and 524 discordances, so its displayed-order direction agrees with the overall association. Somers' D for efficacy given technology is about 0.226, Kendall's tau-b 0.241 and Stuart's tau-c 0.253. These stronger ordinal summaries do not imply that every individual row transition is monotone. Goodman and Kruskal's lambda is about 0.362 for predicting efficacy from technology and 0.286 in the reverse direction: the technology row changes the modal efficacy prediction sufficiently to reduce its errors by about 36.2%. This is a reduction in modal-classification errors, not a fraction of efficacy variance explained.
For Black respondents, High efficacy is 0 of 6, or 0%, in Strongly disagree; 8 of 24, or 33.33%, in Disagree; 2 of 15, or 13.33%, in Neutral; and 7 of 12, or 58.33%, in Agree. Low efficacy is 16.67%, 25.00%, 20.00% and 8.33%, respectively. The strongest-disagreement versus agreement High-efficacy contrast is therefore percentage points, opposite to the Asian and White contrasts. The zero observed High count in the first row does not prove zero population probability, especially with only six respondents in that row. These percentages are compatible with a reversed tendency, but considerable sampling uncertainty is unavoidable.
The Black Pearson chi-squared test of independence gives , 6 statistical degrees of freedom and . The likelihood-ratio test gives , , also above 5%. Thus neither nominal test rejects at 5%; this does not establish exact independence. Eight of twelve expected frequencies are below five, with minimum about 1.158, making the usual large-sample calibration particularly questionable. An exact conditional analysis or Monte Carlo test would be more defensible for a calibrated inferential claim; no uncomputed simulated p-value is asserted.[ref]
The Black Cramér's V is about 0.308, the generalized phi coefficient 0.435 and the contingency coefficient 0.399. An unsigned magnitude of this size can coexist with a nonsignificant test in a small sample. There are 254 concordances and 457 discordances, giving Goodman and Kruskal's gamma about , Somers' D about , Kendall's tau-b about and Stuart's tau-c about . Their negative signs agree with the reversed displayed-order direction. Goodman and Kruskal's lambda is about 0.107 for efficacy given technology and zero for technology given efficacy. In the latter direction, Disagree remains a modal technology category within every efficacy column, so modal prediction gains nothing despite the changed conditional percentages.
For White respondents, High efficacy decreases from 48.55% in Strongly disagree through 43.10% and 32.03% to 27.45% in Agree. The extreme-row contrast is about 21.11 percentage points, from 151 of 311 versus 188 of 685. Low efficacy is 21.22%, 17.10%, 21.57% and 35.04%, respectively. This closely resembles the overall distribution, including the fact that the Low category is not monotone at every step. The White Pearson chi-squared test of independence gives , 6 statistical degrees of freedom and ; the likelihood-ratio test gives , . All expected frequencies exceed 74, so sparse cells are not the problem for these nominal tests.
The White Cramér's V is about 0.152, the generalized phi coefficient 0.215 and the contingency coefficient 0.210. Goodman and Kruskal's gamma is about 0.236, Somers' D 0.155, Kendall's tau-b 0.162 and Stuart's tau-c 0.167: close to the overall ordinal summaries and in the same direction. The two values of Goodman and Kruskal's lambda are about 0.061 for efficacy given technology and 0.062 for technology given efficacy. They again indicate only a small improvement in modal prediction. The large sample size helps explain why the White test has a much smaller p-value than the smaller strata, without implying that its association magnitude is the largest.
The original figure below plots selected empirical conditional probabilities from all the cells. It gives the opposite small-stratum pattern and the dominant White pattern a common scale; it is not a reproduction of a source figure, an estimated continuous trend or a display of uncertainty intervals.
Figure 1.
Efficacy distributions across technology-distrust responses: contrasting ethnic strata and the pooled sample. Lines only connect the four ordered categories; group sizes and sparse cells limit inference.
Details.
The elaboration model asks how the original association changes when a third variable is held fixed. If the association disappeared throughout the strata, an explanation by the control variable might be plausible, subject to a credible causal ordering. Here it persists in the White group, which supplies 94.57% of the sample, and is stronger on several descriptive measures in the Asian group. Therefore ethnicity does not simply explain away the relationship. The White result is a replication of the broad pattern; the reversed Black direction and the Asian shape suggest descriptive specification or possible effect modification. The output supplies no temporal or causal design that would distinguish an actual causal mechanism from other confounding, measurement differences or sampling variation. It also does not demonstrate a Simpson's paradox in which the association reverses in every stratum: that is not what the displayed tables show.
