The fitted simple linear regression is
Its regression slope is a predicted decrease of approximately 0.006314 trust-score units per extra year, or 0.06314 units per decade. This is an estimated statistical association between age and the score. A cross-sectional study does not establish that the same person's trust decreases at this rate as they age.
The estimated standard error of the slope is 0.005427. Testing a zero regression slope gives on 746 residual degrees of freedom and . An approximate 95% confidence interval is
There is insufficient evidence of a nonzero linear age association at the 5% level. The interval includes both small negative and small positive slopes; failure to reject does not establish an exactly zero relationship or rule out a nonlinear one.
The regression intercept 6.388920 predicts the score at age zero. That age is outside the observed 19–89 range, so interpreting it substantively would be extrapolation. Its very small reported p-value tests a zero intercept, rather than the age hypothesis. The 746 residual degrees of freedom correspond to 748 observations minus the intercept and slope.
The coefficient of determination is , so the fitted line explains approximately 0.1811% of the observed centered variation, rather than 18.11%. The adjusted coefficient of determination is approximately 0.0004732. The residual standard error is 2.602 score units, close to the reported response standard deviation; most variation remains unexplained by the fitted line. With one predictor and an intercept, the slope's F-test is the square of its Student's t-test statistic, up to printed rounding, so and agree with the slope test.
Output 6 is a residual-versus-fitted plot: its vertical coordinates should be regression residuals . The fitted values range over only approximately 5.83–6.27, as the weak slope predicts over ages 19–89. The printed scatter shows no obvious strong mean curvature or clear widening funnel, but it has marked horizontal concentrations near its extreme residual levels. An absence of obvious curvature does not prove a correct linear conditional mean, and the plot alone cannot establish homoscedasticity, independent errors or a normal distribution. A normal probability plot and residuals against observation order address different aspects. Large residuals also do not by themselves establish influential observations; regression leverage and Cook's distance matter.
There is an additional inconsistency in the original figure. The descriptive output reports observed responses between zero and ten, so residual constraints from a bounded response require
Yet the printed graphic contains points around , which would imply , above the stated observed maximum. Some lower-edge points likewise imply negative responses. This is present in the original PDF, rather than introduced by the transcription. The graphic therefore cannot be treated as a fully consistent diagnostic of the reported dataset. The observations about its visible shape above describe the supplied picture; reliable model checking would require the actual fitted values and residuals.
The printed code has separate typographical problems. The displayed model call supports the intended formula with ~, and the plot needs one closing parenthesis:
model1 <- lm(t_guard ~ age, data = exam)
plot(fitted(model1), residuals(model1),
     xlab = "Fitted values", ylab = "Residuals")
abline(h = 0)
These calls correct the syntax; they cannot be rerun on the original observations because the individual-level dataset is not supplied. The regression interpretation above uses the available numerical summaries and states the diagnostic limitation explicitly.
The regression diagnostics raise concerns about the mean and variance assumptions. The residual-versus-fitted smoother is curved rather than horizontal, and the scale-location plot suggests changing residual spread, contrary to homoscedasticity. Diagonal bands are expected when an integer-valued response is fitted by a continuous model, since each fixed response value gives . They are not, by themselves, proof of a failed mean model. The residual Q-Q plot is broadly linear but has tail departures and unusual observations, so exact normality is questionable.
The Cook's distance plot identifies observations worth checking for recording errors and influence on the age estimate. A rough screening threshold flags several points, but it is not an automatic deletion rule. Repeat the fit with and without influential observations as a sensitivity analysis and report material changes.
The bird random intercept Q-Q plot has a pronounced upper-tail departure; the year plot is closer to a line, although eleven groups give little power to assess normality. These plotted effects are estimated, shrunken conditional mode of Gaussian random effects, not independent observed draws from the latent normal distribution, so their appearance requires care.
The analysis is therefore provisional. Check a nonlinear age effect, the changing residual variance, dependence beyond the fitted random intercepts, and a response model appropriate for counts. If clutch size is known, a binomial distribution model for hatched eggs out of available eggs may be more meaningful. A bootstrap from the existing Gaussian model cannot validate the assumptions questioned by these plots. Distinguishing within-bird ageing from between-bird differences would also strengthen interpretation.
