For the isothermal equation of state, , with constant isothermal sound speed . A nonzero steady plane-parallel flow has constant mass flux . Choose the positive flow direction for convenience. The continuity equation then gives , and the steady Euler momentum equation becomes
Integrating and absorbing the reference velocity into the constant yields, for the Mach number ,
For the opposite flow direction use ; the same relation holds.
A smooth sonic point has , so its momentum equation requires . Moreover satisfies , and has its minimum . Thus, if the flow reaches at ,
A sonic crossing is therefore possible at a maximum of the potential, with
At a nondegenerate maximum, the expansions give . Choosing either smooth sign gives a crossing slope , joining a subsonic flow to a supersonic flow, or the reverse. This establishes the plane-parallel isothermal sonic transition at a potential maximum. For a globally defined crossing, the same maximum must also be high enough for the Bernoulli relation to remain real over the intended domain.
Write the inward radial velocity as , with . Steady spherical mass conservation and the radial Euler equations for an inviscid fluid give
For a barotropic fluid, define the sound speed and the barotropic enthalpy function by . Choosing , integration gives the Bernoulli equation
The continuity equation gives . Eliminating mass density from the momentum equation produces the barotropic spherical accretion equation
The sonic point is where the inward Mach number equals one. A smooth solution cannot cross the vanishing coefficient on the left with a nonzero right-hand side, so a regular sonic radius must obey
Conversely a continuous flow that is subsonic at infinity and supersonic inward must cross unit Mach number; smooth passage selects a simultaneous zero of the two sides, hence a regular sonic point. The associated critical accretion branch, rather than an arbitrary subsonic solution with smaller flux, is selected by these outer and inner requirements.
For the polytropic equation of state, set to distinguish its exponent from any separately specified perturbation exponent. Assume and first take the usual positive index . Then
For the attractive mixed potential, assume . The sonic condition and Bernoulli equation give
Hence polytropic accretion in a mixed inverse-power potential reduces to
For all nonzero coefficients in the left side are nonnegative for , with at least one strictly positive: there is no finite positive root. For the constant term is negative and the leading coefficient positive, giving exactly one positive root. Define and . Then
This is the finite-radius transonic range for the two positive attractive terms.
The critical point has real distinct crossing slopes. To check this rather than just solve the sonic equalities, put , and . Differentiating the barotropic spherical accretion equation at its simultaneous zero gives
Its discriminant is . The sonic Bernoulli equation says , so this discriminant is strictly positive for . The accretion crossing is the slope for which , namely the smaller root. The two slopes have opposite signs of this Mach-number derivative. This is the regular transonic saddle, not a singular vertical tangent.
The corresponding mass accretion rate follows without an additional arbitrary mass density normalization:
One may equivalently replace by . With a nonzero term, inner free fall has and continuity gives . Thus increases without bound precisely in the positive-index range , consistent with the required inner supersonic branch.
The assumptions on the parameters matter. If and , the finite sonic radius instead requires , the usual Bondi accretion range; is the zero-radius limiting critical case. If and , the condition remains . With arbitrary signs of , one must use the quadratic and retain only positive roots with and real admissible crossing slopes; attraction was not explicitly given as a sign condition in the source.
If positive polytropic index was not intended as an implicit physical convention, there is a further mathematical range. For , positive compressibility also permits , giving . Both potential terms attractive then give a positive sonic root as well:
The same mass accretion rate formula applies; its crossing-slope discriminant is positive. The range has and no physical acoustic sonic point, has constant pressure and zero sound speed, and does not define the printed equation of state. Thus the usual answer assumes and positive attractive coefficients; these conventions should not be confused with additional printed restrictions.
Let the fluid approach a uniform, quiescent state at infinity. Use the outward unit normal vector , pointing from the object into the fluid. Write for the Heaviside step function, , and . With the viscous stress tensor , define
Thus is the Lighthill stress tensor, and is the surface loading exerted on the fluid. The total force on the object has the opposite sign. Extend by zero inside the object. Since the boundary is fixed and impermeable, , and the distributional mass conservation and momentum conservation equations are
For example, the surface contribution to the momentum equation is . Differentiating the first equation in time and subtracting the divergence of the second gives the fixed-body Ffowcs Williams-Hawkings equation:
There is no acoustic thickness noise: a fixed impermeable boundary injects no mass. Apply the retarded acoustic Green function , where . The supplied surface-delta identity converts the loading term to a surface integral. For an exterior observer, the required integral equation is
This acoustic analogy is an exact rearrangement of the fluid equations; source approximations enter later. In the distant linear acoustic region, .