The predominance of White respondents explains why the pooled pattern resembles theirs. By the law of total probability, each technology row's efficacy distribution is a mixture over ethnicity, using the ethnic proportions within that technology row. Those weights need not equal the overall ethnic proportions. As an optional descriptive comparison, standardization with common weights using the overall ethnic shares gives High-efficacy proportions of about 48.38% in Strongly disagree and 27.90% in Agree, a 20.48-percentage point contrast, compared with the crude 21.69-point contrast. This explicitly defined adjustment leaves the broad contrast intact; it is not a causal estimate and does not turn the three different stratum patterns into one common effect.
Finally, a significant test in one group and a nonsignificant test in another is not itself a test that the groups' associations differ. A formal statistical interaction requires a directly specified heterogeneity test or model on a chosen effect scale. The omnibus tests also address whole categorical distributions, whereas gamma and the High-efficacy contrast describe particular ordered features. Multiple stratum tests create a multiple testing issue if used to select a discovery. The defensible result is an association that survives stratification in the dominant group, with important descriptive heterogeneity that merits a direct, sparse-cell-aware investigation rather than an assertion that ethnicity causes the difference.
There are descriptive ethnic differences in the distribution of technology distrust, but the omnibus evidence is borderline and the unsigned association is small. The printed Pearson test just rejects independence at 5%, while the likelihood-ratio test does not; neither establishes a strong ethnic pattern or a causal effect.
Read the body percentages within each ethnic group. Strong disagreement with the distrust statement occurs among 24.68% of Asian respondents, 10.53% of Black respondents and 13.34% of White respondents. Agreement occurs among 27.27%, 21.05% and 29.37%, respectively. Neutral responses are 20.78%, 26.32% and 19.68%. Thus Asian respondents are especially likely to be in the strongly-disagree category, while Black respondents have the largest neutral share. The mode for Black and White respondents is Disagree; Asian respondents have a tie between Disagree and Agree at 21 observations each. The small group totals, 77 and 57, mean that a few observations can materially change the minority-group percentages.
The Pearson chi-squared test of independence has , statistical degrees of freedom and . Under its sampling assumptions, this is a nominal rejection at a prespecified 5% significance level, but not at 1%. The minimum expected frequency is about 7.766, so this particular table has no expected cell below five. The alternative likelihood-ratio test of independence in a contingency table gives and , printed as 0.074. These are different test statistics, not contradictory versions of the same calculation. Their different threshold decisions show that the evidence is close enough to the conventional boundary to warrant qualification rather than selection of the more favourable label.
The generalized phi coefficient is about 0.071, the contingency coefficient about 0.071 and Cramér's V about 0.051. They indicate a small overall unsigned association. This does not erase the particular descriptive percentage differences, and a small p-value is not a measure of their substantive size. Conversely, failure of the likelihood-ratio test to reject at 5% is not evidence that every ethnic group has exactly the same population response distribution.
Ethnicity is a nominal categorical variable, with no natural rank Asian–Black–White. Therefore the printed Goodman and Kruskal's gamma of 0.079, Somers' D of 0.058, Kendall's tau-b of 0.022 and Stuart's tau-c of 0.009 have no invariant substantive ordinal interpretation here. Permuting the ethnicity labels can change the ordinal pair comparisons without changing the underlying observations or their nominal association. These values are not evidence for an ethnic hierarchy; Cramér's V and the actual within-group percentages are appropriate summaries for this question.[ref]
Both directional values of Goodman and Kruskal's lambda are zero. Knowing ethnicity does not improve the number of correct modal predictions of technology response: Disagree remains a modal category within every ethnic group, including the Asian tie. In the reverse direction, White is the most frequent ethnicity within every technology-response column, so knowing technology does not improve modal ethnicity predictions either. Zero lambda therefore coexists with unequal conditional distributions and a nonzero Pearson chi-squared statistic; modal prediction discards changes that do not change the most frequent category. The supported conclusion is a small, weakly evidenced nominal association, with its descriptive pattern and uncertainty stated explicitly.
