After complete ionization, each hydrogen nucleus supplies one ion and one Electron, while each helium-4 nucleus supplies one ion and two Electrons. Neglecting the small metal mass fraction and putting , the mean molecular weight therefore satisfies
Use stellar homology to compare models with common dimensionless profiles. The stellar mass conservation equation, stellar hydrostatic equation and ideal gas law give
The radiative diffusion in a star equation then gives . Inserting the specified opacity yields . Independently, integrating the stellar energy-generation rate over the mass gives . Equating these in stellar thermal equilibrium gives the radiative homology with fifth-power hydrogen burning and inverse-cubic opacity:
At fixed solar mass these reduce to and . The stellar homology approximation, rather than merely the local power laws, is what permits these relations between whole stars.
Equal luminosities imply . Thus
so to one significant figure. Retaining the unrounded hydrogen mass fraction when comparing central temperatures gives
The first model has the higher central temperature.
For homogeneous hydrogen burning at fixed , fuel conservation gives . Since and , the homogeneous fuel-depletion luminosity feedback obeys
Integration with the initial mean molecular weight gives
This idealized stellar evolution law stops when ; it does not predict a physically attainable infinite luminosity. Indeed at fuel exhaustion, giving , strictly before the formal singularity.
Buoyancy and the convective criterion. Consider a small fluid parcel displaced outward by . Assume that sound waves keep its pressure equal to the ambient pressure, while heat exchange is slow enough that its displacement is an adiabatic process. Composition is uniform, so the parcel and its surroundings have the same mean molecular weight. For an ideal gas, , and an adiabatic parcel obeys . If is the pressure change on moving outward, then
The density excess of the parcel at its new location is therefore
If , this excess is negative: the outward-displaced parcel is lighter and accelerates farther outward. A downward displacement similarly continues downward. Conversely, a smaller gradient gives a restoring buoyancy force. The Schwarzschild criterion is thus stability for and instability for , where the adiabatic temperature gradient is . For a monatomic gas,
A composition gradient would require the additional density effect in the Ledoux criterion; it is absent in this calculation.
Opacity and pressure. The supplied opacity is characteristic of a cool hydrogen-rich stellar atmosphere dominated by negative hydrogen ion opacity. Mostly neutral hydrogen can attach electrons supplied by partially ionized metals; bound-free and free-free absorption involving the resulting ions produces a steep positive temperature dependence. The weak density dependence and strong temperature sensitivity can be represented by local power-law fits. At fixed composition the given pressure form is equivalent to , because . This is an approximate fit over the relevant cool-atmosphere regime, not an exact opacity law at all temperatures; molecular opacity or hydrogen ionization eventually changes the regime.
For a geometrically thin atmosphere take the surface gravity of a star to be constant, . Combining with gives hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth,
The grey atmosphere relation gives . With negligible external pressure, , integration yields
An imposed nonzero external pressure would add ; the boundary assumption is what fixes the integration constant here.
The factor in parentheses is . Hence
The grey-atmosphere convection onset with eighth-power temperature opacity occurs when this reaches , so
The radiative continuation below this boundary would be unstable. Efficient convection instead keeps the deeper star approximately adiabatic.
Matching to the convective interior. Write . Eliminating density using the ideal gas law gives
at fixed composition. Since is a fixed number, the matching temperature is proportional to , while the matching pressure satisfies . Consequently
The polytropic mass-radius relation for index gives . Raising the matching relation to the ninth power and using therefore gives
Finally the Stefan–Boltzmann law yields the Hayashi relation with eighth-power temperature opacity,
Composition and the opacity normalization are fixed in this comparison. The entropy coefficient is spatially constant in each convective model, but need not be the same for stars with different masses or radii.
Mechanical balance and equipotentials. Let be the Newtonian gravitational potential and the cylindrical distance from the rotation axis. For rigid angular velocity , a fluid element at rest in the rotating frame has no Coriolis acceleration. The centrifugal acceleration is , so hydrostatic equilibrium becomes
Using the Poisson equation for gravity and gives
On any regular connected equipotential surface, every tangent displacement satisfies and therefore . Locally , with . This makes a function of as well. Equivalently, taking the curl of the hydrostatic equation gives . Thus and are constant on each surface. The last conclusion follows from the modified Poisson equation; it does not constrain the magnitude of the first derivative to be constant there.
