In a complex semisimple Lie algebra whose rank of a semisimple Lie algebra is , a root vector satisfies . To see this, select roots whose images form a basis of the real root span modulo , where . Take the highest endpoints of the root strings through both signs of each selected root. Their distinct root spaces commute with . Together with and , these give independent vectors in the Lie algebra centralizer.
Chevalley basis 2026-10-14
A Chevalley basis of a complex semisimple Lie algebra consists of suitable coroot elements and one vector in each root space, chosen so all Lie bracket structure constants are integers. In particular when the sum is a root, with where is the last negative-direction root in the root string. For independent roots with no root sum the bracket is zero. The integral lattice makes reduction to other fields possible.
For the antidiagonal symmetric matrix in dimension , put and . The diagonal Cartan subalgebra has coordinates . The root spaces of weights are spanned by ; those of weights by , with negative-root spaces given by transposes. The condition gives these generators directly and excludes roots .
Nondegeneracy of the Killing form on a Cartan subalgebra Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-07
For a complex semisimple Lie algebra, the Cartan subalgebra is orthogonal under the Killing form to every nonzero root space. A vector in the Cartan subalgebra orthogonal to that whole subalgebra is therefore orthogonal to the entire Lie algebra and must vanish. On the Cartan subalgebra the form is .
The complex Special orthogonal Lie algebra consists of endomorphisms preserving a nondegenerate symmetric bilinear form infinitesimally:
In an orthonormal basis this is , with the commutator bracket and dimension . Its compact real form is obtained by taking real skew-symmetric matrices. For diagonal root calculations it is more convenient to use an isotropic basis with , including .
A maximal torus of the complex special orthogonal group is
Its Lie algebra is the Cartan subalgebra
In the compact real form the corresponding torus consists of independent rotations in two orthogonal coordinate planes, fixing the remaining direction. Define for , and , .
Writing for the matrix unit in the isotropic basis, lies in and satisfies
Thus the nonzero root spaces are one-dimensional and the root-space decomposition is
Explicit generators for four positive root spaces are
The transposes of these matrices generate the negative root spaces. Each transpose still satisfies the bilinear-form condition and reverses the displayed diagonal weight. These eight root vectors and the two independent Cartan matrices exhaust the dimension ten; a matrix commuting with every is diagonal and the form condition makes it lie in . This also proves that the torus has maximal dimension.
The displayed torus-only Weyl integration formula needs to be a class function, meaning . This hypothesis is implicit in the usual formula but is not printed here. We prove the general version for a continuous function, then specialize:
Here and are probability Haar measures; is the invariant probability measure on the homogeneous space ; and is the finite Weyl group.
We use the following standard maximal-torus facts, as permitted: every element of a connected compact Lie group lies in some maximal torus; all maximal tori are conjugate; two elements of a fixed are conjugate in exactly when they are in the same -orbit; and the complexified Lie algebra decomposes into and one-dimensional root spaces. Opposite roots of a root system give real two-dimensional planes in . At an element for which no root character has value one, the identity component of its centralizer is .
Choose a positive root system . Regard each root as a character through the Adjoint representation. A convenient globally defined denominator is
The usual Weyl denominator additionally has a unit-modulus factor , with half the sum of positive roots. Where that half-weight is not a global torus character, it may be interpreted on a covering torus; the squared modulus is nevertheless unambiguous. In either convention,
Average an inner product on over the Adjoint representation to make it invariant. It defines a bi-invariant Riemannian metric on and the quotient metric on . Consider the conjugation map
At , identify the source tangent directions with and , and translate the target tangent vector to the identity by . Differentiating gives
The two summands are orthogonal. On a real root plane, is a rotation with complex eigenvalues . Thus the absolute real Jacobian determinant on this plane is . The torus direction contributes one. Therefore the conjugation Jacobian for a compact Lie group is
This is also the Jacobian for the normalized measures: the Riemannian submersion has fibers isometric to , so ; the probability-volume normalization factors cancel.
Let be the elements for which . The restriction of is a local diffeomorphism onto the regular elements of . It is -to-one. Indeed, fixing , any pair with has , because conjugation identifies the identity components of the two centralizers. Thus , and there is exactly one pair for each coset in . This argument does not require the full centralizer of to be connected.