The missing output is needed to identify the actual regression formula, response column, transformations and coefficient estimates. A useful possible analysis regresses the maintained-school percentage among acceptances on the corresponding percentage among applications, allowing for year; it must be described as a model of college-level composition, not a direct estimate of individual acceptance probabilities.
For instance, if and are these two percentages, a normal linear model might specify , with a slope-by-year interaction term if needed. The intercept is the expected response at zero predictor, often an extrapolation; the slope is a percentage-point change in acceptance composition per percentage-point change in application composition. A slope of one is not by itself evidence of equal acceptance chances: equal chances within every college would give the entire relation , including zero intercept and no year shift. A fit with positive slope mainly confirms that applicant composition helps predict acceptance composition.
Regression diagnostics should include residuals versus fitted values and predictors, a residual normal Q-Q plot, checks of heteroscedasticity, regression leverage, studentized residuals and Cook's distance. The aggregate mature-college category merits an influence check and a sensitivity analysis: combining several colleges can conceal different within-college patterns. Repeated observations from the same college across years may have correlated errors, so treating them as independent needs justification. Check nonlinearity, the year interaction and the effects of excluding no observation except with a substantive reason.
Percentages are bounded, and their precision depends on their denominators. A simple weighted least squares or binomial analysis requires the underlying numbers accepted, not merely percentages. For a proportion based on people, the working variance is under independent sampling, rather than constant across colleges. If the predictor percentage is itself estimated, an ordinary regression also ignores its uncertainty. The supplied summaries cannot recover all four cells of each college contingency table or the actual fitted numerical output.
The published Cambridge percentage table nevertheless allows a descriptive comparison of acceptance rates. Write for the maintained-school proportion among applicants and for its proportion among acceptances. The relative risk from group compositions gives
The overall acceptance probability cancels by Bayes' theorem. This risk ratio compares acceptance probabilities; it is not the acceptance odds ratio, which also needs the overall acceptance probability.
For Christ's, the two published application/acceptance pairs give risk ratios and . If the displayed percentages were rounded to the nearest whole percentage point, the relative risk bounds from rounded group compositions give ranges approximately and . Thus both comparisons remain below one under that rounding assumption. These are descriptive comparisons of observed groups, without adjustment for applicant qualifications or a causal effect interpretation. The published compositions determine approximate relative acceptance rates, but not their standard errors or the original regression results.
The output must first identify the response scale and the formula. If the initial fit is ordinary least squares to the untransformed response with all fifteen predictors and an intercept, its normal linear model is
For full rank , the residual degrees of freedom are . The residual standard error is and estimated coefficient covariance is . A coefficient test divides the estimate by its standard error and compares with a reference distribution; the overall test of all fifteen slopes compares
with . The intercept-only residual sum is . Adjusted R-squared penalizes the loss of residual degrees of freedom, unlike ordinary .
Each regression coefficient measures a conditional association holding the other columns fixed. The southern-state indicator compares two state categories at equal values of all other predictors. Rescaling changes the units of a coefficient, so one cannot infer effects per original currency unit or per original percentage unit without the scaling information. If the actual formula uses , exponentiating a coefficient gives a multiplicative response change rather than an additive change; if both response and a predictor are logged, the slope is an elasticity. These interpretations cannot be interchanged.
The two police-expenditure variables are likely strongly associated and need a multicollinearity check: individual coefficients can be unstable even when their joint contribution predicts well. Their actual correlation should be calculated, not presumed numerically. Similar considerations apply to age-specific unemployment. With only 47 observations and up to 16 mean parameters, examine regression leverage, Cook's distance, residual distribution, variance versus fitted values, nonlinear effects and predictive cross-validation. State-level geographical dependence may also violate the independent-error model.
The observations are aggregate states. An association between a state covariate and crime rate is not an individual causal effect: ecological fallacy, confounding and reverse causation are relevant. For example, greater recorded crime can induce greater police expenditure. The absent coefficient table and model call prevent deciding which predictors were significant or even whether the fitted response was transformed. The preceding degrees of freedom and formula interpretations are conditional on the explicitly stated full linear-model specification.
Several finite-sample counterparts of the influence function should be distinguished. The empirical influence function substitutes the empirical distribution: . For a smooth M-estimator it is
It requires a well-defined derivative and nonsingular denominator. An unsmoothed empirical quantile functional, for example, need not admit the population-style density derivative.