For uniform composition, an equation of state determines uniquely at fixed in the usual stellar regime. For the gas-plus-radiation equation, the derivative with respect to is positive. Hence , and the opacity and radiative conductivity are also functions of .
Surface flux and the requested sketch. Define , positive for the outward radiative flux. Then
On an outer equipotential surface, is constant and the outward normal is parallel to . Its effective gravity is , so . The Stefan–Boltzmann law gives the radiative gravity-darkening law,
A rapidly rotating star is oblate. Centrifugal support reduces the effective gravity near the equator, which is therefore cooler and dimmer; the poles are hotter. The original sketch below uses a subcritical Roche model of a uniformly rotating star to show this geometry and the corresponding temperature variation. The material temperature on an interior equipotential is not the same quantity as the emergent effective temperature defined by surface flux.
Figure 1.
Oblate rotating star with hot poles, cool equator and radiative gravity darkening
. Details.
Why purely local radiative balance fails. Differentiating the flux gives
On one equipotential, and the proposed source are all constant, but generally varies with latitude. Unless or there is another special cancellation, no single value of can match this flux divergence at all points on the surface. This is the radiative-equilibrium obstruction in a rotating barotropic star. Slow stellar meridional circulation can transport heat to compensate; it is distinct from abandoning hydrostatic balance at leading order.
Integrated energy balance with circulation. The steady continuity equation is . Combining the entropy–enthalpy relation with hydrostatic balance gives
Integrate the energy equation over and apply the divergence theorem:
Uniform composition makes constant on the enclosing equipotential, and is constant there by definition. Pull out of the last integral; the remaining net mass flux is zero by steady continuity. Thus the equipotential luminosity conservation with stellar circulation is
This does not require pointwise on : inward and outward circulation may cancel in the net mass flux.
Finally, is constant on and the divergence theorem applied to the effective potential gives
Therefore . Since ,
The mass is the mass enclosed by this surface, not necessarily the total stellar mass. The denominator is positive for the regular hydrostatic surfaces used here; near loss of centrifugal confinement the assumed stellar model must be reconsidered. The derivation uses slow circulation, retaining hydrostatic/equipotential thermodynamics to leading order while allowing a nonzero advective heat flux.
Use for the stellar gas constant, reserving for the stellar radius. The specific internal energy of a monatomic gas obeying the ideal gas law is . At fixed enclosed mass, the first law of thermodynamics gives the heat available to the outgoing luminosity as when there is no stellar nuclear fusion heating. Therefore
The second coefficient includes both the mass density dependence of and pressure work. This is gravitational energy generation in a homologously contracting ideal-gas star.
Write the characteristic scales as
Then , , , and . Since , direct substitution in the stellar hydrostatic equation and mass conservation gives
For radiative diffusion in a star, dividing the temperature equation by gives
In particular the fourth power here is of , not of the radius.
Because is fixed and is constant, a fixed mass label has fixed . Thus stellar homology gives and . The heating rate reduces to , positive during Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction. Substitution in now yields
The dimensionless profiles fix and . In a common stellar homology family with fixed stellar composition and opacity normalization, the expression for implies
It is independent of radius and constant in time for a particular fixed-mass star. The formula for gives , which integrates to
When the initial-radius term is negligible,
This is the Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction time law in the prescribed stellar homology model. Infinite initial radius is a limiting idealization; a finite initial radius retains the first term.
At main sequence arrival, CNO cycle heating with fixed stellar composition has luminosity
The integral is dimensionless and fixed within the stellar homology family. The constant-opacity radiative scaling still gives . Equating the stellar nuclear fusion and transported luminosities gives
Finally the Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction law evaluated at gives . In a coeval star cluster, the mass just arriving at the main sequence consequently satisfies
These results comprise constant-opacity homologous contraction to CNO ignition; their mass exponents compare fixed-composition models with common dimensionless profiles.
Consider a small outward displacement of a fluid element. It adjusts to the ambient pressure while retaining its specific entropy and stellar composition, so an adiabatic process gives . Its excess mass density over the new surroundings is, to first order,
Restoring buoyancy requires this bracket to be positive. With , the Schwarzschild criterion is therefore
Equality is neutral stability. For uniform mean molecular weight, the ideal gas law gives . Since hydrostatic equilibrium pressure decreases outward, the inequality is equivalent to . Dividing the radiative diffusion in a star and hydrostatic equilibrium stellar structure equations gives
This is the stellar radiative temperature gradient test for stellar convective stability.