The nonregular locus has measure zero. In it is a finite union of sets of smaller dimension; their conjugation images are images of smaller-dimensional manifolds under , and hence have zero volume in . The change-of-variables formula for the regular covering therefore gives
For a class function, the inner integral is , proving the required formula with its correct hypothesis.
Without conjugation invariance, the torus-only expression can be false. For with diagonal , take . It vanishes on , whereas its group integral is : the two squared coordinates of a Haar-distributed unit column have equal means and sum to one. Thus the conjugacy average cannot simply be dropped.
For a Cartan-Weyl basis, the Jacobi identity gives
Thus the bracket has joint Cartan weight . If , it belongs to the zero-weight space, which is the Cartan subalgebra, and so is a linear combination . If is a nonzero root, its root space is one-dimensional and the bracket is proportional to . If that nonzero sum is not a root, the bracket vanishes. This proves the asserted forms without assuming every pair of roots has a root sum.
With the stated normalization, put . The commutators become
The adjoint relations make , , the usual SU(2) Lie algebra generators. Hence every finite-dimensional SU(2) irreducible component has eigenvalues , with an integer. Therefore has integer eigenvalues , including in the finite-dimensional Adjoint representation. Algebraically this is the sl2 subalgebra associated with a root.
If , another use of the Jacobi identity gives
The bracket is therefore zero or lies in the eigenvalue- space. Within one irreducible SU(2) ladder it is proportional to the next chosen vector . If the full eigenspace has multiplicity, the weight statement is the general one; proportionality to one named vector presupposes the ladder choice. Similarly lowers this eigenvalue by two, and the ladder weights run from to in steps of two.
For a root vector , its weight is
The adjoint SU(2) ladder therefore proves
For nonparallel , raising and lowering move its joint Cartan weight through the root string . The finite irreducible ladder has weights symmetric about zero. Starting at , reaching its partner requires . The corresponding nonzero vector lies in the root space of , proving the Weyl reflection property:
There is no zero joint root in this string when are nonparallel. Its one-dimensional root spaces prevent two irreducible ladders with the same weight parity from overlapping, so the ladder argument applies to the entire string. For , reflection simply interchanges the two opposite roots, which already exist by the adjoint relation.
For angle and length restrictions, set and . These Cartan integers have the same sign when nonzero and obey
For nonparallel, nonorthogonal roots, is an integer strictly between zero and four. The possibilities are consequently:
  • : , equal lengths, and or .
  • : , squared-length ratio or , and or .
  • : , squared-length ratio or , and or .
Orthogonal roots have and . Parallel roots have ; the integer pairs would allow only length multiples . The stated reducedness condition excludes the latter two, so parallel roots are equal or opposite, with angles zero or and equal lengths. Thus
Not every root system realizes every listed angle.
The orthogonal pair alone gives no ratio through . To finish the length restriction for a simple Lie algebra, use irreducibility of its root system. Let span the Weyl group orbit of . Both and are invariant under the orthogonal root reflections. If a root had nonzero projections in both, reflection of its projection in would have a nonzero component, violating invariance. Hence every root is entirely in one of these subspaces. A proper nonzero would split the root system into two orthogonal parts, contradicting irreducibility. This proves that the Weyl orbit spans an irreducible root space.
In particular, some orbit root is nonorthogonal to any chosen , and . Applying the previous integer-pair restriction to therefore also handles orthogonal :
There can be at most two different root lengths: three lengths would have ratios two and three relative to the shortest, but then the longest-to-middle squared-length ratio would be , which is forbidden. A reducible collection of orthogonal rank-one factors could have independently chosen scales; the simple-algebra assumption excludes that exception.
Choose a generic linear functional to define positive roots. The simple roots are those positive roots which cannot be written as sums of two positive roots; they form a basis in which all root coefficients are integers of one sign. Distinct simple roots have nonpositive inner product: if their inner product were positive, their root string would contain their difference, and whichever difference is positive would decompose one of them. In rank two, irreducibility excludes the orthogonal case. The allowed simple-root angles are therefore , giving the three irreducible diagrams in the classification of rank-two root systems: A2 root system, B2 root system and G2 root system. Reflections in the two simple roots generate their respective six, eight and twelve roots.
Here are explicit simple-root choices and positive roots; adding their negatives gives each complete diagram.
  • For A2 root system, take and . The positive roots are ; all have squared length one.