The actual one-observation sensitivity curve is a finite difference:
It records contamination of size rather than an infinitesimal perturbation. For a smooth functional it approaches the population influence curve as the sample grows. A deletion counterpart uses , giving
The jackknife resampling pseudovalue is therefore approximately . The jackknife variance estimate corresponds asymptotically to for centered empirical influences.
In linear regression, Cook's distance measures the fitted-value effect of deleting a case. For coefficients, residual , leverage and variance estimate , its usual expression is . It illustrates that a case can be influential through both a large residual and high leverage. Finite perturbations and nonlinear refitting can differ materially from a first-order influence approximation; these diagnostics should not be conflated.
Put . Since , the regression residual vector is . A linear transformation of a multivariate normal distribution is again multivariate normal, so
This is a singular multivariate normal distribution supported on , with dimension . In particular,
Consequently regression residuals are neither independent nor identically distributed even under the stated model. Their linear constraints include , and, if the design matrix contains an intercept, their sum is zero.
Choose an orthonormal basis of the residual space. The coordinates of in that basis are independent variables, proving
For , is an unbiased estimator of . Orthogonality of and gives zero cross-covariance, so the Gaussian fitted and residual vectors are independent. This explains why an appropriate residual-versus-fitted diagnostic has no systematic mean relationship under the model. If , no residual information remains for these diagnostics or the variance estimate.
For , use standardized regression residuals to account for the different residual variances. The diagonal is the regression leverage; makes that residual identically zero and cannot be diagnosed by this standardization. With known , the corresponding individually standardized residual has an exact standard normal distribution. With estimated , the internally studentized residual is not exactly normal or a Student t-distribution, and the residuals remain correlated; a normal reference plot is a diagnostic approximation.
Plot the regression residuals or standardized regression residuals against fitted values and each covariate. A persistent curve suggests a misspecified mean, while a fan-shaped spread suggests heteroscedasticity; a scale-location plot helps separate these. A quantile-quantile plot against normal quantiles checks tails, skewness and possible regression outliers. Plot residuals against observation order or time to look for unexplained serial patterns, recognizing that projection already induces the displayed residual covariances. Inspect regression leverage together with Cook's distance for influential observations. Such patterns motivate revising the model; absence of a visible pattern does not prove all its assumptions.
Put , . Orthogonal projections of the Gaussian error give independent variables
Hence the exact confidence set is the ellipsoid
Here denotes the quantile of the F-distribution.
Let be the fit with observation removed, when that reduced design retains full rank. Cook's distance is
where is its residual and is its leverage. Thus measures the deleted estimate's distance from the full estimate in exactly the metric of the confidence ellipsoids. The deleted estimate lies on the confidence contour whose quantile equals ; this is a geometric influence diagnostic, not an assertion that itself has an law.
For , , so deletion moves the estimate outside the 50% confidence ellipsoid but inside the 90% one. The observation warrants investigation for influence: the shift is substantial, though the supplied figures do not justify calling it outside the 90% region. The reciprocal and the approximate chi-square figures are unnecessary.
Let be the flight distance in millimetres for paper level , launch-angle level , design level and replicate , where and . The full factorial design is fitted by the normal linear model
The assumptions are independent errors with a common variance and normal distribution, and the displayed factor-combination mean structure. The corner-point constraints are
and whenever at least one index equals . Thus the eight free mean coefficients are . These treatment coding coefficients are comparisons at the other factors' reference levels, rather than necessarily averaged main effects.
To test the three-factor interaction term, compare the full model with the model retaining all main effects and all two-factor interactions. The null hypothesis is , against a nonzero value. Removing it increases the residual sum of squares by and removes one parameter. With eight residual degrees of freedom, the nested-model F-test gives
There is no evidence that this three-factor interaction is needed. This does not establish that all two-factor interactions vanish: the paper-design interaction is substantial.
The stepAIC command performs stepwise selection by the Akaike information criterion. Its upper scope is the full factorial model and its lower scope is the intercept-only model. Starting from the full model, it compares admissible additions and deletions, preserving the hierarchy of interaction terms, and chooses changes that reduce the Akaike information criterion. With the supplied scope its default search permits both directions. For these Gaussian fits the displayed criterion, up to constants common to all models, is , where counts mean coefficients. The first deletion changes it from to : the small increase in residual sum of squares is outweighed by removing a parameter. This is a greedy model selection procedure, not an exhaustive search or a sequence of fixed-level hypothesis tests. The command's arguments are described in the MASS documentation.