The acoustic far field requires observer distance much larger than the source extent and , so derivatives of the retarded phase dominate derivatives of . The acoustic compact-source approximation requires , so the source's differential propagation delays can be neglected. These conditions concern different lengths and neither implies the other. Put , , and define the loading and stress moments
The leading compact acoustic far field is
The surface term is an acoustic dipole; the volume term is an acoustic quadrupole. The plus sign of the loading term follows from the minus sign of its spatial divergence and the derivative of retarded time.
For the power comparison, assume low Mach number , high Reynolds number, eddy size , characteristic time , and stress magnitude . Keep the prescribed turbulent region and its leading volume stress comparable when inserting the object; neglect changes of source statistics and exceptional cancellations of the leading moments. Compactness follows from . Since and the outgoing acoustic intensity is , the volume power is
If the object's size is comparable to and its fluctuating resultant loading is , then
Angular factors and dimensionless loading coefficients have been omitted. The acoustic dipole and acoustic quadrupole interference vanishes in the leading power integrated over a full sphere, by odd angular parity; individual directions can show interference.
A size threshold also requires a loading model. For a small nonseparating object of size in an approximately inviscid, smoothly varying incident eddy, a spatially uniform pressure has zero resultant on its closed surface. The first surviving loading is the pressure-gradient or added mass force, . Under these explicitly stated assumptions,
The two mechanisms become comparable at ; for smaller objects the cases with and without the object have the same leading order of power. This is the small-body loading-noise threshold. It is not a geometry-independent size law: a separated drag force fluctuating on the original eddy time instead gives and . If both force and time are set by body-scale eddies, , their loading power is and comparison with the original volume source gives . Each estimate states which source time and force it uses.
The physical distinction is momentum conservation. Unforced turbulence in a fluid supplies internal stresses, whose net-force contribution cancels and leaves acoustic quadrupole radiation. The supported object exchanges momentum with the fluid and the external support, permitting a time-dependent resultant force and acoustic dipole radiation. One fewer retarded derivative makes the loading radiation more efficient at low Mach number.
In the Ffowcs Williams-Hawkings equation, the other source types are a surface acoustic monopole associated with acoustic thickness noise, and a volume acoustic quadrupole involving the Lighthill stress tensor. On an impermeable material surface, fluid and surface normal velocities agree. There is no through-surface mass-flux source; the remaining thickness source is . For a rigid body, the leading acoustic compact-source approximation to that source has
Thus there is no leading net-volume acoustic monopole. To neglect thickness radiation beyond that leading cancellation, assume negligible volume displacement, as for ideal thin blades, or that its higher multipoles are small compared with the retained acoustic loading noise. Rigidity alone does not make a moving finite-volume body's local thickness source identically zero.
The volume acoustic quadrupole may be neglected for low Mach number motion when exterior turbulent or nonlinear stresses do not provide a competing strong source. We also assume small linear acoustics perturbations, a uniform reference sound speed, and negligible relevant viscous and entropy sources. These are source-strength approximations, particularly important if a loading contribution itself cancels by symmetry. Under them, the retained acoustic dipole is the force exerted by the object on the fluid, with the sign used in the previous solution.
Let , , and . In the acoustic far field, is large compared with the object and . For a source of size with and small surface Mach number, source-dependent delays and the Doppler factor can be neglected to leading order. The surface integral then contains just the total force . Differentiating its retarded time, rather than its spreading factor, gives the radiating term
The sign follows from . Differentiating or the direction instead produces the lower-order near field. A constant total force does not radiate at this leading compact order.
The rotation introduces angular frequency and, after combining the two blades, harmonics such as . The acoustic compact-source approximation requires the propagation time to be small compared with . Thus
It also bounds every blade element's Mach number by . Consequently , and its leading value is one. The separate acoustic far field condition is .
Choose the positive rotation sense so that a first blade at phase has radial and tangential unit vectors
Integrating the given line force from to yields . Its axial component is constant, while . Since , the compact acoustic dipole sound from this blade is
The other blade has phase and contributes the opposite rotating force. At a common compact retarded time, their total force is , so
This cancellation calls for the next source-delay correction; it does not mean that the complete moving-source field vanishes.
