Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 1 1 b Solution 2026-10-20
Apply the final splitter only to the first ket. The amplitudes from and cancel, givingThus detection at occurs only in the coincidence , with probability . The other two nonzero coincidence probabilities are and . The cancellation is quantum interference between indistinguishable surviving alternatives.
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 1 1 c Solution 2026-10-20
Interchanging the two wings givesNow detection at occurs only together with , with probability . The remaining nonzero coincidence probabilities are and .
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 1 1 d Solution 2026-10-20
Applying both final splitters givesThe charged-particle coincidence probabilities are in the displayed order, and the annihilation probability remains . In particularConditioning on surviving pairs would change this number to ; it would not change the amplitudes of the unconditioned all-trials state above.
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 1 1 Solution 2026-10-20
Outcome determinism means that a complete hidden state , together with the chosen measurement settings, fixes each outcome. The observed probabilities can still arise from an ensemble of unknown . This differs from deterministic unitary evolution of a wavefunction, which does not by itself specify a unique measurement outcome. Quantum nonlocality means failure of a Bell-local account of the correlations, under assumptions including measurement independence; it is stronger than the existence of entanglement and does not imply controllable faster-than-light signaling.
Use the first ket for the Positron and the second for the electron. Before either final beam splitter, the first pair of splitters and annihilation produceThe photon state is orthogonal to the surviving charged-particle sector. Its probability is , while the remaining sector has squared norm . The states below retain that photon amplitude and are normalized over all trials, without conditioning on nonannihilation. For compactness write , and similarly for .
In a deterministic local hidden-variable model, write or without an argument for the remote splitter setting. That omission is the parameter independence assumption: the local response for a fixed complete hidden state does not change when the other wing changes its apparatus. Measurement independence also requires the hidden-state ensemble to be independent of the freely selected settings, allowing the same assignments to be compared across configurations.
The zero probabilities derived above then constrain those assignments, apart from sets of hidden states of zero measure:
- Case requires .
- Case requires .
- Case requires .
For a trial with , the last two implications force , contradicting the first condition. Thus these deterministic local assignments predict zero probability for the double- event, whereas quantum theory predicts . This is Hardy's paradox, an inequality-free ideal contradiction. With imperfect apparatus the zero-event conditions become small nonzero rates and require a statistical inequality rather than declaring a contradiction from one imperfect detection.[ref]
Quantum mechanics, local realistic theories, and Lorentz-invariant realistic theories by Lucien Hardy. 1992 abstract: a two-particle proof of Bell's theorem without inequalities
The logical contradiction combines counterfactual hidden-variable assignments; it does not assign simultaneously observed path properties to a quantum state. Nor does it allow a message to be sent by changing a distant splitter: the observable local marginal obeys quantum no-signalling. For example, fixing the plus-side splitter to gives for either minus-side setting in the results above.
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 1 2 Solution 2026-10-20
Set , and , with . The ordered vectors are normalized but nonorthogonal, since . Their coordinate Gram matrix is thereforeAn operator matrix in this basis is obtained from the coefficients in the images of its basis vectors, not by treating those vectors as orthogonal measurement outcomes. Directly applying the two reflection operators givesTheir columns are consequentlyThese are physical unitary operators even though the coordinate matrices are not unitary in the ordinary Euclidean coordinate norm: they preserve , so .
The Grover iteration in a nonorthogonal basis isIt has determinant one and trace , hence eigenvalues . For example, the invertible matrix of eigenvectorssatisfiesThis diagonalization is exact for ; no large- approximation is needed.
To extract an actual probability using the Born rule, introduce the orthonormal unmarked superposition . In the ordered basis , the same iteration is the rotationAfter iterations,Equivalently the original coordinates are . The overlap with is the first coordinate plus times the second, recovering the same amplitude. Squaring just the first coordinate would be incorrect in a nonorthogonal basis.
For large , , and dropping the initial angle gives the requested approximation . The first near-unit success occurs at the integer closest to :One can choose , with either neighbor equivalent in a tie. Further iterations overshoot and reduce success rather than monotonically improving it. The special problem needs no search and the two-vector coordinate construction becomes singular.