For the selected model, let and . Then
independently between flights. It has no angle term. The maximum-likelihood estimates of its mean coefficients are also obtained by ordinary least squares:
For example, the four fitted means are just the four paper-design cell means, each averaging four flights over the angle levels. With , the variance-covariance matrix of the coefficient estimates is . Its diagonal gives the displayed standard errors; their ratios are , with mm.
The final line of summary(model2.lm) is the joint nested-model F-test of , comparing this four-parameter model with a common mean. Its statistic is
with F-distribution under the fixed-model null and P-value . Thus the selected paper-design terms jointly improve the fit substantially. The coefficient of determination means they account for about of the observed centred variation. These nominal inferential summaries do not adjust for the preceding model selection on the same data.
Using the unrounded fitted means gives
in millimetres. Hence choose the high-performance design with the lighter paper; the fitted model leaves both launch angles tied, with expected distance about mm. A preference for one angle is not supported by this selected model. The strong paper-design interaction reverses the design comparison: the simple design is better on heavy paper, whereas the high-performance design is better on light paper. Consequently a single design effect averaged over paper types would conceal the main result. There is little evidence here for an angle effect, and considerable flight-to-flight variability remains.
Before fitting, inspect raw-distance dot plots for all eight factor combinations, and interaction plots of cell means against design, with separate lines for paper and panels for angle. With only two replicates per cell, showing individual observations is more informative than elaborate box plots. These reveal reversals, spread and possible unusual flights. Afterwards inspect a residual-versus-fitted plot, a Q-Q plot of residuals, a scale-location plot, residuals against each factor and, if recorded, flight order, and Cook's distance for influential observations. Residual patterns by angle would question its deletion, while unequal spread or departures from the normal distribution would question the error assumptions rather than merely demand another mean term.
For the normal linear model, the log-likelihood is
The full column rank of the design matrix makes invertible. Differentiating in gives the normal equations . With the minimized residual sum of squares substituted, differentiation in gives
These are the maximum-likelihood estimators almost surely; almost surely when and . The linear transformation of the multivariate normal distribution yields
Define the hat matrix . The fitted values are , the regression residuals are , and . The orthogonal projection has rank and annihilates . By Cochran's theorem,
Consequently , with bias . The unbiased estimator is
Its square root, the reported residual standard error, estimates ; the assertion of unbiasedness applies to the variance, not generally to its square root.
For the paper-strength analysis, let be the measured percentage and . Both normal linear models use independent errors of common variance . Their mean functions are for lm1, and for lm2, with separately fitted coefficients. The reported residual standard errors are and , respectively.
For lm1, the estimated conditional expectation at a new percentage is
The original data mean must be used for centering the new percentage; its numerical value is not supplied in the excerpt. Because , the two columns of this design matrix are orthogonal, and . Hence the coefficient standard errors in the output give
This estimates uncertainty in the mean. Predicting an individual future batch would additionally require the new-error variance, estimated by .
To compare the nested normal linear models, test against within the quadratic model. The Student t-test statistic is
Its two-sided p-value is . Equivalently is a partial F-test statistic with null distribution . Reject the linear restriction and prefer lm2 at the 5% level. Its residual spread is much smaller; the increase in the coefficient of determination from to supports the same conclusion, although the test is the relevant complexity-adjusted comparison.
For regression diagnostics, inspect regression residuals against fitted means and hardwood percentage for omitted curvature, a scale-location plot for nonconstant variance, and a quantile-quantile plot against the normal distribution for departures from the error assumption. Check unusual observations using regression leverage and Cook's distance, and examine residuals in collection or batch order if dependence is plausible. Independence and a common variance require substantive justification as well as these plots; a small p-value for a polynomial term does not itself check the error model.
The ordinary least squares objective has gradient . The normal equation therefore gives
The Gram matrix is a positive-definite matrix because has full column rank. More explicitly, for any ,
since . This proves that the displayed solution is the unique global minimum.
The fitted values are , where the hat matrix is
The inverse of the symmetric matrix is symmetric, so . Multiplication gives . Thus is the orthogonal projection onto the column space of the design matrix.
