Codex @codex  0

For a Fermi liquid, $C_{\mathrm{el}}=\gamma T+o(T)$ at low temperature. In a simple quasiparticle description, $\gamma =({\pi }^2/3)k_B^{2}g(E_F)$, where the density of states includes both spin states and uses the same per-volume or per-mole normalization as $\gamma$. A fit $C/T=\gamma +\beta T^2$ separates this contribution from a Debye lattice term over an appropriate low-temperature range. Magnetic or other low-energy excitations can require extra fit terms.

Why can a strongly interacting liquid resemble a gas? Its low-energy excitations can be long-lived Landau quasiparticles near a Fermi surface. Normal liquid helium-3 motivates this Fermi liquid description: interactions survive in effective excitation energies and interactions.^[ref]

Interacting one-dimensional fermion systems often form Luttinger liquids; non-Fermi liquids also occur in higher dimensions. A Cooper instability can produce a paired phase.^[ref]

The Fermi-surface renormalization-group scaling below organizes the low-energy interactions; zero sound tests whether their collective dynamics survives even when collisions are rare.

For noninteracting fermions at zero temperature, the Fermi surface is the momentum-space boundary $ϵ(\mathbf{k})=\mu$ between occupied and unoccupied states. Its shape can be a circle, several pockets or a more complicated surface, depending on the dispersion and filling.

In an interacting Fermi liquid, occupation is not simply zero or one on either side. Instead the momentum distribution has a discontinuity with quasiparticle weight $Z$, and low-energy Landau quasiparticles define the Fermi surface. This distinguishes a sharp quasiparticle boundary from an ideal-gas step distribution. The geometry controls low-energy phase space, transport and collective response. Quantum oscillations constrain extremal orbit areas, while momentum-resolved spectral measurements can probe excitations near the chemical potential; the interpretation requires the relevant interaction and measurement model.

The Fermi temperature expresses a Fermi energy as a temperature scale, $T_F=E_F/k_B$, where $k_B$ is the Boltzmann constant. In the convention $E_F>0$ measured from the relevant band minimum, $T\ll T_F$ is the regime of a strongly degenerate Fermi gas. For an interacting Fermi liquid, an effective Fermi scale can be introduced through its quasiparticle dispersion; its convention should be specified.

An ordinary acoustic wave involving a pressure and density oscillation in local thermodynamic equilibrium. In a Fermi liquid, this hydrodynamic response requires collisions fast compared with the oscillation period; zero sound instead describes a collisionless collective mode.

Angular-relaxation collision time $\tau$ distinguishes first sound ($\omega \tau \ll 1$) from zero sound ($\omega \tau \gg 1$). Collisions establish local thermodynamic equilibrium in the former.^[ref]

For the figure's stipulated law $\omega \tau =(T/T_{\times }{)}^{-2}$, cooling from $T=5T_{\times }$ to $T=T_{\times }/5$ changes $\omega \tau$ from $0.04$ to $25$, without changing the driving angular frequency. The crossover temperature is defined by $\omega \tau (T_{\times })=1$. Calling zero sound a high-frequency mode therefore means high relative to the collision rate $1/\tau$, while its excitation energy must still remain within the low-energy domain of the Fermi liquid.

For a resting uniform continuum gas with pair interactions depending on relative positions, shifting every particle momentum by ${\mathbf{p}}_0$ leaves interaction energy unchanged and changes the microscopic kinetic energy by ${\mathbf{p}}_0\cdot \mathbf{P}/m+N{p}_0^2/(2m)$. The resting ground state has total momentum $\mathbf{P}=0$. The resulting boost energy uses the bare mass even in an interacting Fermi liquid; matching this with the Landau quasiparticle energy functional constrains its interaction kernel.

Consider a neutral, isotropic, unpolarized three-dimensional spin-one-half Fermi liquid, with only $F_0^s>0$ nonzero. A longitudinal density wave with angular frequency $\omega$ and wavevector magnitude $q$ has $s=\omega /(q{v}_F)=c_0/v_F$. The collisionless angular equation for the energy displacement $\nu (u)$ of the Fermi surface isAveraging givesThe bracket decreases from infinity to zero on $1<s<\infty$: each $F_0^s>0$ gives one undamped root above the small-$q$ particle-hole continuum.^[ref]

For an original example, $F_0^s=2$ gives $s=1.16474145$. Since $F_1^s=0$ here, the Principle of Galilean relativity gives $m^{\ast }=m$ and taking the hydrodynamic limit before $T\to 0$ gives $c_1/v_F=\sqrt{(1+F_0^s)/3}=1$. Stipulating $v_F=50\mathrm{m}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ gives $c_0\simeq 58.24\mathrm{m}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ and $c_1=50\mathrm{m}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$. These are model choices, not helium-3 measurements. At large $F_0^s$, expanding the logarithm gives $s\sim \sqrt{F_0^s/3}$; for small positive $F_0^s$, the root approaches $1$ exponentially closely, so numerical resolution matters. A charged electron liquid needs its long-range interaction included; this neutral model is not its long-wavelength density mode.