For an unstructured search, a reversible Boolean quantum oracle implements a phase change on the marked entry, while the diffusion reflection about a uniform state is known. Repeating the pair of reflections amplifies the marked amplitude and measurement yields a candidate that can be checked by another oracle query. The bounded-error query count is for one marked item, compared with classical queries. It is a quadratic oracle-query speedup: state preparation, the cost of implementing the oracle and access to a classical database still matter. The method does not reveal an unknown marked value without the promised query access.[ref]
A fast quantum mechanical algorithm for database search by Lov Grover. 1996 abstract and search construction
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2013 Paper 1 3 c Solution 2026-10-20
Quantum cryptography includes quantum key distribution, which uses quantum transmissions and authenticated public discussion to establish a secret random key. In BB84, the sender independently chooses a random bit and either the computational or Hadamard basis, sending one of . A receiver independently chooses one of those two bases. They announce bases after receipt, retain matching-basis positions and reveal a random sample of those bits to estimate noise or eavesdropping. Ideal uniform independent basis choices retain about half of the detected signals before testing and further processing.[ref]
Quantum cryptography: Public key distribution and coin tossing by Charles H. Bennett and Gilles Brassard. 1984 key-distribution protocol; original proceedings pp. 175–179
The no-cloning theorem prevents an adversary from copying arbitrary unknown nonorthogonal signal states perfectly. In a simple intercept–resend attack, the adversary chooses a random protocol basis. On half of the sifted positions it is the wrong basis, and the resent state then yields an erroneous receiver bit with probability one half. Thus the BB84 intercept-resend error rate isif every signal is intercepted, or when an independently selected fraction is attacked this way. This is an illustrative attack calculation, not a security proof against all possible quantum attacks.
After parameter estimation, classical error reconciliation aligns the remaining keys; privacy amplification compresses them to remove the adversary's bounded information, including information leaked during public reconciliation. The classical channel requires message authentication, otherwise an attacker could impersonate each party to the other. Real sources, losses, multiphoton pulses and detector behavior must fit the security model. A low observed error rate alone is insufficient to certify arbitrary hardware. Finally the protocol distributes a key; encrypting a later message is a separate step.
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 1 3 a Solution 2026-10-20
Consistent histories assigns probabilities to suitably compatible sequences of quantum alternatives without making an external measuring apparatus fundamental. At successive times choose complete orthogonal sets of projection operators. In the Heisenberg picture, a history has class operator . For an initial density operator , its decoherence functional isA common sufficient consistency condition is for . Then is nonnegative and coarse-grained alternatives have additive probabilities: the interference cross-terms vanish. The weaker requirement on real cross-terms can suffice for individual probability sum rules. Predictions must stay within one compatible framework; mutually incompatible history families cannot simply be combined into one classical account.
The many-worlds interpretation instead treats unitary quantum evolution as universally valid and interprets the correlated outcome branches as components of one global state. A measurement interaction givesWhen the environment records become nearly orthogonal, quantum decoherence suppresses observable interference between stable apparatus records. Each relative state contains an observer correlated with a definite record; no additional physical collapse is postulated. Branch structure is an emergent approximation, rather than a unique literal splitting at every arbitrary choice of basis.
Both approaches use the ordinary unitary formalism and decoherence, but their interpretations of histories and branches differ. Decoherence alone does not prove that one unique branch is selected, nor does the unitary equation by itself settle every assumption needed to justify Born rule probabilities. Neither interpretation predicts ordinary interference experiments incorrectly merely by interpreting the same state differently.
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 1 3 b Solution 2026-10-20
In quantum teleportation, Alice transfers an arbitrary unknown qubit using one shared Bell pair and two bits of classical communication. Define , with . Regrouping the initial three-qubit state into this Bell basis givesAlice's Bell-basis measurement selects each label with probability . She sends to Bob, who applies the inverse , restoring . The correction depends on the measurement label, not on the unknown amplitudes. Before the message, Bob's average state is , independent of the input; quantum no-signalling therefore prevents superluminal communication. The shared pair is consumed and Alice does not retain an independent copy, in agreement with the no-cloning theorem.