At a finite smooth sonic point , the equation from (a) requires
Set and . Substitution into the Bernoulli function gives
An inflow from a warm reservoir at infinity has ; an outflow reaching infinity has . Therefore a nondegenerate transonic spherical flow in a power-law potential requires
For the usual range , the critical adiabatic exponent for spherical power-law flow is consequently
The printed assumption also permits . In that range the boxed inequality holds for every finite : there is no finite upper bound. Equivalently, take for . Extending the rational expression beyond would give an incorrect restriction.
The strict inequality also follows from local sonic-point slope discriminant analysis, including the potentially cold zero-energy endpoint. Put . Since mass conservation implies , differentiating the sonic point equation at yields
Its discriminant is . Moreover, the logarithmic Mach number derivative at the sonic point is
A genuine crossing has two distinct branches and a nonzero derivative. At equality the crossing degenerates. In particular, for and , mass conservation and the polytropic equation of state make the Mach number constant along the scale-invariant solution; a solution that is sonic there is sonic everywhere, rather than crossing an isolated sonic point.
Use complex amplitudes with time dependence , so the outgoing two-dimensional Helmholtz equation kernel has phase . Dividing the harmonic form of Lighthill acoustic analogy by and integrating the two source derivatives by parts gives an amplitude proportional to
Only the magnitude is needed here; the specified kernel omits its constant phase and normalization. In the acoustic compact-source approximation, . With , hence , the two-dimensional compact quadrupole scaling is
The half-power difference from three dimensions comes from cylindrical spreading, including its factor. As in part (i), the Mach number power is stated with the geometrical range factor separated; is still required.
Let , , and let the source have size . The retarded acoustic Green function gives the outgoing solution of Lighthill acoustic analogy as
This follows by integrating the source derivatives by parts in the retarded convolution. Assume the source is localized and the boundary terms vanish. In the acoustic compact-source approximation, , the retardation across the source can be neglected, while permits replacement of the denominator by . The integral becomes .
In the radiation region , derivatives of the retarded argument dominate derivatives of the spreading factor. Since , the leading acoustic quadrupole field is
The two negative retardation derivatives give a positive sign. This is a far-field approximation, with smaller near-field terms omitted.
For low-Mach number aerodynamic fluctuations of speed and advective time , take , , and two time derivatives of order . Therefore
The quoted fourth power is the compact acoustic quadrupole Mach-number scaling, with geometric spreading shown explicitly. It assumes the source strength and time scale just stated; the source must be acoustically compact, and the observation point must remain in the radiation region.
Apply the moving-interface conservation jump identity first to mass, then to each momentum component. Write and , with all quantities understood piecewise on the two sides. Define the jumps of flux relative to the moving shock wave by
The global distributional conservation equations are
Differentiate the first in time and subtract the divergence of the second. With and the piecewise Lighthill stress tensor , this gives
Derivatives act on the complete distributions, including their moving support. The acoustic quadrupole term represents momentum-stress fluctuations throughout the volume. The time derivative of the surface mass-flux defect is an acoustic monopole, representing injection or removal of mass/volume. The divergence of the surface momentum-flux defect is an acoustic dipole, representing a force sheet. This is the distributional acoustic analogy across a moving interface.
For an actual freely propagating fluid shock wave with no singular mass or momentum supply, the Rankine-Hugoniot conditions give and . Such a shock does not acquire independent monopole and force-sheet sources merely because it is discontinuous. Its effects remain in the distributional derivatives of , including singular derivatives of its jump. Nonzero surface sources are appropriate for an interface with exchange/forcing or for a formulation that omits one side of the fluid.
A shock does not, by itself, justify retaining the scaling. That estimate required a low-Mach number stress varying on the slow time . Fast shock motion, short time scales, or thermodynamic deviations can invalidate that estimate. If these same compact, slow-source assumptions remain valid for the integrated Lighthill stress tensor, its quadrupole estimate still follows, even distributionally. There is no universal replacement power deducible from the mere presence of a shock; nor should vanished physical flux defects be treated as additional independent radiation sources.
Use the Fourier transform convention . Let , choosing on the real contour with . For time dependence , this is the decaying continuation of the outgoing Sommerfeld radiation condition.