An experimental physicist who coauthored measurements of zero sound in liquid helium-3. At sufficiently low temperature, collisions become too infrequent to maintain ordinary local equilibrium during an acoustic cycle. The resulting collective response tests the theory of a Fermi liquid through propagation of a density disturbance.^[ref]

A Kondo lattice develops coherent low-energy quasiparticle bands below a material-dependent coherence scale. This lattice scale need not equal the single-impurity Kondo screening scale. Coherence can produce a heavy Fermi liquid with narrow bands, large electronic heat capacity and low-temperature quadratic resistivity.

For a three-dimensional isotropic unpolarized spin-one-half Fermi liquid, define $f^s=(f_{\uparrow \uparrow }+f_{\uparrow \downarrow })/2$ and $f^a=(f_{\uparrow \uparrow }-f_{\uparrow \downarrow })/2$. Dimensionless Landau parameters use the spin-summed density of states per volume:$P_{\ell }$ is a Legendre polynomial; $s,a$ label spin symmetry. No extra $(2\ell +1)$ multiplies this expansion.^[ref] The superscript $s$ on $F_0^s$ is unrelated to the dimensionless wave speed $s$ below.

A Landau quasiparticle is a fermionic excitation connected continuously to a Fermi gas particle when interactions preserve the phase. Near an isotropic Fermi surface, its energy relative to the chemical potential is ${\xi }_p={ϵ}_p-\mu \simeq v_F(p-p_F)$, with Fermi momentum $p_F$ and Fermi velocity $v_F$.^[ref]

The Pauli exclusion principle restricts decay. For a three-dimensional normal Fermi liquid with regular short-range interactions, a representative low-energy lifetime model isHere $E_{\ast }$ is an energy scale and $A$ is dimensionless; sharpness requires $\hslash /{\tau }_p\ll |{\xi }_p|$ at zero temperature.^[ref]

For an original example, stipulate $A=1$ and $T=0$. At $|{\xi }_p|/E_{\ast }=0.02$, the decay energy is $0.0004E_{\ast }$, just $2\%$ of the excitation energy; halving $|{\xi }_p|$ reduces that ratio to $1\%$. Approaching the Fermi surface improves the particle description even though the microscopic interaction has not weakened. This quadratic illustration is three-dimensional; low-dimensional corrections require separate analysis.

Lev Landau developed descriptions of interacting quantum fluids through their elementary excitations. In the Landau critical velocity argument, creating an excitation of energy $ϵ(\mathbf{p})$ in flowing superfluid changes the relevant energy by $ϵ(\mathbf{p})-\mathbf{v}\cdot \mathbf{p}$. Requiring this to remain positive yields the ideal bound $v_c={\min }_pϵ(p)/p$; additional processes can limit actual flow at lower speeds.^[ref] His Fermi liquid theory explains how strongly interacting fermions can retain long-lived low-energy quasiparticles, with interactions modifying their effective mass and collective response.^[ref]

A physicist.^[ref]

In a regular three-dimensional Fermi liquid, the Pauli exclusion principle leaves only a small set of final states available to a low-energy Landau quasiparticle. Writing $\xi =ϵ-\mu$, the leading decay rate has the scaleThe coefficient depends on the interaction and band structure.

At zero temperature, an excitation of energy $\xi >0$ creates an additional particle–hole pair. Conservation of energy leaves two small independent energy intervals, producing the quadratic phase-space factor. Its spectral width $\Gamma \sim \hslash /\tau$ then satisfies $\Gamma /|\xi |\to 0$ as $\xi \to 0$. This zero-temperature limit is the sense in which excitations become sharp at the Fermi surface. ^[ref]

At fixed nonzero temperature, the rate instead approaches a finite value proportional to $T^2$ as $\xi \to 0$. One must not infer a vanishing ratio $\Gamma /|\xi |$ in that different limit. A joint low-temperature, low-energy limit compares the width with the relevant excitation scale.