  • For B2 root system, take the long and short . The positive roots are . These give the four axis roots and four diagonal roots, with squared lengths one and two. The rank-two Lie algebra is isomorphic to this one; changing the long/short ordering changes its Cartan presentation.
  • For G2 root system, take short and long . The positive roots are . They give two hexagons rotated by , with squared lengths one and three.
The nonnegative coefficients in each positive-root list verify the chosen simple roots explicitly. The orthogonal four-root system is rank two but reducible, so it is not a diagram for the simple algebra assumed here.
Define the Cartan matrix in the column-coroot convention:
Using the ordered roots above gives
The alternative row-coroot convention transposes these matrices. Stating the convention and root ordering avoids a spurious disagreement in the unequal-length cases.
Figure 1.
The irreducible rank-two root systems A2, B2 and G2, with long and short roots and explicit ordered simple roots highlighted
. Details.
First show that the Cartan subalgebra is orthogonal, for the Killing form, to every nonzero root space. For and , choose with . Invariance and the abelian nature of give
Hence .
Now let be in the radical of the restriction to , so for every . The preceding argument also gives for every root. By the root-space decomposition, is orthogonal to all of . The assumed nondegeneracy on forces . Therefore the Killing form restricted to the Cartan subalgebra is nondegenerate.
Here the Cartan subalgebra of a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra is a maximal toral subalgebra: it is abelian, its adjoint operators are simultaneously diagonalizable, and its centralizer is itself. These standard properties give the root-space decomposition
The roots of a root system are the nonzero linear functionals in for which ; is their finite set. Each root space is one-dimensional. The zero weight space is the centralizer of , hence exactly . Thus the displayed sum is a direct sum of simultaneous eigenspaces of the Adjoint representation. It is the Cartan root-space decomposition meant here.
The bracket respects weight addition: , where and a missing weight means the zero space. This follows by applying the Jacobi identity with to the bracket of two root vectors. It explains how the vector-space decomposition encodes the Lie algebra structure.
Work first in a finite-dimensional SU(2) representation, with its invariant positive inner product. In the complexified Lie algebra, choose and . Let be a highest-weight vector with and , and put . The commutator with gives
Induction also gives
For this is . For the induction step, use on : the coefficient becomes . In particular
which proves the assumed formula rather than merely invoking it.
The norm identity shows that, for nonnegative integer , the ladder is nonzero for and stops with . Distinct eigenvalues make these vectors independent. Their span is stable under , and in the irreducible module it is the full space. Thus
For normalized states, , with the last state killed. General finite-dimensional SU(2) representations are direct sums of these ladders.
The representation category matters here. The Lie-algebra relations alone allow an infinite Verma module even at integral highest weight: its nonzero vector is singular. The finite representation can instead be constructed algebraically by taking the basis with the displayed actions and declaring ; all three Lie brackets then hold, including at the endpoints. Thus the finite-dimensional assertion uses the integrable SU(2) module, or this explicit finite quotient, rather than assuming that a singular vector must vanish in every highest-weight module.
For rank two, take a Cartan subalgebra with commuting basis elements. A root is a nonzero linear functional on for which a root space contains an element satisfying
Choose simple roots and their coroots . In the PDF's index convention, the Cartan matrix is
Normalize so . The difference of distinct simple roots is not a root, so the mixed positive-negative bracket is zero. This gives
The transpose in the last formula is essential and is printed correctly in the original PDF.
A highest-weight vector of labels is killed by both and is an eigenvector of the two . Repeated words in generate its highest-weight representation; each lowers the weight by the corresponding simple root. Restricting to the sl2 subalgebra associated with a root for either simple root gives the preceding integer ladder, so finite-dimensional highest labels must be nonnegative integers. The finite irreducible module is the highest-weight quotient imposing and the submodules generated by these relations, together with the Serre relations. Choosing independent nonzero lowering words gives a simultaneous weight basis; an extra multiplicity index is needed where a weight space has dimension greater than one.
For the specified B2 root system, the simple-root squared lengths are and their inner product is , giving
The positive root is generated by , and by . No further positive sums occur, so and . These are the relevant Serre relations. Applying the Cartan commutators to a weight vector proves
whenever the image is nonzero.