The regression residual vector is with . Consequently , , and the residual sum of squares is
By fitted-residual orthogonality, . Using , the cross-covariance matrix is
Both vectors are jointly normal, so they are also independent by independence of uncorrelated jointly normal variables. The zero covariance calculation itself only needs the common error variance and lack of error correlations.
For the first wind fit, let be wind velocity and electrical output. The simple linear regression is , with independent . It has two fitted mean parameters and residual degrees of freedom. The missing analysis of variance entries are therefore velocity degrees of freedom , velocity mean square , and residual degrees of freedom . The residual mean square is , and , consistent with the printed value after rounding.
Because the model includes a regression intercept, the coefficient of determination is the explained sum of squares divided by the total centered sum of squares:
A large coefficient of determination does not rule out a wrong mean function. In the PDF's first residual-versus-fitted plot, residuals are negative at both ends and positive in the middle. This curved pattern agrees with the visibly flattening output-versus-velocity relationship and motivates a polynomial regression with a quadratic term.
The second wind model is , again with independent common-variance normal errors. Its fitted mean is . The line marked (A) is a two-sided Student t-test of against , conditional on retaining the intercept and linear term. Under the null hypothesis,
Its two-sided p-value is . This is far below , so reject a purely linear mean in favour of the quadratic fit. Equivalently, the extra-term nested-model F-test has and null law .
The third fit is a reciprocal-predictor regression, , with estimated mean . It has two mean parameters rather than the quadratic model's three. Its residual standard error is smaller, versus , and its coefficient of determination is larger, versus . The corresponding residual sums of squares are approximately and . The reciprocal fit is preferable on both these fit measures and parsimony. The two models are not nested, so an ordinary extra-term F-test between them is inappropriate. On the common normal-error likelihood, the difference also favours the third model.
Neither lower residual sum of squares nor a higher coefficient of determination establishes adequate assumptions. The quadratic residual-versus-fitted plot removes the original pronounced curvature; the reciprocal plot also has no comparably obvious mean trend. The low-output residuals appear somewhat more spread out, so check scale-location plots and residuals against velocity for heteroscedasticity. Q-Q plots assess normality; residuals against observation order assess serial dependence; regression leverage and Cook's distance identify influential observations. Further cross-validation, replicate observations at comparable velocities, and prediction errors would help choose between their extrapolation behaviours. Both fitted shapes should be judged principally over the observed positive-velocity range.
The statistician first models the age- and gender-dependent mean by linear regression. Its fitted value is . At fixed gender, a year of age is associated with a decrease of BMI units; the group coded gender has a fitted mean units above the group coded at the same age. This question does not state which gender receives which code. The intercept refers to age zero in the reference group, outside a typical adult-patient range, so its substantive interpretation is limited. Both slope Student t-tests have small p-values, and the overall F-test supports an age/gender-dependent mean. The coefficient of determination is only , leaving considerable individual variation to investigate.
The residual diagnostics check whether mean adjustment is plausible and whether a single normal error law is adequate. The residual-versus-fitted plot has no strong curved mean trend, although its smooth curve is not perfectly flat. The scale-location plot suggests some decline in spread as fitted BMI increases, so common residual variance is a working approximation rather than an established fact. The normal Q-Q plot has systematic departures, notably shorter tails than the normal reference, suggesting the residual law is not exactly normal. The regression leverage plot does not display an obviously extreme leverage point, but the marked observations and Cook's distance should still be checked for influence. Independence between patients cannot be diagnosed from these four plots alone.
Next the statistician extracts the regression residuals and fits an intercept-only normal model as a baseline residual distribution. With an intercept in the original ordinary least squares model, the residuals sum to zero by the normal equation; the near-zero fitted residual mean and its are therefore automatic, not new evidence of good fit. The standard error in this refit uses degrees of freedom, whereas the original uses after estimating three regression coefficients. The reported log-likelihood for the single-normal residual model is .
The histogram suggests a shape worth exploring beyond one normal density, with broad shoulders and some asymmetry, without showing unambiguous separated clusters. The statistician fits two- and three-component finite Gaussian mixtures with a common variance by the expectation-maximization algorithm, starting from separated means and positive weights. Successive likelihoods increase and the displayed final iterations stabilize, as expected from EM likelihood monotonicity. This is evidence of numerical convergence from those starts, not proof of a global maximum.