The Bouwmeester quantum teleportation experiment used photon polarization, a down-conversion entangled pair, a beam-splitter Bell-state analyzer and coincidence-conditioned output polarization measurements. Temporal indistinguishability of the two analyzer photons was essential. Its successful selected Bell outcome demonstrated the state transfer, rather than a deterministic implementation of all four outcomes.[ref]
Experimental quantum teleportation by Dik Bouwmeester and others. 1997, experimental realization and Figures 1–5
The general experimental tasks are to distribute entanglement, prepare and synchronize the input, perform a sufficiently discriminating joint measurement, communicate the label and apply or account for the correction. A demonstration must test nonorthogonal input states, not merely transfer a known classical basis label. Finite efficiency, accidental coincidences, distinguishability and phase drift reduce success probability or teleportation fidelity. Postselected verification, a heralded usable output and unconditional deterministic teleportation are distinct experimental claims.
Past exam of the quantum information course of the University of Cambridge 2014 Paper 1 3 c Solution 2026-10-20
Schrödinger's cat exposes the quantum measurement problem by correlating a microscopic alternative with macroscopically distinct records. Under unitary evolution a schematic state becomesThe difficulty is explaining why a definite macroscopic outcome is observed if the isolated total state is always governed by the linear Schrödinger equation. It is not a claim that one classically contradictory record has literally been observed. Environmental interactions rapidly entangle the records with different environment states, making their reduced density matrix approximately diagonal. That explains the practical loss of interference but does not, by itself, turn a global pure superposition into a selected single branch.
Wigner's friend places an observer's physical memory inside the quantum description. A friend measuring can become correlated asConditioned on one friend record, the corresponding relative state contains a definite outcome. An external observer applying unitary theory to the perfectly isolated entire laboratory instead assigns the entangled vector . In principle, a coherent joint measurement could distinguish it from the collapsed mixturewhereas projecting the pure state onto succeeds with probability one. Preserving that laboratory coherence, including all records and environment correlations, is an extreme idealization for macroscopic observers.
The paradox concerns how state assignment, definite records and universal unitary dynamics fit together. It does not show that an observer can send messages faster than light or that consciousness must be given a special dynamical role. The many-worlds interpretation retains the global unitary state with branch-relative records; interpretations with a physical collapse must specify when and how unitary evolution changes. Stating the chosen assumptions prevents the friend's conditional state and the external observer's unconditioned state from being treated as the same mathematical object.
For a nonzero quantum state and a self-adjoint operator , the expectation value and standard deviation of its measurement areThe squared deviation is also called the variance of the observable. All displayed products are understood on quantum states for which the relevant moments exist. Self-adjointness gives , so is real. Expanding the squared norm gives the variance expression. A norm is nonnegative and is zero exactly for the zero vector, hence precisely when . Thus zero dispersion is equivalent to being an eigenstate.
For bounded , the operator exponential is the norm-convergent power seriesFor a general unbounded self-adjoint Hamiltonian operator, the spectral theorem defines the same notation byThis definition does not require the power series to converge on every quantum state. complex conjugation of the spectral multiplier gives , and multiplication of the phases gives . Thus is unitary, preserves the quantum state norm, and has .
For initial data in the domain of , differentiating the spectral expression yields . Consequentlysolves the Schrödinger equation with the prescribed initial quantum state. Uniqueness follows by differentiating : the two terms cancel, leaving the constant .
In the two-dimensional energy basis, expand the initial quantum state as . Each energy eigenvector receives its own phase under the operator exponential, givingThis is the general solution because every initial vector has a unique basis expansion.
In that orthonormal basis the other observable has the real symmetric matrixIts conjugate transpose equals itself, so it is self-adjoint. Also and , giving eigenvalues and . Direct substitution gives the normalized orthogonal eigenvectorsAn irrelevant global phase may multiply either vector. With the chosen lower eigenstate initially,The Born rule says that the probability for the higher eigenstate is . Its amplitude is . Using givesThis is the transition probability for a rotated two-level observable. Its time dependence comes from the relative phase between two energy eigenstates. If their energies coincide, or if the measured observable has the energy eigenvectors as its eigenvectors, this transition probability is zero at all times.
Use periodic plane waves on the ring. For ,They are orthonormal on one circumference and complete by Fourier series. Thus , with degeneracy : the two signs of nonzero angular momentum have the same energy. Equivalently one may use normalized sine and cosine eigenfunctions for each positive .