In the thin upper stellar atmosphere take , and use gas pressure dominance. The prescribed opacity becomes . Dividing the two structure equations then yields
At zero optical depth, the atmospheric boundary has and negligible gas pressure. Integrating from that boundary, with , gives
To locate the onset, put . Logarithmic derivative gives , hence
This starts at zero at the outer boundary and increases inward. It first reaches at
The corresponding optical depth is , so the onset lies inside the stellar atmosphere. This is grey-atmosphere convection onset with thirteenth-power opacity.
Let the interior of the fully convective star have , with spatially constant. At its boundary is fixed, so the atmospheric pressure formula gives
The Stefan–Boltzmann law, with , consequently implies
The ideal gas equation transforms the interior relation into
For completeness, the mass-radius scaling follows by taking and with . Hydrostatic equilibrium and mass conservation reduce to the Lane-Emden equation , with , . Its fixed dimensionless profile gives and . Eliminating gives , or . Thus at fixed stellar composition. Equating this with the atmospheric expression gives , and hence
This Hayashi relation with thirteenth-power opacity concerns the interior of a fully convective star beneath a thin stellar atmosphere. The coefficient may vary between stars; spatially constant specific entropy does not mean equal specific entropy across the whole sequence.
Use radiative homology with proton-proton burning and inverse-fourth-power opacity, retaining the composition factors throughout. To distinguish the stellar radius from the stellar gas constant, write them as and . With gas pressure alone, introduce the scale factors
The ideal gas equation gives , and . Substitution into hydrostatic equilibrium and mass conservation gives
so and .
Set . The radiative diffusion in a star equation, with the stipulated opacity, becomes
Here . Thus
The luminosity equation follows from the specific heating rate of the Proton–proton chain:
Consequently
These give all four dimensionless stellar structure equations with their numerical coefficients.
The stellar homology assumption means the dimensionless profiles are shared across the models, not merely that an individual model can be written in dimensionless coordinates. The displayed equations then require and to be fixed. Holding the universal constants and fixed gives
Equating the two cancels and yields . Therefore the radius and mass-luminosity relation are
The mass-independent radius is a consequence of the particular heating and opacity exponents in this model; it is not a general radius law for main-sequence stars.
Initially is the same for all stars. The adopted mean molecular weight also has the same initial value, neglecting its small direct dependence on . Thus . At fixed luminosity, the Stefan–Boltzmann law gives
The stars compared here can have different masses; the luminosity law adjusts the mass to keep fixed.
For the evolution, take the stellar mass as constant and maintain homogeneous composition. The available energy in the remaining hydrogen is , so conservation of energy in the nuclear-powered model gives
This includes the entire mixed hydrogen reservoir, not just the mass in a central burning region.
To determine the turnoff mass of a homogeneously mixed proton-proton-burning population, write the luminosity law as , where
Separating variables, the time to evolve from to is
For a common and , this integral is a positive finite constant independent of . It follows that the turning-off stars satisfy
The integration retains the evolving luminosity and mean molecular weight; replacing by its initial value is unnecessary.
For the Schwarzschild criterion, displace a small gas parcel upwards. Assume its composition is unchanged, it remains in pressure balance with its surroundings, and it moves quickly enough that heat exchange is negligible. The parcel obeys the adiabatic equation of state . Combining this with the ideal gas equation gives , so its adiabatic temperature gradient is .
Let the surrounding temperature gradient be . For an upward displacement , the parcel's temperature relative to its new surroundings is
If , this is negative: the parcel is cooler and, at equal pressure and composition, denser than its surroundings. It therefore sinks back; a downward displacement likewise gives a restoring buoyancy force. If the inequality is reversed, the displaced parcel continues to rise. The stability condition is thus
Equality is the neutral boundary. There is no composition-gradient term because the ideal-gas parcel and the background have the same mean molecular weight.