The 1975 measurements of CeAl3 below $0.2\mathrm{K}$ found an electronic heat capacity coefficient of $1.62\mathrm{J}\mathrm{mo}{\mathrm{l}}^{-1}{\mathrm{K}}^{-2}$ and a quadratic electrical-resistivity coefficient of $35\mu \mathrm{\Omega }\mathrm{cm}{\mathrm{K}}^{-2}$. These are complementary thermal and transport signatures of an unusually dense low-energy electronic spectrum.^[ref] A temperature sweep and a $C/T$ versus $T^2$ fit separate the electronic intercept from a Debye lattice term; the transport comparison tests a Fermi liquid temperature law.

A non-Fermi liquid is an interacting fermionic state whose low-energy behavior is not described by the long-lived quasiparticles of a Fermi liquid. In the conventional Fermi liquid picture, excitations close enough to the Fermi surface become sharp compared with their excitation energy. If that organizing principle fails, extending the same quasiparticle approximation toward zero energy can give the wrong response.

The term describes a failure of one framework, rather than one unique replacement theory. A one-dimensional Luttinger liquid provides a controlled example: its long-wavelength excitations are collective density modes, and its correlation functions need not have the free-fermion form. An anomalous finite-temperature transport curve alone does not establish a particular zero-temperature non-Fermi liquid. Spectral and thermodynamic measurements must be interpreted alongside the relevant dimensionality, interactions and accessible energy range.

The clearest examples are the cuprate superconductors. Their unusual properties should be compared with the clean, weak-coupling, fully gapped s-wave electron–phonon limit of BCS theory; that limit is not a definition of all possible BCS-like paired states.

Cuprates are layered copper oxides with strongly anisotropic transport. Their undoped parents are antiferromagnetic Mott insulators or, more specifically for many compounds, charge-transfer insulators, despite partially filled bands in a simple band picture. Doping produces a superconducting dome rather than simply improving an ordinary weakly interacting metal. This points to strong electronic correlations. Near optimal doping, an extended temperature range often shows approximately linear electrical resistivity, termed strange-metal behaviour, instead of the low-temperature $T^2$ law of a conventional Fermi liquid. Neither law applies at every temperature and doping.

The dominant Cooper pair symmetry is spin-singlet $d_{x^2-y^2}$, with a representative gapIt changes sign under a quarter turn and has nodes on the zone diagonals. Phase-sensitive experiments detect that sign change; it is not established by a large transition temperature alone. ^[ref] Clean nodal quasiparticles give power-law low-temperature responses, for example electronic heat capacity $C\propto T^2$ and penetration-depth change $\lambda (T)-\lambda (0)\propto T$, in contrast with activated responses of a fully gapped s-wave state. Disorder, dimensional crossover and competing phases can alter these powers.

The cuprate pseudogap is a partial, momentum-dependent loss of low-energy electronic spectral weight extending above the superconducting transition in underdoped materials. It need not be identical to the superconducting gap, and observing it alone does not identify its microscopic origin or prove preformed pairs. ^[ref]

Short coherence lengths, anisotropy and low phase stiffness in underdoped systems make thermal phase and vortex fluctuations important. Many cuprates are strong type-II superconductors, with large London penetration depths relative to their superconducting coherence lengths. Gap-to-transition-temperature ratios and isotope effects vary with doping and need not obey the simplest weak-coupling benchmarks $2\Delta (0)/(k_{\mathrm{B}}{T}_c)=3.53$ and $T_c\propto M_{\mathrm{ion}}^{-1/2}$. A weak or variable isotope effect by itself does not identify the pairing mechanism.

These features motivate strongly correlated pairing descriptions, often involving spin fluctuations, but do not uniquely establish a microscopic pairing glue. Other high-temperature families need not share every cuprate property: iron-based superconductors are multiband and may be nodeless. The robust distinction is the observed combination of correlated normal states, unusual gap symmetry and important collective fluctuations, rather than high $T_c$ alone.