The transformed Helmholtz equation has upper and lower solutions and . The two kinematic traces give , hence
The elastic membrane equation gives . Therefore the acoustic wave on a tensioned massive membrane has dispersion relation
Equivalently, . The fluid on both sides supplies a positive added mass of an evanescent fluid layer, which is a useful independent check on the sign. In particular, the incident pressure is
The symbol here denotes elastic membrane mass per area, rather than the fluctuating Mach number used in Question 1.
Let be specific internal energy, the heat supplied per unit volume per unit time, and . For an inviscid perfect gas in a prescribed Newtonian gravitational potential , the fluid total-energy equation is
There is no gravitational term if no external body is present. For a time-independent , adding potential energy gives the equivalent conservative form . Subtracting the kinetic-energy equation and using mass conservation gives
For a perfect gas with constant specific-heat ratio , . The isothermal equation of state therefore makes constant. Hence the required heat supply and heat loss are
Compression requires cooling; expansion requires heating. The isothermal sound speed differs from the adiabatic sound speed .
Define the isothermal Mach numbers by . Orient the normal to a stationary isothermal shock along the flow, so the mass flux . Tangential velocity is continuous for this planar hydrodynamic shock. Normal momentum conservation gives
For a genuine discontinuity , factorization gives . Thus the isothermal shock jump relations are
Across a thin shock, gravitational potential and tangential kinetic energy are unchanged. The specific enthalpy is the same on both sides, so the energy removed per unit area per unit time is
Positive net cooling requires , equivalently and . Cooling across an isothermal shock permits only compression shocks; the formal expansion discontinuity requires energy supplied by the surroundings. The continuous state is not a shock.
For steady radial flow, mass conservation gives . Differentiating it and eliminating the mass density gradient from radial momentum balance gives
A regular sonic point has , so the right-hand side must vanish there as well. Therefore
This is the Bondi sonic point for accretion; the same critical radius appears in an isothermal Parker wind. A general steady solution need not pass through a sonic point, but a smooth transonic one must obey both critical conditions.
Put and on a branch whose flow direction is fixed. The radial equation becomes
Integrating yields the integrated isothermal Bondi flow relation:
For a transonic branch, gives . Expansion about the critical point gives , with slope for inflow supplied by gas at rest at infinity and slope for a transonic outflow.
For Isothermal Bondi accretion, integrate radial momentum balance once more, using and at infinity:
At the Bondi sonic point, and , so . The positive inward isothermal Bondi accretion rate is consequently
The critical mass density and rate are fixed by the regular transonic solution and the specified reservoir at infinity; an arbitrary subsonic solution does not share this accretion rate.
Use for the radial speed and distinguish the central mass from the Mach number . In each smooth nonzero-flow region, mass conservation, the adiabatic equation of state, and the Bernoulli equation give
Here is constant on a smooth isentropic flow branch, is the adiabatic sound speed, and is the Bernoulli function. Either sign of is possible. The positive-radius nondimensionalization in the question requires ; flows with do not have these positive and require another scaling.
Indeed, the supplied adiabatic process equations give , so is spatially constant along a steady nonzero radial fluid flow. The adiabatic sound speed is , and the specific enthalpy is . The radial Euler momentum equation, , integrates to because on this isentropic flow branch.
Put . Eliminating the mass density from the continuity equation gives
With , the Bernoulli equation becomes
Therefore the physical constants of the spherical polytropic flow with adiabatic exponent three halves are
For , , so decreases from infinity to its unique minimum , then increases to infinity. This completely determines the algebraic curves. For , there are two disconnected branches at every , one subsonic flow with and one supersonic flow with . For , the line and a decreasing branch meet at . Their slopes are and , since the leading expansion is . For , solutions exist only where : if solve , there is a forbidden interval . At either endpoint the two branches turn at and have an infinite slope.
A smooth sonic point needs ; hence a regular sonic transition requires and . The critical speed of a polytropic flow is then , and the allowed mass flux is . Here the subscript on denotes evaluation at the sonic point, rather than the isothermal sound speed convention used in the next solution.
The simple transonic branch is . Direct substitution gives
Thus the radial velocity has constant magnitude, while the mass density and pressure scale as and . For an outward fluid flow, this is a subsonic flow becoming a supersonic flow as its adiabatic sound speed decreases.