In the thin upper stellar atmosphere, take a plane-parallel approximation with constant , optical depth increasing inward, and zero overlying pressure . Hydrostatic equilibrium in optical depth gives . The ideal gas equation converts the stipulated opacity into
Define , so the given grey atmosphere relation is . Integrating from the surface gives
This proves the required pressure law. In particular times a function only of and .
For the grey-atmosphere convection onset with density-linear opacity, differentiate the two profiles to obtain the radiative temperature gradient:
It increases monotonically from zero, since , and first reaches the adiabatic temperature gradient at . Therefore
Below this point the radiative stratification is unstable and convection must transport some of the outward energy flux.
At the outer convection boundary, depends only on , so and for fixed . The matching constant in is . Consequently
This temperature form of the polytropic relation follows from an ideal monatomic adiabat; its is not the density-polytrope coefficient in Question 3.
For the deep radiative boundary beneath a power-law-opacity convective envelope, negligible envelope mass and absent local energy generation give and . Divide the radiative temperature equation by the pressure equation to get the stellar radiative temperature gradient
This is the gradient that would be needed if radiation alone carried , and it is the quantity to compare with even while the actual region is convective. The deeper Kramers' opacity law gives . Substituting yields
As rises inward this decreases, so the transition back to a stable radiative interior is at
Thus . Using the outer matching and the Stefan–Boltzmann law,
The mass and radius cancel. Hence, at fixed opacity coefficients and composition,
This uses the same adiabat through the convection zone and distinguishes its inner transition temperature from its outer onset temperature.
Use a characteristic midplane temperature , density and disk scale height . For an ideal gas of fixed composition, dominant gas pressure gives , where is the sound speed. Vertical hydrostatic equilibrium and the alpha disk prescription give
Numerical factors in the vertical averaging do not affect the exponents. The stipulated opacity becomes
For an optically thick, radiatively efficient disk, radiative diffusion gives a cooling rate per unit area proportional to . The viscous heating rate is proportional to . Thus
Equating heating and cooling gives , so
At fixed and central mass, . Therefore the gas-pressure alpha disk with inverse-density opacity satisfies
For thermal stability of an accretion disk, perturb at fixed and , since the thermal adjustment is faster than radial mass redistribution. The logarithmic heating and cooling slopes are respectively one and two. At equilibrium, a fractional temperature increase therefore makes the excess heating decrease, and the disk cools back. Thus the local thermal equilibrium is stable within the assumed gas-pressure, radiative-diffusion closure.
For viscous stability of an accretion disk, use the thermally equilibrated relation between viscosity and surface density. It gives
Locally freezing the background radius in the Keplerian viscous diffusion equation, a short radial Fourier mode has growth rate . Density enhancements diffuse rather than grow, so the disk is locally viscously stable as well.
In the radiative layer, take the enclosed mass to be , the transported luminosity to be , and the mean molecular weight to be constant. The envelope's own gravity is neglected. Divide the hydrostatic and radiative temperature equations, and then eliminate density using the gas equation of state:
Put and . For , integration gives
Defining and yields
In the relevant positive-exponent case, writing produces the stated form whenever this integration constant is nonnegative. The exceptional values excluded above lead to logarithms: gives , gives , and both zero give .
For radiative-envelope convection matching, compute the logarithmic gradient of the pressure relation:
At the marginal boundary, the Schwarzschild criterion equates this with the ideal-gas adiabatic gradient . Hence
The positive real notation requires a nonnegative bracket; a general signed is the safer integration constant otherwise. For the later case and a monatomic gas, this bracket is , so is of the same order as .
Deep below the convective boundary, with the temperature-power term dominating , the pressure law becomes . Differentiating this approximation and using hydrostatic balance gives
The general temperature is a term proportional to plus a boundary-dependent constant. Well inside the boundary radius, where that term dominates, it reduces to
The inverse-radius profile is an inner approximation, not an assertion that the boundary term vanishes everywhere.
Now take , so , . Then , , and define so that . The luminosity supplied by the thin burning layer is
Because the integral is strongly concentrated near and , the outer term is negligible. Thus
The factor , rather than merely , is essential since the specified energy-generation rate is per unit mass. This integration uses the deep radiative profile as a leading thin-shell approximation.
Crucially, is not independent of luminosity. Its defining relation gives
Substitution into the shell integral therefore yields . The degenerate-core relation gives , so
This degenerate-core shell-burning mass-luminosity relation is specific to the adopted opacity, burning exponent and structural approximations.