To enumerate the requested representation without guessing when arrows stop, realize it concretely as the Adjoint representation. For a Euclidean weight , its labels are . The highest root has labels , so it generates the irreducible adjoint module of this simple rank-two Lie algebra. Its nonzero weights are exactly its eight roots, and its zero weight space is the two-dimensional Cartan subalgebra. This gives the B2 adjoint representation weight diagram and the nine distinct states labels:
Their actual production by lowering can be seen from
An arrow labelled denotes a nonzero action of between the indicated weight spaces. The two paths into zero produce independent Cartan vectors. Hence there are nine distinct pairs, as requested when degeneracy is disregarded, but the full representation has dimension ten, not nine.
Figure 1.
B2 adjoint weights labelled by the PDF Cartan convention, with simple-root lowering arrows
. Details.
Put and let denote a matrix unit. The antidiagonal matrix satisfies , so the orthogonal condition is , or entrywise . Consequently the diagonal Cartan subalgebra is
We first take . Since , the matrix root basis of the even orthogonal Lie algebra gives
The zero weight space is ; its basis is . No vector of weight occurs, because the corresponding matrix unit is forced to be its own negative. These spaces account for dimensions, exhausting the Special orthogonal Lie algebra. Thus its decomposition as a -module and its Dn root system are
Each nonzero root space has dimension one; the zero weight has multiplicity .
The upper triangular root spaces are precisely those of weights and with . Therefore
These roots form the simple roots. To check that they generate the chosen positive system with nonnegative coefficients, write . For ,
and for use . Empty sums are zero. Their linear independence and these expansions identify the base of the root system.
Equip the real span of the roots in with the inner product making the orthonormal. All roots then have squared length two. The coroots of are , so the fundamental weights of Dn, characterized by , are
Taking their pairings with and verifies the defining identities directly. For each pair , the sum of its two positive roots is . Hence the half-sum of positive roots is
The Dynkin diagram has a chain ending at , which is joined to both and . Every edge is a single bond because the root lengths agree; the nonzero off-diagonal simple-root pairings are minus one. The labelled Dn Dynkin diagram and its low-rank versions are shown below.
Figure 1.
Labelled D-type Dynkin diagrams, including the low-rank cases
. Details.
For , and are orthogonal, giving two disconnected A1 root systems. For , the diagram is the chain , of type A3 root system; the displayed weight formulas still apply. If is allowed, is one-dimensional and abelian: there are no roots or fundamental weights, and .
In dimension four, the two positive roots are and . Using the matrix root basis of the even orthogonal Lie algebra, define
The matrix unit identity gives , , and for . Thus each triple spans an sl2 Lie algebra.
The two triples commute. Their Cartan actions on one another vanish because ; their mixed root-vector brackets vanish because none of , namely and , is a root. This can equally be checked from the displayed matrix units. The six vectors are linearly independent, occupying the four distinct root spaces and two independent Cartan directions, so they exhaust the six-dimensional so4 Lie algebra. The two commuting spans are consequently ideals, and
This gives an explicit Chiral decomposition of the complexified so4 Lie algebra, including generators for both factors.
In the defining representation , the basis vectors and have weights and , respectively, each with multiplicity one. Thus its formal character is
The vector is killed by every positive root space, since all positive-root matrices are upper triangular, and is a highest-weight vector. Any nonzero invariant subspace splits into weight spaces and therefore contains one of the natural weight vectors, since those weight spaces are one-dimensional. The root matrices connect that vector to all the others, so this representation is irreducible for . In terms of the fundamental weights of Dn, its highest weight is for and for .
The flip of the two tensor factors is equivariant, hence
Use the invariant symmetric bilinear form . Contraction is an equivariant map to the trivial Lie algebra representation. Its inverse-form tensor
is invariant and satisfies . Consequently
The traceless summand contains the highest-weight vector of weight . The Weyl complete reducibility theorem states that every finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra representation is a direct sum of irreducible representations, so the submodule generated by this highest vector is . The Weyl dimension formula verifies that it is the entire traceless space: only positive roots involving change their factors, and
This equals . Thus the traceless symmetric square of the defining even orthogonal representation is irreducible, including .
For the other summand, the exterior square of the defining orthogonal representation has the equivariant identification
The image is skew relative to , and in a basis making the identity the images are the independent elementary skew matrices. The map is therefore an isomorphism onto the Adjoint representation of a Lie algebra. For , the connected Dn Dynkin diagram gives a simple Lie algebra (with ); its adjoint module is irreducible because its invariant subspaces are exactly its ideals. Its highest weight is , and is a highest vector. The tensor-square decomposition of the defining even orthogonal representation is consequently
The three dimensions are , and one, adding to . The highest weights are , and zero for ; for the middle weight is .
For , the Chiral decomposition of the complexified so4 Lie algebra splits the adjoint module into its two three-dimensional ideals. Thus
The weights are , , and zero. Equivalently, labelling highest weights by the two sl2 Lie algebra factors, this is . If is allowed, the abelian algebra has and ; there is then no single highest weight for an irreducible natural module.
For , put , . Then , . The matrix unit identity
reads off the root spaces directly. The complete list is
Thus the C2 root system is
All eight root spaces have dimension one. The zero-weight space is the two-dimensional Cartan subalgebra ; zero itself is not a root.
Use the standard coroot normalization . The symbols are vectors in the Cartan subalgebra, not the root-space vectors . The root-string theorem gives , so every root takes real values on
The simple coroots form a basis of this real space.
In the root-space decomposition, is zero on and scalar multiplication by on the one-dimensional space . Therefore, for ,
For every term is real, so the restricted form is real. Moreover,
If it is zero, all vanish. Then commutes with every root space and with , hence is central in . The center of a Lie algebra vanishes for a semisimple Lie algebra, so . Thus the Euclidean subspace of a Cartan subalgebra has
Equivalently, positivity follows because the roots span .
The Killing form is the symmetric bilinear form
The facts needed here are its invariance, , and the root space identity . Invariance follows from and cyclicity of the trace:
Taking , , proves
No normalization of is needed for this identity. Semisimplicity gives nondegeneracy of the Killing form, but that fact is not needed for this particular equality.
Work with a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra. The Dynkin diagram is obtained from its intrinsic root system, with several structure theorems entering the construction.
First choose a Cartan subalgebra . The semisimple structure theory gives the root-space decomposition
The nonzero roots span , root spaces have dimension one, and every root has its negative. The rank is .
Next use the Killing form. Its nondegeneracy on and its positive-definite restriction to the real coroot span identify the real root span with a Euclidean space. Explicitly, if , put . The sl2 subalgebra associated with a root supplies its normalized coroot and the integral pairing
The root-string theorem makes the reflection permute . Together with the absence of multiples other than , this shows that is a finite reduced root system and a crystallographic root system. These properties come from semisimple Lie algebra theory, not from the diagram's definition.
Choose a vector in that is not perpendicular to any root. Define the positive roots by positive inner product with this vector. The simple roots are those positive roots that cannot be expressed as sums of two positive roots. Root-system theory shows that they form a basis , and each root is an integer combination of them with coefficients all of one sign. Distinct simple roots have nonpositive inner product.
Use the standard Cartan matrix convention
There is one diagram vertex for each simple root. For , the integral off-diagonal entries are nonpositive and
Connect the two vertices with respectively zero, one, two or three edges. The corresponding angles are . A multiple edge carries an arrow toward the shorter root. For joined vertices, the length ratio is determined by ; hence the diagram records both angle and relative length.
For example, has simple roots and , giving two equal-length vertices joined by one edge: type . For , take and . Then
so the two vertices have a double edge directed toward , the shorter root: type .
Finally, orthogonal irreducible components of the root system correspond to the simple ideals of a Lie algebra in the semisimple Lie algebra, so its diagram is the disjoint union of their connected diagrams. Conjugacy of Cartan subalgebras and the Weyl group action on choices of positive roots make the resulting diagram independent of these choices up to isomorphism. Thus the vertices, edge multiplicities, arrows and connected components encode the simple-root geometry and the simple-ideal decomposition.
Write and . Block multiplication gives
Its vanishing is equivalent to
This identifies with the symplectic Lie algebra .
We now supply the requested root-space decomposition, including explicit vectors. Let be the matrix units, put , and define the linear functionals on the diagonal Cartan subalgebra by . Then . The Cn root system and a corresponding matrix root basis of the symplectic Lie algebra are
Each listed vector satisfies the block conditions just proved. For a diagonal matrix , the matrix unit calculation gives all the requested eigenvalues explicitly:
The diagonal vectors and difference-root vectors span every possible block. The sum-root and doubled-root vectors span all symmetric and blocks. They are linearly independent, as is evident from their disjoint independent block entries. Equivalently there are of them, exactly the dimension of . The zero weight space is precisely : a zero weight forces diagonal and every entry of to vanish. Hence every nonzero root space is one-dimensional and
Use a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra, or the complexification of its compact real form, as required for the root construction. Choose a Cartan subalgebra with basis . Simultaneous diagonalization of its adjoint action gives the root-space decomposition
The nonzero weights are the roots of a root system; each root space is one-dimensional in this setting, and roots occur in opposite pairs. This supplies the Cartan and root-vector basis.
The Jacobi identity gives
If the bracket is nonzero and , it is a nonzero vector in the root space of weight , so that sum is a root. The printed implication needs the opposite-root exception: for , can be a nonzero Cartan element, while zero is not a root. The supplied simple-root commutator itself gives this counterexample. This is the root bracket and the opposite-root exception.
Choose a real linear functional nonzero on every root; positive roots are those on which it is positive, and negative roots are their negatives. The simple roots are positive roots not decomposable into two positive roots. They form a basis of the root span, and every root is an integer combination
with all for a positive root and all for a negative root. Positive roots can be decomposed repeatedly until simple roots remain; the finite root set makes this procedure terminate.
For , has simple-root coefficients of both signs and is not a root. It is also nonzero, so the root-space bracket rule gives
The operators have the SU(2) Lie algebra normalization , . In a finite-dimensional representation, a vector killed by is a lowest-weight vector in its SU(2) summands. If its value is , those summands have spin , so
One can also read the termination from successive raising coefficients starting at the lowest weight.
Apply this result in the finite-dimensional Adjoint representation, taking the lowest-weight vector to be . The vanishing bracket just proved is its lowering condition. If , the lowest-weight result forces with a nonnegative integer. It also yields
The last identity is exactly the requested nested commutator. This is the SU(2) proof of the Serre relations, and the identities are the Serre relations in these Chevalley basis conventions.
To construct a highest-weight representation, start from its highest-weight vector and apply negative-root operators. Fix an order on the negative roots. The Poincaré-Birkhoff-Witt theorem gives spanning vectors
of weight . The spanning assertion follows by commuting all negative-root operators to the left, Cartan operators to the middle and positive-root operators to the right; commutators supply lower-order words, positive operators kill the highest-weight vector and Cartan operators act there by scalars. In the finite-dimensional highest-weight representation, impose the simple-root string relations and the commutator/Serre relations. At each weight retain a linearly independent set of the resulting words, discarding zero words and dependencies. This gives a basis, with separate independent vectors retained when a weight has multiplicity greater than one. The construction is finite in the assumed finite-dimensional representation; treating all lowering words as automatically independent would overcount.
For SU(3), put , and . The off-diagonal Cartan entries are minus one, so the Serre relations give . With , these imply
For , expand the commutator using Jacobi identity and the distinct-root brackets:
since . Similarly,
and the same calculation on gives . Thus
These signs also agree with the explicit model , , , , , .
For the SU(3) Casimir in Chevalley generators, set
Using , , and putting Cartan elements on the left, the four terms of are
Their sum is . The remaining terms give
The last two cancel, so . Also commutes with every Cartan polynomial and with each : their raising and lowering weights cancel in the product. Hence
On , and vanish and therefore vanishes as well. All three terms consequently give zero, leaving
The paper's normalization is relative to the conventional SU(3) quadratic Casimir eigenvalue. For example it gives in the fundamental representation, in the octet and in the decuplet.
If , and , invariance of the Killing form gives
Unless , some makes its coefficient nonzero, so the two root spaces are orthogonal. Similarly for every root: choose with and use that is abelian.
Now take nonzero . Nondegeneracy on supplies some element pairing nontrivially with . Its root-space decomposition shows that only its component can contribute. Thus the pairing between opposite root spaces is nonzero, and indeed nondegenerate. Therefore
Here nonzero means the bilinear pairing is not identically zero, not that every pair of vectors has a nonzero value.
If is orthogonal to all of , it is also orthogonal to every root space, by the preceding orthogonality. It is therefore orthogonal to all of , forcing . Hence is nondegenerate.