Multiply the Sturm-Liouville form for by and subtract the equation for multiplied by . Integration gives
The boundary expression is zero because and the functions and first derivatives remain finite. Since are distinct positive integers, this proves
For the derivatives, apply integration by parts once to the same Sturm-Liouville form:
Thus the new weight is
This is derivative orthogonality when the Sturm-Liouville potential vanishes. For the derivative is identically zero, which is consistent with the identity.
Seek an integrating factor such that the differential expression becomes . Its leading coefficient requires , while the first-derivative coefficient requires . Thus
Choose the positive solution . The Sturm-Liouville form is therefore
with
The weight is positive on the open interval. The endpoints are singular because vanishes there, but the prescribed boundedness of makes the integration-by-parts boundary terms vanish.
Introduce a constant Lagrange multiplier for this isoperimetric constraint and make stationary. Its integrand is , so the Euler-Lagrange equation gives
The endpoint conditions therefore force a parabola . Its area and budget are
Solving the quadratic and choosing positive area gives
This requires ; no positive-area barrier is possible for a nonpositive budget. The corresponding multiplier is .
To verify a global maximum rather than just stationarity, use the sharp area-cost bound for a barrier with fixed endpoints. For , integration by parts gives , and . The Cauchy-Schwarz inequality implies
For the last expression increases strictly, yielding exactly the boxed upper bound. Equality requires proportional to , hence after imposing the endpoints. Thus the displayed optimum is unique and lies above the baseline throughout the interior.
The Fermat principle makes the optical path length stationary. For a graph the variational integrand is
The Euler-Lagrange equation is
Use the chain rule and differentiate to obtain
Multiplying through and combining the terms gives the required second-order ordinary differential equation with no derivatives in denominators:
All partial derivatives of the refractive index are evaluated along the ray.
A finite point is an ordinary point when the normal-form coefficients are analytic at . Then arbitrary values determine a convergent Taylor series, and two independent choices give two linearly independent local analytic solutions.
A singular point is a regular singular point when and extend analytically to . The Frobenius method then provides at least one solution
with a locally convergent analytic factor and an exponent fixed by the indicial equation. If its two indicial roots differ by a noninteger, there are two independent Frobenius solutions. For integer-separated roots a second solution may include a logarithm; a repeated root gives a Logarithmic Frobenius solution accompanying the single pure series. Such solutions need not be finite or ordinary Taylor series at the singular point.
Set . Partial fraction decomposition gives
Expand both terms as geometric series:
The two bracketed terms are complex conjugates. Using produces the required real coefficients:
The initial terms are . The nearest singularities are the simple poles , both at distance from the center. Hence the Taylor series has
Write and let its constant modulus be . If , then . For , differentiating with respect to and , then applying the Cauchy-Riemann equations, gives
Thus
The coefficient matrix has determinant , forcing . The Cauchy-Riemann equations then also give . Therefore are constant on a connected domain and
This proves the constant-modulus holomorphic function result. If a domain is disconnected, the conclusion applies separately to each connected component.
The Cauchy-Riemann equations are . They give the gradient identity
At a regular intersection, where , the two nonzero gradients are normal vectors to the two level sets, so their tangent directions are perpendicular. This is the orthogonality of regular real and imaginary level curves.
The regularity qualification is necessary: , so at a critical point both normals vanish and the curves need not have unique tangents. For example gives diagonal lines for and coordinate axes for , all meeting at the origin. Thus the conclusion is , rather than an unrestricted claim at critical points.
Since both real matrices are antisymmetric, and . Thus . Expand the two unitary identities:
Subtracting and adding give . Because has simple eigenvalues, each of its complex eigenspaces is one-dimensional. Commutation makes each one invariant under : if , then . Hence for some scalar . The complete eigenbasis of is therefore a common eigenbasis, which also diagonalizes .
The skew-Hermitian decomposition of a unitary matrix is explicit:
If , unitarity gives . Consequently
Equivalently, for the paired eigenvalues are . The hypotheses can only occur in even dimension: and is invertible, whereas an odd-dimensional skew-symmetric matrix has zero determinant.
To avoid confusing the diagonalizing matrix with the exponential, write from part (b). The convergent matrix exponential series gives
Each is purely imaginary, so . The diagonal exponential is therefore a unitary matrix, and
Hence the matrix called in this part is unitary. The series identity gives the same conclusion directly and also covers repeated eigenvalues.
Let and . The skew-Hermitian matrix property gives
where the last equality uses part (a). Distinct eigenvalues therefore imply . Normalize each eigenvector to length one. Since there are distinct eigenvalues, these vectors form an orthonormal basis.
Put them in the columns of . Then is a unitary matrix and , so
A skew-Hermitian matrix satisfies , where denotes the conjugate transpose. If with , then
Since , this gives .
A unitary matrix satisfies . It preserves the Hermitian inner product and norm. Thus if ,
and therefore . Zero is allowed among the purely imaginary eigenvalues in the first statement, but not among the unitary eigenvalues.
Expand the quadratic form of this Gram matrix:
For , linear independence of the real vectors implies , so its squared Euclidean norm is strictly positive. Thus
proving the positive definiteness of a Gram matrix in the independent-vector case.

There are unlisted articles, also show them or only show them.