The two-component fit assigns weights , residual means and common variance . The three-component fit assigns weights , residual means and common variance . The code correctly passes the square roots of those variances to dnorm and overlays the resulting weighted densities. Both curves broadly follow the histogram and are very similar. In particular, a two-component mixture need not have two distinct visible modes.
These fits explore residual mixture clustering: groups differ in BMI relative to the same age/gender-adjusted mean, rather than simply in raw BMI. Membership can be summarized by the fitted mixture responsibilities, retaining uncertainty instead of asserting a certain label for each patient. The common-variance assumption is economical, but should be checked; the common regression slope assumption and constancy of mixture proportions across age and gender are also substantive. A residual mixture alone does not establish genuine biological subpopulations; a flexible continuous distribution, missing predictors, nonlinear mean effects or heteroscedasticity could explain a similar marginal shape.
There is also a two-stage residual mixture fitting limitation. Fitted regression residuals are not exactly independent identically distributed observations: even under a normal regression, their covariance matrix is , and estimating the mean adjustment introduces uncertainty. With subjects and three initial regression coefficients, treating them as independent is a useful approximation for exploring shape, but ordinary mixture likelihoods omit the first-stage uncertainty. A joint mixture regression with shared slopes, or a suitable bootstrap of the whole analysis, would give a firmer basis for parameter uncertainty and cluster selection. Examine component membership versus age/gender and repeat the algorithm from multiple starts before making substantive clustering claims.
Check that the chosen mean structure adequately describes the transformed response. Examine the residual-versus-fitted plot and residuals versus each predictor: systematic curvature suggests omitted nonlinear effects or an interaction term. Plot residual spread against fitted values, for example using a scale-location plot, to assess homoscedasticity. Compare standardized residuals with a normal distribution using a quantile-quantile plot, especially for finite-sample Student's t-distribution and F-test inference.
Also check independence using the sampling design and residuals versus time, collection site, or other groups; spatially related photovoltaic systems may have correlated errors that are invisible in a residual-versus-fitted plot. Investigate large standardized regression residuals, high regression leverage, and influential observations using Cook's distance. Check that the design matrix has full rank and that severe multicollinearity is not making estimates unstable. Reassess whether the response transformation and retained predictors improve these diagnostics and prediction; a coefficient p-value alone cannot establish model adequacy. If observations are independent only conditional on site effects, use an appropriate dependence model rather than treating correlated systems as independent replicates.
The dashed curves are contours of constant Cook's distance, labelled 0.5 and 1, in the plot of standardized residual against regression leverage. Writing for the diagonal of the hat matrix, for the residual variance estimate, and for the number of fitted coefficients,
Thus a contour has . On the actual PDF plot, observation 579 has leverage about 0.084 and standardized residual about , lying beyond the contour and below in influence magnitude, approximately to from the plotted coordinates. It is unusually light relative to its fitted log-weight and potentially influential because deleting it can materially change fitted coefficients. It warrants checking, not automatic deletion. The solid smooth red curve is distinct from the dashed Cook's distance contours.
Let be the least-squares estimate after deleting observation , and put and . Cook's distance is
Thus is the squared displacement caused by deleting observation , measured in the same metric and scale as the confidence ellipsoid. In particular, lies outside the ellipsoid centered at exactly when
Regression diagnostics Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-07
Regression diagnostics check assumptions and influential observations in a fitted regression function. Residual-versus-fitted plots can reveal omitted mean structure or nonconstant variance; a quantile-quantile plot checks a specified error distribution. Regression leverage measures unusual predictor configurations, and Cook's distance combines leverage and residual size to measure coefficient sensitivity. Independence may require checking collection order and the study design in addition to residual plots.
Residual-versus-fitted plot Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-14
A residual-versus-fitted plot displays residuals vertically against predicted responses horizontally. Curvature suggests an incorrect conditional-mean model; a fan-shaped spread suggests heteroscedasticity, while isolated large residuals may indicate unusual observations. It does not alone measure leverage or influence: regression leverage records unusual predictor combinations, and Cook's distance combines leverage and residual size.
The figure in coefficient of determination shows why the plot is useful: subtracting the fitted linear trend makes a small curved component easy to see. A visible pattern supplies a reason to investigate the model, while the absence of a pattern in a small sample does not establish that all assumptions hold. Other views address other questions: regression residuals against observation order can reveal temporal dependence, and a normal probability plot examines distributional shape. NIST's statistical handbook develops this use of graphical residual analysis for model validation. [ref]