On the other transonic branch, decreases as increases. At large , the terms and dominate, giving . At small , the terms and dominate, giving . The resulting asymptotic expansions are
For inward fluid flow, these are the nearly static reservoir at infinity and the inner free fall region of Bondi accretion. The specific enthalpy is smaller than in the inner limit, which explains free fall. Reversing the radial velocity gives a decelerating outflow with the same profiles. The formal small- limit describes the point-mass model: if the spherical gravitating body has a finite surface, the exterior solution stops there.
A stationary, nonradiative normal shock wave conserves the mass flux and the sum , while the Newtonian gravitational potential is continuous across its thin layer. Hence and are unchanged. The entropy production in a perfect-gas shock increases , so
More explicitly, the Rankine-Hugoniot condition for gives, with upstream ,
Thus the shock wave jumps vertically, at the same , from the supersonic flow to a subsonic flow on a larger- curve. The figure illustrates an outward flow on with a shock wave at ; the downstream subsonic flow has and continues to larger . The shock wave radius is an additional boundary-data choice, rather than being determined by the smooth equations alone.
Figure 1.
Transonic curves and a stationary shock
. Solid blue curves have ; grey curves have ; orange curves have the downstream shock value . The vertical arrow is a supersonic-to-subsonic jump at fixed radius. Details.
A regular sonic point must make both sides of the flow equation vanish:
Substituting into the Bernoulli equation yields
For , positive finite sound speed therefore requires the critical adiabatic index for dipolar accretion
To check that this gives real regular crossings, differentiate the flow equation at the sonic point and put . The transonic accretion in a power-law tube calculation gives
The minus sign gives the transonic branch whose Mach number increases inward. At the positive-energy reservoir cannot match a finite sonic point; for larger the required is negative. A physical surface-crossing solution also requires and validity of the narrow flux tube approximation up to the sonic region.
Take to be the inward radial speed and select the regular critical solution for a gas reservoir of density and adiabatic sound speed . Other mathematically subsonic steady solutions need a different inner boundary condition. For the polytropic equation of state, let , so
Mass conservation and the Bernoulli equation give
The gas is at rest at infinity, so its kinetic and gravitational terms vanish there.
Differentiate these two conserved quantities, using . Eliminating the density derivative yields the polytropic Bondi accretion equation
At a regular sonic point, both sides vanish:
The Bernoulli equation at that point reduces to . For , equivalently ,
Since , the critical density is . Evaluate the conserved mass accretion rate at the sonic point:
where
The isothermal limit gives , agreeing with Isothermal Bondi accretion.
For , and the Newtonian critical radius tends to zero while diverges. The limiting critical solution approaches Mach number one only as ; it has no finite-radius Newtonian sonic transition. This is a failure of the Newtonian inner approximation, not an obstruction to accretion onto a black hole. A physical Schwarzschild black hole has a finite event horizon, and the regular relativistic inflow becomes supersonic outside it.
The singular-looking factor in the rate has a finite limit. Writing , its logarithm is , so the critical Bondi accretion rate for gamma equals five thirds is
This is also the leading cold-reservoir limit of relativistic spherical accretion; an exact rate for relativistically hot gas requires the relativistic equations, not this Newtonian expression.
For completeness, the finite relativistic sonic point can be seen without assigning it an arbitrary inner radius. Let denote the relativistic squared sound speed and . For an isentropic relativistic gas with , its dimensionless specific enthalpy is . Conservation of rest-mass flux and relativistic Bernoulli energy gives the critical relations
For and , expansion gives , hence
Here the asymptotic relativistic and Newtonian sound speeds agree to leading order. This finite-radius transition explains why the gas can reach the horizon despite the Newtonian result.
Let denote the inward speed. Steady spherical mass conservation and the radial momentum equation for an isothermal gas give
Eliminating produces the Isothermal Bondi equation
A smooth flow can cross Mach number one only where both sides vanish. Its Bondi sonic point is therefore
The integrated Bernoulli equation which approaches rest and density at infinity is
At the sonic point this gives , and hence the unique regular transonic branch has
Let be the inward radial speed. Steady spherical Bondi accretion conserves mass:
For , and the adiabatic sound speed satisfies . Matching the reservoir therefore gives
The Bernoulli integral is
Writing the Mach number as and eliminating with mass conservation gives
Multiplication of the Bernoulli equation by now yields
where