For the position measurement put . Direct integration givesThe energy measurement requires projection onto whole degenerate eigenspaces, rather than just onto one traveling wave. The expansion coefficients areFor instance the imaginary integral vanishes by reflection about , and the product-to-sum identity evaluates the real integral as . ConsequentlyEvery numerator is positive and no integer makes a denominator zero, so every energy has nonzero probability. Parseval's identity guarantees that these probabilities sum to one. The supplied state is a valid normalized periodic state; its derivative need not obey the operator-domain periodic condition for the spectral probabilities to be defined.
Write , and , for nonnegative integer . The angular Laplacian satisfies . Direct radial differentiation givesBecause , the contribution cancels the Coulomb potential in the Hamiltonian. ThereforeThe volume element contributes . The squared state factors into radial, polar and uniform azimuthal densities, so the angular normalization cancels in every radial expectation. With ,The supplied integration-by-parts recurrence gives . HenceIn particular . Put . Chebyshev's inequality gives
For the polar variable set . The polar density is proportional to , soAn exact expression for the requested tail, as well as its useful estimate, isThe inequality is Markov's inequality applied to . If a finite expression is desired, expand : the numerator is and the denominator is the same sum with .
By the union bound, with probability at least both and . The height above the equatorial plane is then at most . The cylindrical radius differs from by at most . Thus the distance from the circle of radius in the equatorial plane is with probability tending to one. This is relative concentration around a growing circle; it does not assert an absolutely shrinking thickness. The probability concentration of a circular Coulomb eigenstate is a precise version of the large-angular-momentum orbit picture.
Inside the infinite well, the time-independent Schrödinger equation is with Dirichlet endpoints. Negative or zero energy gives no nonzero solution satisfying both endpoints. For , the sine solution requires . ThusThe normalization follows from . These functions form an orthonormal basis. Substitute the expansion into and take the inner product with each basis vector: orthonormality gives , equivalentlyFor a general infinite expansion this is interpreted in the usual Hamiltonian domain or its unitary evolution; the particular state below has only two terms.
Put . The identity gives , , all others zero. Their squared magnitudes sum to one. HenceThe evolved state is . Its position probability includes an interference term with frequency . Specifically,The three required integrals are , and , respectively. ThereforeThe energy expectation is constant while the spatial probability oscillates, because relative energy phases affect interference but not the energy probabilities.
Let . Multiplication of the radial equation by gives . With the constant terms cancel, leavingThe indicial equation is , with roots and . The usual physical Coulomb radial origin condition selects : it imposes the regular reduced radial boundary condition . Normalizability alone at the origin is insufficient to make this selection when an irregular branch is locally square-integrable, notably at .
Write . Coefficient comparison givesA nonterminating regular series has the exponentially growing asymptotic branch, suggested by : it supplies an component, which the prefactor cannot normalize. Equivalently the regular confluent-hypergeometric solution grows unless its first parameter is a nonpositive integer. Thus a bound state requires the numerator to vanish at some , givingThis is series-termination quantization of the Coulomb radial equation. It requires for the assumed ; at there are no such negative-energy Coulomb bound states.
For , . The angular integral cancels when computing , while the radial volume element contributes . ConsequentlyThe ratio follows by one integration by parts and remains valid for real ; no integer-only factorial identity is needed. Since now ,For a classical particle with that negative total energy, nonnegative kinetic energy requires , hence . This is a necessary radial bound; extra angular momentum can impose a stronger restriction.
At , and the classical boundary is . The normalized radial probability density is . With , the exterior quantum probability isThe final integration gives . This is the nonzero quantum tail beyond the classical turning region.
For classical events, : an outcome in but not in either fails or belongs to . Monotonicity and the union bound prove the Fréchet-Bell inequalityMalus' law gives transmission for a photon polarized by the first filter, so its conditional rejection probability at the second is . Conditional and joint probabilities must be distinguished: .
For equal unbiased marginals , the quantum two-setting rejection probabilities are . A classical common assignment of all three outcomes would therefore require . Choose directions . ThenFor example gives . More generally . In a triangle whose side directions are these filters, the internal angle supplementary to is obtuse exactly in this violation range. This specifies the angle convention behind the triangle description: with polarization axes regarded as unoriented lines, a claim that every sufficiently large physical axis separation violates the inequality would not be correct. The contradiction concerns a single classical joint model for all settings, not the validity of ordinary probability or a comparison of arbitrarily renormalized sequential experiments.