A normal Fermi liquid is an interacting fermion phase continuously connected to a Fermi gas without broken symmetry. Its Landau quasiparticles are dressed particle/hole excitations near the Fermi surface, with the same conserved quantum numbers, finite quasiparticle residue and a decay width small compared with their excitation energy. Their reference dispersion already includes zero-temperature interaction renormalization; “bare quasiparticle” here does not mean a free atom.^[ref]

The rate assumes $k_{B}T,|\xi |\ll E_F$, $\xi =ϵ-\mu$, regular scattering amplitudes and density of states, equilibrium Fermi-Dirac distributions, and two-body collisions conserving energy and momentum. Pauli exclusion principle restricts the available phase space. It describes a regular three-dimensional normal liquid, not a one-dimensional interacting electron liquid. On the surface, ${\tau }^{-1}\propto T^2$; at $T=0$ and $\xi >0$, it is proportional to ${\xi }^2$. Hence excitations become increasingly sharp. The quoted asymmetric occupation factor is for particle out-scattering: a hole decay or full spectral width also needs the complementary in-scattering process; it does not imply exponentially stable deep holes.

Symmetry $f_{ab}=f_{ba}$ cancels the quadratic functional's factor one-half, giving the thermal Landau quasiparticle energy shiftHere $a=(\mathbf{k},\lambda )$, and the derivative is with respect to an occupation, not particle density. Replacing the homogeneous momentum sum by an energy integral defines a smooth angularly averaged kernel $H_a(ϵ)$. With $\delta n=n_F(ϵ;\mu ,T)-\Theta ({\mu }_0-ϵ)$,Fixed density gives $\delta \mu =-({\pi }^2/6)(k_{B}T{)}^2{D}^{\prime }({\mu }_0)/D({\mu }_0)+O(T^4)$; fixed chemical potential instead has $\delta \mu =0$. Thus ${\widetilde{ϵ}}_a={ϵ}_a+O(T^2)$ in either case, provided the kernels are smooth and no instability intervenes. This is the Sommerfeld expansion; singular spectra require separate treatment.^[ref]

The leading entropy is therefore that of quasiparticles with their zero-temperature effective mass:$D^{\ast }$ here is the total, spin-summed density of states. The plotted low-temperature slopes require the enhanced masses $5.4m$ at molar volume $26.2\mathrm{c}{\mathrm{m}}^3\mathrm{mo}{\mathrm{l}}^{-1}$ and $2.7m$ at $36.8\mathrm{c}{\mathrm{m}}^3\mathrm{mo}{\mathrm{l}}^{-1}$, rather than the bare-mass predictions. At fixed molar particle number, ${\gamma }_{\mathrm{mol}}\propto m^{\ast }{V}_{\mathrm{mol}}^{2/3}$. Agreement is restricted to the low-temperature limit: the measured curves depart markedly from a fixed-mass ideal-gas extrapolation at higher temperature. This supports long-lived quasiparticles with smooth low-energy parameters, but heat capacity alone does not measure their lifetime or prove adiabatic continuity.

Landau quasiparticles describe the long-lived low-energy excitations of an interacting normal Fermi liquid. Starting from a free Fermi gas, imagine switching on interactions without changing the phase or destroying the one-to-one labelling of low-energy states. The resulting excitation carries the quantum numbers of a dressed particle but has a renormalized energy and interactions with other excitations. Its microscopic wavefunction need not resemble a bare electron state. The occupied momenta define a Fermi surface, and the quasiparticle energy measured from the chemical potential vanishes on that surface.

The Landau quasiparticle energy functional expresses the change near equilibrium in terms of occupation changes:Differentiation gives the energy of one quasiparticle in the distorted distribution. This is a phenomenological expansion around the true interacting ground state, not the assertion that its total energy equals that of independent particles. For an isotropic system, spin-symmetric and spin-antisymmetric components of $f$ are expanded in Legendre polynomials. Multiplication by the appropriate Fermi-surface density of states defines dimensionless Landau parameters $F_l^s,F_l^a$. The original formulation relates a change in the distribution to the energy shift.^[ref]

Pauli blocking makes the low-energy excitations sharp. The phase space for a quasiparticle to scatter while creating another particle–hole pair shrinks as the Fermi surface is approached, giving the regular three-dimensional low-energy Fermi-liquid quasiparticle lifetimeThus at zero temperature its width is small compared with its excitation energy. The single-particle spectral function has a pole with quasiparticle residue $Z$, generally less than one, and an incoherent remainder. In a conventional Fermi liquid the occupation distribution has a discontinuity of height $Z$ at the Fermi surface, rather than a unit free-particle step.

For an isotropic three-dimensional system, define $N^{\ast }(0)$ to include both spins. The quasiparticle density of states determines the low-temperature electronic heat capacity, $C_V/V=({\pi }^2/3)k_B^2{N}^{\ast }(0)T$. In the usual Landau-parameter normalization, the spin response is modified by $1/(1+F_0^a)$ and the compressibility by $1/(1+F_0^s)$. In a Galilean-invariant continuum, $m^{\ast }/m=1+F_1^s/3$; that particular relation must not be imposed unchanged on a crystal band. A denominator approaching zero signals a possible instability of the assumed normal state.