Greater technology distrust is associated with lower efficacy in the overall sample. The omnibus evidence against independence is strong, while the unsigned association magnitude is modest: on 6 statistical degrees of freedom, and Cramér's V about 0.148. The observational study does not establish that changing trust would cause efficacy to change.
Rows identify the technology response and columns identify efficacy. Each body percentage is a within-row conditional probability estimate, not a column percentage. For example, of those who strongly disagree with the distrust statement have High efficacy, whereas of those who agree do. The difference is about 21.69 percentage points. High efficacy decreases across all four rows: 49.40%, 42.41%, 31.02%, 27.72%. Low efficacy is 20.54% in the strongly-disagree row, 18.00% in Disagree, 21.43% in Neutral and 34.26% in Agree. Thus the overall pattern is clear without claiming that every category changes monotonically: the low-efficacy proportion initially falls, and the Medium proportion peaks at 47.55% among neutral respondents.
For the Pearson chi-squared test of independence, the null hypothesis says that the two categorical variables are independent, equivalently that the efficacy distribution is the same in every technology-response row. With row totals and column totals , the expected frequency under that hypothesis is , and
All twelve expected frequencies exceed 79, with minimum about 79.844, so sparse expected cells are not the concern here. Under independent sampling and the usual large-sample calibration, the very small p-value rejects independence at conventional significance levels. This is an omnibus finding: it does not provide a separate adjusted significance test for every pair of row percentages.[ref]
The likelihood-ratio test of independence in a contingency table uses . The supplied with 6 statistical degrees of freedom gives . Its displayed 0.000 is rounded, not an exact zero. It corroborates the omnibus finding. The generalized phi coefficient is , the contingency coefficient is about 0.205, and Cramér's V is . These are unsigned measures of association strength rather than three additional significance tests; they do not describe causal effects or percentages of variance explained. Their magnitude and the small p-value answer different questions, especially with a large sample size.
The ordinal measures use the displayed order: increasing row index means increasing distrust, while increasing column index means decreasing efficacy. There are 882033 concordant pairs and 552543 discordant pairs. Hence Goodman and Kruskal's gamma is
Its positive sign therefore means that increasing distrust tends to accompany movement toward lower efficacy. Under an ascending efficacy order its sign would be negative, by sign reversal under reversal of one ordinal ordering. Goodman and Kruskal's gamma ignores tied pairs; it is not a claim that 23% of efficacy variation is explained. The displayed pair counts partition all unordered pairs correctly, including ties. Somers' D for efficacy given technology is about 0.151, Kendall's tau-b about 0.158, and Stuart's tau-c about 0.163. Their different denominators handle ties or table dimensions differently, so their differing magnitudes do not constitute disagreement about the direction.[ref][ref]
Goodman and Kruskal's lambda concerns the proportional reduction in errors when predicting a most frequent category, not ordinal movement. Without technology information the modal efficacy category is Medium, producing errors. Choosing a separate modal efficacy category in each technology row yields errors. Thus . In the reverse prediction direction the reduction is , matching the other printed lambda. The improvement in modal classification is small even though independence is decisively rejected. Both the conditional percentages and these distinct summaries support a real sample association; ethnicity and other possible confounders still require attention before any causal account.
All three frequency tables describe 2466 valid observations with no reported missing values. The sample is overwhelmingly White, Medium is the most common efficacy category, and disagreement with the technology-failure statement is more common than agreement. These statements describe the sample rather than establish population composition or causal relationships.
In a frequency table, a count gives the number of observations in a category, and a percentage divides that count by the full sample total. A valid percentage instead uses the total with an observed value of that variable. Here the two denominators coincide because every table reports zero missing values. A cumulative percentage adds categories in the displayed order; its substantive meaning depends on whether that order is meaningful.
The ethnicity counts are 77 Asian, 57 Black and 2332 White respondents, or 3.12%, 2.31% and 94.57%. Ethnicity is a nominal categorical variable: the displayed order is not a low-to-high ethnic scale. Its cumulative percentages are bookkeeping for that listing rather than an interpretable ranking. The two minority groups are small relative to the White group, which will matter for the precision and expected cell counts of the stratified comparisons.
For the three-category efficacy measure, 908 observations are High, 972 Medium and 586 Low, giving 36.82%, 39.42% and 23.76%. Medium is the mode, and 76.24% fall in the combined High-or-Medium categories. This is an ordinal categorical variable, but the table does not imply equal numerical distances between categories. Its order is descending efficacy, High then Medium then Low. Therefore the cumulative 76.24% refers to that upper portion of the scale, not to the proportion at or below Medium under an ascending convention. The cutpoints used to form these categories are not supplied and need not be invented to interpret their frequencies.