Use and . Projecting the first photon with gives the unnormalized product vector , with success probability . Projection of the second onto givesConditioned on success, normalize these vectors; a zero amplitude means that outcome never occurs. For the maximally entangled equal-amplitude pair, rotation of both real polarization bases gives the same correlations for arbitrary settings. Comparing the appropriately normalized coincidence/rejection frequencies at three setting pairs tests the inequality above. A general unequal-amplitude state need not reproduce the unbiased rotationally invariant probabilities, so the maximally entangled choice supplies the clean explicit example.
For swapping, label the four systems in order and let . Its overlap with is . Applying its rank-one projector to Alice's two systems givesAfter regrouping the remote and local systems, this factorizes into . The selected outcome has probability . Therefore the normalized conditional remote state isIt has Schmidt rank at least two whenever the original pair was entangled, since squaring a nonzero coefficient does not make it zero. Thus the two photons that never interacted become entangled conditional on Alice's joint measurement outcome. This is entanglement swapping. Alice is projecting onto a specified Bell state, not performing a universal test of whether an arbitrary unknown state is entangled. Averaging all her outcomes leaves the remote reduced density operator unchanged, so no faster-than-light signal is available without her classical outcome label.
On Rabi resonance, and , soFor nonzero drive the probability starts at zero, reaches unity at , and repeats with period . The population oscillation therefore has angular frequency . This is complete resonant Rabi transfer; a drive of zero strength gives no transition.
Use the orthonormal energy eigenstates of the infinite square well,The identity resolves the initial wavefunction into . Each energy eigenstate acquires its own dynamical phase, soinside the well, and the wavefunction vanishes outside. The energy probabilities are and at every time. ConsequentlyFor the left half, each diagonal integral is , whileThe interference term therefore yieldsThis probability lies between approximately and , with period . A conserved energy distribution is compatible with time-dependent position probabilities because the relative quantum phase keeps evolving.
For classical events, : an outcome in but not in either fails or belongs to . Monotonicity and the union bound prove the Fréchet-Bell inequalityMalus' law gives transmission for a photon polarized by the first filter, so its conditional rejection probability at the second is . Conditional and joint probabilities must be distinguished: .
For equal unbiased marginals , the quantum two-setting rejection probabilities are . A classical common assignment of all three outcomes would therefore require . Choose directions . ThenFor example gives . More generally . In a triangle whose side directions are these filters, the internal angle supplementary to is obtuse exactly in this violation range. This specifies the angle convention behind the triangle description: with polarization axes regarded as unoriented lines, a claim that every sufficiently large physical axis separation violates the inequality would not be correct. The contradiction concerns a single classical joint model for all settings, not the validity of ordinary probability or a comparison of arbitrarily renormalized sequential experiments.
Use and . Projecting the first photon with gives the unnormalized product vector , with success probability . Projection of the second onto givesConditioned on success, normalize these vectors; a zero amplitude means that outcome never occurs. For the maximally entangled equal-amplitude pair, rotation of both real polarization bases gives the same correlations for arbitrary settings. Comparing the appropriately normalized coincidence/rejection frequencies at three setting pairs tests the inequality above. A general unequal-amplitude state need not reproduce the unbiased rotationally invariant probabilities, so the maximally entangled choice supplies the clean explicit example.
For swapping, label the four systems in order and let . Its overlap with is . Applying its rank-one projector to Alice's two systems givesAfter regrouping the remote and local systems, this factorizes into . The selected outcome has probability . Therefore the normalized conditional remote state isIt has Schmidt rank at least two whenever the original pair was entangled, since squaring a nonzero coefficient does not make it zero. Thus the two photons that never interacted become entangled conditional on Alice's joint measurement outcome. This is entanglement swapping. Alice is projecting onto a specified Bell state, not performing a universal test of whether an arbitrary unknown state is entangled. Averaging all her outcomes leaves the remote reduced density operator unchanged, so no faster-than-light signal is available without her classical outcome label.
At the midpoint the second sine vanishes, whereas the derivative of the first sine vanishes. Thus the wavefunction and its spatial derivative simplify toSubstitution in the probability current givesThe continuity equation, integrated over the left half, gives . The Dirichlet boundary condition makes , and the preceding probability formula givesPositive midpoint current removes probability from the left half. This is precisely the midpoint current of a two-mode box state.
Interference between the first two box modes transfers probability between the two halves; midpoint current is minus the derivative of left-half probability
. Details. 