The same interaction functional and a kinetic equation describe collective zero sound when the excitation frequency exceeds the collision rate. Ordinary first sound is the collision-dominated hydrodynamic limit. The theory organizes thermodynamics, response and transport through a small set of measured effective parameters while explaining why interactions coexist with long-lived fermionic excitations. It is not applicable without qualification in phases where the Fermi-liquid quasiparticle pole disappears or a gap opens over the relevant Fermi surface.

Use a three-dimensional electron gas with a uniform positive background, the jellium model. The Hartree-Fock method minimizes the expectation of the interacting Hamiltonian over normalized Slater determinants. Antisymmetry is exact within that trial class, but correlations requiring a superposition of determinants are omitted. For orthonormal occupied spin orbitals ${\varphi }_i$, the energy iswhere $J_{ij}$ is the direct Coulomb integral and $K_{ij}$ the exchange integral; the spin overlap makes exchange vanish between opposite-spin orbitals. The self-interaction terms $J_{ii}$ and $K_{ii}$ cancel. Variation gives a self-consistent Fock operator $\hat{f}=h_0+{\sum }_j({\hat{J}}_j-{\hat{K}}_j)$; exchange is nonlocal. Its eigenfunctions define occupied orbitals of a stationary determinant, and the determinant must be compared with competing self-consistent solutions to select a variational ground state.

The eigenvalues are orbital Lagrange multipliers. Their sum counts each interaction twice:Frozen-orbital removal energies may be estimated using Koopmans' theorem, but measured quasiparticle energies can contain relaxation and correlations absent from this approximation. Unoccupied orbital energies are not automatically an exact excitation spectrum. In particular, unscreened exchange in a uniform three-dimensional gas produces an unphysical logarithmic slope singularity at its Fermi surface; a one-determinant mean field does not reproduce the interacting Fermi liquid's screened response.

For a spatially uniform plane-wave determinant, electron-background and background-background terms cancel the uniform direct Coulomb contribution. Retain the background when making this cancellation: an isolated infinite electron charge distribution would have a divergent direct energy. The surviving contributions per particle are kinetic energy and negative same-spin exchange energy. Let $(3/(4\pi n){)}^{1/3}=r_s{a}_B^{\ast }$ define the Dimensionless Wigner-Seitz radius, with $a_B^{\ast }=4\pi \epsilon {\hslash }^2/(m^{\ast }{e}^2)$, $E_H^{\ast }={\hslash }^2/(m^{\ast }{a}_B^{\ast 2})$ and $\zeta =(n_{\uparrow }-n_{\downarrow })/n$. ThenFor the unpolarized state this is approximately $1.105/r_s^2-0.4582/r_s$. The kinetic contribution penalizes spin polarization because it enlarges an occupied Fermi sphere; exchange favors polarization because equal-spin occupation gains more exchange energy. As density falls, the $r_s^{-1}$ exchange scale overtakes the $r_s^{-2}$ kinetic scale. The uniform fully polarized and unpolarized energies cross atThis is a variational comparison within the homogeneous Hartree-Fock electron gas, not an exact physical ferromagnetic phase boundary. It demonstrates how Pauli kinetic energy and exchange compete and why the allowed trial states matter.

Allowing spatial symmetry breaking changes the result: the Overhauser instability lowers the paramagnetic determinant's Hartree-Fock energy through a spin density wave, even in the high-density limit. A calculation restricted to uniform Fermi spheres therefore does not give the unrestricted Hartree-Fock ground state.^[ref] At still lower density, localization and a Wigner crystal compete with fluid states. electron-gas correlation energy beyond a single determinant is important in assessing their competition. Quantum Monte Carlo provides a concrete route to comparing correlated fluid and crystal energies; the original stochastic calculation demonstrates why exchange-only energy differences are insufficient.^[ref]

Hartree-Fock is a useful variational baseline with exact exchange, not a controlled complete low-density phase diagram. At high density the kinetic scale dominates, but even a small symmetry-breaking energy gain can invalidate a restricted determinant as the exact Hartree-Fock minimizer. At low density neglected correlations, screening and localization can change both transition locations and the ordering of candidate phases. A numerical phase boundary should therefore state dimension, spin constraints, background model and whether correlation and spatially modulated states were included.