For techfail_chr, 336 strongly disagree, 922 disagree, 490 are neutral and 718 agree: 13.63%, 37.39%, 19.87% and 29.12%. The wording concerns not trusting technology because it fails when needed. Thus moving toward Agree means more distrust, not more trust. Combining the two disagreement categories gives , versus 29.12% agreement and 19.87% neutrality. Adding the separately rounded displayed percentages gives 51.02%; the difference is ordinary rounding error. There is no displayed strongly-agree category, so its frequency cannot be inferred or added to the agreement count.
The technology percentages add to 100.01%, including the printed valid-total figure. The integer counts still sum exactly to 2466; rounded percentages need not sum exactly to 100%. Finally, three separate univariate frequency tables say nothing by themselves about which efficacy categories the trusting or distrusting respondents occupy. That requires the joint information in the later contingency tables.
Conditional on the printed two-group test output, the male-coded group has higher mean efficacy by about 1.034 scale points, with a 95% confidence interval of about 0.785 to 1.282 points. This is strong evidence against equal population means under the test's assumptions. It does not establish a causal effect, and the accompanying overall mean is inconsistent with the group summaries.
Here the coding identifies group 0 as male and group 1 as female in this dataset. The counts are 1215 and 1251, respectively, or approximately 49.27% and 50.73% of 2466 observations. These are sample compositions, not evidence that the sample represents every population of interest. The continuous efficacy scale runs from 0 to 16, with higher scores indicating stronger efficacy. Its printed sample median is 10 and its quartiles are 8 and 12, so its interquartile range is 4 points. The printed overall sample mean, 9.348, requires the separate consistency qualification below.
Let and denote the two population means. The null hypothesis is , and the alternative hypothesis is the two-sided test . The two sample means give
The positive sign means higher mean efficacy in group 0, given this coding; it does not say that every member of that group has higher efficacy than every member of group 1.
Welch's t-test estimates uncertainty from the two groups separately rather than assuming equal population variances:
The printed implies a standard error of approximately points. The noninteger 2277.4 statistical degrees of freedom comes from the Welch approximation; it is not a count of fractional observations. Using the corresponding Student t-distribution gives the displayed p-value, approximately . The test and interval calculations agree to the precision of the printed numbers.[ref]
A p-value is the probability, under the null hypothesis and the assumed sampling model, of a test result at least as incompatible with equal means as the observed result. It is not the probability that the null hypothesis is true, the probability that the finding is a chance mistake, or the size of the mean difference. At a prespecified significance level such as , this result rejects the equal-mean null hypothesis; it also rejects at 1%. A Type I error is rejection when that hypothesis is true, and a valid level- procedure controls its long-run probability. A Type II error is failure to reject a false hypothesis; statistical power is the probability of rejection under a specified alternative. Neither error probability for this one realized claim is supplied by its p-value.
The 95% confidence interval comes from , with critical value about 1.961. Its positive endpoints support the same direction and exclude zero. The frequentist 95% statement concerns coverage over repeated samples, not a 95% posterior probability assigned to this fixed interval. Reporting the difference in scale points supplies an effect size; its practical importance also depends on what a point means substantively. A very small p-value alone does not answer that question.
The inferential calculation requires independent observations and an appropriate sampling model. With these large groups, approximately normal sampling distributions of the means can be more plausible than normality of individual bounded scores, but a large sample size does not correct dependence, clustering, selection bias or measurement problems. The output does not establish random assignment or remove possible confounding, so the estimated difference is an association.
There is a material source inconsistency. For exhaustive groups with complete outcome data, the sample mean must be the sample-size-weighted mean of the group means:
which cannot round to 9.348. Figure 7 independently reports all 2466 efficacy values present and again gives 9.348; Question 6 refers back to the same continuous scale. The pooled-mean compatibility under rounding rules out explaining the discrepancy by the displayed decimal precision. Thus the two-group test supports the stated conclusion if its own group summaries and test fields are trusted, while the overall mean cannot simultaneously be accepted as a coherent summary of those groups. No unprinted exclusion or uniquely correct replacement mean is established.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact