The vector current is odd and the axial current is even under charge conjugation. Under parity symmetry in quantum field theory, the first is a vector and the second a pseudovector. Thus their difference obeys under CP, with . If a neutral vector has under CP, the interaction transforms by the factor . It is invariant for . Being a real field restricts its intrinsic phases but does not alone fix this sign. The conventional C-odd neutral gauge-vector assignment makes real diagonal Z boson vector and axial couplings CP invariant, despite their separate C and P violations.
Higgsstrahlung 2026-10-14
Higgsstrahlung produces a Higgs boson together with a massive electroweak gauge boson. At an electron-positron collider the process uses the Higgs boson coupling to Z bosons. The associated Z boson provides a recoil and identifiable decay products. This was the dominant Standard Model Higgs-production channel used at LEP2.
Each effectively massless active neutrino species contributes the same invisible Z boson partial decay width. Subtracting calculated or measured visible widths from the total width therefore measures the displayed number, assuming no additional invisible channels. The inference concerns particles lighter than with ordinary weak couplings. It does not exclude heavier neutrinos or right-handed neutrinos that are gauge singlets. Early LEP resonance measurements were consistent with three light active species, with statistical uncertainty. See the OPAL report on its 1989 data for the original resonance-width comparison.
For the Z boson vertex , sum over the three initial polarizations and final fermion spins. The symmetric Dirac trace is . The vector-axial interference is antisymmetric and drops out of the massive vector polarization sum. The longitudinal term drops out by current conservation for massless final particles. Contracting the remaining trace gives the displayed result. The massive-vector spin average divides it by three; two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space then gives per color. These coefficients are twice those used with a vertex prefactor .
Use the current convention in the question, whose vertex prefactor is . The neutral-current vector and axial couplings are then
For a charged lepton, , , giving
For an active neutrino, , , so . The right-handed weak singlet contribution is purely vectorlike in the charge term; combining it with the left-handed contribution gives precisely this Dirac-current form. These coefficients would be halved if the vertex prefactor were instead.
Let be the Z boson momentum and the outgoing massless lepton momenta. The decay amplitude is
Use the fermion spin sums and . Anticommutation of with the Dirac gamma matrices gives the symmetric part of the trace,
The vector-axial cross term is antisymmetric in , and hence drops out of the massive vector polarization sum. The massless equations also give : in the symmetric part, the first two contractions sum to , canceling the last; the antisymmetric term vanishes because . The longitudinal term therefore makes no contribution.
Since , contraction with gives . Thus the massless fermion Z decay spin sum, including all three initial polarizations, is
To use this fully summed expression for the decay width of one unpolarized Z boson, apply the massive-vector spin average, dividing by three. The width of each fixed polarization is the same after integration over all directions, so that procedure also gives the physical single-particle width. Omitting the division would sum the widths of three initial states.
For two massless distinguishable final particles, the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space is
Consequently
The tree-level electroweak symmetry breaking relation is . Combining it with the Fermi constant normalization gives
For an active neutrino, the vertex itself projects out inactive chiralities, so no additional helicity factor is needed. This is the tree-level massless leptonic Z decay width; lepton masses and radiative corrections have been excluded.
Work with canonically normalized real components of the scalar field; a complex representation can first be written in terms of its real and imaginary components. At a vacuum expectation value , expansion of the scalar potential gives
The linear term vanishes by stationarity. Thus the scalar mass matrix is the Hessian matrix of the scalar potential. Invariance under each Lie algebra generator gives the identity . Differentiating this identity with respect to and evaluating at the stationary point removes the term containing , leaving
The kernel of the map is precisely the Lie algebra of the stabilizer subgroup H. Consequently its restriction to a complementary space of broken Lie algebra generators is injective: a linear combination that annihilates would belong both to the stabilizer algebra and its complement, and hence would vanish. There are therefore independent Goldstone directions in the scalar mass matrix, tangent to the vacuum manifold. There are symmetry-protected massless scalars.