Removing some envelope mass while retaining the hydrogen-burning shell and the deep-envelope regime leaves the leading luminosity approximately unchanged at fixed core mass. The envelope can instead change the radius and effective temperature. This independence is not valid for arbitrarily complete stripping: removing the fuel or the pressure-confined shell structure quenches or modifies shell burning, and the assumed giant model then fails.
For constant opacity, the ratio cancels the height dependence in the radiative diffusion coefficient. Since , the radiative flux is
Consequently . Equating this to the viscous heating rate gives
Thus the dynamic viscosity is uniform in height even though pressure and mass density decrease. Its units are mass per length per time, since has those units. A pointwise pressure-proportional alpha prescription would be incompatible with this exact profile, which is why the subsequent alpha relation is vertically averaged.
The first relation is vertical hydrostatic equilibrium. In a thin disc, the central object's gravity near the midplane is ; the pressure gradient balances it. The second is an equation of state combining ideal gas pressure with isotropic radiation pressure. Write , so and ; is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant and the mean molecular weight in proton-mass units.
The third is local energy balance: the increase of upward radiative flux with height equals viscous dissipation. Here is dynamic viscosity, not mean molecular weight. A Keplerian disc has shear , so its heating rate is . The fourth is optically thick radiative diffusion, with opacity per unit mass and diffusion directed down the temperature gradient. Midplane symmetry gives and oppositely directed fluxes from the two faces. The four relations express vertical force balance, gas–radiation thermodynamics, local heating, and diffusive cooling.
The required pressure integral uses . With and ,
The vertically averaged alpha closure for a mixed-pressure layer therefore gives
The height-integrated dynamic viscosity is . Equate it to to obtain
These are integrated equalities, not an imposed pointwise relation .
Now keep , the opacity and molecular constants independent of radius, and use Keplerian rotation . In the gas-dominated limit, but positive, the last equality gives . The column-density relation gives . Eliminating yields , whence
This is the gas-pressure branch of a mixed-pressure alpha disk. In the radiation-dominated limit, , so and
For viscous stability of an accretion disk, linearize the Keplerian viscous diffusion equation at fixed radius: a local mass density perturbation has diffusion coefficient . The gas branch has and a positive derivative, so it smooths perturbations. The radiation branch has and a negative derivative, giving radiation-pressure viscous instability. The gas-pressure branch is viscously stable; the radiation-pressure branch is viscously unstable in this closure. This concerns radial mass-transport stability on wavelengths where the vertically averaged thin-disc model applies.
Efficient convection makes the interior follow a nearly adiabatic process and maintains uniform specific entropy. For the fully ionized monatomic ideal gas, the specific-heat ratio is , so the adiabatic temperature gradient gives . Integrating at a fixed time gives
The coefficient is spatially constant because the composition and specific entropy are uniform. It can change as the star loses energy. Equivalently the gas is an adiabatic stellar polytrope with and polytropic index ; and the pressure-temperature coefficient are different quantities.
This fixes the dimensionless Lane-Emden equation profile throughout a stellar homology sequence. Writing in the mass integral gives , with a fixed positive shape constant . Integrating the stellar hydrostatic equation through the same profile, with negligible surface pressure compared with central pressure, gives . Hence
These are homology scalings of central stellar pressure. Substituting the central quantities into yields
Thus is constant for the fixed stellar polytrope family.
At the approximate photosphere, take and use the ideal gas relation . The prescribed opacity gives
The stellar surface boundary condition and surface gravity of a star therefore imply
This is the temperature-four special case of convective contraction with power-law opacity.
Using the Stefan–Boltzmann law, the luminosity is
For , the supplied gravitational-energy formula is . The stellar virial theorem for a monatomic gas gives , so the total energy is . During Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction, with constant mass and no significant nuclear source, . Thus
Multiplying by and integrating gives
The sign makes the radius decrease as time increases.
When the accumulated contraction term dominates the initial-radius term, this yields . Combining it with the central ideal gas temperature gives the late-time central-temperature scaling
Replacing by gives the stated late-time form. The asymptotic step also requires a time long enough to forget the initial radius, not merely a choice of zero for the age.