This Goldstone theorem guarantees at least that many zero quadratic masses. The claim that these are all the massless scalars additionally requires nonzero curvature transverse to the vacuum orbit. For example, , with , has an ordinary spherical vacuum manifold but its entire Hessian matrix vanishes there. These accidental massless radial modes beyond Goldstone modes are not excluded by the hypotheses. For the indicated orthogonal group breaking, the protected number is
For the Higgs doublet, put and wherever . If , then
This explicitly exhibits the three angular coordinates as an SU(2) transformation of a real radial field. In particular, the polar coordinates for the electroweak Higgs doublet can locally be chosen in the form
At the vacuum the three variations generated by , , and acting on are independent over the reals. They span the three broken directions; the remaining generator annihilates the vacuum. This proves that the exponential supplies local angular coordinates. An inverse local gauge transformation, applied also to the gauge fields, removes these three fields in unitary gauge. They supply the longitudinal polarizations of the massive W bosons and Z boson through the Higgs mechanism. The parameterization is local about a nonzero vacuum, rather than a coordinate system through every possible zero of the Higgs doublet.
Use the metric and define the charged W bosons and neutral gauge fields by
where , , and . Direct substitution into the gauge-covariant kinetic term gives
and hence
The electroweak doublet gauge-boson mass matrix in the basis is
Its normalized zero direction is and its massive direction is . Thus the scalar-vector terms in physical fields are
with the tree-level electroweak gauge-boson masses
These are also charge eigenstates. The unbroken U(1) gauge symmetry has generator ; on the Higgs doublet, . Since , the combinations have charges , while Z, the photon, and H are neutral. The photon disappears from the displayed scalar-vector terms because . The photon is massless and has no direct tree-level coupling to the remaining radial scalar in this sector. This does not remove its interactions with charged W bosons, or exclude a scalar-to-photon interaction generated by loops.
Finally, retain the printed normalization of the Higgs field potential:
The kinetic term is , so the Higgs radial mass for a half-normalized quartic potential is . The extra factor of two familiar from a potential with prefactor , rather than , does not apply here.
Put and neglect electron and final-quark masses compared with . First fix a final color charge; its multiplicity will be restored for the inclusive rate. The photon-exchange scattering amplitude is, up to an overall phase,
Averaging over the two spins of each incident particle and summing final spins gives
By the gamma matrix trace identities, the first trace is , and likewise for the second. Contracting the two tensors cancels the terms proportional to , giving
In the centre-of-mass frame all four energies are . The first pair of scalar products equals each, and the second pair equals each. Hence .
For clarity, the printed flux hint has a factor-of-four inconsistency: when , the prefactor multiplying the spin-averaged amplitude is , not . Alternatively, is correct if . Use this massless two-body scattering flux normalization, keeping the spin average separate.
To obtain the two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space directly, integrate the momentum-conserving spatial delta function, leaving . The remaining radial integral is , so . The relativistic scattering cross-section is consequently
Since , the integrated electron-positron annihilation into a quark pair result, for this fixed color, is
The first two printed formulas are thus color-stripped. Distinct final colors are orthogonal states and must be summed, producing . At leading order each accessible quark flavor contributes independently. Away from thresholds and narrow resonances, quark-hadron duality relates the inclusive parton rate to the observed inclusive electron-positron annihilation into hadrons, giving
This formula concerns the photon channel, assumes is large compared with the relevant quark masses and the strong-interaction scale, and does not include Z boson exchange.
Beyond leading order, an exactly exclusive pair of colored quarks is not an observable asymptotic state because of confinement and hadronization. Moreover its virtual corrections have infrared divergences; real soft or collinear gluon emission cannot be excluded if a finite rate is wanted. The inclusive sum includes both the corrected two-parton channel and channels such as , with their degenerate soft and collinear limits. Real and virtual infrared divergences then cancel for an infrared-safe observable. A specified jet observable can also be meaningful if it defines an infrared-safe observable; a bare two-quark final state is not.
A convenient inclusive calculation uses the optical theorem. For the electromagnetic hadronic current , define
The hadronic electromagnetic-current spectral density is obtained from its discontinuity. In this convention the hadronic R ratio is , where at this order. Cutting the forward amplitude sums all allowed hadronic intermediate states, so perturbative Quantum chromodynamics applied to this inclusive quantity implements the required sum of real and virtual contributions.
Finally, write , , , and . The given truncated correction is
Differentiate with respect to , using the stated one-loop beta function and . The derivative of cancels the explicit logarithmic derivative at order . Keeping the residual derivative of the truncated expression gives
Thus the principle of minimal sensitivity, applied to this expression with nonzero coupling and , selects the one-loop stationary scale for the hadronic annihilation correction
This is a prescription based on the residual order- scale dependence of an order- approximation. At strictly order , the derivative already vanishes for every renormalization scale; the prescription does not assert exact scale dependence of the observable. It is useful only while the selected running coupling remains perturbative. If or , the stated derivative imposes no unique scale.
A useful model of spontaneous breaking of a Z2 scalar symmetry is the four-dimensional real scalar theory
The action is invariant under the Z2 symmetry . Its classical vacuum manifold consists of the two values . In the broken quantum phase, choose a pure vacuum with ; the symmetry maps it to a different vacuum with opposite expectation value, although it leaves the action unchanged. To distinguish quantum symmetry breaking from simply minimizing a classical potential, introduce a small source and take the infinite-volume limit before . A finite-volume symmetry-preserving ground state can remain an even superposition because of tunneling, whereas the selected infinite-volume pure vacua have nonzero vacuum expectation values. The parameter below is the tree-level expectation, with its quantum value determined by renormalized parameters.
Writing gives
The original sign symmetry relates expansions about the two vacua; in one expansion it acts as . It is not a symmetry that fixes the chosen vacuum. Since the broken group is discrete, there is no continuous broken generator and no required Goldstone boson.
With relativistically normalized external states, the general two-body partial decay width is
Here the bar sums final spins and averages initial spins only if the initial ensemble is unpolarized. The identical final-state symmetry factor is for two identical daughters and one for distinguishable daughters. Integrating the three-momentum delta function in the parent rest frame leaves . The energy delta function fixes and has radial Jacobian . Hence the two-body decay phase space is
Consequently
when the spin-summed amplitude is angle independent.
For Higgs decay to two W bosons, the scalar parent has no spin average and the amplitude, up to an irrelevant phase, is . Use the massive vector polarization sum with :
Momentum conservation gives . With the PDF's ratio , this becomes
The charged daughters are distinguishable. Combining the last two equations with gives
For Higgs decay to two Z bosons, the Higgs boson coupling to Z bosons is , using . This compensates the changed powers of in the polarization contraction, giving the same normalization of the squared amplitude with replaced by . The two Z bosons are identical, so the phase-space symmetry factor supplies an additional half:
Both expressions have mass dimension one, vanish at their two-body thresholds and approach the ratio for . The cubic large-mass behavior comes from longitudinal-vector polarizations. These are on-shell tree-level widths under the stated heavy-Higgs hypothesis; below threshold the physical off-shell multi-particle decays require a different calculation.
Use , the Minkowski metric and . Distinguish the numerical charge-conjugation matrix from the unitary operator acting on fields. The adjoint Dirac equation is . Transpose it and multiply by ; the identity gives
Thus the charge-conjugate field satisfies the same free Dirac equation.
To compute its Dirac adjoint, use and Hermitian with . The supplied unitary property of , together with the Clifford identity for its square, implies this Hermiticity. Since ,
Therefore charge conjugation of the Dirac adjoint gives
The intrinsic phase obeys . Antisymmetry of also gives .
Charge conjugation exchanges electron and positron modes while preserving momentum and the spin label in a compatible spin basis. Write the mode expansion of a Dirac field as
Its charge conjugate is
Choose the charge-conjugate particle and antiparticle spinors so that
This is legitimate: transposing shows , and the involution above supplies the inverse relation. Comparing the two independent frequency coefficients in then gives
Different conventional spinor phases can move the phases between these relations, but the exchange of particles and antiparticles is invariant.
For local fermion bilinears, understand the products as normal-ordered or equivalently use a consistent renormalized composite-operator prescription. The transformed product is initially . Reordering the fermions gives a second minus sign, hence
For , the transposed matrix is , so the vector current is C-odd:
The quantum electrodynamics interaction is C-invariant when the photon field is also odd, . Its field strength is then odd and its quadratic kinetic term even.
For the chirality matrix, there is no complex conjugation of the numerical by this unitary field operation. Thus
The reversal takes six swaps of mutually anticommuting gamma matrices, giving a positive sign. Therefore
The axial current is C-even. Hence a photon-like interaction containing both currents transforms as
It is not C-invariant when the axial part is present; C symmetry of ordinary electromagnetic vector coupling does not extend to this chiral combination.
For parity symmetry in quantum field theory, taking the adjoint of the field transformation gives . The phases cancel in bilinears, and , with . Since anticommutes with ,
In components, the vector's time component is even and spatial components are odd; the axial time component is odd and its spatial components are even.
Combining the C and P transformations, both currents acquire the same overall minus sign:
Let the real vector transform as , with . A real field permits such a real intrinsic sign but does not determine it merely by being real. The Lorentz contraction then gives the CP invariance of a neutral chiral vector interaction criterion:
It is invariant for . With ordinary vector parity and the C-odd neutral-gauge-field assignment, this is precisely the usual transformation, and .
The diagonal Z boson couplings have the form with real coefficients. The same calculation applies to any real vector and axial coefficients. Thus the tree-level flavour-diagonal neutral-current Z interaction preserves CP although it violates C and P separately when both current structures occur. This statement is about the neutral-current interaction, not a claim that the entire Standard Model preserves CP: complex charged-current CKM matrix phases provide CP violation.
Use metric signature and average over the four initial spin states, summing over final spins and the quark color charge states. The Electrons carry no color charge, so their initial color charge average is trivial. A final color charge average would not give the inclusive relativistic cross-section requested.
Photon exchange gives the tree amplitude, up to an irrelevant overall phase,
Massless spin sums give and . Therefore
The color charge multiplicity is , not . Each trace equals . Contracting them, the terms proportional to cancel, leaving . Thus
In the centre-of-momentum frame every energy is . Let be the angle between and . Then
Consequently .
The supplied two-body Lorentz-invariant phase space formula has a factor-of-two error. Deriving the normalization explicitly,
so the massless two-body scattering flux normalization is
For example, integrating the spatial Dirac delta in leaves ; its radial integral supplies the factor . The printed denominator would double the relativistic cross-section and cannot reproduce the requested result with the standard scattering amplitude.
The correctly normalized differential and total results for electron-positron annihilation into a quark pair are
and hence
At energies where photon exchange and the parton description apply, sum over kinematically accessible quark flavors. The produced quarks undergo hadronization, so the leading inclusive hadronic rate is
This is the hadronic R ratio. Perturbative QCD adds a leading relative correction ; thresholds, narrow resonances and, near the Z boson scale, electroweak exchange require additional treatment. The calculation is a photon-exchange, massless result from a tree-level Feynman diagram.
Set . The angular integral of the electron-positron annihilation into a muon pair differential cross-section is
Therefore
The printed comparison of with a quantity in has inconsistent units: the high-energy condition means an energy large compared with particle masses, or equivalently an energy-squared large compared with their squared masses.
At leading order, inclusive electron-positron annihilation into hadrons proceeds through , as in the first panel below. The photon couples to each quark with strength ; the corresponding contribution is times the muon-pair rate per colour. Summing over the three orthogonal final colours and active flavours gives the hadronic R ratio
For massless flavours this gives , with charm included , and with bottom as well .
The approximation assumes unpolarized beams and negligible electron mass; active quark masses are small relative to , and heavy flavours below threshold are excluded. Photon exchange dominates, so exchange and photon- interference are neglected; this is appropriate sufficiently below the Z boson scale, not at arbitrary high energy. The coupling must be evaluated consistently in numerator and reference rate. We also neglect higher-order QED radiation. Relating the inclusive partonic calculation to hadrons invokes quark-hadron duality: the energy should be in a perturbative continuum region, away from thresholds and narrow resonances, with power-suppressed nonperturbative effects neglected. An exclusive hadron channel cannot be obtained merely by multiplying the parton rate by the colour count.
Figure 1.
Born hadronic production, real and virtual first-order QCD corrections, and their local counterterms
. Details.
At next order in QCD, the real-emission amplitudes are the two distinct diagrams for , with the gluon emitted from the quark or antiquark. They must be added before squaring, including their interference. Each amplitude is order at the hadronic current vertex and gives a relative order- contribution to the rate.
The virtual order- amplitudes consist of the gluon correction to the photon-quark vertex and the quark and antiquark self-energy/external-state normalization contributions. The figure also shows the corresponding local vertex and field counterterms. In an amputated on-shell calculation the external-leg terms are represented by wave-function factors, rather than counted as extra final states. There is no gluon attachment to an electron, since it carries no colour. Gluon self-energy insertions and additional non-Abelian vertices enter at higher orders here. The rate correction is the Born-virtual interference plus the integrated squared real-emission amplitude, not the square of the one-loop amplitude.
Use dimensional regularization, , to keep ultraviolet and infrared singularities in a common scheme. Ultraviolet divergences in the virtual quark and vertex contributions are removed by consistent wave-function renormalization and local counterterms; the conserved electromagnetic-current identity relates the vertex and field renormalizations. One uses a renormalized QCD coupling ; its running changes this first correction only at the next perturbative order. In the massless on-shell scheme some external self-energy integrals are scaleless and vanish, but that statement combines ultraviolet and infrared poles and must not be used to discard the associated normalization terms inconsistently.
The remaining infrared divergences occur when a gluon is soft, and collinear divergences occur when it is parallel to a massless quark. They appear in both virtual diagrams and the real-emission phase-space integral. For the fully inclusive total rate, unresolved final states are summed and real-virtual infrared cancellation in inclusive QCD removes their poles. A resolved jet rate instead needs an infrared-safe observable and a resolution prescription. An isolated real or virtual correction is not a finite physical inclusive cross-section.
Define the dimensionless constant with the conventional loop factor extracted. Then the requested form is
Fixed numerical and colour factors are contained in ; choosing another extracted prefactor simply redefines that constant. No explicit loop coefficient is required to establish the form.
The Born and virtual processes give two energetic particle jets. Hard, well-separated real radiation gives a three-jet event; unresolved radiation changes jet widths and event-shape distributions, while the combined terms correct the inclusive rate. Resolved three-jet events in electron-positron annihilation provided the direct gluon signature, observed at PETRA in 1979. Their interpretation is energetic quark, antiquark and gluon fragmentation, with approximately planar three-body momentum balance. The primary institutional account is www.desy.de/news/news_search/index_eng.html?openDirectAnchor=1643&printversion=1 .
Assume and . The vacuum manifold is the sphere . Choose . For the given generators, whereas and are nonzero and independent. The Adjoint representation of SU(2) rotates this sphere, and the full connected stabilizer subgroup of is generated by . Hence the classical symmetry pattern is
The central element of SU(2) acts trivially on the triplet and belongs to this stabilizer; it does not add a separate broken direction. The gauge-field-free representative has zero gauge field strength and constant scalar magnitude. Locally near this nonzero classical vacuum, unitary gauge aligns the triplet along the third axis.
First make the gauge normalization explicit. Write the gauge kinetic term as , where if is the matrix used inside the printed trace. Canonical normalization of a gauge kinetic term gives
For a conventionally normalized component trace, and . If the trace is the ordinary matrix trace in the displayed three-dimensional representation, and . The PDF does not specify which trace convention is intended; both are covered by this formula.
In unitary gauge, the gauge covariant derivative is
Expanding this kinetic term and the scalar potential gives the complete physical-field Lagrangian
Here a square of a vector means its contraction with the Minkowski metric, in signature . The labels 1 and 2 represent massive vectors; 3 represents the surviving Abelian vector.
To display their charge and all interactions more clearly, put , , and define
With the sign of gauge field strength printed in the paper, and . Thus the same Lagrangian becomes
The physical masses are
In particular, literal adjoint matrix trace gives ; the standard canonical component convention gives . These are descriptions with differently normalized couplings, not different physical spectra.
The complex vector pair carries opposite charges under the unbroken U(1) gauge symmetry. The gauge field strength terms contain cubic interactions, quartic interactions, and four-vector interactions involving the charged fields. There is no pure Abelian cubic or quartic self-interaction. The Higgs mode has cubic and quartic scalar interactions and couples through . It is neutral and has no tree-level interaction. This is the physical charged-vector Lagrangian for an adjoint SU2 Higgs model.
If the angular fields and were retained, their vanishing potential masses would identify the two Goldstone bosons of the ungauged triplet. In the gauge theory they mix with the broken-direction gauge fields and can be removed by gauge fixing; the Higgs mechanism uses them as the longitudinal polarizations of the two massive vectors. They are not additional physical massless scalars. The physical degrees of freedom are conserved: before rearrangement, and afterwards.
This is not the Standard Model electroweak interaction. It has three original gauge bosons, leaving two massive charged vectors and one massless neutral vector, with no massive neutral Z boson. The Standard Model instead has , a complex Higgs doublet, and three massive vectors plus the photon. Its charge is , not just the surviving . Adding fermions cannot supply the missing gauge generator or turn the surviving neutral vector into both a photon and a Z boson. In particular, the usual right-handed fermions in the Standard Model are SU(2) singlets; they would have zero charge if only were available, instead of the charges produced by hypercharge.
There are two diagrams: -channel Z boson exchange and -channel W boson exchange. The incoming Electron and Electron-antineutrino can annihilate into , which then produces the outgoing pair. The charged-current propagator carries momentum , hence invariant . The solid-line arrows in the diagram indicate fermion-number flow; those on antineutrino legs run opposite their physical motion.
There are two diagrams: the -channel Z boson exchange from the weak neutral current, and a crossed -channel W boson exchange from the weak charged current. The charged-current vertices pair the incoming neutrino with the outgoing Electron and the incoming Electron with the outgoing neutrino . The exchanged momentum has square . With charge flow from the first vertex to the second, the exchanged boson is . The corresponding panels show both topologies; no photon or Higgs diagram survives the stated neutrino assumptions.
Only a -channel Z boson connects the muon-neutrino line to the Electron line. Its endpoints are the weak neutral current vertices and . A W boson couples to a muon, so it cannot produce an additional elastic charged-current diagram with external electrons. There is no photon-neutrino vertex, and a strictly massless Standard Model neutrino has no Higgs Yukawa vertex. There is one diagram.
The three real components form the Adjoint representation of . Around a nonzero vacuum, a local gauge transformation rotates the direction of to the third axis. In this unitary gauge, the two angular fields are removed from the scalar parametrization and become longitudinal polarizations of two gauge bosons, through the Higgs mechanism. Thus describes the perturbative physical fluctuations, with .
The subgroup generated by fixes , giving . Define the physical vector fields
The gauge covariant derivative on the radial configuration is
so the scalar kinetic term becomes .
Here is an exact form of the Lagrangian in these physical fields, up to its additive vacuum constant. Define
and
The minus sign in the printed non-Abelian gauge field strength gives precisely these signs. Then
Its quadratic terms give , , and . The two massive vectors have six real polarization degrees of freedom in total; the massless vector has two and the scalar one. Their total of nine equals the original six vector plus three scalar degrees of freedom.
Under the surviving , and have opposite charges and is neutral. The Yang-Mills theory supplies and couplings and quartic charged-vector self-interactions. The scalar term supplies and , together with the cubic and quartic scalar self-interactions. There is no direct term.
With suitable fermions, this spectrum offers a massless photon and massive charged mediators of short-range weak charged currents, so it captures part of the weak/electromagnetic pattern. It differs crucially from the electroweak interaction of the Standard Model: the latter gauges , uses a complex Higgs doublet, and breaks to . Three rather than two generators are broken, leaving a massive neutral Z boson as well as and a photon. Its charge operator and independent hypercharge coupling give a nontrivial weak mixing angle. The present theory has no massive neutral mediator, no such mixing angle, and does not reproduce the observed chiral fermion charge assignments or their usual Yukawa couplings from the standard doublet/singlet assignments.
Both the left-handed Electron and the electron neutrino participate in weak charged currents through , and both have weak neutral currents mediated by the Z boson. Their electromagnetic interactions differ: the Electron has electric charge and couples to the photon, while the neutrino is electrically neutral and has no tree-level electromagnetic coupling.
In the minimal massless-neutrino Standard Model, the active neutrino has only a left-handed particle state and a right-handed antiparticle state. The Electron has both chiralities: its right-handed component has electromagnetic interactions and a weak neutral current, but no weak charged current. Its nonzero mass comes from a Yukawa coupling to the Higgs field; the minimal massless-neutrino model contains no right-handed neutrino for an analogous Dirac mass term.
Observed neutrino oscillations establish nonzero neutrino mass-squared differences. Atmospheric muon-neutrino disappearance depends on travel distance and energy, and solar electron neutrinos convert into other active flavors; reactor and accelerator oscillations provide complementary evidence. In propagation, the relative phase of two mass eigenstates is . If all masses were zero there would be no such relative phase. Thus at least two neutrino mass eigenstates are nonzero in the three-neutrino description with two independent measured splittings. A flavor state is a superposition of mass eigenstates, so the evidence does not assign a single definite mass to a flavor label.